8 Video Games Fans Didn't Deserve

Sometimes the classics are what no one wants or expects.

god of war
Sony

Humans are predictable. They appreciate comfort, and rarely change by choice. This truth extends to fandoms too, having a more passionate appreciation for specific comfort zones.

Fans revere their demographics to the point of denying what they dislike in sequels or reboots as "non-canonical”. The 21st century has seen an overabundance of film and TV series veer hard into the danger zone of despair.

Star Wars, Game of Thrones, the DC Extended Universe - the list goes on.

With video games, it's a thin line to walk for developers to honor what came before whilst still innovating in gameplay, taking risks in storytelling, executing universal themes and writing "acceptable" character development. Even introducing a new IP that is clearly inspired by a particular game, series or genre welcomes the odd paradox of "too familiar".

It is in this paradox that fans often proclaim their outrage, but honestly, some of that is just the old-fashioned, self-entitled privilege of gatekeeping. What follows are video games that have hindsight on their side, slapping the privilege of "deserve" out of the way to cement their places in video game history as fantastic challenges to - and progressions of - the medium.

Note: Spoilers ahead.

8. What Remains Of Edith Finch

What Remains Of Edith Finch
Giant Sparrow

What Remains of Edith Finch is a "walking simulator", a genre often tedious with slow movement and an overabundance of dialogue or reading over action.

Translation: Boring.

Well, Giant Sparrow's title certainly relies on dialogue and walking, but when Edith visits each of her family members' rooms to tell the story of a supposed "curse", we step into that person's imagined past, playing them for a time.

It is with these memories that the gameplay ascends. A young girl who imagines herself as a cat, a baby playing in the tub and conducting a symphony with his toys, a man creating a fantasy world in his head whilst working at a fish factory, etc. However, the player inevitably experiences each family member's unavoidable and tragic death.

What Remains of Edith Finch is depressing and often grim, but always validating and expressive in its artistry. Only three hours long, it leaves the player equally shaken, yet steeled, ready to face mortality.

Ultimately, it is THE walking simulator detractors never expected, expanding the genre to reflect on death, the power of the imagination and the validity of what it means to live. All of its themes are tied into engaging gameplay.


7. Dragon Age: Origins

Dragon Age Origins
BioWare

Before BioWare delivered a sequel to their successful sci-fi shooter Mass Effect, they dropped a "fantasy Mass Effect", Dragon Age: Origins. It's understandable how fans of the former considered overlooking this new IP, but they couldn't realize at the time how much Origins shaped BioWare's future successes.

Whilst fans had already oriented themselves with Mass Effect's races and their militaristic disagreements, they found Origins' politically urgent commentary on social-class struggle "too real" for fantasy. Ironically, other fans regarded the fantasy setting as either "nerdy" or "childish" compared to a hard sci-fi tone.

However, with elaborate and elegantly executed conflict, Origins challenges fans to consider the overlap of empathy and social consequence. The player must rely on a history of thousands of years to decide right from wrong between underprivileged elves, isolationist dwarves, and self-interested humans.

"Childish"? "Too real"? Merely a mirror of life's overflowing inequities.

Also, Origins implemented a system to radically change companions, either positively or negatively, based on thorough, personal quests. Mass Effect 2, a G.O.A.T. contender, later built an entire game around these quests to determine who survives its climactic Suicide Mission.

Well done, Origins.


6. Bloodborne

Bloodborne Father Gascoigne Beast
FromSoftware

FromSoftware released three Souls games from 2009-2014, setting the standard of the last decade for challenging-yet-rewarding gameplay. Bloodborne was marketed as Dark Souls' spiritual successor, albeit with a Victorian Gothic setting and some monster hunting.

However, whilst fans expected "Goth Souls", the marketing intentionally left out the Lovecraftian aspects that shape the game's often sickening lore. Dark Souls had been revered as the new paradigm of world-building, but fans received Bloodborne's story as something... "other".

Rather than pathos for fallen knights and sun lords, it was scornful regard for mutated beasts and their tentacled cosmic "gods". Also gone was the patient gameplay of "block, roll, and attack from behind". With Bloodborne, players had to re-frustrate themselves and learn how to manage the frantic "just attack, you heal when you attack!" methodology.

Skeptics proclaimed, "Why do we have to learn how to play a From Software game again? What is even happening in Yharnam?"

Regardless, Bloodborne redefined what "tough but fair" could be. It gave the gaming world a consistently alienating tone, whilst still commenting on human consequence and tragic ambition as Dark Souls had.

It is Dark Souls' feral cousin, and always part of the family.


5. Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4
Capcom

Resident Evil 4 did not invent third-person shooters. It did, however, reinvent them, with its over-the-shoulder camera and more responsive gameplay.

In the span of a decade, the Resident Evil series had defined survival horror for the PlayStation era. Resident Evil and its two sequels' fixed camera angles, limited inventory and tank controls create an overbearing atmosphere of suspense as protagonists dodge and survive undead abominations.

In Resident Evil 4, however, an over-the-shoulder 3rd-person camera follows Leon Kennedy as he rescues the President's daughter in Spain. Players use button-prompts during quick-time events to interact with the environment - dodging giant boulders, building barricades and implementing hand-to-hand combat during cutscenes.

