8 Video Game-To-Movie Adaptations That Get Way Too Much Hate

Not-so-flawless victories.

prince of persia movie
Disney

Video game adaptations, it seems, are not the general moviegoer's cup of tea. How many films based on games have performed well enough at the box office to justify sequels that aren't direct-to-video? Less than a handful. How many have earned critical acclaim? Even fewer.

Despite the gaming business evolving to the point that the writing and cinematography frequently exceed Hollywood's feeble standards, it still seems like it's incredibly difficult to translate a video game property to the big screen without a large portion of the audience taking up pitchforks and trying to run the filmmaker out of town.

With Warcraft and Assassin's Creed - two of the most beloved video game franchises in recent history - making their way to multiplexes this year, all we can do is hope that these films make a more significant impact than previous attempts.

The real question, though, isn't whether filmmakers will ever figure out how to make an impressive and celebrated video game adaptation, but whether we, as an audience, will ever let them.

Because like it or not, we're just harder on these types of movies. Which is why, even though we've already seen plenty of good - or even great - video game adaptations over the years, none of them get even a modicum of the respect they deserve.

So let's stop the hate. Even if just for a moment.

8. Need For Speed

Need For Speed (film)
Disney

Perhaps no other movie on this list better exemplifies the predicament that video game adaptations currently find themselves in. When filmmakers go for big, shameless fun, they're condemned for adding yet another lightweight film to the already silly genre. But when they try to veer into human drama, they're criticized for "trying too hard" and going away from pure, boffo entertainment.

It's frequently a no-win situation.

But Need For Speed actually hit a lot of the right notes, especially when it came to paying homage to its source material. The cops are just as insatiably and frustratingly vigilant as they are in the game, and the vehicular mayhem is spectacular and ludicrous in all the right ways.

The story can get a little murky when it dips into the redemptive/vengeful angle, but Aaron Paul is a capable enough leading man to carry the sometimes hollow script.

And sure, it could have done a bit more to separate itself from that other car chase franchise, but Need For Speed bests Fast and the Furious simply by its ability to present beautifully choreographed, expertly executed stunts without having to pump the brakes to showcase a character's humanity, or use the sequence as a muddled metaphor for a relationship.

Need For Speed is a worthwhile watch, even just to see all those bada** wipeouts from the game transposed onto the big screen using practical effects and ballsy stunt work.


7. Prince Of Persia: Sands Of Time

Jake Gyllenhal prince of persia
Disney

Look, it's never going to be okay that the studios tried to pass off Jake Gyllenhaal as a hero of Middle Eastern descent. It's weird that they decided to whitewash the cast like that; no one's arguing that point.

But if you're able to overlook that one transgression, there's actually a pretty satisfying action-adventure film to be found. It was a little bit of Indiana Jones mixed in with some Pirates of the Carribbean-style swashbuckling, though, admittedly, not quite as good as either of those franchises.

Many of the criticisms thrown at this movie involve wasting the immense talents of its all-star cast, which also includes Ben Kingsley and Alfred Molina. But those critics mustn't have watched the whole movie, because all three of those principal actors were given ample room to shine.

If anything, it's lead actress Gemma Arterton who was unfairly cast into the shadows for much of the film. But even she was given a couple of standout scenes to strut her stuff.

As mentioned above, Prince of Persia is more than a tad derivative - even aping part of another Disney property, Aladdin, where our hero valiantly defends a child who got caught stealing an apple - but at least it borrows from the best.


6. Wing Commander

Wing Commander
20th Century Fox

Wing Commander is the rare example of a video game adaptation being directed by the actual creator of the video game, Chris Roberts, which ensures that things don't stray too far away from the source material. Roberts' oversight, along with an extremely likable cast, make the movie more entertaining than it probably should be.

For a very brief window in the late '90s/early '00s, inserting either Matthew Lillard and Freddie Prinze Jr into your movie was a surefire way to draw a huge teen crowd into theaters. In fact, these two momentary teen heartthrobs were in five movies together over the span of five years.

And it's clear the two have great onscreen chemistry. In fact, the most redeeming parts of this movie - which even the most cynical viewer should be able to appreciate - are the various relationships and character studies involving the principal cast.

The action sequences are...there...but it's almost impossible to tell them apart.

There's also some serious Star Trek mimicry happening throughout this movie - the first of which is an obvious Scotty clone, who shows up five minutes in - and that's largely a detriment. Because it's those borrowed elements that drive the story. And the story is awful.

But again, anyone who watches movies more for characterizations than stories will find plenty to like here.


5. Double Dragon

Double Dragon Robert Patrick
Gramercy Pictures

Set in a post-apocalyptic, earthquake-ravaged version of Los Angeles, Double Dragon tries its best to provide a political message. And while it fails spectacularly on a broader front, it actually does a pretty stellar job handling some smaller moments of social satire.

Commercials for Jack City sell their fashion-forward lift devices to citizens who worry that the quakes won't just wreck their homes, but also throw off their design scheme. Vanna White and George Hamilton cameo as themselves, but playing a typically vapid pair of news anchors, while a pre-controversy Andy Dick (also playing himself) slums it as the weatherman giving the daily smog alert.

