FIFA 16: 10 Ways To Improve Manager Mode

"When I go to the press conference, in my mind the game has already started." – Jose Mourinho

FIFA Manager Mode
EA

As EA Sports continue to push toward Ultimate Team, their primary cash cow, those players who prefer the offline Manager Mode experience are becoming marginalised by the minuscule number of changes made every year. The Manager Mode feels like something of a spent force and has left many of its once loyal following turning toward the 'dark forces' of Konami's Pro Evolution.

The simple fact is that not everyone wants to play online or spend real money to create some strange Frankenstein football club; wearing Cambridge United's shirt, playing in the King Fahd Stadium, and starting with Seydou Doumbia up front. Those players who live the dream of building the future of their respective clubs have been overlooked and ignored since the introduction of Ultimate Team, as EA Sports chases the easy money from micro transactions on its glorified football stickers.

FIFA's Manager Mode evolved over a decade, from merely playing through seasons as a club's coach to a fully functioned and vital part of the offline experience. Players were able to take their chosen club and craft its future from transfers to tactics. However, where it was once the cornerstone of the FIFA platform, this mode has been neglected over the last two iterations of the title.

So what can EA Sports do to win back those fans which its ignorance is haemorrhaging to Pro Evolution Soccer's classic Master League or even Football Manager's incredibly in-depth take on the world of football?

Here are ten things it must bring to Manager Mode...

10. Make Free Transfers More Competitive

Germany's Sami Khedira celebrates victory in the World Cup Final
Mike Egerton/PA Archive

A few years ago EA Sports introduced the idea of free agents to the FIFA series. For most transfer wheeler-dealers the Free Agent System was something of an aside, full of terrible players and a very rare gem who players could pick up for nothing and hope beyond hope that they would perform.

In FIFA 15, players were given the opportunity to sign players whose contracts were due to expire in six months. Seasoned players would have been delighted to be able to snatch up players like Real Madrid's Sami Khedira who were running their contracts down, but what about those who ended up on the free transfer list?

For some reason, FIFA 15 made it almost impossible to sign free agents with most, except 45-60 rated Macedonian internationals, snapped up by unlikely clubs within the first day of the transfer window. Anyone who tried to sign Angelo Henriquez on a free will have experience of this.

Introducing a system where players are able to bring in free agents on a trial basis might actually give meaning to those pointless pre-season Manager Mode friendlies and finally answer the question of whether Karanjit Singh can cut it on a rainy night against St. Etienne.

He probably can't.


9. Refine The Player Interaction

Hull City manager Phil Brown gives his team talk, on the pitch during the half time interval, Featured, Features, Lists, Phil Brown, Hull City
Nick Potts/PA Archive

Manager Mode players will be used to the inexplicable sight of an 18 year old fringe player popping their head round the door and asking to start in a top of the table clash. Those same players will be familiar with the feeling of abject fury when that player then comes to them after the game (after being left out for their hubris) and claims that they felt they were in good form and should have started.

There needs to be clearer interaction between manager and players. Instead of being told that a player is unhappy after the fact, players should be able to tell their star striker that they're performing worse than James Franco at the Oscars and are being dropped in favour of a precocious talent from the youth ranks.

It would also be nice to see player personalities more akin to their perceived real life counterparts. Liverpool fans wouldn't be surprised to see Raheem Sterling demanding £360,000-a-week so does he have to be such a wallflower in FIFA?

Too much of FIFA 15's Manager Mode feels like pulling twenty five Tamagotchis along on a string and without serious improvements to interaction and player personalities its inexorable march toward the scrapheap will doubtless continue.


8. Make Transfer Requests Less Arbitrary

Dortmund's Mats Hummels reacts during the German Bundesliga soccer match between Borussia Dortmund and Hamburger SV in Dortmund, Germany, Saturday, Oct. 4, 2014. Dortmund was defeated by Hamburg with 0-1. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner)
Martin Meissner/AP

Player interactions are one thing but most Manager Mode players gather around darkened tables in pubs and lament that inevitable moment that their star player (usually an important defender) decides that his time is up at the club for some entirely arbitrary reason.

Those who have experienced Borussia Dortmund's Mats Hummels tell them that he is homesick (despite being German) before completing a move to Real Madrid for half of his value can tell you the agony of these ridiculous decisions generated by the game engine.

Surely signposting warning signs of a player's discontent or even bringing in that element of interaction would save players the indignity of losing that talismanic player that they've been building their team around?


7. Make The Captain Work For It

Michael Dawson, Andre Villas-Boas
Media Image Ltd

Captains are one of FIFA's many entirely decorative feature, proved by the fact that they can't be changed mid-match. It's hard to see why the processing power of a next generation console is unable to render a small armband on another player, rather than simply passing it off to the player coming on.

