Destiny 2: 10 Big Things Bungie Must Fix

Making the rest of that $500 million count.

Destiny was an awkward idea from the day it was announced. An attempt at hybridising the FPS and MMORPG genres, Bungie's new-gen breakout wanted to make history. In many ways, it did; but its name has been engraved on all the wrong trophies. "Most Infuriating Loot System" probably wasn't a planned achievement; "Most Limited Endgame" is none too appealing either. For all its promise, due to a nasty mix of poor management and general underdevelopment, Destiny has fallen flat at nearly every opportunity. And the game's raft of reactionary patches, while undeniably necessary, have done little to patch up the faults at its core. With all that said, at its best Destiny is what all games should strive to be: just plain fun. If you come into it with the right mindset - or better yet with friends - its universe becomes a playground packing hundreds of hours of fun. Visceral shooting and detailed landscapes lift the game above the squalor of its overly 'grindy' and sparse challenges, and hearken back to the adrenaline-fuelled days of Halo by which Destiny was so clearly inspired. Sadly, its troughs far outnumber its peaks, and as it stands Destiny is a mediocre experience on the whole. However, although the gap between the possible and the realised is dangerously wide, Destiny has at least succeeded at the most basic goal of series progenitors: laying the framework for something great. It all comes down to whether Destiny 2 can make the right changes.

10. The Small Universe

Three big characteristics separate such titans as World of Warcraft and Guild Wars 2 from the likes of Dragon Age and The Elder Scrolls. Conveniently, they're spelled out in the identifying initialism of the former: massively, multiplayer, and online. Destiny has the second down pat and is at least aware of the third (though it continues to wrestle with connectivity), but that whole massive part flew right over its head. With a scant four planets to speak of - planets themselves consisting of tiny and circuitous routes - Destiny feels about as expansive as a literal sandbox down at the park. That content is unevenly distributed between the four and is instead concentrated on Earth and its Moon only pours salt on the wound. To make matters worse, the game's first proper expansion, The Dark Below, failed to add what the game most desperately needed - a new area. A new endgame challenge in the form of TDB's hive-flavored raid is a welcomed addition, certainly, but a paltry substitute for some proper wilds to explore. Destiny's saving grace here is its premise. With space exploration buried firmly in its canon, Destiny 2 can add in virtually anything; no environment is off-limits when even the craziest of environments are all just a flight away.

9. Creating Redundancy

Long-time MMORPG players are no stranger to having their gear obviated by new expansions, and if console fans want the genre to catch on in the living room, it's something everyone's going to have to accept. But nobody should sit idly by as all their hard work and grinding is rendered pointless a mere three months after a game's release. For all intents and purposes, every piece of gear obtained between Destiny's September 9th release and the December 9th release of The Dark Below is utter crap. This isn't normally the case for MMO expansions; ordinarily, you'd still need your old raid gear in order to take on the new challenges. However, the merchants of Destiny have wrecked that idea. After TDB, Tower vendors now sell Legendary weapons and armor with better stats than "original" Legendaries, including Vault of Glass raid gear. In addition, all Exotic weapons obtained after the expansion will automatically be boosted to 331 attack whereas pre-expansion Exotics must be upgraded via a ridiculously convoluted and random system involving merchant Xur. It'd be one thing if existing gear was automatically brought up to speed with the new tier of Legendaries, or if you could only beat existing gear by playing the new raid. But you don't have to; you can just buy it - without putting in an ounce of effort, you can just buy it. So what was the point in playing? Why are early adopters being punished for their patronage? It doesn't matter what comes to the game if the entire thing is rewritten with each add-on; "new expansion" will just mean "cull the player count", because nobody is going to stick around long enough to play it.

8. Repetitive Challenges

Outside the raids, what is there to do in Destiny? Well, you can shoot things or ... watch your Ghost zap things. That's about it. It's not so much having too much of a good thing - the good thing in this case being the game's stellar combat - as it is too little of everything else. Shooting things is great; it's the things we're shooting that are problematic. Daily Heroic missions, Weekly Heroic and Nightfall strikes, and everyday strike playlists are all basically search-and-destroy missions. Planetside bounties and missions just iterate on "find the thing, kill the thing", or worse, "find the thing and stand on it." Again, that's about it. That's boring! And it's lazy design. There are so many more tools at the game's disposal. The rare dark-lit sections involving players' HUD-mounted flashlights, for example, are just crying out for longer sections with enemies leaping from the darkness a la Dead Space. What about some stealth or saboteur missions in the same vein as the Vault of Glass Gorgons? Why do we have so many jump abilities but no platforming sections to bring them into? And why don't we get to use the Hive sword more often? Virtually anything other than putting bullets into bad guys would be a refreshing change of pace for Destiny 2, which certainly can't just be more of the same.

