8 Video Games That Should Have Been Movies

From home cinema to the silver screen.

We happy few
Compulsion Games

As video game budgets balloon to almost Mr. Creosote levels in the current day and age, so do their ambitions. As time has moved on many video games have mined deep into the realm of the "cinematic" in the hopes of being seen as "art" alongside their silver screen counterpart.

This means a focus on deep emotionally driven narratives, complex character arcs that feel believable and relatable, and of course a metric shedload of money being thrown at developers in order to make video game projects "look" like films.

It's a journey that almost feels bizarre looking back at where the medium was in the 80s and 90s, where coin collecting, point-chasing, one screen of text explaining the story (if you're lucky) was considered the norm, especially now that we have trilogies of games that carry on a continuous narrative or are so intricately created that you have to applaud the writers and art directors for creating something so beautiful.

However in some cases, video games possibly go a little too far in their pursuit of the cinematic and arguably offer little actual gameplay to speak of, and it's in these instances we all throw up our hands and say "Well why weren't you just a film?"

8. L.A. Noire

LA Noire
Team Bondi

With Team Bondi sinking a sizeable portion of their budget into new facial capture tech in order to bring their lofty vision of "being able to see the lie", there was considerable pressure on L.A. Noire to deliver the crime-caper goods upon release.

And in this one area, it bloody well did.

However, while looking for facial ticks and sweaty brows was a novel and interesting feature, the rest of the title did feel like it was dragging a heavy load to keep pace, as the gunfights often felt clunky and the very world around you empty and devoid of anything truly interesting to do. This is an almighty shame because the tale on show here really is one of the ages and one that fits perfectly with the Noire film genre.

It's got everything, corrupt cops, murders, scandal, and tragedy, all of which would make for one hell of a film without any of the meaningless downtime driving around quiet streets at a max of 50 miles an hour. Hell, you hired actors for this game and then painstakingly digitized them so why not use the exact same cast and shoot a big-budget movie instead?

Likely wouldn't have had such a massive falling out with Rockstar and their crunch culture either!


7. F-Zero Climax

F Zero Gx Captain Falcon 786636
Nintendo

So you might be thinking to yourself, "pretty sure the plot of F-Zero Climax is Space Car Zoom Zoom so why the hell do you think this GBA game should have been a film you stupid small-eyed toad?"

Well firstly, jokes on you my eyes are actually normal-sized it's just my head is massive, and secondly, because deep within this pixellated handheld game is a story worth telling on the big screen. Plus let's face it Climax is the weakest game in the franchise, if only because every other entry is an absolute banger. Plus Plus the world needs more F-Zero in general so just give me this one.

The story in question centers on a brand new cast of characters, one of which is Rick Wheeler, who admittedly debuted in the prior GB game, but truly takes center stage here as he dons the mantle of the New Captain Falcon. This moment could provide the entire drive of the movie, seeing Rick grow up watching the original Captain as a kid, mastering racing himself, and then finally continuing on the Captain's Legacy.

Plus if you took notes from the absolute masterclass in animation that is the film Redline then you would for sure have a game that felt as fast on the screen as it does in real life.


6. Afro Samurai 2: Revenge Of Kuma

afro samurai 2
Redacted Studios

For those not in the know, and quite possibly for those looking for a copy of this game seeing as the IP it's based on is quite literally the coolest thing going, Afro Samurai 2: Revenge Of Kuma was a title so unanimously hated by critics and fans that the devs out and out apologized for its existence before then deleting digital copies of it from every single storefront possible.

It was that bad, trust me I've played it.

However what truly sucked about the entire experience was that there was a brilliant story here, yet was one just covered in total and utter horseshit. The narrative picks up after the first film with Kuma seeking revenge against Afro. His hatred for the titular character stems from the fact that Afro killed the pair's master in order to take the Number 2 headband from him in order to challenge the Number 1 and avenge his father.

This tale of revenge fits beautifully next to the wider cyclical nature of violence that Afro finds himself in and to have to murder his childhood friend not once but twice is one that is tragic and emotional in equal measure. As a film sitting alongside the other animated media in the franchise, it would have allowed fans another opportunity to delve into the cyber-wild west style of the film.

Instead, all we got was a lukewarm dollop of nothingness that tasted only of what could have been.


5. Mega Man Legends

Mega Man Legends
Capcom

Now I won't lie here, the main reason I'm putting this entry on the list is because I truly want more people to appreciate how special Mega Man Legends was, as it encompassed a real break from the formula, came with a beautiful new coat of paint and tried to push forward in new and innovative ways.

