9 Video Game Hard Modes That Were WAY Too Easy

When Nightmare mode is an afternoon breeze.

infamous second son
Sucker Punch

Putting a game on Hard Mode should be a way for a player to challenge themselves, and usually it does just that.

There are countless games where the highest difficulty setting is practically designed to swiftly deliver misguided souls to a Game Over screen: Doom's Ultra Nightmare, Metro 2033's Ranger Hardcore and The Last of Us' Grounded modes, to name but a few.

The thing is, no matter how good a game might be, without any challenge it feels hollow and robs players of a sense of accomplishment, and as a result we find ourselves constantly fiddling with the difficulty settings to find our own personal sweet spot where challenge meets experience.

Except... what happens when Hard Mode really isn't that hard?

In theory, it shouldn't be a disappointment. After all, if you're better than the toughest challenge that the developers set for you, shouldn't you be proud?

Not always.

When Hard Mode is too easy, we're left feeling robbed and dissatisfied, especially after getting all geared up for a proper challenge.

9. Guitar Hero

Guitar Hero 3
Activision

The difference between Guitar Hero's difficulty settings is fairly straightforward. Easy only uses 3 of 5 buttons, Medium uses 4, Hard uses all 5, and Expert adds notes and chords designed to be more difficult for players to wrap their fingers around.

Yes, the whole point of Guitar Hero is to offer people who don't necessarily play an instrument an opportunity to get a few heads banging, but a mode labelled "Expert" in what equates to a guitar simulator perhaps could have offered something more akin to playing an actual guitar.

After all, anyone who has had even a passing acquaintance with playing a real guitar tends to find Guitar Hero's Expert mode pretty straightforward.

While there are certainly more than a few people out there unable to perform the dexterity of the digits that Guitar Hero's Expert mode demands, it really doesn't take an expert to master.

Still, let's not be too hard on Guitar Hero. After all, without it, we'd never have been given the opportunity to outperform the Devil himself in a guitar duel.


8. Kingdoms Of Amalur: Reckoning

Kingdoms of Amalur
THQ Nordic

Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning is a title that has conjured mixed emotions for many since its 2012 release.

On the one hand, you have an absolutely outstanding RPG set in an original world with a classic fantasy narrative; on the other, you have the game's studio declaring bankruptcy shortly after beginning work on a sequel, meaning that almost immediately after the games release, all hopes of a blossoming franchise were quickly killed.

The gameplay itself is fresh and fun, with a charmingly colourful world to explore filled with all manner of creatures to sink sword or spell into.

Upon starting your game, if you were to select the hardest difficulty, you'd soon find yourself checking the settings to make sure it hasn't somehow lowered itself. Yes, enemies do considerably more damage, but make use of the game's dodge and block mechanics and you'll barely need health potions at all.

The lack of challenge shouldn't take anything away from the experience that this beautiful game offers, though, and with THQ Nordic remaster Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning recently released, you'll be able to experience it all over again.


7. Infamous: Second Son

infamous second son
Sucker Punch

Infamous: Second Son gives us the opportunity to step into the shoes of superpowered Conduit Delsin and make choices that influence not only the world around him, but his powers themselves and Delsin's own morality.

Using his powers, Delsin takes on the DUP, a government organisation intent on capturing the Conduit "bioterrorists".

Infamous: Second Son also has an Extreme difficulty setting, meaning that players keen to feel the full force of the evil Department of Unified Protection have the chance to do so.

Maybe it should have occurred to players that having superpowers would make everything easier, but it just isn't what you'd expect from a video game played on "Expert" diffculty.

While there are a few times where certain enemies can absorb damage like super-sponges, Expert difficulty on Second Son really isn't anything to write home about.

It's an annoyingly small flaw in an otherwise impressive game, but players who came for a challenge were sorely disappointed, and that earns it a place on the list.


6. Minecraft

minecraft video game
Mojang

Minecraft has never been a game that prides itself on its difficulty.

Quite the opposite, in fact - Minecraft is popular with audiences of all ages for the simple fact that the game boasts a level of challenge that isn't directly related to the difficulty settings you've selected.

With that said, Minecraft does have difficulty settings. Players can play on Creative or Peaceful mode, which allow the means to enjoy the building/gathering elements of gamplay rather than defending against Minecraft's many monsters, but Minecraft also has a "Hard" difficulty setting.

Essentially the only difference on Hard mode is that your character is able to starve to death, and their hunger level depletes slightly faster. Other than that, Minecraft on Hard is in no way different to Minecraft on any other non-Peaceful mode, making it feel like a redundant inclusion to long-time players hoping for something of a challenge.

At least the difficulty settings have no effect on the heart-stopping fear you feel when a Creeper invades your hand-built castle, and that's not something that can ever be taken away.