7. Character Customisation

Social elements are one of a few areas of Destiny where the FPS mentality has all but completely overshadowed MMORPG. Even with armor, shader, and skill options, it can be difficult to build a Guardian that fits your vision due to the threadbare character creator. Humans, Exos, and the Awoken comprise the game's races, and other than the shared quality of having no context or backstory whatsoever, stand out as unique and different beings. However, although a wide color palette makes for distinctive characters, other options are extremely limited. Hair, facial structure, markings, and a sort of accessory are the meat and potatoes of character creation, all of which offer a paltry handful of presets. There are no sliders to play with, so it's impossible to emphasize one particular aspect of your Guardian. We don't need the bird people-spawning sliders of Dark Souls, but Destiny could use a healthy injection of detail. Annoyingly, despite only being able to customize your face (no height, weight, build, or so on), you cannot rotate the camera, meaning you'll only get a feel for how your character looks from other angles once you've accepted their appearance. You only see those other angles at the Tower, but it's still a strange omission. Making a character is arguably the biggest investment you can make in an MMO, so you're going to want to make sure they're up to snuff. Not allowing that is just asking to be picked on at MMO Academy.

6. Pint-Sized World Hub

Destiny's iconic Tower, the last vestige of the Traveler's protection, is in many ways a microcosm of the game. Small and deserted, the Tower is little more than another stop on the "Go here, press button" tour to which all Guardians have bought tickets. Joining any of the three factions does little more than add a different meter to your grinding. Vanguard and Crucible masters are just glorified merchants, and most of their wares are shoddy anyway. The Cryptarch and Bounty heads catch more limelight than anyone, but we all know just how poor a choice they are for conversation. The aptly named Speaker does nothing more than ramble on about a plot that isn't concerned with you, and the remaining NPCs are just fodder for the occasional objective icon. Everything about the Tower is so empty, perfectly echoing one of Destiny's worst qualities. Given that all these facilities are crammed into such a small area, it's almost fitting that only 16 players can inhabit a single Tower (game) at a time, but it leaves it a ghost town all the same. It's a positively miserable place, a nagging excuse to backpedal each time you complete anything that players would be better off without. Even Super Mario 64 knows what a world hub should do: tie things together. For an ostensibly massive game such as Destiny to try and do that with the square footage of a studio apartment in Los Angeles is simply laughable. Besides, it's called the Tower, not the Plateau; where are the levels? This isn't a city; it's a strip mall, and it needs some serious renovations before we see it again.

5. Missing Incentive

MMORPGs owe much of their popularity to their addictive, goal-driven design. Even if the means are mind-numbingly repetitive, fans of the genre will put up with the toughest grind if the reward is tempting enough. This takes one of the core appeals of gaming - surmounting challenges - and almost industrialises it, trading bosses and secret rooms for more consistent numbers to be raised. But if the reward isn't worthwhile, that golden trade is lost and the ugliness of the often tedious work shines through. This is the unsavory offer that Destiny makes on a regular basis, albeit not for everything. If you want top-shelf gear, you raid. That's a fine incentive, and the raids themselves are the highlights of the game. But what of difficulty? You have a shot at unique gear if you take on hard raids, but the same isn't true of missions. Why would you play on a higher difficulty when the bare minimum will fulfill bounties and get you the same loot and experience? And what's the point of topping the board in the Crucible if any amateur can roll the same loot at the end of the match? It's fun to win, sure, but what's stopping you from just joining matches and racking up the loot? Destiny's ceiling, the point where you run out of things to do, is uncomfortably low. Beat the raids a few times and you're practically bumping your head; level multiple characters and you'll be picking paint out of your hair in no time.

