Fallout 4: 8 Whiny ‘Fan’ Complaints That Won’t Be Addressed

God forbid you modernise your game in 2015.

How thoroughly spoilt have we all become by the exponential growth of the game industry over the last 30 years, that when they finally stop to take a breath or refine some initially phenomenal ideas, everyone declares it tantamount to creative bankruptcy? Case in point, Fallout 4. Bethesda creative director Todd Howard finally emerged at 2015's E3 to a rapturous applause, demoing a thoroughly spectacular-looking new instalment in the franchise to an audience of millions. The studio appeared to have taken on board every piece of feedback possible from Fallout 3 and New Vegas, and from the overhauled animations to a game engine that looked to make the first-person shooting as tight and enjoyable as possible, it was one hell of a resounding, jaw-dropping success. Oh but... but the graphics weren't necessarily completely mind-blowing, and didn't have the visual clout of The Witcher 3 or Batman: Arkham Knight. As if that matters, when the game itself will most likely be the most expansive and feature-filled RPG of all time. Come the latest release of more footage nothing has changed, as it truly feels like some fans are grasping at straws to find things to moan about, this Millennial culture of hating on everything truly starting to run its course. Bethesda have a proven track-record, and it's time to address these nonsensical 'issues' head-on, as it looks as though Fallout 4 will be one hell of an achievement any way you look at it. Quite simply, the studio don't need to waste their time kowtowing to a bunch of deluded purists.

8. "Voicing The Protagonist Sucks"

Cry to the heavens, it seems that a game. In 2015. Will feature a voiced protagonist. It's almost like Mass Effect did that about a decade ago and it was a huge success, who could've predicted this madness?! Okay, I'll not be doing that tone any more, but come on - putting a voice behind the Lone Wanderer has so much potential for good it's really just asinine to focus on the negatives. And that's if you think "Well I imagined myself saying the lines" as a negative in the first place. Seriously, when the realisation we'd be playing as a character who'd vocalise their thoughts settled in, tons of past Fallout players took to the forums to proclaim it as a backwards step, insinuating it wasn't 'real Fallout' unless you were piloting an empty husk of a 'character' through a desolate, colourless environment. It's far easier to remember, grow attached to and empathise with a voiced hero more than just a model with a handful of emotes (take GTA's CJ/Tommy Vercetti versus Claude from III), and as Bethesda are wanting to tell a more impactful tale overall, boosted by what's been touted as 13,000 lines of dialogue between male and female options, it's a no-brainer that this is the only way forward.

7. "It's Being Made For COD Fanboys"

When did we all get so disenfranchised with blowing stuff up? I know, "They're appealing to the Call of Duty crowd", many will say. Well, maybe there's some enjoyment to be had there, y'know? COD has definitely overstayed its welcome (despite Advanced Warfare being the first breath of fresh air for that series in years), but such a landmark franchise shouldn't mean that whenever any title veers off into gun-happy territory, the haters get free-reign to hurl expletives and cry that their beloved game is being dumbed down. At the end of the day, Fallout's past shooting mechanics sucked. V.A.T.S wasn't just an optional toggle, it necessary to surviving not only the in-game wasteland, but ensuring you didn't put out any windows in your house through sheer frustration in the process. It's quite possibly the single best thing Bethesda could've done in tightening up this immediately engaging part of the game, and you need only take a look at the severely underrated Metro series to see how intense atmosphere and meaty gunplay can work in perfect harmony.

6. "The New Dialogue System Sucks"

So this is a strange one; many Youtube comments and forum threads are complaining about the 'new dialogue system' - but it's not all that different. The only negative I can pick out is a stripped down amount of options when you're talking to people, but overall that's just going to produce better and more worthwhile responses anyway. Think about it; how many of you honestly asked every single one of the 5-10 lines you could start an interaction off with when talking to certain characters? Most of the time picking one then meant after they'd stopped talking you'd be presented with more options anyway, letting all that other dialogue essentially go to waste. You can chalk that up to "Well, everyone has a different experience" and it's true, but all the same Bethesda would surely rather reign in the amount of conversational paths you can go down, make them all interesting and then let you find your way. Plus, the only place Mass Effect messed up was in having elaborative options forever on the left of the dialogue wheel, with the 'good' or 'bad' options on the top and bottom respectively. Providing Bethesda throw up four choices and let you pick them with no foresight into how they're going to go down other than through phrasing alone, it should work better than ever.

5. "The Dog And Character Models Looks Terrible"

When you've been covering the industry and writing about games for even a little while, you can start to detect what the online reaction to something is going to be as you're watching a trailer or first shot of gameplay. With Fallout 4 it was no different, and the moment you knew people were going to focus on the graphical side of things was right when the debut trailer showed Dogmeat wandering through the abandoned house. His character model was fine, it was identifiable and served its purpose - but this point is to illustrate just how much people will take their most reactionary first impression and run with it. Put it this way; would you really have cared that much more if the dog had more defined hair? How about if it was a pre-rendered cutscene where they mo-capped a real pooch exploring an actual environment, and layered over their art assets afterwards? Of course not. You see it as a dog, it works where it needs to. Bethesda have more on their plate than spending hours refining their canine cutscene animation - they'd probably rather make the feeling of a headshot more exquisite, or plan a unique string of side-missions only the most adventurous of gamers will find. Point being, stop whining about something as absolutely pointless as the fidelity on a character model. Does the action in the scene come across? Can you tell what's going on? Yes? Then move along, as we never worried about any of this stuff in past generations.

