Assassin's Creed: Every Major Villain RANKED
Which Templar was the baddest of them all?
Like all long-running gaming franchises, Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed series, which is due to get its 12th mainline instalment with Valhalla later this year, has had its fair share of highs and lows.
Taking us to a range of locations throughout history, all of which have been recreated in stunning detail thanks to scrupulous research, the Assassin's Creed games have allowed millions of players to live out some of their favourite historical fantasies.
Whether it's sliding down the Great Pyramids Of Giza in Assassin's Creed: Origins, running across the Colosseum in Brotherhood, or sailing your own pirate ship in Black Flag, the series is home to some of the best gaming moments of the last decade.
Fronting the series has been its roster of Assassin protagonists. Though not all of them have been as charismatic as the likes of Edward Kenway, the Frye Twins, and Ezio (we mean you, Connor and Arno), they're nevertheless our gateway to experiencing the series' worlds and action.
Of course, it wouldn't be an Assassin's Creed game without some Templars to stab with our hidden blades. But which of the collection of the series' many main villain was the biggest bad of them all?
-- Spoilers for the entire series within --
12. Prince Ahmet - Assassin's Creed: Revelations
Despite being the final chapter in the outstanding Ezio trilogy that also consisted of Assassin's Creed II and Brotherhood, Revelations contained arguably the blandest and most unremarkable villains in the entire franchise to date: Prince Ahmet.
An ambitious outing that connected Ezio's story to that of the first game's protagonist Altair, Revelation's saw the Italian assassin venture to the historic city of Constantinople in search of keys to unlock a hidden library in Masyaf.
Naturally, the Templars also have their eyes on the same prize; and leading this sect of the order is Prince Ahmet. A real Ottoman prince who attempted to win the throne by recruiting a rebellion to join his cause, Ahmet was the obvious choice of villain given the game's setting.
While he was at the centre of some of the game's most memorable sequences, his motivations ultimately boiled down to wanting power, making him a cliched villain archetype. We didn't even have the opportunity to kill him ourselves as we watched him get pushed off a cliff by his brother instead.
Though still an enjoyable game, Ahmet was far from being the best part of Revelations or a villain worthy of Ezio's last game.
11. François-Thomas Germain - Assassin's Creed: Unity
The game that was supposed to bring the franchise into the next generation with revitalised gameplay and a dense 18th century revolutionary Paris to traverse, Assassin's Creed: Unity is sadly better remembered for its catastrophic, bug-riddled launch.
While the game does have plenty of high points such as a phenomenal hot-air balloon set piece and assassination missions that give you plenty of options to dispatch your target, the overall Assassins vs Templar storyline is arguably one of the most lacklustre in the franchise. A Romeo And Juliet romance mixed with a murder mystery to uncover the killer of Arno's adopted father, a trail that leads to France's Templar Grand Master François-Thomas Germain - a silversmith with royal connections.
Exiled form the Order only to form his own radical sect, Germain had potential to be a very serious threat for Arno and his Assassin brethren. Instead, Germain was more concerned with politics and the standard Templar philosophies of controlling mankind, meaning he was unable to inject some much-needed character into an already dry plot.
Although he does get an interesting boss fight and is the reason for the game's most emotional moment, neither is enough to make this villain any more memorable.
10. Aspasia - Assassin's Creed Odyssey
As its title suggests, Assassin's Creed Odyssey provides an epic adventure of mythic proportion. A quest to reconnect with your family, uncovering the secrets of a mystical spear, and dismantling a masked cult at the centre of it all, there's plenty to keep players busy for hours on end.
As you gather clues throughout your time in Ancient Greece to unveil and hunt down the cultists, you get a step closer to unmasking the mastermind behind it all, the very person who tore apart your family. Unfortunately, though, the reveal is anti-climactic to say the least.
After hours of tracking and assassinating, the Ghost Of Kosmos, as they're known by, turns out to be Aspasia, the wife of Athenian leader Perikles. Only encountered a handful of times during the main game, Aspasia's presence is nowhere near prevalent enough for this twist reveal to be as impactful as intended.
Serving only to deliver large amounts of exposition and providing a laughably easy boss fight should you decide to kill her instead of romancing her, Aspasia is easily one of the weakest villains in the series.
Deimos would've made for a much more satisfying main antagonist than her.
9. Crawford Starrick - Assassin's Creed: Syndicate
One of the only Templars to be completely fictional, Crawford Starrick is the hot-tempered main antagonist of Assassin's Creed: Syndicate with an immaculate moustache and silky vocals.