The gameplay constantly focused on the tense action and the stressful, unpredictable moment-by-moment.

Is this a far cry from the mostly quiet and moody horror of games past? Of course. But a change of execution is not intrinsically synonymous with a loss of achievement or simple enjoyment.

Resident Evil 4's legacy continues in the Resident Evil 2 remake and the upcoming Resident Evil 3 remake, both swapping the fixed-angles and tank controls for that now classic over-the-shoulder camera.


4. Okami

Okami Capcom
Capcom

Okami released on the PlayStation 2 and then Wii to unimpressive sales, despite critical acclaim. Gamers either didn't know what to make of the "Zelda knockoff", or didn't yet have a gateway to appreciate the game's roots in classical/mythological Japan.

Protagonist Amaterasu, the Shinto sun goddess in wolf form, uses brush strokes to revitalize environments, solves puzzles and defeat enemies. Another game from 2006 overshadowed Okami though - The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, in which the player spends significant portions of the game as... a wolf.

Therefore, playing as a wolf with the staples of a Zelda game was already in a Zelda game itself. Also, Okami's cel-shaded style had already been implemented in ANOTHER Zelda game - The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker, which received fan backlash at launch for being "too cartoonish".

However, in hindsight, Okami has been recognized as an artistic game, particularly because Amaterasu is a literal artist of nature.

She brings life and balance to her realm with slashes and swirls controlled by the player. (Oh, and the 2017 remaster made perfect use of the PS4's rarely implemented touch pad, allowing players to use their own fingertips to paint alongside Amaterasu.)


3. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Metal Gear Solid 2
Konami

In 1998, Hideo Kojima deserved our pity because of the overwhelming fan demand for a Metal Gear Solid sequel. Kojima didn't want to make one despite the critical acclaim.

However, that demand inevitably resulted in his 2001 sequel, the first "postmodern video game" - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty.

Play as MGS1's protagonist Solid Snake? Only in the first two hours of the game within a tanker the marketing pitched as the focal setting - it wasn't. Then, the player takes control of Raiden, whose long blond hair and "feminine" appearance were triggers for fans of Solid Snake's gruff stoicism.

Political commentary/existential philosophy? Consider the ominous control and selective distribution of information that leads consumers into funding a shadow organization secretly ruling the world. (Makes one uncomfortably aware whilst sitting on the couch playing the game, eh?)

Fourth-wall breaks? Guiding voice "Colonel Campbell" is actually an AI that reveals how Raiden’s virtual-reality training simulations are similar to those the player used for practice in MGS1. Also, this AI orchestrated Raiden's mission to mimic the terrorist incident from MGS1... with the goal of creating a new Solid Snake. (You know, the player/Raiden.)

Between the game and the player, who is playing whom?


2. God Of War (2018)

God Of War Kratos Atreus
Sony

#notmykratos, am I right?!

Jokes aside...

Other than a few prequels and interquels to fill in the gaps, God of War did not continue Kratos's story until 8 years after the debut of God of War III.

Cory Barlog, director of God of War II, returned in 2018 to drop Kratos into Norse mythology. No more Ancient Greek trappings or a revenge narrative ending with the destruction of anything between Kratos and his goal.

Kratos has married and started a family again, and another wife's death begins his journey... but not to kill a god, not to seek vengeance, not to enact nihilistic rage.

But so that he and his son Atreus can scatter Faye's ashes atop the peak of the highest mountain in Midgard, inadvertently and finally beginning a genuine father-son relationship.

"Ugh, but he's not alpha anymore - he's too chill and quiet and restrained."

Yes. That's the point.

A mature comeuppance of sorts for fans of the original games, God of War reminds players how they've - hopefully - grown beyond glorifying violence for violence's sake. Players have to live with the consequences of their actions, whilst also trying to spare others from repeating the same mistakes.


1. The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD
Nintendo

1998 - Ocarina of Time. The first Zelda on N64. Young Link and Adult Link save Hyrule through a time-travel narrative.

Fans: Innovative! Masterpiece!

2000 - Majora's Mask. Focused on a surreal plot with emphasis on side-quests, looking and playing similar to its predecessor. Whilst only Young Link is playable, the darker tone delivers a mature game.

Fans: Innovative! Spooky masterpiece!

Also 2000 - Nintendo debuts a tech demo of Adult Link and Ganondorf's climactic fight from Ocarina of Time, promising a more realistic Zelda game.

Fans: Innovative! The future is here!

2002 - The Wind Waker: Link is a child the entire game, and it looks like a cartoon.

Fans: Wait! Where's the dark and realistic Zelda game the tech demo promised?!

Define irony: To create a more balanced style, Skyward Sword and Breath of the Wild implemented The Wind Walker’s cel-shading with just a touch of the more realistic design from Twilight Princess.

Furthermore, due to its dusk-heavy lighting, Twilight Princess has not aged as well as Wind Waker. Like, whatsoever.

We can somewhat forgive fans in light of the 2000 tech demo, but ultimately, Wind Waker is a clear inspiration on its own series (and Zelda-honoree, Okami).


In this post: 
God of War
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

33 and doesn't look a thing like Jesus. English teacher with a Master’s degree. Neutral-good Malazan.