9 Video Game Ideas We’re GLAD Got Cancelled
More like Jack and Dexter.
From sequels to reboots or, well, just making anything successful in video game form whatsoever, nailing a creative vision goes through any number of sizeable changes.
Maybe you're a Hideo Kojima, a Corey Barlog or a Ken Levine and maybe there's a design doc full of reference points you can't stray TOO far away, but even then, chances are some unforeseen element is going to rear its head and upend everything.
Planned set-pieces get canned because deadlines come around too soon, maybe a physics model wasn't perfected so now an entire mechanic can't be leaned on anywhere near as much.
In the end, fans and critics alike can only analyse the product they've been given - that is, until word comes out of various forks in the road that could've gone a different way entirely.
Looking back you can often side with the creator when viewing a deleted scene or element; appreciating the larger whole they were striving for, but there are some ideas we're just glad didn't make it through.
9. Reloading Using A Controller Add-On - GoldenEye 007
Maybe it would've been genius - a whole new way to even think about how to interact with a first-person shooter... or maybe it would've singlehandedly destroyed GoldenEye's reputation from day one, and denied millions of us one of the finest multiplayer shooters of all time.
Either way, back when Rare were assembling GoldenEye in this ragtag, experimental time that was the early 90s in video games, they tried out the idea of reloading using an external peripheral. Namely, the very exciting Rumble Pak, that was adding optional vibration to a host of titles.
Rare had it so reloading in GoldenEye meant you had to physically grab the controller and actively remove - then reinsert - the Pak every time you wanted to reload, as they thought it simulated reloading an actual gun.
While there's no denying a custom-modded, in-person game of GoldenEye today would be a great laugh with everyone having to reload this way, it's safe to say they made the right call taking it out.
8. A Realistic Jak & Daxter - Jak 4
Bizarrely, you actually have Jak & Daxter to thank for The Last of Us.
Whilst it sounds insane, flash back to the late 2000s and Naughty Dog were having something of a crisis when developing a potential fourth Jak & Daxter. Why? Because they were attempting - assumedly in the wake of Uncharted maturing the studio's visuals and taking them away from cartoonish platformers - to do a "realistic" version of Jak & Daxter.
Featured in the studio's 30th Anniversary artbook, we can see a version of Jak as far more humanoid, accompanied by a Daxter that's also drawn more realistically to represent a fox-like creature, rather than the fictional Ottsel.
Naughty Dog's Neil Druckmann and Evan Wells would later note that they were getting "so far away from what makes Jak & Daxter Jak & Daxter", that it felt as though they were just "slapping the name on it for marketing reasons".
The project was shelved as the team accepted they'd be "doing everybody a disservice", everyone moved onto The Last of Us, and now all we're left with are the horrifying images of what once was.
7. A Game That Smells Like Blood - Snatcher
Hideo Kojima. You've gotta love him. Especially retrospectively when we're now in an age of hyper-calculated projects designed for maximum reach and maximum profit. The very idea of someone thinking outside the box and getting away with it is why so many people fell in love with Death Stranding, warts and all.
In previous generations though, some of Kojima's even MORE "out-there" ideas were scrapped, because they were just too insane.
One came alongside 1988's detective thriller Snatcher, where Kojima wanted the game to literally smell of blood over time, eventually revealing a secret you could only see for a few seconds, then it was gone.
Hideo explained to Engadget that “Maybe when you put [Snatcher] in your disk drive and you’re playing for about fifteen minutes, the heat from the disk drive interacts with a chemical and creates a certain smell. It smells like blood or something like that. When you pull it out you see a dying message on the disk".
He says the idea was pitched early on, "but unfortunately, I got yelled at for it and they didn’t let me do it".
6. Sticking With What Works & Ditching Atreus - God of War (2018)
It's safe to say God of War is the game of the eighth generation. The most recommendable, easily enjoyable, powerfully resonant thematically and mature in its re-approaching of what Kratos as a character represents, and what he can be going forward.
All-round, Creative Director Corey Barlog and the team at Santa Monica turned in an immaculate piece of art, but dive into the project's history and you'll find endless stories of non-stop uphill battles, alongside the idea of removing Atreus at every turn.
As Barlog touched on in many documentaries, even Sony's own Shuhei Yoshida couldn't get on board with what he and the team were putting together, actively walking out of an in-person gameplay demo. An early QA tester was furious that Santa Monica were "ruining Kratos!", and as Corey told Gamespot, "it was the most stress you could possibly deal with".
From the beginning through to shipping, everyone other than Corey was insisting that Kratos and God of War remain the way it was.
Thankfully - and you can see the outpouring of emotion from a creative lead being proven right in Corey's reaction video to God of War's review scores - Barlog held true, and we got an exemplary effort he and everybody involved can be proud of for the rest of their lives.
