9 Overused Video Game Criticisms That Make No Sense

Trevor's a dick, and that's a good thing.

Grand Theft Auto V Trevor
Rockstar

Everybody's a critic in the age of social media, and though a deeper and more extensive discourse surrounding video games is definitely a positive for the most part, some people just can't help but fire off their spicy-hot takes without much thought.

No video game is perfect - no, not even Rocket League - yet as insightful as it can be to discuss the flaws of games both good and bad, sometimes people take this too far, levelling "damning" criticisms that don't hold up to basic scrutiny and...don't really make much sense.

Context is always going to be key, of course, but the vast majority of the time people make these complaints about video games, they're simply screeching grossly hyperbolic statements with little basis in fact.

There are plenty of reasonable ways to critique most video games, but going back to the well and regurgitating these "issues" again and again is an easy way to lose an argument and look a bit silly in the process...


9. "Games Are Too Easy Nowadays"

Kingdom Hearts 3
Square Enix

You'll often hear people complain that games are skewing too easy these days, and that lower difficulty levels are inherently a bad thing, as though every game needs to provide some degree of frustration in order to be truly enjoyable.

Yet to disregard games simply because they don't punish the player is to deny yourself so many titles created with a spectacular sense of artistry - not everything needs to be Dark Souls, after all.

Recently, many complained about both Kingdom Hearts III and Devil May Cry 5 offering up the most accessible gameplay of their respective series...despite both also providing the hardcore crowd with more challenging difficulty levels.

Options are ultimately a good thing, and just because FromSoftware's games enforce a strict difficulty level upon players, it doesn't mean that every game needs to.

Easy games exist because not everybody has the time to replay the same damn sequence again, and that's a good thing.

We all get different things out of games, of course, but if you can't value a game artistically because it doesn't get your blood pressure pumping, then that's a damn shame for you.


8. "It's Not What I Expected"

Resident evil 4
Capcom

Expectations are always a dangerous way to leave yourself disappointed, especially if you're expecting an upcoming game to be one very specific thing, but the end result turns out somewhat different.

There are certainly instances where a game flatly fails to deliver what was promised - looking at you, Anthem - but this criticism is directed more towards games that simply pivoted into a different style or type of game than fans precisely expected.

Take Resident Evil 4, which while widely regarded as one of the finest survival horror games ever made, still released to a chorus of hate from some "purist" fans who felt that, because it deviated from the series' traditional formula, it was immediately worthless.

It's this sort of attitude which will so often prompt publishers to follow trends and be content with their developers basically just releasing the same old thing every damn time.

Nobody's saying you have no right to be mad if Grand Theft Auto VI turns out to be a chess simulator, but creative leaps should be encouraged where appropriate. Otherwise, we're basically being resold the same stagnant gameplay systems and story tropes without sufficient variation.


7. "A Bad Ending Ruins The Entire Game"

Mass Effect 3 ending
Bioware

It's commonly said of movies, TV and video games that the journey is more important than the destination - meaning that a piece of media's quality comprises the sum of its parts rather than simply how it leaves you feeling at the end.

Yes, it's undeniably disappointing when a game fumbles the ball at the eleventh hour - Mass Effect 3's infamously terrible ending surely being the most shining contemporary example - but it also shouldn't drastically colour everything that happened up to that point.

Is it not a teensy bit melodramatic to say that an unsatisfying final 20 minutes totally obliterates 30-40 hours of play? A bad ending can definitely diminish the overall experience, but can it really ruin all that prior enjoyment?


6. "No Multiplayer = No Sale"

Rage 2
Bethesda

There are many people out there who simply won't part with a full retail price tag for a game that doesn't have multiplayer features, and that's damn depressing.

The last decade-or-so has seen multiplayer aggressively shoehorned into an increasing number of single-player games, and the results have proven predictably messy. Fallout 76 was of course a colossal stinker, while Red Dead Redemption 2's online suite hasn't exactly set the world on fire.

Last year God of War proved the viability of entirely offline, single-player experiences, and for multiplayer-minded gamers to wilfully shut themselves off from that completely is just...baffling.

Is a game's worth entirely determined by the hundreds of hours you can pour into it while repeating the same core gameplay, over a more strictly curated - and yes, far shorter - core experience?

Spend your money how you like, sure, and wait for a sale if you don't feel like spending £45 on a 20-hour single-player game, but writing off sans-multiplayer titles entirely makes no sense at all. And yet, there are those who do it.


5. "The Protagonist Is Too Unlikeable"

GTA V trevor
Rockstar

Across art forms, there's an increasing misconception among audiences that a protagonist who happens to be an awful person is an inherently bad thing.

This is especially contentious in gaming, where the medium's greater sense of interactivity makes players more conflicted about playing as a character who commits terrible acts.

