9 Mediocre Video Games Made Awesome By Twists
A twist in time saves nine.
There’s been a longstanding question within the entertainment industry: can video games be considered art? This discussion has existed for decades but back in 2005, it was Roger Ebert who brought the question to prominence, arguing that gaming’s medium "prevents it from moving beyond craftsmanship to the stature of art."
It hardly needs saying that gamers look to titles for, well, their gameplay, but sometimes this isn’t enough to carry an experience alone. Many games rely on their artistic expression, channelling this through visuals, music or story.
We’ve witnessed a number of games saved by their story, stepping in when mechanics prove subpar, proving strong enough to turn opinions around and quite often, all this requires is a simple, effective plot twist.
Many games have famously included them, though this often proves detrimental to the experience. When executed well however, plot twists can elevate an average game into a great one, bringing a fresh new perspective to your actions.
With this in mind, here are some prominent examples that utilised twists to turn things around.
9. Crackdown 2 - The Villain Isn't The Villain
Crackdown’s long-awaited revival may have seen mixed reception last year upon arrival but before then, it’d been 2010 since we’d seen it. An open-world action adventure, Crackdown 2 took place 10 years after the original, finding Pacific City under threat from the “Freak” virus.
Ordered by The Agency, you’re informed that former Agency scientist Catalina Thorne caused this outbreak. Stating she performed unauthorised experiments, this led to her expulsion, and Crackdown 2 tells a tale of revenge. Seeing her infecting an agent cloning facility, she forms a terrorist group called “Cell”, who unleash Freak Pacific City’s population, claiming The Agency has its cure.
Except that’s not actually what happened at all. Through a series of collectable audio logs, it's revealed that The Agency manufactured Freak outbreak, providing incorrect public justification to maintain control of the city. Having seen her clinic invaded by Freaks, Thorne instead lead protests against The Agency and was targeted by their propaganda as a result.
It's a great twist, but it was no surprise to those who completed the original Crackdown, where it was revealed The Agency had manipulated Pacific City’s gang crisis behind the scenes, allowing them to save the day.
The sequel received mixed reviews, but this subtle revelation brings a whole new light to its plot.
8. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare - The Rogue One Ending
Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare left a strong impression on fans when it was first revealed, albeit a distinctly negative one. Moving towards a more futuristic setting, COD’s fanbase was split back in 2016, but its story held an interesting premise.
Playing as Commander Nick Reyes within the Special Combat Air Recon (SCAR) team, based within spaceship Retribution, it showed an Earth stripped of its natural resources, seeing humanity create new colonies across the Solar System.
Mining further planets, this draws interest from militant groups, leading to a struggle emerging between Earth’s United Nations Space Alliance (UNSA) and Martian separatist group, the Settlement Defense Force (SDF), led by Admiral Salen Kotch.
Escalating into war, Commander Reyes kills Kotch and devises a plan to destroy SDF’s orbital shipyard, crippling their fleet but crashing onto Mars’ surface in doing so. Rallying together the Retribution’s remaining crew, the team realises one thing: they aren’t going back to Earth alive.
This mission then turns into a last stand, seeing Retribution’s survivors mostly killed one by one, but in this moment, Reyes orders surviving crew members into an SDF Destroyer, himself heading to SDF’s control centre to untether it. As this is completed, Reyes orders a reluctant Lt. Salter to open fire on the centre, killing him in the process.
It’s a pivotal moment, turning the war in UNSA’s favour and Reyes’ sacrifice doesn’t get forgotten.
7. Metroid - The Big Reveal
Metroid may have become one of Nintendo’s more popular franchises, bringing in modern audiences through the Metroid Prime trilogy, but back in 1986, it was something of a mixed bag.
Playing as bounty hunter Samus Aran, it saw her attempting to retrieve a series of Metroid organisms from the Space Pirates seeking to use these creatures for biological weaponry.
Its approach to exploration inspired the “Metroidvania” sub-genre, but Metroid hasn’t aged particularly well by modern standards, largely surpassed by Nintendo’s Game Boy Advance remake, Metroid: Zero Mission, back in 2004.
