9 Video Game Endings That Were Changed Because Of Fan Feedback
If at first you don't succeed... patch in a completely different ending a few months later.
While a wobbly introduction can leave a terrible first impression, a bad ending can sink a whole game. Because no matter how great the potentially hundreds of hours that came before may have been, if a title ends on a frustrating anti-climax, any built-up goodwill a developer might have earned gets dashed in an instant.
And although you can find examples of internet backlash for controversial endings no matter the medium, sometimes gaming fans just can't continue their lives knowing that writers have botched a conclusion to their favourite games. Because if history has shown us anything, it's that if fans are vocal enough, even the biggest companies can - and will - bend to the demands of a fanbase, returning to a project to amend something like a terrible ending.
While there's something to be said about respecting the creative decisions of the dedicated and passionate writers at the helm of these narratives, many a horror story has leaked detailing rushed development processes that have ended up in unfinished and disappointing games (I'm still in mourning over Metal Gear Solid V's butchered second act).
Occasionally, a vocal fanbase is the only thing powerful enough to give publishers the push they need for a developer to finish their work, but how many times has it worked out for the best?
9. Infamous 2's Bad Ending Was Supposed To Be Canon
The Infamous series has always been big on moral choices. Throughout the first two games especially, players were able to tailor protagonist Cole MacGrath to their liking, deciding whether the reluctant superhero's tale would end in tragedy or a 'happy ever after'.
But when it came to crafting the latest spin-off, Infamous Second Son, the development team were forced to make one of the endings to the second game canon. The world of the series after this climax could have been wildly different depending on whether you went down the good or bad moral path, and as a result, there was just no way the dev team could have catered to both outcomes.
In the end, the darker, more ominous ending was chosen as canon, however, mid-way through development the writers had a change of heart when they analysed the game's trophies, revising this original plan after discovering that almost 80% of players chose the good ending.
So, while a Second Son set in an evil post-Infamous 2 world could have been amazing, it makes sense that the developers remained faithful to the ending most players preferred.
8. Shadow Of Mordor's DLC Has A Second Attempt At A Battle With Sauron
For all the things 2014's sleeper hit Shadow of Mordor did right, it couldn't quite nail its final boss battle with iconic series' villain, Sauron. Dropping the frantic combat that made the title so memorable, the final boss was instead comprised of an unconventional stealth segment, full of cheap deaths and gimmicky quick-time events.
So, in order to make up for that lacklustre finale, developers Monolith decided to just have a complete do-over of the whole fight, developing a piece of prequel DLC that put you in the shoes of side-character Celebrimbor as he took on the Dark Lord himself.
Instead of sneaking around drab areas and mashing the same combos, this new battle with Sauron attempted to be as epic as possible, letting you wield the powers of the one ring in a grandiose suicide mission against an iconic villain at the height of his powers.
It's a shame we had to pay for the luxury of getting the final boss everyone wanted, but at least now Shadow of Mordor no longer has to end on the anti-climactic note it once did.
7. Portal Patches In A New Ending To Explain The Sequel
The original ending to fan-favourite Portal didn't leave much room for ambiguity. In fact, blowing your way out of the Enrichment Centre while destroying villain GLaDOS was about as happy of an ending as you could have hoped to get for Valve's seemingly doomed protagonist, Chell.
But then a sequel was announced, and fans were worried that her happy ending would be ignored for the sake of building a franchise. Confused as to how Valve were going to include the character after wrapping up her story so neatly, this announcement only fuelled suspicions that the new game would be nothing more than a derivative reimagining of the original rather than a fully-fledged sequel.
But Valve had already anticipated this kind of fan response, and sneakily patched in a brand new ending to the original Portal days before the second game's announcement to address some of these issues.
Instead of the game cutting to black after an optimistic final shot, the update changed the climax of the original to be much more ominous, with a barely conscious Chell being dragged back down into the depths of the Enrichment lab by an unseen AI, thus justifying her appearance in the second game.
6. Knights Of The Old Republic 2's Fans Finish An Abandoned Ending
Although it was a disappointment at the time, Knights of The Old Republic 2 has gone down in history as an underrated Star Wars gem.
Unfortunately, even though the game has grown in stature as the years have worn on, it's still evidently clear that the sequel was rushed out in order to capitalise on the success of the original. And it didn't take long for fans to discover that the abrupt and deflating end to the game wasn't exactly what the developers had planned.
A quick scout of the on-disc files revealed that parts of the unfinished ending could still be located within the game's code, and for a time, fans of the series were privy to a few soundbites that clued them in on what the finale of Knights of The Old Republic 2 originally was.
Fortunately, these unused files were eventually developed by hardcore fans into a newly-modded ending for the game that added a few more scenes into the original finale. It still didn't completely bring the developer's original vision to life, but it at least provided a little more closure to an otherwise rushed and unfinished ending.
5. Frozen Synapse Gives The Players Whatever They 'Want'
Plenty of people had a response to Bioware's controversial decision to bow to fan demand and change their ending to Mass Effect 3, yet the developers of Frozen Synapse wanted to show just how dangerous it can be to let fans dictate the way a game should conclude.
