Battlefield 5: 9 Reasons Fans Should Be Worried

It might be good, right? Emphasis on "might".

Battlefield 5
EA

Since stumbling onto our screens in a divisive first trailer, Battlefield V has had a difficult time finding its feet. Mired amongst controversy, fan outrage and sheer bad PR, it seems like the game is already doomed. And whilst fans can try to be optimistic, there isn't much out there to stoke faith in their favourite series.

EA has something to prove with this game's success, though ultimately we don't need to wait for release to understand how BFV has impacted the company. Poor preorder sales are indicative of the current mentality towards EA, and by sheer attachment to the project, they appear to be harming it. It seems many fans have simply had enough.

But what is there to actually worry about? And should the fans condemn it as a misstep at such an early stage?

Even if you've watched the trailers, seen gameplay and played the alpha thinking it's not that bad, chances are EA will find a way to get a garbage fire going. And despite their best efforts to seemingly 'save' the project so far, there are still a lot of things fans are raising their eyebrows at.

9. EA's Tendencies

Darth Vader Battlefront 2
EA

Let's get the obvious out of the way. This is EA we are talking about. And whilst it seems almost trivial to mention it, anything with their name attached must be taken with a grain of salt until all the information is in the consumer's hand.

We still don't know much about the game's DLC plan, which as fans will know, raises a lot of red flags. With a propensity for overindulging in shady DLC schemes, EA isn't exactly comforting people by keeping such details in the dark.

That, and EA seem to care universally about the bottom line, whether it helps the consumer or not. With Star Wars Battlefront 1, it was DLC. With Battlefront 2, it was lootboxes. EA have a track record of doing something to milk money out of fans, only to retrofit those greedy problems in the next game.

The question really isn't whether or not they will do something, but rather what is the crux of the game this time?


8. The Alpha

Battlefield V
EA

The Alpha needed to a lot in order to secure the fan's confidence. Despite alphas almost never being emblematic of the final product, EA and DICE really needed to put an impressive experience forward. And did they? Well... no.

Looking past the obvious balancing issues and various other nitpicks, the alpha was entirely underwhelming. The class system was a nice addition but was quite abusable. The snow effect for the maps was abysmal and definitely, need to be tweaked. And the game just lacked anything special.

Considering the muddy waters that Battlefield V is trudging through on the way to launch, the alpha was necessary to bolster fans faith in the series and it didn't really do that.


7. Battle Royale

Fortnite Battle Royale
Epic

Including battle royale fundamentally shows a misunderstanding of the audience that enjoys these games. There was never much of an outcry for DICE to go down this route in the first place, so a lot of fans feel alienated as the others problems they have with the series remain unattended to in lieu of following a trend.

It's also very unlikely that the game will even dent the proverbial monopoly that Fortnite has established, with the resources to develop it being wasted.

However, recent revelations indicate that the mode will be completely free to play, which is at least a step in the right direction. However, most fans presumed it would be free to play before this announcement anyway.

It feels very much like EA are trying to save a sinking ship, which may look all well and good, but even if you can order a three course meal on the Titanic, it doesn't change the fact you're gonna hit that iceberg.


6. EA And Dead Products

Battlefield 5 bad company
EA

EA is a company that wants to turn a profit. Their business practices in the past have always indicated that. Their affinity for dropping projects as soon as they no longer turn a decent amount of revenue is widely known which puts Battlefield V in hot water. At the current rate, it seems that the game may not even get a decent lifespan, at least in terms of EA putting hefty amounts of money into it. It could very much be dead out of the gate.

There is a multitude of games that have been axed simply because of their lack of monetizability. You have Visceral's Star Wars game that was cut because it had no multiplayer options and no room for things such as loot-boxes. Andromeda got support for its single player cut as soon as it was no longer disasterous.

Of course, a cash cow like Battlefield isn't going to get axed, but supporting an unprofitable game isn't EA's MO.

Though, to many people's surprise, a notable rumour centres on Battlefield V coming with a Battlefield Bad Company 2 remaster, either on launch or as post-game content.

