8 Video Games That Tragically Wasted Their Genius Premise

Some people's eyes are too big for their stomachs. Some developers' ambitions are too big for their ability.

Video games are a dime a dozen these days, but finding one that can accurately execute its premise is seemingly rare. It's a sad fact of life that not every game developer's vision comes to fruition. In fact, so much can go wrong when converting ideas into art. Just think of it this way €“ the developer has to ensure that his premise is communicated accurately, but must also maintain a certain level of quality throughout the design while lying under the heel of authority that insists the developer adhere to some regulations, a budget and a deadline. In this list, we focus on those ambitious games that failed to execute what could have been an ingenius new way to enjoy their respected genres. If you're a gamer, then chances are some of these titles may have disappointed you for their poor execution of such ideas. Read on....

8. Knack

At first glance, Sony Computer Entertainment's Knack for the PlayStation 4 seemed like both a fresh and exciting romp for fans of action platformers and a good way to kick off the launch of the console. Like most platforming heroes, Knack had a gimmick for reaching ledges and stomping on enemies, but his over-arching premise seemed nothing short of genius. The autonomous hero's unique power allowed him to shape shift into larger masses and back by collecting an losing fragments of relics respectively. Unfortunately, the premise of Knack would come undone thanks to oddly placed limitations not common in platformers. Combat in Knack was repetitious and boring thanks to a simple beat-em-up scheme and Knack's miniscule bag of tricks that took little advantage of his ability to shape-shift. When used for exploration and platforming, Knack's powers were especially limited due to the linear map design and the player's lack of freedom for choosing which elemental relics to use whenever possible. Other complaints can be used to explain Knack's overall disappointing appeal including story, linearity and repetitiveness, but the real bottomline is the game wasted one hell of a good premise thanks to being bland.

7. Dark Void

Ever wondered what it would be like if Gears of War had jet packs? Instead of just sliding into cover, you could also fly to cover and shoot enemies above or below you. Genius, right? The added dimension seemed intriguing to try in a cover based shooter, which is exactly what Airtight Games tried to execute in their sci-fi shooter, Dark Void. As a human resistance fighter armed with a weaponised jetpack while battling aliens on another world, the player was afforded both the tactics of standard cover system for terra firma and the vertical cover system when resorting to ariel battles via a jetpack. Sounds cool, doesn't it. Too bad it's anything but that. The cover system seemed fairly incompetent, whereas sliding or flying into cover with the press of a button felt sticky. Even run-and-gunning wasn't spared from flaws, courtesy of an odd, counter-intuitive move where enemies could be floored easier with just one punch compared to bullets. The only saving grace was the dogfighting, but that doesn't last long since the campaign is pretty short. Oh, and there's no multiplayer, so you can't bring this admittedly lunatic formula into a server and smash your mates around. Shame, really. Dark Void could have been so much more if the developer had flown further.

6. Brink

First-person shooters have become the biggest genre in the video game industry due to their basic gun-action premise. Unfortunately, this has also been the genre's biggest downfall. Now it's required for developers to think outside the box when approaching the genre and Splash Damage seemed to be adhering to this requirement with their title, Brink. Or so we thought. Indeed, Brink had high hopes of being a revolutionary team-based shooter thanks to two unique novelties. Firstly, its campaign would combined single-player populated with bots and multiplayer seamlessly through a drop in/drop out online mechanic. And secondly, its patented S.M.A.R.T. system would allow players to manoeuvre across the map while avoiding obstacles parkour-style with just the press of a button. Both features made Brink seem magical to those who were anticipating it. So what went wrong? Firstly, the campaign's bots had apparently skipped school as they couldn't figure out how to properly support the player or even themselves without tumbling around obstacles that were sticking out in front of them. As for the S.M.A.R.T. system, if we give it it's due, it was fairly reliable. However, for such a barnstorming new innovation, 'fairly' doesn't cut it €“ it would sometimes struggle with negotiating the various ledges, balconies or walls throughout the maps, leaving your uncoordinated avatar humping a wall while enemies cut him to ribbons. While Brink has improved somewhat with patches, these initial problems were all that were needed to sabotage its premise.

5. Aliens: Colonial Marines

From the beginning it seemed that SEGA's multi-platform first-person shooter, Aliens: Colonial Marines was destined to crumble under its own weight given the six long year development hell it underwent before release. However, when Borderlands developer Gearbox finally stepped up to the plate to take over development from in 2008, gamers felt relieved €“ at least for the time being. Gearbox's vision for a topnotch adaptation of Ridley Scott's Aliens franchise almost appeared flawless in the demonstrations leading up to launch. Everything was there; from the most detailed depiction of alien-infested colonies to the authentic Marines, note-perfect right down to the weapons and equipment used for hunting down their phallus-headed adversaries. Unfortunately, ACM's premise was completely dismantled by a wide variety of common bugs and amateur-ish design choices too unforgiveable even for Gearbox. Simply put, one just has to think of everything that could ruin a first-person shooter to have a good idea why ACM failed. Just go down the list €“ inferior console ports? Check. Graphical bugs? Check. Horrendously stupid AI? Check. Horrible controls for the aliens in multiplayer? Check. Uninspired multiplayer modes? Check. After its release, ACM was a total flop, and a shady Gearbox came under fire from all sides.