So of course it died a commercial death.

Now before I bemoan that this game was a gem unfairly buried, there is one point of contention that many had with the game that I have to concede didn't help in the slightest. The bloody camera controls.

In a world of ropey, slippery, and clipping cameras Mega Man Legends is right up there with Drake of the 99 Dragons, and for many it was the sledgehammer that broke the camel's back, meaning they never got to truly immerse themselves into this charming world.

As a film, this would obviously remedy this key issue while also allowing us more time to get to know the wonderful cast of villains in the form of the Bonne family, and allow for kid-friendly action to play out on the big screen which you just know fans would eat up.

With this obvious success on their hands, then you make the video game and do so with a sizeable fanbase ready to see the gameplay switch up.


4. Anything By David Cage

detroit become human
Quantic Dream

So, let's be honest, David Cage is a man who seems trapped in the wrong industry, because every single game he has a hand in always comes with the same underlying message of "Please for the love of God let me make a full-blown movie"

I say this because all of his projects possess a cinematic focus which often comes at the detriment of any actual gameplay. Think about it, at most in titles like Heavy Rain, or Beyond Two Souls all you really do is move a character from one space to another and any action within is presented in QTE form.

It's just a series of decisions taking you from one beautifully crafted setpiece to another and when the term "plays like a movie" is often thrown at these projects, that's a clear sign that maybe someone should just give him an actual camera and crew to work with.

This isn't to slight the games in question, but you have to admit that the "gameplay" of these titles is so minimal and sometimes feels so tacked on, that it can sometimes take away from the stories being told, especially when they're used to pad out the runtime. Is it any wonder that "full movie" searches for his games are among the most viewed videos for each title?


3. Death Stranding

Death Stranding
Kojima Productions

Ok so hear me out on this one. I actually quite like Death Stranding for what it is, and for what Hideo Kojima tried to say with this game. It's just....maybe he could have said those things a little bit more concisely?

I mean come on did we really need a two-hour cutscene at the end of the game? That's literally a movie in itself! And the repetitive missions in the third act really did feel like things were being phoned in somewhat.

So what about we take this massive whale, cut out all of the blubber, and fashion a two, maybe a three-hour movie (but that's it Hideo afterward we're cutting you off) and use all of the wonderful characters and the rich world that's been created to tell a more focused tale.

All the pieces are there as well, a man looking to literally rebuild humanity, an ever-present threat of explosive death, and giant BT's that could make for entrancing setpieces.

Chuck in your baby buddy cop pal and you've got a story with heart, danger, and meaning that wouldn't overstay its welcome by about ten hours.


2. Lost Odyssey

Lost Odyssey
Mistwalker

After completing Lost Odyseey on the Xbox 360, I sat back and exhaled deeply before commenting.

"That was the most fun I've had with a boring game"

And it's true, because at its core Lost Odyssey has a great story to tell but does so in the most padded and bland way possible. With endless reams of dialogue repeating the same story points over and over, plus enough filler to make some Naruto arcs feel concise, Lost Odyssey dragged itself out at least ten hours more than it should have.

I get that JRPGs are usually a long-form storytelling format but there were so many moments where you could feel that all the gameplay department had to work on from the writing team was "Apathetic Shrug for two hours". The combat system might have been nicely conceived but it was relied upon too much to the point where battling felt like a chore come to the end of the game.

On the big screen this tale of wars long gone, immortal souls and corrupt civilisations would have been one for the fantasy record books, but on the 360 it came across with a big bang of "we've got Final Fantasy at home"


1. We Happy Few

We Happy Few Rat Pinata
Compulsion Games

Before I start tearing this game apart, I am aware that a multitude of patches and expansive DLC has made We Happy Few a much more rounded affair in the gameplay department since it's launch as well as a title that boasts some clever storytelling in its add-ons, however upon launch there was only one word to describe this game.

Disappointing.

The disconnect between the outstanding setting of a pilled-up Swinging 60's Britain clashed hard with the tried and tested (read: boring) survival and stealth driver gameplay, which is such as shame as the lead-in marketing for this game had me falling in love with the style and eerie tones.

There's also a great story at play too with our hero Arthur trying to find out what happened to his brother and the world around him, and the flashes between what those see on the drug Joy versus reality could have been used to great effect in a film as it was one of the few factors that worked in the game.

It's just a shame that the actual gameplay was so worn out and frustrating that in many ways it sapped what joy the story provided, as it was so janky in places that soon it became a nightmare experience for all the wrong reasons.


Watch Next


In this post: 
We Happy Few
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.