With an iron grip over Victorian London, controlling the industries, politics, and a ruthless street gang known as the Blighters, Starrick is established as a tyrannical force to be reckoned with from the game's opening. Despite his hypnotic malevolence which makes him one of the franchise's most entertaining villains, Starrick is unfortunately criminally underused.
Aside from appearing in a handful of excellent cutscenes that act as reminders for just how excellent a villain he is for the Frye twins, Starrick's physical presence in the story is virtually non-existent.
When he does finally interact with the Fryes during a climactic mission in Buckingham Palace after they've all but annihilated his allies and gang, we're thrown straight into a final boss fight with him before he gets a chance in the villain spotlight himself..
While the boss fight itself is fun enough, it nevertheless feels like we're only saying goodbye to this Templar just as he was coming into play.
Starrick is a great villain who deserved better.
8. Achilles Davenport - Assassin's Creed Rogue
Unlike any of the other games in the
series, Assassin's Creed Rogue (which released alongside Unity) is the only
full game that sees players take control of a Templar instead of an Assassin.
Set prior to the events of Assassin's Creed III, Rogue centres around the story of Shay Patrick Cormac, an Assassin who defects to the Templars under the mentorship of Haytham Kenway after inadvertently causing a devastating earthquake whilst on a mission to recover an artefact for the Assassins. When he confronts his Brotherhood, believing they shouldn't have the power to cause world-changing catastrophes, he's shot and left for dead.
Consequently, the main antagonist of this game isn't a Templar, they're an Assassin, namely a younger Achilles Davenport. While the story of Rogue provides a far more nuanced take on the main themes of the series, Davenport is still as uninteresting and bland as he was when we first met him as the old recluse in Assassin's Creed III.
Though seeing just how this once strong collection of Assassins were wiped out is an interesting addition to the series' narrative, Achilles' presence added little to the overall experience.
7. Bartholomew Roberts - Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag
Although Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag has received some criticism for its lacklustre modern day sections that consisted of wandering around an office building to complete some hacking puzzles, its light-hearted, swashbuckling pirate action has seen this entry be elevated to the status of fan favourite.
Exploring tropical Caribbean islands and engaging in action-packed naval combat as lovable rogue Edward Kenway made for some of the game's biggest highlights as we embarked on a grand pirating adventure to uncover the location of the Observatory, a powerful artefact that allows people to spy on anyone in the world.
And what would a game set in the Golden Age Of Piracy be without some legendary pirates, one of which being Bartholomew Roberts - also known as Black Bart.
Though initially sceptical of Edward, Roberts eventually aided him in locating the Observatory as only Roberts can open it. However, being a merciless pirate, he betrays Kenway and sends him to prison for piracy.
Although Roberts only really becomes the main antagonist during the game's final act, his colourful character and ruthless nature added some extra flavour to this already fantastic game - even if his boss encounter wasn't as interesting.
6. Julius Caesar - Assassin's Creed: Origins
Taking the series in a bold new direction, Assassin's Creed: Origins took us to Ancient Egypt to discover the origins of the Assassins and their ensuing feud with the Templars.
Playing as Bayek, one of the last surviving Medjay, players will travel across Egypt on a quest to hunt down members of a shadowy organisation named The Order Of The Ancients following a traumatic event in which Bayek's young son is killed after the pair are captured.
Joining forces with Aya, Bayek's wife, and Cleopatra to eliminate everyone involved in the Order, the trail will eventually lead Bayek to none other than historical heavyweight Julius Caesar.
Supported by the Order after becoming the leader of the Roman Republic, Caesar would ultimately become the Order's Grand Master and Father Of Understanding. However, his lust for power would see him become a target of the Hidden Ones. And while Bayek preoccupied himself with taking out Caesar's general, the one who killed his son, Aya travelled to Rome to assassinate Caesar.
Seeing this historic figure brought to life is just one part of what made Origins fantastic; and being the one to start his famous assassination is all the more satisfying.
5. Dr Warren Vidic - Assassin's Creed To Assassin's Creed III
Whatever your thoughts may be on the series' modern day elements, these sections were nonetheless an integral part of the earlier games as we followed deadbeat bartender Desmond Miles train to become an Assassin while on the run from the Templar-ran Abstergo Industries. And the face of this company was Warren Vidic.
One of the very first characters we met in the series, Vidic was the director of the Animus Project and the one hunting Desmond and his ragtag team of associates down until his death in Assassin's Creed III.
Although Vidic's only major role in the series was in the first game where his Templar reveal was a major (but not completely unsurprising) twist, he remained the main antagonist for the modern day sections for years to come, with the narrow escapes from his clutches being a promise for things to come.