4. Adventure Time: Explore The Dungeon Because I DON'T KNOW!

Adapting a children's show into a video game shouldn't be too hard since most of the material is already written out for the game developers. It's especially seamless if that show draws inspiration from video games like Cartoon Network's popular Adventure Time for example. The show takes cliches from popular dungeon crawlers and weaves them into its gleeful plots with ingenious results. So it was only a matter of time before some developer seized the opportunity to create a brilliant dungeon crawler starring our heroes Finn and Jake going on their adventures as the premise. Unfortunately, Adventure Time: Explore The Dungeon Because I DON'T KNOW! from WayForward isn't that dungeon crawler. In fact, ATETDBIDK isn't even much of a dungeon crawler since it lacks all the essentials for such a game. Although you have an assortment of unique characters to choose from €“ each with his/her own unique power €“ that's all you're getting. Where are the deep character customization options, special attacks, powerful weapons and equipment, intricate dungeon layouts, hidden areas, and memorable enemies? Nowhere is where. In the end, ATETDBIDK proved to be another quick cash grab destined for the garbage bin with the exception of having a cryptic subtitle for a clue.

3. Grand Theft Auto Online

Although Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto series isn't exactly unfamiliar with multiplayer €“ it finally took the plunge in GTA IV €“ it has remained fairly competent due to bugs and limitations. Dropping multiple player controlled criminals into a sandbox where anything goes can be quite challenging especially when you don't get it right the first time. Rockstar promised to not only get it right, but also expand on it beyond measurement with Grand Theft Auto V's upcoming online portion called GTA Online. Players could jump in and wage street wars against each other. Or band together to form crews and engage in their own Hollywood-style heists and celebrate afterward. Or simply paint the town red for all they care. Simply put, the sky was the limit with GTAV's online space. Sadly, it don't go as well as planned. On launch, GTA Online was ransacked by bugs that prevented players from saving their loadouts or even loggin on and by cheaters acting like real world criminals in a simulated criminal underworld. if Rockstar had truly moved Heaven and Earth just trying to launch the mode, the developer would have to go beyond the effort just to fix these problems. Yet both the developer and its game just couldn't seem to catch a break, $500,000 bribe be damned. Fortunately, GTA Online is doing so much better now that Rockstar has eliminated most of these problems. But it was a bumpy ride to get there, and the premise suffered a great deal along the way.

2. Beyond: Two Souls

The single, most obvious problem with interactive story games is that they limit the player's impact in the world; they are strictly an on-rails experience that restrict control. In order to hide this despair from the player, developers offer them choices with rewards and repercussions. Sadly, not all interactive story games offer enough, and Quantic Dreams' Beyond: Two Souls for the PlayStation 3 is one of them, which is a shame since it could have been the most innovative entry in the genre. On paper, Beyond: Two Souls seemed to have what it all for surpassing its predecessor Heavy Rain in regards to Hollywood-style quality; it featured a a seemingly riveting sci-fi plot as well as some of the most breathtaking character models coupled with critically acclaimed actors like Ellen Page and William Dafoe to go with it. The problem starts with the narrative that struggles to find its own identity when juggling several genre types including psychological horror, emotional drama, action thriller and more, making it quite disjointed. What's worse is that through this narrative players will find the gameplay with both Ellen Page's character Jodie Holmes and her poltergiest-like pal Aiden as ridiculously simplistic, full of tasks laid out for them and no room for dynamism Also the game only hands out few choices in critical moments and even fewer rewards waiting for them. In the end, Beyond: Two Souls features an incoherent and uncontrollable mess for a premise. This is especially sad because at first glance, it could've been so much more, like Heavy Rain with an intriguing hook and no Boston-South African accents.

1. Super Mario 3D World

As confusing as it may seem, the placement of Nintendo's Super Mario 3D World in this list can be justified by exposing the tiniest chink in it's armour that consequentially ruined its premise. As it stands, the critically acclaimed Wii U exclusive platformer doesn't seem to fit this list at all since it perfectly balances nostalgic platforming, innovative 3d environments and a perfectly balanced, competitive co-op multiplayer almost perfectly. So what's wrong in 3D World? Believe it or not, it's the multiplayer. Again, SM3DW features what is considered the most balanced €“ if not best -- multiplayer experience of all Super Mario games. However, that's true only to those who have never heard or cared for the online experience. Sadly Nintendo hasn't either, which is why all of those who own the game are forced to put up with sharing the experience strictly on a couch. What's worse is that the Wii U currently supports only one Gamepad, forcing the other three players to fend with Wii Remotes and Pro Controllers. hence, someone is obviously going to feel left out from experiencing the console's marvellous novelty that combines companion devices with peripherals. Besides that, nothing else seems to interfere with SM3DW's overall appeal. But for those who enjoy playing their friends, family and strangers from around the world, the appeal feels compromising.

Contributor
Contributor

Ryan was born in Barbados and grew up with a pen in one hand and a paper in the other. He is an accomplished blogger, freelance writer and vlogger. He is also an avid gamer (in case you couldn't tell from the things he writes about).