To do this, the devs looked through suggestions for new endings that had been discussed on their message boards - and then took the whackiest ones to create a crazy alternate ending that had nothing to do with the game itself.
Full of top hat-wearing dinosaurs and talking ponies, the new ending was only available for one week, but even in that small amount of time managed to effectively convey how dangerous it can be to leave the ending of a game entirely up to fans.
Sure, it was probably a bit of an unneeded dig against the whole Mass Effect 3 controversy, but the message of respecting a creator's creative decision and understanding that all fans want different things was an idea not being spread around enough at the time.
4. Prince Of Persia 2008 Retcons That Downer Ending
For as much as people didn't take to the 2008 reboot of Prince of Persia, you have to admit that it at least attempted to do something daring with the story.
Because the entire game is presented as the Prince and his companion Elika's desperate attempt to stop the oncoming "darkness" from enveloping the world, the two make a pilgrimage to a blessed site in order to prevent the release of a wrathful god. However, just before they arrive at their destination, the duo are ambushed - with Elika being killed in the crossfire.
The Prince, by this point having grown rather fond of his travelling companion, opts instead to destroy the ritual site in order to complete a spell that would bring Elika back from the dead, undoing all of his attempts to push back the corruption and dooming the rest of the world in the process.
Unfortunately, this bummer of a finale didn't go down too well with players, and Ubisoft released an Epilogue that picks up right where the original game left off.
Instead of sticking to their guns, the devs used the DLC to give the Prince and Elika a happy ending, trading in the foreboding original finale for a generic climax where the hero defeats the bad guy, saves the world and gets the girl. But at least this time, there was a world left to save.
3. Fallout 3's DLC Brought Your Character Back From The Dead
Fallout 3 is an expansive game, to the point where if you want to see everything the title has to offer, you'll have to spend hundreds of hours investigating every nook and cranny in the DC Wasteland.
But if you decided to power through the game's main narrative (which only makes up about 20% of the content, tops), then upon completion you'd be locked in a state where it's impossible for you to continue adventuring with your current character.
Why? Because the final mission of the main quest actually kills off the protagonist, and unless you were lucky enough to have a recent save from before you started the chain reaction of quests that lead to this climatic battle, the game ultimately forces you to start all over again.
Fans were rightfully frustrated that they couldn't continue developing their main character that they had spent countless hours with, and in response Bethesda released Broken Steel, a DLC update that retconned the original ending and decided that, nah, your character wasn't dead after all.
It wasn't the most elegant way of doing things, but at least it meant that you didn't have to replay 50 hours of a game you'd just finished in order to see all of the cool stuff you missed.
2. Mass Effect 3's Extended Cut Finally Explains Your Decisions
Mass Effect 3 has one of the most infamously bad endings of all time. The culmination of three games, Bioware's sci-fi epic opted to trade in everything that had made the franchise so special up until that point for an easy finish.
Out the window went the nuanced approach to player choice and in its place was a finale that let you choose one of three pre-determined endings that completely disregarded every major decision players had ever made over the past three games.
Even worse, the endings themselves weren't even well crafted, offering vague and unsatisfying wrap-ups that completely jarred with everything set up beforehand.
So it's no surprise that the fan backlash was monumental. Initially refusing to go back on their creative vision, developers at Bioware eventually caved, releasing a piece of free DLC that expanded on the endings and showed players how their decisions impacted a galaxy they'd invested so many hours in.
It didn't exactly fix the foundational problems that made the finale so disappointing in the first place, but it at least allowed players to actually understand the choices that were forced on them.
1. Metal Gear Solid 4 Only Exists Because Everyone Hated The Second Game's Ending
Okay, we know that after the release of every single Metal Gear Solid game, series creator Hideo Kojima always used to promise it will definitely, absolutely, for total realsies this time, be the last one.
Naturally, this couldn't be further from the truth in retrospect, but there was a time when the legendary developer actually meant it; and the ending of Metal Gear Solid 2 was supposed to wrap up the story of Solid Snake in an incredibly meta and post-modern way that drew attention to the entire fallacy of soulless, corporately-produced sequels.
But fans famously didn't like its ambiguity, and even an excellent prequel release starring Big Boss couldn't stop them from demanding to play as Solid Snake one more time.
So Metal Gear Solid 4 was born, and in the end, Kojima himself even admitted that he only returned to Solid Snake's story because he was sick of hearing everyone asking him about it. Which is pretty evident if you've ever played the game, as MGS 4 bends over backwards to explain every little mystery in the series in order to satiate the fans who demanded answers for years.
So yeah, the constant whining resulted in players getting an entire game chock-full of nanomachine-based explanations for everything that happened in Metal Gear Solid 2, taking away all of the magic and mystery that made the title so fun in the first place. I hope getting Old Snake in return was worth it.
--
Let us know in the comments if there were any other game endings notoriously swapped when you were or weren't looking!