Despite his longevity in the series, Vidic never received the same status as historic counterparts. Though his death was rather unceremonious (and ironic), shot by his own guards under the control of the artefact he was so desperate for, his impact on the series cannot be underestimated.
Hopefully another modern day villain will take his place in Valhalla.
4. Haytham Kenway - Assassin's Creed III
While the final villain in Assassin's Creed III is the sadistic Charles Lee, it's suave Templar Grand Master Haytham Kenway who is the most memorable nemesis of the game, and one of the most iconic in the series.
Son of Assassin Edward Kenway and grandfather to Assassin's Creed III protagonist Ratonhnhaké:ton (aka Conor), Haytham was sent from England to the American colonies, tasked with finding a way to access a precursor vault.
Poised, elegant, and witty even during his most cruel acts, it's virtually impossible not to fall for Haytham's charms. We know he's supposed to be one of the bad guys, but his rational reasoning for his actions gives him a far more sympathetic portrayal than your standard Assassin's Creed villain.
With large sections of the game seeing Conor and his Templar father working together, not only is Haytham more directly involved in the game's overarching narrative, the connection between him and Conor is also strengthened through great writing and chemistry, which made the father-son subplot all the more relevant and Haytham's death more affecting.
Thankfully fans got to see more of what made Haytham great when he appeared in Rogue. And hopefully we can see more of him soon, too.
3. Rodrigo Borgia - Assassin's Creed II
Responsible for the deaths of Ezio's father and brothers, Rodrigo Borgia is the main antagonist in Assassin's Creed II and the main target of Ezio's quest to avenge his family.
The Templar Grand Master in Renaissance Italy, Rodrigo was born in Spain and, with his uncle being Pope Callistus III, began to work his way up the ranks of the Catholic Church, eventually being elected Pope Alexander VI in 1492. Always one step ahead of Ezio, he made for a formidable foe.
As well as being considered one of the most controversial popes in history, his game counterpart had a massive god complex, believing himself to be a prophet. In fact, his entire campaign to acquire the papacy was purely to gain access to a vault under the Vatican he believed contained God.
A vindictive, cruel, and totally ruthless individual, Rodrigo is the Assassin's Creed villain we loved to hate. Not only was it immensely satisfying to finally catch him, he also had arguably the most engaging boss encounter in the series. Ezio would soon regret letting him live, however.
And if all that wasn't bad enough, he's also the reason we spent so long collecting those feathers.
2. Cesare Borgia - Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
If you thought Assassin's Creed II's Rodrigo Borgia was bad, then wait until you meet his (illegitimate) son Cesare.
Sharing his father's massive ego but without his subtlety, the younger Borgia is more eccentric and over-the-top than his predecessor and was a lot more fun because of it.
Kicking events off Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood with a bang by invading the peaceful town of Monteriggioni where Ezio and his Assassins friends called home, killing Ezio's uncle, and stealing the Apple Of Eden for himself in the process. From herein, Ezio travels to Rome to once again take back the artefact and put an end to Cesare's power-hungry madness.
As Ezio gradually gains a foothold in Rome, Cesare's actions only got more extreme. Alongside crippling the city's Brotherhood, Cesare captures Caterina Sforza, kills his own father in a fit of rage (but only after he tried to poison him), and then there's the whole incest part of his life with his sister Lucrezia (although there's no direct historical evidence for this actually happening).
Perhaps best described as a spoiled brat with too much power, sending Cesare to his death was a moment that players couldn't wait for, and it didn't disappoint either.
1. Al Mualim - Assassin's Creed
Betrayal is commonplace within the Assassin's Creed series. Roberts, Cleopatra, and Aspasia are just some of the characters who turned on you at one point or another. None of them, however, were as effective as that of Al Mualim's from the first game.
The leader of the Masyaf Assassins, Al Mualim is the one who guides Altair on his road to redemption after his arrogance led Templar Knight Robert de Sable to assault the Assassins' stronghold.
Eliminating a list of targets given to you directly from Al Mualim himself, we believed we were doing the right thing by killing dangerous people. He even gave us new equipment as a reward for our had work, how could he possibly be one of the bad guys?
Towards the end of the game, however, the supposed Assassin mentor reveals his true colours. Using the recovered Apple Of Eden to control the minds of the other Assassins, he unveils that he shared the same goal as the Templars all along and you were being used the entire time to make his goal a reality.
Also giving us our first taste of the series' sci-fi elements, Al Mualim is undoubtedly the definitive and original Assassin's Creed villain.