Battlefield 2042 Review: 6 Ups & 6 Downs
The new Battlefield has 2042 problems.
Battlefield 2042 has been fighting an uphill battle since it was announced. Coming in the wake of Battlefield V - a series low point but far from a terrible game - and increased competition from a renewed Call of Duty and Halo: Infinite, DICE and EA needed a home run.
Despite a blistering reveal, the buzz around the first next-gen Battlefield has fluctuated. A last-minute delay and buggy Beta didn’t inspire much optimism, nor did the small amount of gameplay footage actually shown prior to release.
Still, there were reasons to be optimistic. A shooter over three years in the making, Battlefield 2042 has lofty ambitions. With up to 128 players on next-gen machines and PC, it’s easily the biggest game in the franchise, built around three multiplayer pillars.
The first, All Out War, comprises two classic game modes (Conquest and Breakthrough) across large maps. Second is Hazard Zone, a tactical squad-based mode akin to a battle royale where players need to extract data points behind enemy lines. Finally there’s Battlefield Portal, a community-driven mode that allows fans to mix-and-match rules, maps, and weapons from not only Battlefield 2042, but remastered versions of Battlefield 1942, Bad Company 2, and Battlefield 3.
After a week of early access and with the official launch day finally here though, how does EA’s latest effort hold up?
--
Disclosure: In the interest in full transparency, it’s important to note the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast has featured episodes sponsored by EA & Battlefield 2042. This review, however, is not sponsored.
Reviewed on PS5, copy provided by EA.
UPS
6. Maps Are Huge & 128 Player Battles Are Intense
As mentioned in the intro, this is the biggest Battlefield yet, and thankfully that scale translates into intense, varied firefights.
Though the first couple days of early access didn’t make the best first impression as players familiarised themselves slowly with the maps - discovering choke points and the general flow - now action isn’t difficult to find.
Each of the seven All Out War maps have distinct points of interest that are fun to battle over, encouraging a wide variety of play styles in the process. There’s a lot of flat terrain to traverse which isn’t always fun (especially with the lack of transport vehicles), but attacking points are mostly well designed, offering plenty of memorable moments.
One gripe from the beta was that even with the increased player count, maps felt empty. That’s thankfully not the case in the final release, and being a part of those huge fights offers a sense of awe that’s incredible when the game clicks.
5. Breakthrough Is A Standout Mode
I’ve been a Conquest man through and through for most of my Battlefield career, but call me an out-of-date meme because my head has well and truly been turned by 2042’s rendition of Breakthrough.
For those unaware, this sees an attacking team attempt to take sectors from defenders by capturing a handful of flags in a specific section of a map. If the sector is taken, the teams move to the next sector of the map to capture the flags there, and so forth until finally reaching the defenders’ HQ.
Unlike Conquest, the immediacy of this mode in 2042 makes for an unrelenting experience, as teams throw themselves at each other in focused environments. With that many players in such a small area - and a mix of infantry and vehicular combat - you’re constantly experiencing spectacular, player-driven set pieces.
Coming over a hill with tens of players and a couple of tanks offers the kind of fist-pumping energy this series captures so well, and this mode constantly delivers on those trailer-level moments where firefights are happening all around you, while explosions rain down from the sky.
Balance issues hamper the consistency of this mode (more on that later), but overall Breakthrough gameplay is an impressive, next-gen-feeling feat.
4. The Art Direction Is Great
While DICE’s World War franchise entries have been solid, it’s great to see the developer return to a near-future setting. Unlike the drab, desaturated warehouses of Modern Warfare, Battlefield 2042 is full to the brim with visually interesting levels.
Whether it’s a metropolis in the desert, a map split in two with lush greenery on one side and harsh canyons on the other or a cavernous glacier, the semi-familiar sights of this time period are a welcome change of pace.
Generally as well, the visuals across the board are top notch. On next-gen machines gun models are detailed, the draw distance is impressive, and the overall ambience is absolutely there.
It’s not the most beautiful game on the market, but considering the increased scope and added players, the visuals haven’t been sacrificed.
3. Battlefield Portal Has Incredible Potential
Ever since Battlefield 2042 was announced, Battlefield Portal has been the one thing the fanbase has been able to fully get behind.
Led by Ripple Effect, this suite allows fans to make their own custom game modes by mixing and matching weapons, factions, maps, classes and vehicles from Battlefield 2042, Battlefield 3, Bad Company 2 and Battlefield 1942.
