Batman Arkham Origins: 3 Reasons Why Having 8 Assassins Could Suck
Let me start off this article by saying I have high hopes for this game: it is part of a quality franchise that provided me with one of the best single-player experiences I ever had, second only to Assassin's Creed. I am concerned with the change of developers, but I trust Rocksteady and I have faith in their decision, and besides, they have a solid formula to work with, so what could go wrong? Well, a lot, actually. And the chief reason for this is that Warner Bros Montreal have decided to have not just one or two, but EIGHT assassins in the game, who will be the main focus of game, aside from Black Mask of course. Now this might sound epic on paper, but if the execution is off even slightly, this game could be a disaster and become victim of the Third Curse, just like The Dark Knight Rises and Raimi's Spider-Man 3. NOTE: This article contains minor spoilers from Arkham City.
3. Shallow Story And Repetitive Gameplay
When you decide to do a prequel for anything, there are usually two possible outcomes: it could be excellent and enhance the character stories that have been told so far while keeping the continuity intact, or there could be problems with continuity and only surface additions to story. Quite fatally, it could also weaken the relationship between characters, which is good for noone. While I highly doubt Origins will have the second outcome, I'm not so sure it can achieve the first either. I'm 99% sure the game won't mess up the continuity, but it is a good chance it will fail to add any layers to the characters. Part of the problem comes from the characters themselves: do we really need to feel more connected to Bane? Is there much to show between the Bat and the Joker? Maybe, maybe not - it all depends on the direction the writers take. For instance, we could just get a Batman who fully embodies the no-killing rule or we could receive a slightly different Batman. Maybe Batman firmly believes in this rule, but that changes when he meets the Joker. He may find himself questioning whether or not Joker should be put down, assuming Joker is committing any large murders. Once again, it depends on the writers. As far as the gameplay, just look at the trailers: Batman goes to one location, takes down regular thugs, and is surprised by an assassin. This happens in both in the Deathstroke and Copperhead trailer, which makes one wonder if this is the only approach the game will use? Depending on how you play the game this might not be a problem and there are other ways to introduce the killers, but with this new studio, they might go the lazy route.
2. Under-cooked Characters
This is probably my biggest fear for this game. When I heard Origins will have eight people out to kill Batman, I was initially excite,d but now that I had time to reflect, this could be very bad for the story, especially since this game will follow its predecessors by making these events occur in one night. If they chose to increase this time limit, not only would it solve this problem but it would also add a change to the good, but repetitive formula. But, since it's the same, the problem still exists. Now the danger is in Gotham where citizens are supposed to be out and about and that can make or break the game. If there are going to be a lot of side characters causing mayhem, we need to see the people panicking. We need to feel the urgency so we can see Batman become the hero he is meant to be. We need to see that strong hatred for crime Batman has grow. If this doesn't happen, the side missions will come off as pure filler. See, in Arkham Asylum and City, the setting themselves addressed any development issues. In Asylum, the location was a small island, where Joker was the main focus and large numbers of innocent people weren't at stake. Well, there was the poisoning of the water system and in City the blood in the hospitals was poisoned, but I that was more indirect and the urgency wasn't really there. But back to what I was saying; in City, it takes place in a prison cut off from the main city, so innocent lives aren't at stake as well. It also eliminated the need to focus on all the criminals, since they were already in jail and only posed a threat to themselves. There's also the fact that time this took place handled the development, as well. Batman has been Batman for quite some time, just like the Joker and Bane have already established their place in the rogue gallery. All the relationships have been developed. That's not to mention that if WB decide to put relatively unknown characters like Copperhead as the killers, the players would want some background. Just a quick little dialogue or cinematic will suffice, but I would hate for them to just be random hit-men.
1. So, How Long Have You Been Doing This?
This is the biggest problem the game must tackle. This iteration of Batman is not the seasoned hero we all know; he is in his second year and have yet to fight opponents that match, or even surpass his skill. So, to become the best you had to fight the best. But fighting eight, in one night?! I hate to say it, but I better be seeing this Batman getting bested more than once, or it won't be very realistic. Having so many deadly opponents go against a fresh Bat in one night is quite a tall order, and if done wrong, the game won't make much sense. We are supposed to see a struggling Batman. If he can beat everyone with ease, the game becomes pointless. I mean, just look at the competition. Bane broke Batman's back and I looked it up and it seems that Deathstroke came close to killing the Bat more than once. I'm pretty sure it wasn't a beginner Batman either. However, Montreal seems to have this covered if we look at the trailer. Deadshot ended up unintentionally saving Batman from Deathstroke, so that could show they recognize the difficulty of Batman's enemies. Still, I don't want Batman to always need an convenient event to occur to defeat his enemies. I don't think Montreal will mess this up, but only time can tell. Let me know what you think in the comments.