9 Dark Video Game Secrets You DON'T Want To Find
Red Dead and The Last of Us get GRIM.
While there’s rarely anything we don’t love about video game secrets, references, and easter eggs, that’s not to say they’re all fun in-jokes and charming additions.
Those kinds of secrets are certainly prevalent and have their place but they aren’t the only kind of hidden curiosity you can stumble upon in a video game. In this list we’re digging into the discoveries that are quite a bit darker.
Whether due to their implications, how they sit within the lore of the game, or what they ask of the player, these video game secrets had some of us feeling like we could have been just fine going the rest of our lives without the extra knowledge. Misery loves company though so whether you’ve happened upon these entries yourself or you’re a sucker for creepy easter eggs already, by the end of this list we’ll all know a good extra handful of unsettling video game things.
--
9. The Mirror Room - Silent Hill 3
Not all the dark secrets on this list which you wouldn’t want to find are dark because they’re actually scary but this one combines Silent Hill and horror movie mirror trickery so, yeah, this one’s just straight up creepy.
You’re told that Silent Hill 3 heroine Heather Mason is not a real big fan of mirrors and being the horror juggernaut that it is, Silent Hill is pretty good at making sure you exit the game being no friend of mirrors, either. Where Team Silent really hits the nail on the head for this one is in the Store Room on the third floor of the Brookhaven Hospital.
This room is pretty much empty except for an enormous mirror, look at it long enough and you’ll see blood crawl around the room before Heather’s own reflection corrupts and turns bloody as well.
If this is all feeling like easy mode so far, the door to the room locks and the scene comes to a head with Heather’s reflection freezing and staring at her while you try to navigate your way out of the room which is now covered in blood. You can’t break the mirror and if you stay in the room too long your health will deplete.
This room is totally optional but totally terrifying so if you’re a scaredy cat who found it and had to endure it despite getting no reward, you’d be forgiven for wishing you’d never gone in.
8. Isabela Is A Murderous Slave Trader - Dragon Age II
This next secret is definitely dark and something I bet you wish you didn’t want to know but I’m going to tell you anyway because if I have to know it then you do too. The pirate queen Isabela is a fan favourite character in Dragon Age II and why wouldn’t she be? She’s fun, roguish, super hot, and plenty charming.
Unfortunately, it turns out we may have been a little blinded by that charm since there’s a pretty important part of her backstory most of us were ignorant of.
The canon comic Dragon Age: Those Who Speak reveals that prior to being our lovable rapscallion companion, Isabela was pretty big on the slave-trafficking scene. At one point, even going as far as to throw the slaves she had in her hold overboard when she was being pursed by an Orlesian ship in order to get away. In the events of Dragon Age II she’s clearly hugely repentant and anti-slaver but once you know, you know, and this one is pretty hard for us to gloss over.
I’m just glad after learning this that I decided not to romance Isabela and instead chose Anders who is obviously not problematic at all.
7. Mr X. Never De-Spawns - Resident Evil 2 Remake
It’s pretty common knowledge by this point that antagonist Lisa from P.T. ties herself to your character and always hangs out behind you even when you can’t see her.
If you thought you could leave the nightmare fuel behind by simply not playing P.T., though, you’d be sorely mistaken because Resident Evil 2 Remake does a similar thing. The YouTube show Boundary Break discovered that the hulking tyrant with a snazzy hat, Mr. X, never actually despawns and he is always looking for you. Unlocking the camera revealed that Mr. X is always walking around the map trying to spot you even if he’s super far away in actuality.
You’d expect he only spawns up near you or he simply doesn’t exist but knowing he’s just roaming the halls the whole time is unnerving to say the least.
There are absolutely times he’s scripted to spawn or despawn but otherwise we now know that The T-00’s menacing stalking never actually stops, even when the tyrant is nowhere to be seen, so that’s something you probably never wanted to know.
6. An Especially Grim Fate - Red Dead Redemption 2
Few video games go hand in hand with horrible dark secrets you wish you’d never come across quite like Red Dead Redemption 2. While we’ve pretty comprehensively covered nasty discoveries like the serial killer and the Braithwaite’s horrible treatment of Gertrude, there are some smaller horrifying things that don’t make lists as often so let’s take a walk down miserable memory lane and make sure you’re across those too.
Mosey by the Dakota river and you take a break from riding and fishing to stumble on the corpses of two children. Fun, I know. Nobody does it like Red Dead.
They can be seen lying on and up against a bed in a cabin, and a nearby note can be found that is written by their mother. The note suggests she’s had to leave them for a bit, but everything is locked, they shouldn’t open the door to anyone, there’s enough food to last them four days and she’ll be back soon.
Evidently she was not back soon for whatever reason and the children starved to death.
This is so incredibly grim but it ties in nicely to our next chilling entry so let’s keep this wildly unsettling train of dark video game secrets rolling.
5. They Didn’t Suffer - The Last of Us
It may be true that nobody does it like Red Dead but if you had to make the argument that another video game did, it’s probably got to be The Last of Us.