5. Chronicles Of Riddick: Escape From Butcher Bay

chronicles of riddick escape from butcher bay
Vivendi Games

Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay is a game that has moved into relative obscurity, despite being an absolutely stellar example of how much fun stealth games can be.

Tasked with escaping from the supposedly impenetrable Butcher Bay Correctional Facility, notorious anti-hero Riddick takes on an entire planetful of guards and monsters in order to forcibly regain his freedom.

As anyone familiar with the character would likely suspect, the game leans heavily on its use of stealth tactics and less on out-and-out action sequences, and quietly disposing of guards from the shadows is the name of the game.

While Escape from Butcher Bay's hard mode does present a certain level of challenge, the use of stealth negates much of it, and once you obtain the stun gun you'll breeze through without hitting many snags. The weapon can be used to silently destroy the prison's lighting, making it even easier to move around unseen.

Escape from Butcher Bay is a truly brilliant title, but its difficulty levels were seriously miscalculated.


4. Dragon Age: Inquisition

Dragon Age Inquisition bears
Bioware

Dragon Age: Inquisition is a solid RPG that fulfills everything fans of the series had hoped it would, and built on the franchise's strengths in almost every way.

Dragon Age: Origins and Dragon Age II both came equipped with a number of difficulty levels ranging from I'm-here-for-the-story-Easy up to I'm-a-masochist-that-remembers-to-save-every-few-minutes-Hard, meaning that no matter your skill level, you could enjoy an appropriate amount of difficulty.

Dragon Age: Inquisition, however, presented us with not just a Hard mode but a "Nightmare" difficulty setting, which combined with the games tactical battle camera option seemed to be an enticing opportunity for players to truly challenge themselves.

The problem was that Nightmare really didn't measure up. As long as you stick to areas designed for your own level and keep at least one character of each class in your party, you'll be able to zip through the game in no time at all.

It wasn't as much an absence of difficulty as a poorly named difficulty setting, but it really should have been even just a little harder.


3. Doom 3

Doom 3
iD Software

The Doom franchise has always prided itself on its particular brand of sci-fi horror, and, to its credit, it has always delivered more or less what it says on the box.

Stuck on a research facility on Mars after scientists have opened a literal portal to Hell, the player must fight through the hordes of monsters pouring through in order to survive.

Suspenseful, sure. Horrifying? You betcha. But difficult? Not really.

Doom 3 boasts 4 difficulty settings: Recruit, Marine, Veteran and Nightmare. With damage scaled up in each mode, it seems on paper as though the game should be impossibly hard on Nightmare mode.

It's difficult at certain points throughout the game, although ultimately, cutting through the hell-spawn is rarely taxing for any players with a modicum of FPS experience. When you're constantly armed to the teeth, it's not too hard to send the monstrous hordes straight back where they came from.

If the mode had simply been named "Hard", it may not have made this list, but mislabelling something as a "Nightmare" really doesn't count as making it more difficult.


2. Terminator Salvation

terminator salvation
Warner Bros

Terminator Salvation was released as a tie-in for the movie of the same name, which, if you've seen it, should give you some indication of its quality.

By no means is Terminator Salvation a good game, but considering that it pits us against literal killing machines, it should have presented something of a challenge.

Instead, the game offered a bare-bones cover shooter with no substance whatsoever, and was filled with a grand total of six different enemies, all of which are easily killed by throwing a few grenades, pipe bombs, or a number of bullets in the weak spots on their backs.

Terminator Salvation can be played through and completed to 100% in a matter of hours, even on the game's hardest difficult setting, which is especially disappointing when you consider that even that short play time feels like too much.

Terminator Salvation's Hard mode most definitely should have been harder, but it seems as though the developers had a trick up their sleeve: if they make the game an absolute chore to get through, it becomes difficult in a whole new way.


1. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines Xenomorph
SEGA

Aliens: Colonial Marines is infamous for its lack of difficulty, so its inclusion on this list likely isn't very surprising.

A sci-fi shooter that takes place inside the universe first brought to life in Ridley Scott's Alien, Colonial Marines gave us control of the marines tasked with fighting the Xenomorph, which should have been an impossible task.

What the game actually gave us though, was enemies that could be cut through with ease, permanently scarring the Xenomorph's reputation as the baddest being in all the universe, not to mention upsetting fans that had shelled out their hard-earned cash on the title.

It was since discovered that a typo in the code was likely the issue with the game's AI, which itself was the main culprit of the chronically easy gameplay, and once fixed, Aliens: Colonal Marines does actually play with slightly more substantial difficulty.

The problem wasn't just in the development of the game, but in the enemy they used. Nothing in Alien should ever be easy, and we should never feel in control.

Thankfully, Alien: Isolation eventually came along and set the record straight, but that only went a short way towards fixing the mess that Colonial Marines had already made.


Contributor
Contributor

Antisocial nerd that spends a lot of time stringing words together. Once tried unsuccessfully to tame a crow.