However, it became highly noted for its twist that Samus is a woman, requiring players to beat Metroid within five hours to witness the reveal. It may not seem that significant in 2020 but back in 1986, this was a much bigger deal, seeing her become one of the first ever female protagonists in a major release.
6. Haze - You're In A Black Mirror Episode
It’s hard not to look at Haze and remind ourselves of its wasted potential. Initially deemed a “Halo killer”, Free Radical Design’s FPS game was a surprise miss after their acclaimed work on TimeSplitters, becoming their last release in 2008 before being bought out by Crytek.
You played as Sgt Shane Carpenter, a veteran soldier for the ruling Mantel Corporation. Controlling the world’s population through a drug called Nectar, it limits what each soldier sees, drowning out dead bodies and destruction.
Sent to eliminate a South American rebel group called The Promise Hand, Shane becomes aware of the drug’s effect on his surroundings after a series of failed injection attempts. Every war has two sides and upon meeting rebel leader Merino, Shane realises he's been on the wrong side of history.
Later rescued by rebels after suffering Nectar withdrawal, he’s discovers he’s been brainwashed by Mantel, having been fed propaganda this whole time. Swearing allegiance to Promise Hand, he then takes up their cause and starts destroying Mantel’s Nectar supplies.
The game received widespread criticism, but most agreed that it held promise, with it being the execution that was lacking. Its story wasn’t exempt from criticism but this twist brought to us the concept of a self-aware soldier.
It gave Haze some story redemption, though better examples have since followed.
5. Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword - Explaining The Cycle
Depending on who you ask about Skyward Sword, responses will likely vary. The last traditional Zelda game before Breath Of The Wild, it released back in 2011 on Nintendo Wii. Mostly seeing positive reception, it acted as a prequel to the main entries but was mainly criticised on two aspects.
Its linearity came under scrutiny, seeing producer Eiji Aonuma scrap this in favour of BOTW’s open-world but its controls were also criticised. Making awkward use of the Wii Remote’s motion controls, they’ve not exactly improved with age.
Set within Skyloft, a floating town above the clouds, we saw Link and Zelda as childhood friends before she becomes a princess. Seeing Zelda get kidnapped, we discover she’s the reincarnation of Hylia, an ancient goddess who disappeared after defeating the Demon King, Demise.
Captured by Ghirahim towards the end, he tries to revive Demise within the past by sacrificing Zelda. Upon his return, Demise challenges Link to battle but gets defeated, though it comes with a grave warning.
Cursing Link and Zelda, Demise tells them his hate will be reborn, cursing those that “share the blood of the goddess and the spirit of the hero” within a never-ending cycle, ensuring their battles are doomed to be repeated.
It explained a long-standing mystery, showing how these characters kept re-appearing across different games without any connection to previous titles. Demise eventually reincarnates into Ganondorf and true to his word, this cycle continues.
4. Castlevania: Lords Of Shadow - Gabriel Is A Vampire
Castlevania is more popular than ever, thanks to the Neflix adaptation, but on the gaming front, it’s been six years since we saw a new title. Back in 2010, Konami decided to reboot this classic popular through Lords of Shadow, developed by MercurySteam.
Bringing in a new 3D gameplay approach, it received positive reviews but moving away from 2D proved highly divisive amongst Castlevania’s established fanbase. Even for more traditional fans though, its story proved quite exceptional.
Set in 1047, Shadows starred Gabriel Belmont, finding Earth under threat by the Lords of Shadow after they’ve cast a dark spell on it. Separating Earth from Heaven, deceased souls are now trapped in limbo, Gabriel’s wife Marie amongst them and evil creatures terrorise the lands.
Heeding Zobek’s advice, Gabriel sets out to obtain the God Mask, being informed this can resurrect her but its split between these Lords. After obtaining them, Zobek reveals himself as the third Lord, granted this power by Satan himself.
Gabriel defeats Satan but realises he cannot revive Marie, this Mask only allowing him to see through God’s eyes. Its an ending full of twists but undoubtedly, the post-credits held a more shocking revelation.
Cutting to the modern era, we discover Zobek finding Gabriel is still alive but has turned into a vampire. Not just any Vampire though, Dracula himself.