It’s been marketed as a love letter to fans, and that is absolutely felt in the suite at the moment. Jumping into Bad Company 2’s Rush mode, for instance, with its remastered maps and authentic-feeling combat pace and weaponry, is a dream come true for fans longing to see that sub-series return. Even if you don’t jive with the new content in 2042, there’ll be something here for you.
Likewise, the tools given to you to create custom matches are extensive, with players having unprecedented levels of control over their own servers.
However, it should be noted that as good as Portal is, it’s only a start. Currently most of the "imaginative" game modes players have come up with are XP farms, and the XP cap DICE has included to make sure people don’t abuse this suite for levelling like this does feel particularly restrictive.
This is a mode that’s going to live or die on both community support as well as DICE adding content - let’s just hope they don’t let this gem of a mode languish post-release.
2. Specialists Are Surprisingly Fun
Perhaps the most controversial positive on this list, fans have been split on DICE’s decision to remove the regular Battlefield classes with locked weapons and gadgets, and instead include a bunch of operators with unique gadgets, abilities and customisation options.
While the argument that swapping out classes will massively impact team play is a valid one, specialists do have a lot going for them. Each plays radically different, with a bunch of team-focussed strengths and weakness. The unique gadgets are fun as all hell as well, whether it’s the grappling hook that makes you a master of verticality, or the wingsuit, which will make even the weakest Battlefield player feel like they’re living out a top YouTuber’s best play montage.
The ability for players to mix and match gadgets also hasn’t negatively impacted team play from my experience. There are still plenty of people running medic roles, dishing out ammo and providing a variety of support on the field. For a very different Battlefield like this, specialists are an intriguing experiment.
Just please get rid of those cringe end-of-round one-liners, DICE.
1. The Sense Of Scale Is Insane
Much has been said about the game’s implementation of storms and weather effects. Rather than each map being static and locked to a specific time of day, throughout matches they’ll be hit with different weather that changes the texture of the environment. Sometimes this is a simple downpour, but other times you’re hit with extreme sandstorms or tornadoes.
It’s during these moments where the scale of Battlefield 2042 really shines. Seeing the giant wall of sand roll into a level provides an evocative backdrop to fight against, and overall adds to the intensity of each bout. It might be a bit of a gimmick, but it does make 2042 look and feel unlike any other shooter on the market.
The added verticality to the maps is also a plus. While it’s a shame there isn’t much of a middle ground, reincorporating skyscrapers, huge towers and massive tankers into maps makes them as tall as they are wide. Fighting at different levels keeps the action flowing, and adds more dynamics to combat.
DOWNS
6. A Severe Lack Of Content
Okay so this is technically one down, but it’s a biggie.
On the surface, Battlefield 2042 seems to provide decent bang for your buck. Yes there’s no campaign, but the three main modes of play are expansive, the maps are bigger than ever, and there are a wealth of specialists to choose from.
When you actually look at what’s on offer though, it’s incredibly lacking.
First up is the weapon variety. In All Out War players have a mere 22 weapons to choose from. SMGs and Assault Rifle classes get four weapons each, but on the other side of the coin there’s only two LMGs and one shotgun.
Unfortunately, weapon attachments aren’t much better, and don’t offer the kind of transformational opportunities that, say, Gunsmith provides in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare. In fact, a lot of the attachments share stat buffs, meaning the choice is purely cosmetic. Weapon variety is at an all time low, and it removes the incentive of levelling up.
The same is true for gadgets. Anti-armour options are laughably slim, while cosmetic changes like camouflages are few are far between, and require demanding grinds to unlock.
Next up is the maps. With seven in All Out War, the selection isn’t awful, but the size of the areas don’t make up for the lack of variety and the sense of familiarity that quickly sets in.
What compounds this even more is the lack of continuous lobbies. After every round you’re thrown back to the menu to search for another game, meaning if you’re unlucky like me, you can go hours playing the same handful of maps. If I have to replay Kaleidoscope back to back one more time, I won’t be held responsible for my actions.
Portal is perhaps the most disappointing though. With each older game only getting two maps each, players will be yearning for more at launch, especially as Portal is such a saving grace overall. Let’s hope fan favourites arrive in future seasons.
That’s part of the problem though. The content here feels barebones for a multiplayer-only experience, and you can’t shake the feeling that the game won’t feature a full arsenal or suite of maps until post-launch content is added with the planned seasons.
