FIFA 16 Ratings: 11 Most Shocking Player Upgrades

The ratings are out, and there are some surprises... Obviously.

EA Sports have revealed their top 50 Ultimate Team stars for FIFA 16, and as usual, every time ratings are released there will be raised eyebrows. It's essentially all down to personal opinions. Some players have been jumped up on the back of one good season, others have drastically dropped after a barren campaign, while there are some who manage to maintain their lofty position based on past reputation. Each season the ratings tend to remain fairly close to the predecessor game, with EA doing a decent job of avoiding knee-jerk boosts, yet still they are known to make decisions that not everyone would agree with. A big fee transfer is usually good for an extra notch or two on the player's overall rating, while media hype can always have a bearing on the perceptions of a player. If EA based their ratings purely on hype then you'd be selling your Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo cards for a Harry Kane card, but he doesn't cut the game's top 50 quite yet. So here are the 10 most shocking confirmed upgrades in the game so far. They're not necessarily the wrong decisions, but there's a surprising aspect about every one of them.


11. John Terry (Chelsea) - 85

John Terry is without doubt one of the best defenders since the turn of the millennium. Forget about his personality and misdemeanours, he's constantly proved himself to be a bold leader and fearless footballer on the pitch, and that's how ratings are determined. He was instrumental during Chelsea's title triumph last season, providing a largely airtight base for Jose Mourinho to build on. However, he's been bumped up two marks, despite a poor start to this current season. He hasn't looked himself in the opening weeks of the campaign, being substituted and red-carded in two separate games. He was already on a high rating, and EA are usually conservative with their upgrades, so a 2+ boost is surprising.

10. Naldo (Wolfsburg) - 85

Naldo is probably the least-familiar name to be included here, and that is part of the reason why it's surprising to see him flying so high in the ratings. The towering 6'5" centre back put in a dominant season for Wolfsburg as they finished second in the Bundesliga last season. The big Brazilian was an 81 on the last game, and at the age of 32, that would appear to have been his peak. However, EA have generously gifted him a 4+ bonus on FIFA 16. It's a very surprising jump, but not entirely ridiculous. Great defenders need equally great ratings.

9. Santi Cazorla (Arsenal) - 85

Does Santi Cazorla deserve to be in the top 10 outfield Premier League players at the moment? I'd say no. Given the huge summer of investment and the stellar talent already in the English top flight, I'd say that while Cazorla is a very good player, I don't think he's elite level. At 85, he's only jumped up 1 point in the overall standings, but that's a pivotal milestone to reach. Being an 84, it felt like Cazorla had peaked but EA have decided to give him a boost probably based on the team's successful 2014/15 campaign. Arsenal have started inconsistently this season, so he may fall in the live form ratings upon release.

8. Arturo Vidal (Juventus) - 86

Arturo Vidal may be a controversial inclusion, but again, down to personal opinion, I think he's a touch overrated. He's only been handed a boost of 1, but 85 felt like his maximum level until he could prove himself on the biggest world stage. He was majestic in midfield for Juventus and played a huge part in their fantastic run to the Champions League final, however, he completely lost his mind against Barca and his team were thwarted. Vidal has a complete 'loose cannon' feel about him, and he looks like a man ready to snap. He's likely to grow in his new surroundings at Bayern Munich, but a boost simply because of his big transfer seems premature.

7. Kevin De Bruyne (Manchester City) - 86

Kevin De Bruyne's transfer came with one of the most outrageous transfer fees in football history; £58 million, the sixth highest of all-time. He cost £12 million MORE than Zinedine Zidane at his peak. Who do Manchester City think they've bought? The Belgian midfielder sparkled for Wolfsburg with an immense goals and assists tally, but this transfer has came just one year after Chelsea deemed him not good enough for their side and shipped him out for £18 million. No player should see their value skyrocket that highly, particularly if they're returning to a league they failed to impress in. De Bruyne has received a 3+ boost for his big move. That's incredibly high.

6. Carlos Tevez (Juventus) - 86

As players reach the tail-end of their careers, they tend to realise: 'Oh, wait. My boyhood team IS a cash-laden team in the middle of the Arabian desert.' There are other footballers who move onto the suddenly fashionable MLS, while Carlos Tevez has indeed moved 'home' to Argentina. Still, his move was a strange one. He was in peak form for Juventus and could've gone on to achieve even more glory. Surprisingly, EA have actually boosted his stats despite the move whereas players usually get gently lowered as they move on.

5. Jerome Boateng (Bayern Munich) - 87

Jerome Boateng is a very good defender, and he's been excellent for Bayern Munich but is he really worthy of a rating higher than (or equal to) every other centre back on the game? For starters, Boateng was utterly annihilated by Lionel Messi during the Bundesliga giants' Champion's League match. Of course it was only one game, but he was made to look like a fool, not a man worthy of such an immense rating. He's clearly a talented defender, but playing in such a dominant team in one-horse race league can create an illusion.

4. Georgio Chiellini (Juventus) - 87

Georgio Chiellini is a monstrous talent and his excellence shone through on the road to the Champions League Final last season with Juventus. He's an Italian stalwart who goes somewhat under-praised, mainly because he's been so good for so long. It's a surprise to see him jump up 2 points at the age of 31, though defenders do tend to peak later than their whippet attacking teammates. It's well deserved for Chiellini and as the old saying goes: 'better late than never' for the Italian defensive maestro.

3. Mesut Ozil (Arsenal) - 87

Mesut Ozil suffered a torrid spell at Arsenal, not because he was truly awful, just down to his 100% averageness. His high fee combined with mediocre performances drew a wide range of critics and fans wondered whether he'd be departing the Emirates sooner than expected. However, the German star turned it around, and looks like one of the first names on the team sheet for the Gunners. His technique and skill on the ball is masterful, and justifies a high overall rating, but does that mean he should be boosted up another point to 87? No. His 86 rating last season looked steep after his poor run of form, but he raised his game up to that level, though 87 is excessive. He needs to add more goals to his game before he can be rated that highly.

2. Cesc Fabregas (Chelsea) - 87

Cesc Fabregas' return to the Premier League was sensational. He combined with Diego Costa to create carve out one of the most deadly midfield-striker combos in world football at the time. However, while Chelsea bolted out to an unassailable lead in the title race, they did slow down their charge in the second half and part of the reason was Fabregas losing his uncanny knack for assists. He's started this season sluggishly too, and looks a shadow of the player he could be which is why a 1+ boost is confusing to say the least. If he can get back to his best, that's a fair rating, but for a man off form it's very high.

1. Luis Suarez (Barcelona) - 90

When Luis Suarez retires, his autobiography (translated from Spanish, of course) will be absolute dynamite, and he could even release a side book entitled 'Hero to Zero to Hero to Zero and Back Again'. Suarez was adored and vilified in Liverpool colours, then loved and hated in a Uruguay shirt, but since his move to Barcelona, he's been all quality, without the sideshow. He's unlocking his true potential now, and looks a worthy member in one of the greatest attacking trios in a generation. He absolutely deserves his 90 rating, boosted up 1 mark yet it's still a surprise to see any player breach the highly elite gaggle of players which currently has just five members: Suarez, Arjen Robben, Manuel Neuer, Cristiano Ronaldo, and Lionel Messi. Are you surprised by any other ratings from the Top 50 rated by EA?

Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.