Undoubtedly, an attempt to bolster pre-order sales, this would definitely show EA wants to make sure Battlefield V sells, but in terms of ensuring the quality of the new instalment it's damning, if anything.


5. Server Problems

Star Wars Battlefront Gonk
EA

The launch of DICE's previous few online oriented shooters have all been belaboured by poor servers and match-making connections. It seems at launch they simply don't have the infrastructure in place to support such massive multi-player experiences.

Which is worrying for the latest game in that genre. We can all hope that they have finally learnt their lesson, but after Battlefront 1 and 2, Battlefield: Hardline and many more, we have to wonder whether or not they have even realised it's a problem.

It's not exactly been a minor issue. From launch, these problems have belaboured these games and fans have been enthusiastic in their critique for the lack of support. But time and time again, they seem to skimp on the infrastructure to keep a multiplayer game alive.

It is massively frustrating, as with game's like Battlefront 2, there was a decent game to be played. But stomaching connection issues made it impossible to do so. So, chances are, we could get a great Battlefield game, but the likelihood of many of us playing it with stable connections is very low indeed.


4. Nothing New

Battlefield V
EA

The first-person shooter genre has been adapting to the market over the years. The rise in popularity of Doom and Wolfenstein marks a shift in the minds of the consumer, a shift that Battlefield appears confident to ignore.

Of course, shifting the series towards the more run and gun viscera of the Doom and Wolfenstein would be a mistake, but a failure to adapt and innovate is a worrying problem.

The fact that at E3, the developers proudly announced that you could finally move artillery around as a "new feature" appears to be emblematic of their stance on innovation.

People want something new and at the moment, Battlefield V looks to simply be a piece of glorified DLC. Nothing new and nothing exceptional.


3. EA Goading Fans

Battlefield 5
EA

You would expect EA to be extremely tentative at this point and time, rolling over to fans and simply doing anything they can to curry favour. But that doesn't seem to be the case. Everyone will have seen the article in which EA says that if fans don't like the direction of the game, then they shouldn't buy it, all before preorder numbers underperform.

It is likely that EA thought their goading was going towards critics of their new take on WW2, but what they didn't realise is that the people who are complaining are genuine long-term fans, who want their beloved franchise to be great.

So, telling said fans that they can just deal with it simply idiotic and has obviously backfired. Rule 101 of business: Don't tell your fans they can bugger off.


2. "Historical Inaccuracy"

Battlefield 5
DICE

The historical inaccuracy of the game is a big topic for debate and one that is hovering over the game like a rain cloud. But it ultimately comes down to the major selling point of these yearly release shooters. And that is the setting. No one buys these games for the new guns, but the historical dressing, and not retaining a consistent level of accuracy is going to annoy fans.

That's not say there is not a place for disabled people and women in video-games. Of course, there is, you'd be an idiot to argue against that. But when you are trying to sell a historical WW2 shooter to fans of the franchise, they will want it to be as accurate as possible. That's why people liked Battlefield 1.

It is again, another misunderstanding of the core fanbase for these games. The fact that that fanbase has turned from the game because of the direction of the series should be enough to raise red flags. It's not that the fanbase is sexist, it's that they want a WW2 game. And at this present moment and time, it doesn't seem like they are getting exactly what they want.


1. The Delay

Battlefield 5
EA

EA has announced that the game is going to be delayed a month which seems like a really good step to take in terms of saving the game's image. But, a month in terms of game development isn't exactly much. Chances are this is simply to ensure that the game launches in a playable state and isn't as buggy and broken as their past few releases.

When it comes to fixing the fundamental problems that fans have (the historical inaccuracy and so on), that month isn't going to help. The game is pretty much finished in terms of structure and design, so we can't expect major things to be changed.

It is still a positive step that EA is making an effort to ensure the game is of a notable standard, but again, it is very much like clapping a baby's first steps.


Contributor

I like video games, writing and writing about video games. Expect sarcasm and the dry wit of a Brit. And the occasional rant of a unhappy Scot. You know... the usual.