Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare Beta Review - 5 Ups & 5 Downs
Call of Duty: Battlefield.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare finally opened up its multiplayer beta to all players this past weekend, and it's fair to say that the response across the fanbase has been divisive, to say the least.
On one hand it's clear that Activision and Infinity Ward are trying to claw back goodwill with fans who have been alienated by the series' increasingly silly entries over the last few years.
Yet from the evidence provided by this beta, they've also taken a fairly simplistic and unoriginal approach to recapturing that former glory.
Modern Warfare appears to be a (mostly) back-to-basics romp that also offers up a semi-admirable attempt to expand the scope of the multiplayer suite, while presenting some uniquely democratic options for the global player-base.
Overall it delivers enough fast-paced carnage to satisfy in spite of its flaws, even if it's clear that the whole needs some work - and some complaints clearly aren't going to be fixed for when the game hits stores on October 25th...
Downs...
5. It's Like Battlefield...But Not As Good
Almost immediately after diving into a match of 32v32 Ground War, players would be forgiven for assuming they were actually playing a Battlefield game rather than the latest Call of Duty.
In addition to the larger-scale combat, the HUD and general map layout feels far more akin to Battlefield, albeit executed without the same level of polish or panache.
Given that fans have been asking for larger teams for years, it's great to see Activision finally pushing ahead with it, though it's tough to escape the feeling that the end result is really just a watered-down Battlefield, with less intuitive map design, spawns and so on.
While Battlefield brilliantly realises the push-and-pull of war, on the basis of this beta Modern Warfare's epic battles feel more like an attempt to throw everything fans could possibly want at the wall and see what sticks.
It's not bad by any means, but it does feel rather sloppy in all of its chaos.
4. Spawns Are A Mess
One of the most obvious areas where Modern Warfare pales in comparison to a Battlefield game is the atrocious state of the spawns at present.
The larger scale fights invite arguably the worst spawns in the history of the Call of Duty franchise, though even on smaller modes such as Team Deathmatch and Domination, it's not uncommon to spawn comically far away from objectives or enemies, spawn in the same spot repeatedly, or even spawn mere inches away from the other team and die immediately.
Thankfully this is at least one aspect of the game that Infinity Ward can reasonably tweak in the remaining weeks before release, because at the moment it leads to intermittent frustration regardless of the mode.
3. Massively Underwhelming Visuals
Activision has extensively talked up the new engine being used to power Modern Warfare, succeeding the wildly outdated IW engine which the franchise has been using for almost 15 years.
And yet, despite a series of glossy trailers playing-up the slick new 4K visuals, from what's on offer in the beta, the results are pretty underwhelming.
Even when running in 4K on a powerful PC, textures frequently look blandly low-poly and there's an embarrassing amount of graphical pop-in.
Worse still is the game's approach to dynamic range lighting: dark areas are frequently too dark, making it difficult to spot enemies until they've got the drop on you.
It might be "realistic" for sudden lighting changes to affect the player's vision, but it's not fun wandering into a room with compromised visibility for a second-or-so.
Performance is meanwhile far more variable on consoles: base PS4 can't regularly maintain 60 FPS, and there's a garish blurriness that's incredibly offputting.
Overall, whatever the platform, this isn't the tectonic leap in visual fidelity fans were led to believe, and it ultimately still looks utterly pedestrian from a graphical perspective.
2. Time-To-Kill Is Too Low
The time-to-kill in any major FPS is always going to be a significant talking point among fans, and in fairness, mileage is always sure to vary between those who love twitchy, split-second TTK and those who prefer a more sustained battle with less predictable outcomes.
And while Modern Warfare certainly doesn't boast the lowest TTK of the franchise, it still feels frustratingly fast, especially given Ground War's more sprawling map layout and the greater travelling required to arrive at a gunfight.
Most encounters will simply come down to who saw who first, while a higher TTK would inject a greater sense of tension into the game as skilled players can turn the tide despite being fired upon first.
Again this is at least something which can be tweaked pre-release, but as it stands, despite the overall high quality of the gunplay, it feels like you're downed a little too quickly for combat to be fully satisfying.
1. "Return To Combat Area" Strikes Again
Battlefield's dreaded "invisible" boundaries make their presence known in Modern Warfare's Ground War mode, and as usual, it feels like an incredibly lazy element of game design.