4. "There's Too Much Colour Everywhere"

Graphical clout is one thing, but actually designing game worlds that are fun to explore and romp around in is another. As such, Bethesda have totally doubled down on the fact the time period they're aping was positively rammed with over-the-top vibrant colour schemes in every direction. There's definitely more a sense of over-animating the characters within F4, but it's an aesthetic that should pay dividends when coupled with the world itself. After all, there are two things all fans need to remember: 1. The older games were far lighter in tone in F3, had lots of humorous dialogue exchanges and even easter eggs/secrets that brought about years of chuckles (being onset by a herd of cows, anyone?). Bethesda's new graphics engine lets them get ever-closer to that original (dare I say 'fun') take on the apocalypse, whilst also retaining their own signature touch. 2. The world itself has many comic book-style elements that feel far more at home with a graphics engine and robust set of animations to bring them to life. Travelling across the Wasteland you're going to encounter all sorts of different races and character designs, twisted ethereal aesthetics, clothing that wouldn't look amiss in Mad Max - and a general sense of adventure that should propel you to keep going. When taken as a whole, this new approach to Fallout's 'look' is a resoundingly positive one, and even though everything immediately feels far more inviting than before - that's by no means a bad thing.

3. "The Graphics Have To Get Better"

Fallout 4's graphics are incredible. Just look at them; beautifully polished, nice full, rounded character models and a world with just the right sensation of individuality. You actively want to explore not just because you can, but because it all feels more inviting. In a recent interview with Gamespot, director Todd Howard laid it out pretty well, a couple of choice quotes I'll highlight here. It's very important to note how directly he addressed the common complaint about Fallout 3 that the game's environment didn't have much variation, mentioning "if you're playing the game for an eight-hour stretch, a little depressing." "Depressing" isn't the word I'd use, but you can tell what he's getting at - especially when you look at how immediately more vibrant everything about 4 looks. He also states,
"Memory is important to us. [...] If we make a world that has, not just more details, but more dynamic details that we can keep track of and stream in and load quicker, all of that suspends your disbelief that this is a real world."
It's a great point to focus on, because although having your breath taken away by a setting sun or a particularly spark-filled explosion is one thing, wrapping a whole game up in a tighter, more consistent package is a better way to go. The Witcher 3 is absolutely stunning, but its frame-rate and occasional hitches are not. It's not all about pure visual fidelity. Instead, providing the most instantly enjoyable and reliably impressive game (factoring in that gargantuan world size) should be just as impressive.

2. "It's The Same Game Again"

There's a point that needs to be raised in gaming about forced continuity, as in film, say your move did extremely well and it looks like the public would lap up a sequel; you can't literally put out more of the same. You have to innovate, pull at threads to expand the story and genuinely make a completely new movie in every respect, reusing nothing, albeit tying enough elements back to the original. In gaming, not so much - at least, it's not as necessary. Instead, forgoing a game that already has a high amount of replayability, gamers are looking for more excuses to take a titles' core mechanics and apply them to a new set of levels or scenarios. Yes there is a level of continuation that comes with how story-focussed a first instalment was, but for the most part in Fallout's case especially, Bethesda just need to keep refining an already near-perfect formula to guarantee success. That means in many ways it is 'the same game again', but people who fall back on that are completely missing the point. If the devs can refine the elements that put people off their last main instalment, it can be just as (if not more) worth playing as a completely original idea where a whole new set of untested innovations fail to come together. Sufficed to say, people nearly always include some mention of how broken 3 and New Vegas were in any Fallout conversation, and if 4 can completely turn around that assumption in the cultural psyche, providing a perfected version of what Bethesda have always been trying to deliver, it's not in any way a negative.

1. "It's Not Fallout"

The Fallout series is a strange beast, no matter which way you look at it. On the one hand you've got original developers Black Isle Studios who brought you the first two games, thereby establishing a tone and entire group of fans that still love their work to this day. On the other it's Bethesda's entry back in 2008 (after purchasing the rights to do so when BI were shut down) which darkened everything tonally, completely reworked how it all played - but again, brought about a group of fans that hold that take as the definitive and more definitive take. New Vegas was again handed off to another developer, Obsidian - formed by ex-Black Isle members - which tapped back into the original mindset of Fallouts 1 and 2, but now we're seeing Bethesda's return to a franchise that's only really their second attempt at commanding. Point being, no one can fully say what Fallout "should" or "shouldn't" be. It's a rather elasticated mythos in the first place, with all manner of creative teams having stretched and pulled it in many directions since its inception. Rather startlingly, we've really not seen enough widely-regarded instalments from any one developer over a long enough time period for anyone other than those at hand to lay claim to a worthwhile identity. Right now, whatever Bethesda puts out 'is Fallout' - and you can bet if they ever did a big-budget top-down entry, there'd be thousands of modern fans screaming from the rooftops that that "Isn't Fallout!" all the same. What do you make of the criticisms surrounding Fallout 4? Do any hold water, or does it feel like people are complaining for the sake of it? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.