Batman: Arkham Knight DLC - 7 Reasons The Season Pass Is A Total Failure

$40 for some character skins?! Come the f**k on.

Did you know Batman: Arkham Knight is STILL not available on PC? Way back in June it emerged the console versions had been prioritised by developers Rocksteady (for whatever reason, I don't know), so come release you had a fairly butter-smooth experience on both PS4 and Xbox One, whilst the PC release was a genuinely unplayable mess for the majority of players. It resulted in Warner Bros. pulling the game from Steam to make amends, yet three whole months later checking the same sales page returns a prompt that proves it's still not ready. That's simply not good enough, and it's an attitude that ties directly into WB/Rocksteady's rollout of the season pass content. Bat-fans have been thoroughly taken for a ride with this, as many put their faith in the reputable developer/publisher combo, coughing up the very hefty £32.99/$39.99 initial asking price, hoping it would be justified in the long run. To their credit, following the announcement of this (rather ludicrous) 'buy now, play later' approach, Rocksteady did break down what you'd be receiving, albeit in fairly vague terms. "New Story Missions" here, "Extra Riddler Raceways" there - even a tantalising look into the 'Season of Infamy' pack, where it looked like none-other than Mr. Freeze was going to make a return. Where are we with all that though? Well, you can get a 1989 Michael Keaton skin, a half-hour Batgirl mission or... some more skins. It's pitiful, and leads me to really take a step back and look at this thing with a mix of opinion and objectivity. Fans are suitably pissed, and they have every right to be. Note: Spoilers will be discussed in reference to a certain returning character and the Arkham Knight's identity.


7. Nobody Wants (To Pay For) The Racetracks

I mean, you've gotta hand it to Rocksteady, they're not abating from the notion of "The Batmobile is the best thing ever!" for one second. Scratch the reviews that said it ruined the game or felt unnecessary, they had a solid innovation to the core Arkham game formula (something I personally really liked), and they're going to supplement that with a bevy of Riddler trophies and additional raceways going forward. The thing is, even if you go with the idea that the Batmobile is liked as an extension of the base gameplay, NOBODY wants to do time trial races in it. Even in dedicated racing games elsewhere, time trials are the things you avoid, and in Arkham Knight they're most definitely not a big enough draw to plump down extra cash on the content. Despite the Michael Keaton-themed skin being pretty cool and the associated 1989 racetrack being loaded with everything from tiny penguins to floating snowmen-balloons, if we'd got eyes on this content before paying the money in good faith, I hazard to say nobody would've paid for it. And that's despite the notion such a novelty addition to the base game should've been an easter egg unlock in the first place, not something intended to convince early-adopters their money's been well spent.

6. Batgirl's Content Should've Been In The Main Game

There's a niggling feeling when you look at the Batgirl DLC, that it feels like it was initially scheduled to be in the main game. Think about it; the core story of Barbara being crippled is key to her character, provides a spot for Mark Hamill to get his Joker on outside of wandering in and out of your subconscious every few minutes, and helps establish her presence as something more than just a voice in your ear. Most likely we'd have experienced this as a flashback or optional secret trigger from inside the Clocktower, not as a paid extra that - although it 'works' in as much as it's fun to play in another skin - doesn't even come close to feeling worthwhile. Even thematically, aside from saving the reveal of the Joker's existence as something inside Bats' mind, the fact Mark Hamill was in the game became apparent as soon as cast lists and reviews started filtering out. The point where he pops up from behind Bats would still have hit home from the way it was shot, and we could've been led to believe he was dead by deliberately focussing on this one-time flashback mission as his last hurrah.

5. Where Are The Meaningful Story Missions?

One of the major criticisms for AK came from both the forced Batmobile sections, and the side missions that were far too easy to complete. For me it came across as intended, as the whole game takes place in one night (something that admittedly is a bit of a stretch), so it gets across the idea of Batman applying himself more than ever before to round up Gotham's worst offenders in one evening of superheroic brilliance. However, as enjoyable as slamming Hush through a table and choking Penguin out was, it was all over too fast - particularly with Two-Face's inclusion as essentially a character skin on a regular goon, being you take him down in exactly the same way. Hope came with the Season Pass then, and the 'Season of Infamy' portion of the upcoming DLC. Digging into Arkham Knight's files produced code that pointed towards this DLC including everyone from Prometheus to Mr. Freeze, Ra's al Ghul, Black Mask and even Killer Croc. However, as far as the official word's concerned, fans don't know about these extra characters, instead Rocksteady announced the supremely vague-sounding "Play as Batman in all new story missions featuring legendary super-villains invading Gotham City, with new story arcs, missions and gameplay features". Way to convince us you know what you're doing and not making it up as you along there, guys. All this time later and no comment on what's coming outside of the next month, with nay even a tweet addressing the leaked info, it only reinforces the idea that the team are scrabbling to put out fires left, right and centre, rather than executing on a plan they've been comfortable with since the beginning.