Venture into the red fringes of the map and you'll be greeted with a "return to combat area" message, accompanied by a mere five-second timer to exit the Zone of Death or be instantly annihilated.
Given that most people stumbling into this area will be in vehicles, it's a pretty damn strict time limit in which to return to the fray. That's not to ignore how transparent an attempt it is to ensure players remain funnelled into the main map area.
So, Modern Warfare clearly has issues, but there's also a lot to like. Here's what it gets right...
Ups...
5. Ground War Is Entertaining 64-Player Mayhem
Though Ground War definitely needs some work, Infinity Ward at least deserves credit for finally delivering a larger-scale multiplayer mode that attempts to match the insanity of the Battlefield skirmishes.
While Activision claims that the final retail version will feature over 100 players, even 64 players makes for a uniquely dynamic - and yes, chaotic - Call of Duty experience.
Some will surely find the action too busy for their tastes, especially with the broken spawn system being what it is, but if the developer can iron out the issues while delivering 100-player carnage, this could easily end up Modern Warfare's main selling point (especially with the apparent lack of a Battle Royale mode).
4. CoD's Best Gunplay In Years
Though the TTK definitely needs a tweak, at a base level the gunplay in Modern Warfare is the slickest and most satisfying the Call of Duty franchise has offered in years.
Stripping back the outlandishness of more recent CoD games, there's a refreshing simplicity to the point-and-shoot gunplay here, with machine guns packing an entertainingly meaty punch. Sniping is also extremely fun, especially if you can find a sneaky perch during a round of Ground War.
Even with the low TTK, the overall pace of the game feels slower and more methodical, so impatient players will be punished for rushing in, while those who take their time to set up a kill will be rewarded.
3. Fun New Gimmick Modes
The beta also showcased many of Modern Warfare's new gimmicky modes, and while they won't be for all tastes, there's a welcome amount of diversity among them.
NVG mode sees players equipped with night-vision goggles as they battle the opposing team in near-darkness, creating a unique sense of urgency, even if the hyper-saturated visuals can often make it frustratingly tough to spot enemies. Still, a fun diversion all the same.
Then there's Gunfight, a 2v2 arena-type mode, where all players have the same starting weapon loadouts and can collect more advanced guns scattered around the map. Typically, rounds don't last long, and it's a neat addition that's destined to appeal to the hardcore shooter crowd.
Hardcore players may also love Realism mode, which strips the HUD away, heightens bullet damage and activates friendly fire. And finally, there's Cyber Attack, a new riff on Search and Destroy, where players can either wipe out the enemy team or plant an EMP device on their objective.
What separates it from S&D is the simple-but-brilliant revive mechanic, allowing players to bring their teammates back from the brink and keep the fight alive, albeit at the risk of being caught off-guard by an enemy.
While these modes probably won't strictly sell the game to many, they do represent a solid amount of added value in a game that's been dinged by fans for not featuring the traditional Zombies mode.
2. Crossplay & Cross-Progression Support Is A Major Win
Fans the world over were thrilled when Activision confirmed that not only will Modern Warfare support crossplay between PC and consoles, but players could test it out for themselves during the open beta period.
And the results are, for the most part, pretty damn seamless, allowing friends to play together regardless of their platform choice, and even create a cross-platform friends list allowing for maximum ease of navigation.
Given that crossplay is one of the big gaming buzzwords right now - and understandably so - it's great to see one of the biggest video game franchises of all time setting an impressive standard for what its AAA brethren should follow.
And better still, because Modern Warfare requires players to create an Activision account, cross-progression is reportedly also possible, allowing players to carry their levelling and loadouts between versions of the game. What a time to be alive.
1. Incredible Sound Design
Sound design is always ultra important for the FPS genre, and Modern Warfare offers up quite arguably the strongest that the series has ever seen.
Playing the game with a good set of headphones is a transformative experience when compared to tinny TV speakers: Infinity Ward has clearly taken major pains to create as immersive and realistic a soundscape as possible.
Bullets make different sounds depending on circumstance, and with their unique layering sound far more authentic than a simple stock gunshot sound effect.
Quite how it measures up to the Battlefield games will be up for debate - that series has historically dunked on CoD in this department - yet on its own merits, Modern Warfare offers a major aural step up from the last few games in the series.
That rigorous commitment to "realism" evidently isn't purely marketing spiel.