4. Excessive Grinding

In true triple-A fashion, Destiny has released several patches with large implications in response to mounting fan outrage. First, we got the Cryptarch a pair of glasses so that he could distinguish between a Legendary Engram and a broken toaster when handing out rewards. Skip ahead a few weeks and we get to the resource changes and exotic fixes that were so desperately needed. These and numerous other fixes improved the game exponentially, but while the latter eliminated huge chunks of material farming from every Guardian's to-do list, there were still chores to be done. Destiny has quite a lot of the bad kind of grinding, the kind games should work to minimize. It's one thing to strikes out in search of loot in Diablo 3 or Borderlands 2, knowing that you'll turn up some goodies relatively quickly. It's quite another to repeat familiar scenarios or struggle to fill an arbitrary meter in order to progress through the game. Why does upgrading a pre-TDB Exotic require the owner to completely re-level its skills? Why can't players equip multiple Exotic pieces when in the Tower, where they cannot be used or, by extension, break the game, in order to apply experience gains more efficiently? Why don't higher level enemies yield significantly more experience? Will every new expansion introduce a new currency system, or will The Dark Below be the only one capable of that level of stupidity? On top of this tedium, Destiny has the audacity to limit how many Vanguard and Crucible marks can be earned each week, thereby removing the benefits of playing heavily (read: more than two days a week) - all in a cheap effort to artificially lengthen the game. Destiny is not a Super Nintendo game; it has better ways to add longevity than all this.

3. Limited Matchmaking

Do people play MMORPGs because they want to play solo? Potentially, yes; solo MMO players have their own masochistic pride, eager to take on any challenge single-handed be it an army or goliath. People do not, however, play MMOs because they want to raid alone. Raids are the pinnacle of endgame, the toughest PvE challenges around, and require careful planning and teamwork between dozens of people. Destiny has scaled this experience down to six-man teams, which actually makes for a more personal environment and allows for easier communication, but completely forgotten to enable the things with matchmaking. Naturally, players turned to forums in order to build raid teams. But as is the case with Destiny's collection of online lore cards, it doesn't count if it isn't in the game; otherwise Bungie would've made one heck of an event-finder. And for a game that wants to sit at the MMO lunch table, not including matchmaking is just unreasonable. That it is possible to effectively form raid teams via forums does not excuse the inconvenience of having to go outside the game to do it, especially when World of Warcraft is raid-finding away at the other end of the table. It was possible to play Dark Souls on PC when it first released (before approximately four hundred patches and fixes were developed for it), but players shouldn't have to go go outside the game just to be able to play it. The same is true here.

2. Bug Count

With the new console generation still early in its life cycle, developers are inordinately eager to get their next big thing on the market - whether it's polished or not. We're already seeing the results of this through myriad bug-ridden releases that put even Bethesda's slipshod track record to shame, the most glaring being Assassin's Creed Unity. But with its September birthday, Destiny is one of the forerunners of the train wreck brigade. Disconnects and crashes were rampant for months after release, and even today network bickering can make playing with friends nigh on impossible. Crashes, too, ended many a play session prematurely, most commonly if players, in their hubris, dared to open a menu during a loading screen. Then there's the plethora of raid bugs ranging from stuck doors to game-breaking non-spawns. But the most famous of Destiny's technical hiccups are the many holes in the Vault of Glass and Crota's End raids, better known as "cheeses". Bosses have been pushed off maps, checkpoints have been obviated - anything and everything that can be broken has been shattered to pieces. These are bugs in the favour of easy loot, but they represent broken content regardless. More sinister cheese such as the new Crota Cable, which involves the raid's host literally disconnecting his Internet in order to paralyse the boss, are easier to forgive, but design oversight far outnumbers lapses in infrastructure. Long story short, games - especially games with over-costed DLC - shouldn't be broken. You know that, Bungie knows that, and Destiny 2 had better prove that we all know it.

1. Absent Storyline

You knew this was coming. You can't play Destiny and not notice how appallingly it's written. It's sad to even hear of rumors of the far richer sci-fi tale that might have been, but arguably more depressing to speculate on the sheer volume of deadline-pushing and content-pulling necessary to turn it into the skeleton of a narrative that's currently struggling to prop Destiny up. It's not even fair to call it bad - apart from highlighting such lines as, "I don't even have time to explain why I don't have time to explain." Destiny's story is closer to unfinished, or non-existent altogether. From the second your Guardian opens his or her eyes, things get off to a slow start at breakneck speed. So much nothing is happening, and it's all happening too fast to care anyway. The game never loses this absurd pace, and by the third planet, you'll likely have no idea what you're doing. (Spoilers: The Dark Below, promised to redefine how the game treats storytelling, doesn't change that.) So yes, Destiny 2 could probably use an extra writer or to. Or some appropriate planning. Or damn near anything. What are your hopes for Destiny 2? Do you want the sequel to come about at all?

In this post: 
Destiny 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A freelance games writer, you say? Typically battling his current RPG addiction and ceaseless perfectionism? A fan of horror but too big a sissy to play for more than a couple of hours? Spends far too much time on JRPGs and gets way too angry with card games? Well that doesn't sound anything like me.