4. The Pre-Order 'Story Packs' Left A Bad Taste That Isn't Going Away

Did you pre-order to get the Red Hood 'Story Pack', or Harley Quinn's? It can be a bit too blunt to say they were lazily put together, but at some point you just have to call a spade a spade. The Red Hood section - a very important character to the story, being if it was handled better, could've paid off massively with the reveal of the Arkham Knight himself - was resigned to a three-area arena, with only one of them allowing for the barest modicum of experimentation. The first and third of these areas were focussed on beating the tar out of Black Mask's followers, weren't topped or tailed by cutscenes, and had their loading screens fronted by such pathetically motivational text as "Embarrass Black Mask by taking out his men". What are we, eight years old? "Yeah I'm gonna show him!" isn't a solid motivation for a character hellbent on getting revenge on a mentor who failed him, and all-round Hood came across as a more of a moody teenager (admittedly a trait he had in the books) than someone with a worthwhile motive. Quinn's faired a little better with a larger area to explore and some environmental triggers to dispatch guards with, but as a 'Story Pack', by definition it was completely lacking. The latest announcement is a Nightwing story add-on where he "Must prevent Penguin from leaving his cell in the GCPD" - but I'm calling it right now, come the end of September that'll be a series of Arkham Asylum-style rooms where you batter goons and eventually one-shot Cobblepot himself.

3. The 'Exclusive Look' Videos Aren't Fooling Anybody

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jS5F5WMhP9Q Any intrepid Arkham series fan will know Dax Ginn, the lovably happy motormouth who presents the behind-the-scenes videos for the development of Knight and the past titles in the series. You can't fault the guy for trying his best to salvage the content given to him, but when last month's video dropped and he was tasked with selling the idea of both the cartoonish 1989 racetrack and one challenge map being anything other than a cop-out, it really started to feel like you were having the wool slowly stitched over your eyes. Thanks to the mobile gaming scene taking off as much as it has and proving the average consumer will happily shell out additional cash for DLC packs or micro-transaction currencies, it's led to the standard model of 'Full retail price-equals-full game' being shattered. We're increasingly seeing games sold with these practices firmly in place, the latest being Metal Gear Solid V's option to purchase 'Diamond Dog coins' for upwards of £70. However, it's when you look at Rocksteady's post-launch offerings where watching the team try their best to re-sell content that's only been siphoned off by their publisher overlords in the first place, that the whole thing just feels disingenuous.

2. There's A Lack Of Confidence We've Never Seen Before

From Arkham Asylum through City and now Knight, Rocksteady proved they're a developer with a devout vision, the smallest easter eggs in both preceding games foreshadowing what was coming in the next. That's a quality you almost never see in any major-released franchise, and as the credits rolled on Arkham Knight, the flashback montage of these tie-in images cemented their original vision as something that was always grander than just one game. However, since Warner Bros. took notice of how phenomenally well the past titles sold, they've seen fit to segment off as much content as possible, much to what must be Rocksteady's behest. We'll most likely never know the day-to-day machinations of what's happening in those offices, but the reality for 99% of game developers is not to ever rip-off the consumer, instead quite the opposite. The overall reception and implementation of the Season Pass is endemic of this; a studio that's had their initial vision for the final Arkham game wrestled away, a compromise being they give up the most ancillary parts of the experience to satisfy corporate needs and create the Pass, yet that means they've got nothing worth showing off after launch day. Right now it feels like Rocksteady don't know what they're doing with their own game's post-launch release schedule, and that's almost definitely down to a clashing of ideals when it comes to financial motivations versus those of the studio's creative leads.

1. They Refuse To Listen To Fan Feedback

Four words: 'Where's the free-roam?!" Thing is, for everything the PC release wasn't (a workable enjoyable product en masse), it still let modders do their thing and deep-dive into the game's code. That resulted in a custom patch that lets you play as everyone from Batman to Nightwing, Harley Quinn, Joker and Catwoman in the open-world. It's something fans somewhat expected as a feature coming out of the Catwoman-fronting Arkham City, yet despite us mentioning it on the official forums and plastering everywhere the devs may look, "We want to control other characters in the open world", it's not even been discussed. In terms of possibilities, look at The Witcher 3 and its post-release content. Firstly, it was all free, and second CD Projekt RED listened to fan-demands, adding a New Game Plus option simply because consumers demanded it so much. They admittedly had to ask for a bit more time to implement it properly, but four months on that game now has a slew of additional costumes, free additional quests, customisable character items and a fully-working New Game Plus. That's how it's done. By contrast, Arkham Knight is unplayable on PC, has charged gamers $40 for a handful of skins and a half-hour of single player content, continuing to churn out "And look what's coming next!"-style videos as if nothing's wrong. At some point both Rocksteady and Warner Bros. need to throw up their hands and admit this is verging on a disaster of Ubisoft/Assassin's Creed: Unity proportions, and whether that means chunks of content get given away for free or they take the time to rewrite the ship, I'd say it's testament to how much we love this studio and franchise that such a complete mess has been allowed to go on so long already. Did you pay for the Season Pass? Have you been satisfied with the game's post-release content? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.