There are glaring omissions here, and it sucks for a full-price game of this calibre.
5. A Step Back For Player Mobility
Say what you will about Battlefield V, but it was a huge step up for the franchise in terms of game-feel.
The added control over your soldier combined with immersive new animations resulted in a FPS that felt different from the competition. From being able to prone on your back to vaulting to high areas to the general finesse when it came to mobility, it felt great to play.
For whatever reason, 2042 feels like a step back in this regard. Gone are most of those mobility refinements (including leaning!), to the point where your soldier feels rigid, awkward, and somewhat unresponsive.
If this is your first Battlefield you may not have an issue with this, but if you’re coming from previous games, it’s baffling that movement feels so limited.
4. The UI Is Awful
Battlefield 2042 doesn’t make the best first impression, and part of the reason why is the headache-inducing UI design.
An overwhelming mess of colours and button inputs, just figuring out how to find a game to begin with can be confusing.
The HUD during gameplay is just as bad as well. It’s difficult to get your bearings or understand what each symbol means. Likewise, the HUD doesn’t convey simple information clearly or elegantly. Throw up the map screen and you’ll have trouble figuring out where the hell you are on it. Icons and colours blur together, making it far more difficult than it should be to parse what’s going on.
Combine this with a large banner at the top every time you take sector, and the whole thing feels a little bit… oppressive. It’s not immersive, and it’s certainly not clear, so what function does it serve?
3. Weapon And Team Balance Isn’t There
Quite frankly, the weapon balancing in 2042 at the moment sucks.
Assault rifles might as well be non-existent, thanks to the extreme recoil and low damage output. While it is refreshing that DICE decided to give weapons the kick fans have craved for a while, inconsistency between classes makes the implementation frustrating. SMGs, for instance, currently outclass rifles even at range. How does that work? I have no idea, but it makes the already limited weapons even more limited.
Add in hit registration issues on top of this, with bullets clearly impacting targets but not registering damage, and gunplay sometimes devolves into nothing but frustration.
Team balancing issues also rear their head. For instance, playing Breakthrough, a great mode when things are working correctly, matches can be over in an instant, with one team often dominating. It’s not uncommon for attacking teams to not capture the first set of objectives and between this and being kicked back to the menu after every match, it’s difficult to get into a proper flow with the game.
Thankfully DICE is already addressing these issues at the time of writing - promising fixes in the future and already tweaking Breakthrough settings - but this stuff should be sorted at launch.
2. An Overall Lack Of Polish
Thankfully Battlefield 2042 isn’t a technical disaster at launch. This isn’t the Beta build and it’s not Battlefield 4, but there’s still a lack of polish on the whole.
While I have been playing in early access, there have still been issues with matchmaking. I’ve launched into lobbies populated solely by myself, while the server browser for Portal sometimes throws me out of queues despite waiting through the map loading screens, while other times it’ll decide to put me in the All Out War screen instead.
In-game you have issues as well. As mentioned there’s the hit-detection issues, but there are also vehicle glitches like the hovercrafts being able to drive up the side of skyscrapers like they’re the batmobile from Batman Forever. It’s hilarious to see in-game - until it absolutely annihilates you, anyway.
Then there’s the lack of player feedback. Much has been said online about the lack of a player scoreboard, but it really is a big omission. Seeing a basic overview of some stats at the end of a round is fine enough, but what reason was there to totally discard the regular points scoreboard?
Fighting vehicles also isn’t satisfying unless you deliver the finishing blow thanks to a lack of feedback. There’s no way to gauge how much damage you’re dealing thanks to a hit only registering with a “10xp Part Destroyed” prompt which at best is deflating, and at worst sees you waste rockets on fights you can’t win.
1. Disappointing Destruction
Destruction has always been a staple of Battlefield, but on certain maps in 2042 you’d be forgiven for forgetting about it entirely.
While there are still some structures scattered around maps that can be blown up and partially destroyed, these are often the exception, rather than the rule. More than ever, the maps in 2042 are filled with environments and interiors that can’t be destroyed, resulting in levels that feel more static than in previous titles.
It’s such a shame, especially with this being the first next-gen game in the series, to see DICE’s attention move away from this core pillar of gameplay. It feels almost like an obligation at this point, rather than a unique mode of play that can be utilised to make interesting pathways through levels.
It’s not a total failure, but playing Portal reminds you what the destruction could have been like in All Out War.