Whilst later DLC explains how this occurred, finding a Belmont had become Castlevania’s big bad proved quite shocking, setting a bold new premise within Lords Of Shadow 2.
3. Telltale’s Game Of Thrones: Episode 1 - Ned Stark's Counterpart
Following on from their successful The Walking Dead series, it wasn’t long before Telltale began adapting other major franchises. Coming to us back in 2014, Game Of Thrones was next in line, and this episodic series took place within the TV series continuity.
Spanning from the Red Wedding to before Season 5’s opening, it saw mixed reviews but Episode 1 proved an interesting introduction and it’s a shame Telltale’s following episodes couldn’t live up to it.
Playing as members of House Forrester, a minor northern house based at Ironrath, your family finds itself on the wrong side of the “War Of The Five Kings” and Lord Gregor is slain by House Frey. His heir Rodrik is also presumed dead and second-born son Asher is exiled, so Ironrath’s lordship falls upon Gregor’s third son, Ethan.
Despite sending Gregor’s squire Gared to The Wall to appease the new Warden of The North, Roose Bolton, Episode 1 ends with his bastard Ramsay Snow paying Ironrath a visit. Acting as his father’s enforcer, he asks Lord Ethan to bend the knee, demanding they split their ironwood supplies with rival lords, House Whitehill.
It doesn’t matter how you treat Ramsay here, as it leads to a shocking outcome. Pulling a dagger on Ethan, the Bastard Of Bolton stabs him in the neck, fatally wounding him. It’s a classic case of Telltale utilising a false protagonist but it’s a twist few saw coming.
2. Nier - The Clone Saga
Nier: Automata received high praise when it launched in 2017 but back in 2010, its prequel Nier didn’t fare as well. A spinoff of Yoko Taro’s Drakengard series, Nier followed Drakengard’s fifth ending, seeing the Earth fall to decay, and Nier takes place one thousand years later.
It received mixed reviews, many criticising its gameplay systems but Nier’s story is its highlight, requiring multiple playthroughs to reach the true ending, an approach utilised within its sequel as well.
Playing the titular character, Nier focused on his attempts to locate a cure for the Black Scrawl, an illness his daughter Yonah is succumbing to. Joined by Kainé and Emil, Earth is plagued by aggressive monsters called Shades, which are led by the Shadowlord. Setting out to defeat him, they encounter Popola and Devola, who reveal the truth of this world.
Trying to save themselves from the Black Scrawl, Humanity separated its souls from their bodies, looking to fuse them inside disease-resistant clones, known as Replicants. What they didn’t anticipate however was that Replicants would develop their own consciousness, leaving their original humans without physical form.
Becoming resentful, humanity’s aggression manifested into Shades and upon defeating the Shadowlord, yet another twist unfolds. He reveals himself as the original Nier, confirming you’ve been playing a replicant this whole time.
For those who can forgive its gameplay, it’s a story that more than makes up for it, presenting an engaging adventure worth seeing through.
1. Spec Ops: The Line - Konrad Is Dead
Spec Ops was quite the surprise when it launched in 2012. Made by Yager Development, this third-person cover shooter rebooted the franchise and took a different direction than the originals, presenting a much darker narrative than we were used to.
Playing as Captain Martin Walker, we found ourselves sent to a destroyed Dubai, coming to blows with commander John Konrad and his 33rd Battalion. It puts a heavy emphasis on morality and war’s devastating effects on soldiers. One example includes Walker’s use of white phosphorus against the 33rd so his team can advance, only to later discover they’d accidentally killed civilians.
Having faced several battles, Walker finally meets with Konrad and what follows is one of gaming’s greatest twists. Upon confronting him, Walker instead discovers his corpse, revealing Konrad’s been a hallucination all this time.
Having desperately tried to rationalise the white phosphorus attack, it becomes clear Walker’s been an unreliable narrator ever since. How he chooses to handle this guilt determines the ending, leading to Walker either shooting himself or trying to shoot “Konrad” and later calling in the military.
It’s not a flawless game, having faced criticism for its lack of replayability and average gameplay but its storyline turned it into a cult classic, cemented by this unexpected twist.
Watch Next
The Legend Of Zelda Quiz: How Well Do You Know A Link To The Past?