8 Video Games Whose Best Endings You Never Saw

Sometimes a "bad" ending is way more satisfying than the "good" one.

Mafia III
2K

For better or worse, the interactive nature of video games - and the fact that they try to tell "your" story as much as the writer's - means they often aren't confined by a single, official ending.

Sometimes this gives developers an excuse to throw in joke climaxes that reward the most dedicated players (the world of Silent Hill being controlled by a dog being a particular highlight), however they often allow the writers to explore multiple different endings that are just as detailed as the one considered canon.

That said, you can usually tell when you've achieved a "bad" ending, either on purpose for being an ***hole and making "evil" choices while you're playing, or by failing an integral part of the story and dooming characters (and sometimes the world) in the process.

However, while sometimes these finales are a punishment, they can occasionally outshine the "proper" ending the writers decide is official, giving players a more satisfying finale they wish was real.


8. Secret Brainwashing - Far Cry 5

Far Cry 5
Ubisoft

The canon ending of Far Cry 5 is a complete shambles. Throwing you a last-minute choice to either give up on your crusade and leave Joseph Seed to his own devices or actually take the murderer down, if you finish your objective and choose the latter option then the world just... explodes. Bringing Seed in triggers a nuclear holocaust (for some reason - it's never confirmed whether it was his doing), implying that he actually may have been right the whole time.

Visually, it's a stunning ending, but it doesn't make a lick of sense, and muddies the themes the rest of the narrative were seemingly building up. However, if you decide to walk away and escape with your squad, you'll be treated to something equally downbeat, but the game at least sets it up prior to it happening.

Whilst driving away a song comes on the radio - the very same song which brainwashed you earlier and made you kill your own allies. Your eyes fixate on the passengers and the screen ominously cuts to black. It's similarly as daft, but it makes for a far more believable ending.


7. Niko Takes Revenge - Grand Theft Auto IV

Grand Theft Auto 4
Rockstar

Even though it's been completely overshadowed by its world-conquering sequel, Grand Theft Auto IV's story of Niko Bellic and his bowling-loving cousin Roman marked a step up in storytelling for Rockstar, who moved away from the over-the-top genre pastiches of previous games to tell a more "mature" tale this time around.

They also flirted with divergent story branches as well, allowing players to achieve different endings depending on how they navigated the criminal underworld. If you do everything right you could cut a deal and attempt to shake off the heat you've acquired, going to Roman's wedding and enjoying a small moment of respite. Of course, the people you cut a deal with betray you, and a bullet primed for Nico ends up taking out his cousin instead.

That's a pretty good ending, but you can opt to avoid the deal and instead hunt down Niko's enemies, taking the violent route and getting his girlfriend Kate killed in the process. Though both endings get somebody murdered, it's the latter which is more emotionally affecting, and suits the violent tendencies Niko's succumbed to so many times before.


6. Nobody Wins - Resident Evil

Resident Evil
Capcom

When Resident Evil came out back in 1996, nobody was writing home about its story. Sure, it was great to involve yourself in the cheesy one-liners and revel in the ridiculously camp cut-scenes, but the narrative infamously undermined much of the horror present in the actual gameplay.

That same sensibility made its way into most of the endings as well, capping the game off with the heroes flying away from an explosion after shooting the main boss with a rocket launcher. While they were inline with the rest of the narrative, they were surprisingly upbeat considering how horrific the experience had been up to then, and it rang a little false.

However, the sole survivor ending remedies this somewhat. The basic story beats are the same, but instead of everyone getting out and living happily ever after, it's instead only your specific character who escapes, with the ending lingering on their battered body.

It's suitable sombre, and appropriately reflective of the tense experience you've just clawed your way through.


5. The Beast Unleashed - Infamous 2

Infamous 2
Sony

Infamous 1 and 2 weren't really the most complex games when it came to moral choices, but the two distinctive "good" and "bad" endings the developers came up with were often as enjoyable as each other. The second title took that one step further though, and its "bad" ending was way more satisfying overall.