For a kids movie, there was an abundance of these satirical bits playing out on the perimeter, which, believe it or not, actually makes this a film worth re-watching.

The big picture stuff is more hit-or-miss. The filmmakers went a little far with the steampunk-ish aesthetic - Billy and Jimmy Lee's car is literally fueled by garbage - and the film would've been better had it steered away from the grim fantasy stylings that were de rigueur in the mid-'90s. But they nailed some of the smaller elements of the Nintendo world, right down to the music used during the fight scenes, which are both comical and well-choreographed.

Also...Alyssa Milano is in short shorts for the majority of the runtime. Game, set, match: Double Dragon.


4. Dead Or Alive

Dead Or Alive Holly Valance Bra
Dimension FIlms

The Dead Or Alive movie should not have made it past pre-production. Seriously, how did a film based on a video game whose central conceit is "we made these boobs capable of bouncing a lot" ever get greenlit in the first place?

But more to the point, how did a movie like this actually turn out to be so...so...good?

The premise is exactly like that of every other tournament-based fighting game: A diverse group of fighters from all over the world converge on an island to compete in a secret martial arts tournament and prove that they are, in the words of the Karate Kid soundtrack, the best around.

The key difference here is that the fighters are women. Women who aren't afraid of using their sexual wiles to gain the upper hand. This, naturally, brings up scenes that involve a women effortlessly kicking the hell out of some bad guys while simultaneously putting on her bra.

It sounds stupid. Hell, it is stupid. But since when did big, stupid action movies suddenly turn into worthless movies?

Besides, considering the occasionally braindead source material, it's kind of amazing that Dead Or Alive turned out to be as fun and rewatchable as it is.


3. Mortal Kombat

Scorpion Mortal Kombat
New Line Cinema

Whereas the sequel was all iconography and terrible one-liners, the original Mortal Kombat had a fully-realized world chockfull of grimy locales, oversized personalities, and inventive martial arts choreography. It may have come off as cheesy, but at least everyone involved was dedicated to their cheese.

Mortal Kombat is to video game movies what Tim Burton's Batman was to comic book movies: A unique, somewhat gritty take on the genre that spawned a handful of imitators.

The acting may not be Oscar-worthy, the dialogue occasionally hurls itself into cornball territory, and the plot follows some predictable beats, but it also presents itself with the ideal blend of gravity and cheekiness.

Yes, we're supposed to be genuinely terrified of the four-armed monster that shows up halfway through the film, but it's also okay to laugh when Goro gets uppercutted in the taint by Johnny Cage and groans like...like...well, like someone who just got uppercutted in the taint.

Because, you see, entertainment is not always serious business.

That doesn't stop the director from trying to shoehorn in some lofty allegories about the importance of overcoming your own fears and "vanquishing the enemy within." But that's not the stuff anyone's paying attention to. Really, you just can't wait until Scorpion shows up in all his glory. Which is reasonable.


2. Silent Hill

Silent Hill
Tri-Star Pictures

Horror movies, like video game adaptations, don't usually get much love from people outside their specific fanbases. The prospect of merging those two genres, then, might sound like a recipe for the worst movie ever. And if you listen to the majority of critics, that's pretty much what Silent Hill turned out to be.

Which is ridiculous. Especially considering that most other adaptations get dragged through the mud for distancing themselves too far from the source material. Silent Hill, on the other hand, fully embraces it.

For all the qualms about the film supposedly crapping on the most iconic parts of the video game series (cough, Pyramid Head showing up for no reason, cough), this is one of the more painstakingly crafted films to come out of the genre, with director Christophe Gans' love of the original games oozing out of the screen at every turn.

Not only was Gans a legit fan, he also received oodles of input from the Silent Hill development team all the way through production. Hell, he even used parts of the original game's soundtrack in the movie!

So it's a little weird for gamers to have such a problem with the film's very limited failings as an adaptation.

Silent Hill is a tense, stylish, appeasing adaptation that achieves some genuine scares along the way, the kind that will stick with you long after you've finished the film. What more could you ask for?


1. Street Fighter

Street Fighter
Universal Pictures

There was an abnormal amount of vitriol spewed in Jean-Claude Van Damme's direction after his portrayal of Colonel Guile hit the big screens. Most of it fell in line with the typical JCVD critiques - the overacting, the generic storyline, the unintelligible dialogue - but some especially angry critics pointed to Street Fighter as being Example A of why video game adaptations just can't work, and need to be stopped at all costs.

Which is...harsh. Because Street Fighter was a perfectly enjoyable live-action cartoon.

Most people were upset that Street Fighter: The Movie was campy, colorful, and derivative. Basically, they were mad that a movie inspired by a video game looked and felt like a video game. It wasn't gritty or ultra-realistic, because its source material involved martial artists who could shoot fireballs from their hands. You can't take something like that too seriously.

There was plenty about this to enjoy if you could push your cynicism to the side: Raul Julia hamming it all the way up as M. Bison, the grotesque transformation of Blanka, and the sheer delightfulness of the dopey Zangief.

And if a little part of you didn't geek out when they all did that freeze frame group pose at the end, then quite frankly you're not worthy of a Street Fighter movie.


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.