While we’re on the topic of the super depressing demises of characters who didn’t deserve their fates, let’s talk about Kyle and his kids.
The apocalypse wasn’t going too bad for Kyle and his family for a while there. They built a hideout of almost fifty residents and their encampment had a school, beds, and even showers. Sadly it went the way of everything in The Last of Us when the infected managed to breach the walls.
Kyle and some of the children fell back into a certain area of the sewers which you can happen upon and investigate if you’re just having way too good of a day. There you can see how it all went down. Presumably to prevent a far worse fate, Kyle ended the lives of himself and the children, but not before scrawling a message on the floor that reads “They didn’t suffer.”
I promise the next entry does not have any deceased children in it. Although, I can’t make any promises about the entry after that. Or the one after that. But we’ll cross that bridge when we get to it.
4. Creepy Mannequin Attack Of Your Own Making - Call of Duty: Black Ops III
Though it’s fairly well documented now, the zombie mannequins of the Nuketown map in Call of Duty: Black Ops III are a shocking easter egg you probably wouldn’t want to come across but totally deserved if you ran into it organically. For the uninitiated, shooting off the heads of every mannequin minding their own business around the map within the first two minutes of a match kicks off a whole lot of nope.
The mannequins will come to life and pursue you with what is a very reasonable vengeance kick given all your unwarranted headshots.
It’s definitely terrifying all of sudden being attacked by a swarm of robot mannequins that move around like zombies, but if you want to up the ante again, there is a way. Shooting off every one of the statue’s arms instead will kick off a different version of the attack where the mannequins go all Weeping Angel on you, not moving so long as you’re looking at them.
You’ll quickly be overwhelmed no matter where you look because there’s just loads of the dudes but, again, you kind of had this one coming.
3. Cannibalism Or Starvation - Until Dawn
Supermassive Games have proven themselves to be masters of horror storytelling once again with their recent hit The Quarry, but if we’re talking about the nastiest things you can uncover then their original must-play Until Dawn has it beat.
I have to go ahead and spoil a bit of the ending here to tell you about this one so if you don’t want to hear it then skip ahead and I’ll have more awful things to tell you about over at number two.
This one classifies as a secret because it’s entirely missable if you walk the wrong way, though I’m breaking my own rule by saying you won’t want to find i,t because it serves as an important piece of the puzzle that fleshes out the narrative.
It is, however, so horrible that once you discover it, you might have wished you hadn’t so I think we’re good to go with this one as an inclusion.
At the beginning of the game sisters Hannah and Beth tumble down a mine and it appears they both die from the impact. In a chilling late game reveal you discover that Hannah actually survived with a broken leg. Though she initially buried her sister, thirty days into being trapped with no sign of rescue Hannah resolved to dig her up and eat her corpse in order to survive.
As if that isn’t bad enough this is a game where cannibalism turns you into a beast called a Wendigo so Hannah then undergoes this transformation.
There are other hints that this is what’s befallen the two earlier in the game and you can work it out for yourself, but actually reading Hannah’s account through her diary is as sickening as it is revealing.
2. The Poisoned Family - Red Dead Redemption 2
When it comes to the most chilling things you can happen upon in a video game, Red Dead Redemption 2 is just the gift that keeps on giving so they’ve snuck in another entry that’s just as if not more horrifying than the last.
If you’re able to just enjoy the environmental storytelling here and not find this incredibly scarring you’ll probably appreciate this one but it’s a big ask to overlook how dark it is.
East of Emerald Station and West of Kamassa River you can find a place called Osmans Grove and this little area holds a pretty terrible sight for those who dare to investigate a certain cabin. Inside you’ll find an entire family dead including their young children and there appears to be some gas in the air. The best guess for most players is that the family died from carbon monoxide poisoning via exhaust from the stove pipe as they appear to have just finished a meal and died wherever they stood.
Pretty blood grim, Red Dead. Very on brand.
1. The Truth About Handymen - BioShock Infinite
There are many enemy types in video games whose backstory is much deeper and darker than you’d know. Half Life’s Headcrab Zombies are a popular example of this and BioShock Infinite’s Handymen fall into the same unsettling category. If you didn’t dig any deeper you probably just know the Handymen as the hulking half-man, half-mech brutes who can really mess you up in a combat arena if you get on the wrong side of them.
Because of how much trouble they can be in a fight you might not have a tonne of sympathy for them but you really should.
That’s because further investigation in Infinite and the Burial at Sea DLC reveals that Handymen are unwilling humans, often the sick or disabled, who have been forced into these hybrid bodies. It’s revealed that they are in constant pain, they can’t sleep, and are ostracised from society, all of which causes their outbursts of rage. In battle they’ll cry out telling you they’re in pain, suggesting the marvel that is their hybrid technology bodies aren’t so effective after all.
The reality of how Handymen are made and why they act the way they do is so damn dark you might feel like you were better off just seeing them as Infinite’s response to the Big Daddy.