After a huge creature known only as The Beast rises, protagonist Cole promises to carry on its legacy, taking on the mantle himself and attempting to build a new world for super-powered conduits like him to prosper, all the while shunning humans. Though it's far darker than the alternative, it was a better, less neat fit with the narrative as a whole. So good, in fact, that it was actually going to the be official canon.

When the developers came together and hashed out the story for the next entry in the series, this was what they were originally building off, until trophy data revealed the majority of players actually chose the "good" ending, indicating they should probably honour that.


4. Killer At Large - The Suffering

The Suffering
Midway Games

An overlooked masterpiece of the PS2 generation, The Suffering's story about a convict on death row, who suddenly finds himself battling creatures birthed from the inherent evil in the prisoners, made for a superbly sickly psychological action game.

The main character, Torque, has been sentenced to death on account of brutally killing his two children and ex-wife, a crime which he claims he didn't commit. The good ending clarifies that he actually wasn't responsible for the deaths, but instead his family was killed by hitmen, something which makes sense but feels a little like a copout.

While there is something in the idea of a good man being taken to the island and being corrupted, the fact that he eventually shakes this off and continues to be something of a hero felt at odds with the tone. The bad ending, however, which reveals he did indeed kill his family and couldn't resist the temptations of the island fit more satisfyingly with a game as grim as this.


3. Destroy All Humans - Prey

Prey ending
Arkane Studios

The ending of Prey is a bit of a sticking point for fans, as the epilogue reveals that everything you had accomplished over the course of the narrative was merely a simulation of an event which eventually led to the end of the Earth.

It turns out that you were never playing as Morgan Yu, but an alien creature put into the consciousness of the scientist, and thrown into the same world-ending scenario the real Yu was involved in, in order to analyse the decisions it made.

The plan is to see if the aliens themselves are capable of learning empathy and other human traits, in the hopes of creating a creature able to push back against the scourge currently destroying the planet. Like everything in the game though, you essentially get to decide whether or not this conditioning works, either joining the cause or killing everyone in sight and dooming the human race.

It's the latter option which is the most satisfying, as while it dooms the planet, there's also the implication that it was the humans' own fault for accidentally creating an even deadlier enemy.


2. Welcome To Dubai - Spec Ops: The Line

Spec ops the line
2K

You don't need me to tell you that Spec Ops: The Line has one of the best stories in all of gaming, but while its original ending is great already, its alternate "evil" climax is perhaps even more inline with the actions of main character Walker.

Throughout the entire story you realise that the soldier has slowly been losing his mind, sparked primarily after killing a whole host of civilians with white phosphorous, with the villain "Konrad" being a mere figment of his imagination.

Walker comes to terms with his own psychosis and calls to be extracted from Dubai, however when he's greeted by the patrol he can either surrender his weapon and go home, or attempt to gun them down and give in to his villainous side.

Gunning them down is, of course, the bad decision, but it's the most thematically rich, showing Walker signing off with the line "Gentlemen, welcome to Dubai" - the exact words "Konrad" greeted him with at the very beginning.


1. Father James Whacks Lincoln - Mafia III

Mafia III
2K

Like with the beginning, Mafia III ends on a very strong note. After hunting down the men responsible for destroying his family and shooting him in the head, Lincoln Clay has built his own crime empire, with the epilogue giving the player final say over how he's going to operate the syndicate going forward.

If you don't want to share the power, you can opt to take out your sub-bosses and run everything yourself, making Lincoln a bona-fide celebrity in the process. However, while you might think you've taken out all loose ends, there's one man still around to bring you to justice: Father James. He can't live with himself for letting you go down the path of self-destruction, and actually places a bomb in your car to assassinate you.

Father James has been a voice of reason all the way through the title, and Lincoln indulges far too much in his revenge even if you try to steer him into the light. The character doesn't really get a great close to his story in the "good" ending, but this explosive murder is exactly what his prior interactions with Lincoln were all seemingly lead up to.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Far Cry 5
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.