But the world is a complex place, and wouldn't playing as a squeaky-clean hero in every video game just get boring incredibly fast?

If the likes of pre-2018 Kratos and Grand Theft Auto V's Trevor have proven anything, it's that unrepentant a**holes can be a ludicrous joy to play as...as long as you put some personal distance between yourself and their undeniably heinous actions.

Obviously it's all about the game's overall intent - if a game wants the audience to like their hero and they come off as dull or irritating, then that's a whole other conversation.

But hand-wringing over morally grey (or even black) heroes is rather silly, because not every game needs to be a hero fantasy in the purest sense of the phrase.


4. "It's Too Short"

Journey game
ThatGameCompany

There are countless AAA games released every year that will steal your life away if you let them, so to complain that other games - typically single-player narrative-driven ones - are too short does feel a bit like missing the point.

Sure, nobody's going to be happy about a 6-hour AAA experience with no multiplayer that costs £45, but the indie and mid-budget gaming boom over the last decade has seen publishers opt for a far wider array of price points better-suited to a game's given length.

Not every game wants or needs to be an intense 40-hour experience. A balanced "diet" of games is necessary to prevent even the most enthusiastic player from feeling burned out, and playing a couple of games you can complete in an afternoon between the big AAA hitters is an easy way to avoid that.

After all, isn't it better for a game to leave you wanting more than leaving you exhausted and frustrated by the time the end credits roll?


3. "Representation Is 'Pandering'"

The Last Of Us Part II
Naughty Dog

Representation has become a major talking point across media over the last few years, and given how cinema, TV and games all traditionally skew towards straight white men, it's definitely been refreshing to see more diversity as of late.

But of course, to some, the prospect of playing as anything other than a generic white guy with a giant beard is unconscionable, and presenting players with a female, ethnic or LGBTQ hero is "pandering" to the "SJWs."

For instance, there was considerable uproar over the lesbian kiss in the E3 trailer for The Last of Us Part II, as though a tender moment between two consenting individuals is somehow controversial.

But in 2019, where Donald Trump is the President of the United States, the world isn't quite as progressive and permissive as many hope it to be.

For another example, Ubisoft (finally) letting people play as a woman in Assassin's Creed isn't merely some lazy attempt to score easy political points.

Giving players more options to see someone like them on-screen (where appropriate) is good for everyone - it betters people's sense of self, and allows others to more easily identify with them as, you know, actual human beings.


2. "Video Games Are Too Expensive"

Devil May Cry 5 Nero
Capcom

Video game prices have maintained a consistent baseline for a long time now, rather than rising with inflation and the greater costs of production as you'd expect.

And yet, there are still those who relentlessly whine about games being too damn expensive.

Ultimately, if you want to boil it down to a cash-for-time ratio, games are cheaper than just about any other major form of entertainment - certainly buying an album or spending a night at the movies.

Though it's definitely fair to say that Nintendo have been consistently stingy with their mediocre sales and aggressively rigid RRPs, games have largely never been priced more competitively than they are today, with the majority of AAA titles across PS4, Xbox One and PC receiving huge price drops within a month or two of their release.

Many gamers unfortunately get it into their heads that they "have" to submit to the full-board season pass experience, where getting the "complete" version of a game can cost over £100. But you're absolutely not obliged, and for most, the base experience should represent solid value in of itself.

If anything, the market dictates that games should probably be more expensive than they are, and even if you're a frugal gamer, it's mind-boggling that so many still find gaming to be such a high-price hobby.

Alright, VR games might be pushing it, but even then, you're getting a "premium" experience compared to conventional, flat gaming, so something of an uplift is expected.

If you earnestly believe that games generally cost too much, you might do well to shop around more.


1. "Factual Inaccuracy Is A Deal-Breaker"

Battlefield 5
DICE

This complaint generally applies to games with an historical backdrop - typically a war-time setting - and concerns players who can't stop complaining when a game doesn't fully represent a certain period accurately.

There was an enormous uproar recently when EA confirmed that Battlefield V would feature playable female soldiers, causing many "purists" to cry foul that this wasn't historically accurate and, therefore, too immersion breaking.

Except, there were female soldiers in World War II. And more to the point, in a video game franchise which allows you to stand astride a horse while firing a flamethrower, are woman soldiers really that damaging to your immersion?

The Battlefield franchise has always prefaced spectacle over accuracy, and that's exactly how it should be. After all, if you're expecting a rigorous history lesson from an EA-produced multiplayer shooter, you might have your priorities a tad out of whack.

It's fine to prefer historical accuracy in your games, but if it's enough of a big deal to stop you playing a AAA blockbuster outright, you might want to re-think how you perceive them.

Which overused video game criticisms get your goat the most? Got any of your own to add? Shout them out in the comments!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.