Fallout 76: 9 Past Franchise Problems It Can Finally Fix

A protagonist whose setup doesn't conflict with the game itself, anyone?

Fallout 76
Bethesda

With the announcement of Fallout 76 came controversy, and now there's been some sizeable gameplay demos and feature breakdowns we have... more controversy.

Yes, the Fallout fandom is notoriously hard to please. Assembled from two initial instalments made by a different developer, one phenomenal title that saw the entire world take notice, a spin-off from another developer that's actually, arguably, the best one, and a fourth that's divisive to this day. Not to mention a mobile app that has just as many people sounding alarm bells and shouting about the end times, as those who enjoyed it.

Next up on the list? An MMO-influenced survival sim, ditching NPCs for an entire world of players going about their business. Bethesda have insisted the game can still be played solo, but will be online at all times, as quests for the vast majority are designed around groups of players instead.

Understandably - and given the enjoyably rocky road it's been to get here - people are split. Though, speaking of Fallout's characterful history and its myriad of discussion points...

What if 76 ends up being the best one?


9. Quest Markers & General Pathfinding

Fallout pip boy
Bethesda

The last three Fallouts (3, New Vegas and 4) occasionally suffered from quest markers denoting doorways or entrances were the way forward... only for you to enter and realise they were now telling you to go back the other way.

It's immediately paralysing - what are you supposed to do when the game's own pathfinding is overlapping on itself? Often it means a quick trip to Google or a Youtube video walkthrough, just to make sure you're not going crazy.

Outside of realising you're in the correct spot and whatever's meant to be happening isn't happening, actually getting there isn't very much fun, either.

Fallout's 3D games have annoyingly correlated "pathfinding" with "one giant invisible line from you to your goal". It doesn't account for verticality, nor a particular path through some rubble, a set of houses or a facility. Just... here's a marker, go figure out how to get there.

The solution would be some sort of real-world Pip-Boy visualisation of exactly where to go, or a more accurate line on the map that helps us reach our destination.


8. Truly Great Gun Combat

Fallout 4 main character
Bethesda

Props to Fallout 4, it finally included shooting that didn't make you only want to resort to V.A.T.S. - though, the knock-on effect was that V.A.T.S. fundamentally wasn't as useful, and Fallout 4 became more of a shooter overall.

This is potentially fine, but we need 76 to nail down precisely how we even play a Fallout game. The original two titles were isometric, falling back on V.A.T.S. as a turn-based combat method, whereas Fallout 4 saw the system minimised to the point where time barely slows and you can't really plan anything in the moment anymore.

76 is ditching the slow-motion/pausing aspect altogether to help with player-on-player fights and how one person couldn't force the other's game speed to change, but the result could go either way.

Staying positive, hopefully Bethesda design a series of shooting mechanics that incorporate taking cover, lining up V.A.T.S. shots in real-time, weighty weapon handling and maybe even a tactical slide.

If we're going all-in on Fallout being a FPS, it should be one of the best on the market.


7. The Protagonist Problem

fallout 4
Bethesda

Fallout 3: You're someone brand new to the wasteland... but you desperately need to find your father, and then save the water supply for everyone. No room for exploration without breaking the established motivation.

New Vegas: You're a courier who survives being executed... only to find themselves in the centre of a time-sensitive factional warfare dispute. Less imperative up front, but you're still confined to a revenge tale and pacy story until after the credits.

Fallout 4: Your infant son has been kidnapped and is now missing somewhere out in the wasteland. Anything other than finding them immediately is just plain weird. No room for exploration unless you actively discard the motivations set up across the first half hour.

Fallout 76: At time of writing all we know is the player is one of many dwellers from Vault 76: The first of all Vault-Tech's chambers to open into the newly irradiated wasteland.

There's no motivation or prerogative other than "Explore, discover, survive. Find who you can, see what's still standing, build a life and restore humanity across the land".

Perfect.


6. Unreliable Companions & Broken NPCs

Fallout 3
Bethesda

Another upside to having human companions and NPCs rather than continuing with the broken - and often hilarious - Bethesda A.I.

We've seen everything from companions getting stuck in world geometry to accidentally firing on friendlies, falling off parts of the world to just plain not moving or levitating away from the mission area.

Bethesda are known for buggy games when they're this big and complex, yet this gets game-breaking when NPCs either don't respond to their scripting, or helper companions don't, well, help.

All that goes away with the human element across the wasteland... providing you don't buddy up with someone who just wants to shoot you in the back, anyway.


5. Colourful & Inviting World

Fallout 76
Bethesda

Say what you like about "Well, it's a post-apocalyptic world, there wouldn't BE any colour!", but Fallout 3's entirely smushed-grey palette is pretty damn off-putting, and New Vegas swapping that for a rusty subway bathroom brown didn't help.

The latter mixed things up nicely when you finally got to New Vegas, but Fallout 4 recognised this issue from the get-go. Now we have 76 taking the revamped approach and pairing it with the fact we're playing as new explorers wandering in every direction.

Bethesda have noted there'll be various Virginia folklore creatures in the game for us to find, and that's before you get to the player/character motivation of wanting to explore every last nook and cranny to see what you can find.

The best discoverable parts of all Fallouts have always been more in the writing, characters and moral dilemmas than anything visual. Fallout 4 started to change that, but it really sounds like 76 is taking the next logical step.