5. A Gritty, Realistic Mortal Kombat Inspired By Gears Of War
Mortal Kombat is currently on the form of its life. Yes, MK dominated the headlines in the 90s thanks to everybody discovering fatalities by accident down the arcade, but it's nothing compared to the guest star-filled roster of MK 11.
Back in the late 2000s though, the entire franchise was on the downturn. With enjoyable enough minigames filling out the disc and sales starting to suffer, Ed Boon noting to CVG in 2007 that the eighth Mortal Kombat would be completely overhauled.
Going with a "more realistic", "grittier" presentation, Boon said the team "[felt] no obligation to bring back favorite fighting styles or weapons", later saying to Game Informer that MK8 will be "unbelievably unexpected", and that it was largely inspired by Gears of War.
Boon went on, "We're not going to have three fighting styles, we're not going to have the same punches and kicks and the same kind of control scheme. Everything is getting trashed. We're reinventing everything from the ground up. We really think that's needed".
Well, if - like me - you were there at the time, all this talk had us MK fans mighty worried. The "grounded" version of Mortal Kombat was ultimately ditched, and following Warner Bros. stepping in after Midway folded, Mortal Kombat was soft-rebooted in 2011 and has only gone from strength to strength since.
4. Ellie Kills Abby - The Last Of Us Part II
Bold, risky as hell but ultimately a necessary piece of art precisely because of it, The Last of Us 2 being a bleak revenge tale houses a message that's eventually extremely pro-life, and extremely encouraging of letting go of any longterm grudges.
It gets there over a 30 hour runtime that explores every facet of how hate can be constructed, reinforced and passed on, coming through the lens of militarised factions vying for dominance, religious doctrines or just personal vendettas.
By the close of the game, you're actively begging Ellie to just let Abby go, like she has earlier, and to settle down with partner Dina and their young child.
Thankfully Ellie relinquishes Abby's throat and the game ends on an optimistic(ish) note, though it wasn't always this way.
Revealed to IndieWire, Naughty Dog's Neil Druckmann stated that "for more than 50 percent of the production, Ellie used to kill Abby at the end", giving in to the same cycles of violence as everyone around her, and further dooming human nature to a constant race to the bottom.
Druckmann notes the team eventually realised this "wasn’t honest to Ellie’s character" as "deep down inside, there is goodness there. Hopefully, she can go forward and build her life”.
Phew.
3. Ethan's Mind Is Connected To The Killer - Heavy Rain
David Cage is a treasure trove of brilliant unused concepts, hilarious or otherwise.
In Heavy Rain's case it's a popular talking point that Scott Shelby being the Origami Killer makes very little sense, as throughout the story we see Ethan Mars black out, only to wake up elsewhere with a paper origami model in his hand.
Turns out Cage did have an answer for this... it was just a deleted scene.
Now, you might immediately be thinking "Surely an answer to a prominent plot question is better included no matter what!", and you'd be right... if the explanation wasn't total out-of-place BS.
No, these deleted levels would've had you play Ethan's blackouts as underwater segments, the twist being that when Mars is unconscious, he forms a psychological link with the killer at the same time as one of the murders. Water then floods into the room because the killer's brother drowned when they were kids.
Injecting random supernatural insanity is what thoroughly killed Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy, and keeping the story more firmly in David Fincher territory is often thought of as the only saving grace in Cage's entire back catalogue.
2. Die And The Game Self-Destructs - Unreleased Hideo Kojima Game
Back to Kojima for this quick one, because he really did used to throw out some ludicrous ideas once Metal Gear Solid resulted in scores of interviews in the early 2000s.
One sketch for what he would do next came in an issue of Official PlayStation Magazine #59, where Kojima talked about a "raw" game where if you die, the game self-destructs.
"I think the whole concept of 'continues' in games is totally outdated and unnecessary. It all came from arcade games, where you throw in a coin when the game ends. I don't want to imprint children with the idea of virtual worlds where you can just play and die with infinite lives. Even if it is a virtual world, I want people to value their own lives. In that sense, a 'raw' game would be perfect."
Whilst the idea of only a fraction of the populace making it through an interactive story is pretty enticing, can you imagine losing all your progress, forever, just because you died in-game?
1. The Dark Knight Movie Tie-In
For the top spot, something that if it had gone ahead, would've denied us some of the finest superhero games of all time, and a melee combat system that would go on to be in everything from Sleeping Dogs to Hand of Fate.
That game was The Dark Knight's movie tie-in on consoles - the reality of which was a hellish time for studio Pandemic, who tried their best to use The Saboteur's engine for an open-world Batman game. Sadly the project was reportedly running at "five frames a second", and as Pandemic imploded and EA missed their release window, the rights for a Batman game went to Warner Bros., who promptly gave them to absolute nobodies, Rocksteady.
A cheaper and more viable prospect to cash in on the Batman IP with, they just happened to be total virtuosos making the most of their big break, turning in Arkham Asylum and revolutionising the very idea of superhero video games.
Without The Dark Knight game going sideways though, none of that would've happened.