4. Interior Loading & Seamless Exploration

fallout new vegas nipton hotel
Obsidian

Something of a small bugbear that makes all the difference (just ask Yakuza 6), past Fallouts instancing every part of the world separately lead to a LOT of load times, when it would be remarkable to have interiors ready and waiting on the other side of a doorway.

According to Bethesda, Fallout 76 is 16x more detailed than Fallout 4 - though whether that means open-world detail, texturing or that work has been done when meshing the world together, we'll have to wait and see.

Loading interiors this old school way also sets up the game engine for failure. Carrying NPCs and players from one loaded state to the next has seen many crashes and hangups - something I can only see getting worse when it's real people with real connection woes all needing to be grouped together.

Here's to a Fallout where - like vast majority of The Witcher 3 - everything is good to go.


5. Making Settlements Matter (Plus Meaningful Expansion DLC)

fallout 4 settlement
Bethesda

A lot has been said about the bizarrely Minecraft/survival game-esque inclusion of settlement building in Fallout 4. Coming after Skyrim's Hearthfire DLC also let you make all sorts of humble abodes in Tamriel, it seemed like there was some contingent of Bethesda fans hankering for customisable homesteads.

Naturally this lead to Bethesda not knowing precisely how to integrate these features into the game, and besides one specific mission towards the end of the campaign, you didn't even need to bother building anything at all.

All of that changes in Fallout 76, as now Settlements are literally where you'll be making camp and holding out with friends/other players. You'll need to invest in security and think about the placement of everything because you'll be staving off player raids and monster attacks.

DLC-wise it means things like the once pointless Workshop expansions and Automatron/robot-building suite we got for Fallout 4 would matter tenfold. Anything settlement-based in 76 will be game-changing, and though that might annoy those who wish Bethesda would stop trying to be Minecraft, tying it directly to gameplay should at least realise their vision for settlement functionality.


4. The Human Threat

Fallout 76 Mutants
Bethesda

Answers in the comments as to whether you want Fallout's greatest threats to be more creature or supernatural-based (like parts of the older games, hello The Master), or routed in factions and gun combat (like the newer ones).

That's an ongoing conversation, but right now, a group of raiders is not a Deathclaw, despite Bethesda trying to make combat with gangs a more formidable and tactile experience.

Put simply: There's no point putting so much emphasis into shooting if WHAT we're shooting doesn't require anything other than pulling the trigger. Things like disarming foes or slowing them down by crippling limbs is a great idea, but unlike many other post-apocalypse games like The Last of Us where other humans are a real threat no matter what, in Fallout they're mostly disposable.

Once again, with the influx of real players comes completely different, unexpected ways to deal with them. Combat can never be the same, and exploring takes on another dimension of battle royale-like terror when you realise the seemingly abandoned house you're in has footsteps coming from upstairs.

Do you hide out? Try to flee? Kill them for their gear and move on? It's going to change the very nature of humans as a threat and their inclusion in Fallout as an experience.


3. World-Affecting Faction Integration

Fallout 76
Bethesda

Where New Vegas introduced joining a number of factions that then affected trade discounts and how NPCs addressed us, Fallout 4 pretty much wiped the slate clean, still letting you join, but without any gameplay incentive.

In Fallout 76, factions are yet to be detailed, but we can say two things - one of which is confirmed:

1. As the first online Fallout, even joining up to the Brotherhood of Steel or other factions in the land will have an immediate impact on how your character can look - not to mention how you're perceived by the world itself. Taking quests for reputable entities should change your path through the full game, be it through weapons, armour or quest items binding groups of players together.

2. We know that groups of players can band together to nab nuclear codes from specific silos, firing actual nukes off into the world that can take out other settlements. This isn't tied to larger factional warfare, but as part of this mechanic is then raiding the nuclear blast site to grab gear, you're likely to have a much easier time buddying up with your fellow clansmen.


2. Fix Pip Boy HUD & Integration

Fallout 4
Games Radar

The Pip-Boy interface and integration needs a meaningful overhaul. Fallout 4 did a bit of work when it comes to accessing our inventory faster... but then resigned it to the companion app.

In-game, without a second screen you were still bringing up the Pip-Boy to do everything from equip a newly picked up weapon to healing or flicking the radio on, whereas with the app you could tap to use a Stimpack, fast-travel, apply RadAway and everything else.

Basically, Fallout 76 needs a better hotkey menu - perhaps a "Hold button and tap directions/other buttons" to give us a quickfire interface on the go, not to mention the terrible "everything's just in a list" approach to customisation overall.

If the layering system is staying - and it should - we need this part of the Pip-Boy (at least) to be meaningfully streamlined.


1. A Rewarding Progression That Feeds Everything Into Everything Else

Fallout 76 Powersuit
Bethesda

Maybe you made a point of combing the landscape in past games out of sheer love for the Fallout mythos, but from the outset, Fallout 76 looks to be combining so many elements to form a much more driven sense of exploration.

Moving in any given direction is immediately rewarding thanks to the revamped aesthetic. Weapons, items and better gear is tucked away behind more intense combat encounters or quests - things you can make easier by grouping up or exploring factions.

Because you're new to the world, side-quests off the beaten path really matter - as do settlements.

Even the perceived threat of a given area can be toppled by co-operating, or you can move away and head off in another direction, should you be foraging solo.

Together, all of this should drastically increase the immersion of Fallout, giving us a world we want to explore, filled with meaningful rewards that all feed into one another.


In this post: 
Fallout 76
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.