Changing mid-game would only add to the immersion of the experience. Anyone who has substituted their captain in the dying minutes of a big final, only to see a youth team player lift the trophy will know that it's an incredibly jarring experience but it could also be put to practical use.

The captain is an incredibly important part of any side and picking the right captain could even result in a small stat boost for each player on the team. Listings like "A Leader of Men" on the profile screens might actually mean something and finding a positive influence on a team might help more than just pure statistics.


6. Bring Coaching In

Russia head coach Dick Advocaat instructs players during a training session of Russia at the Euro 2012 soccer championship in Sulejowek, Poland, Sunday, June 10, 2012. (AP Photo/Sergey Ponomarev)
Sergey Ponomarev/AP

Gamers often decry the number of pointless mini-games found inside AAA video games but Manager Mode has an opening for one that could actually make a difference.

Instead of the ridiculous (although entirely optional) pre-match skill challenges, why not give players the option to run a training drill for an area of their team that they may want to improve before the game. 

Players already receive stat boosts due to their perceived in-game form so where's the harm in players sharpening their strikers' shooting skills before a big game or ensuring that their central midfielder can pick the vital pass when it matters?

A similar system to the Youth Staff could be implemented with different types of coaches ranked by their individual areas of focus. The better the coaching staff, the better the team.

Again it comes back to FIFA's desire to have players face off against their friends for high scores. The pre-match sequences are naturally more diverting than a loading screen but integrating them with the manager mode experience rather than just providing bragging rights for the top scorers.


5. Build On Youth Scouting

James Ward-Prowse, Southampton
Daniel Hambury/PA Archive

One of the few things that FIFA's Manager Mode has done well is to introduce a simple, easy-to-follow youth scouting structure to the game, allowing players to pick up talented "regens" from across the world. 

A few tweaks and a couple of fan-service introductions could see it become one of the most important features in the game. While signed youth players currently sit in the 'youth squad' doing nothing and occasionally complaining until the player is ready to offer them a proper contract, it would be a worthwhile addition to bring in a proper youth team which could be monitored by the coaching staff.

It would also be a nice touch to have optional games which the youth team players could participate in, allowing players to evaluate their youth candidates before offering them proper contracts. EA Sports' partners at Manchester City would likely be delighted by the prospect of showing off the Etihad's impressive academy stadium.


4. Make It A Story

Sir Alex Ferguson, Manchester United manager welcomes Juan Sebastian Veron brought for a British record of 28.1 million pounds
John Walton/EMPICS Sport
"So Mister Manager. You sit here aside your new signing and many are asking if you believe Christian Nadé will be able to handle the pace of playing for Real Madrid. What are your thoughts?"

You shift uncomfortably in your seat.

The need for a genuine story mode in FIFA has been laid out for all to see from the peerless NBA 2K15. The sequences used 'out of game' for introductions and interactions between players, coaches, the press and even each other are incredible and as football moves toward being a game of personalities, is something EA Sports should seriously consider. 

FIFA 16 is crying out for a story mode where you carve out your niche as the swashbuckling manager of League 2 Plymouth Argyle who insists on playing four strikers. Adding press interaction before, during and after the game along with fully modelled managers on the touchline would be a wonderful addition to the game.

Imagine a manager leading their team off the field, 3-1 down to lesser opposition in a final day decider and desperate to lay a punch on someone. He's accosted by Geoff Shreeves in the tunnel. Perfect.

The next generation systems have more than enough power to put players firmly in the shoes of their managers. EA Sports just have to take the leap. 


3. Touchline Tactics

Chelsea's manager Jose Mourinho, centre, greets former player Samuel Eto'o of Everton before their English Premier League soccer match at Goodison Park Stadium, Liverpool, England, Saturday Aug. 30, 2014. (AP Photo/Jon Super)
Jon Super/AP

There are many RPG elements which EA Sports could introduce to FIFA 16 to make Manager Mode a real competitor again but by far and away the most impressive would be the ability to create a manager.

Like Be A Pro mode, players could choose to create a manager or take on the personality and role of an established coach. Those who choose to take on the mantle of Jose Mourinho would need to balance a media persona with a close-knit squad and commit to playing in his style, whereas those who created their own manager could set their own direction with a series of goals they want to complete.

Quite apart from that, players should be able to use FIFA's impressive character creation system to model the look of their manager. If the focus of the Manager Mode is on immersion then what could be better than the sight of your manager walking down the touchline ready to take charge of their first game in charge of the national team?

Pipe dreams, obviously, but there's scope for FIFA 16 to focus more on the eponymous Manager. What drives them? What makes them tick? It's something that Sports Interactive have captured with their mighty Football Manager series- so what's stopping EA Sports?


2. Make That Big Move Happen

Sir Alex Ferguson
Dave Munden/EMPICS Sport

Everybody gets bored sometimes. Whether trapped in the relegation doldrums at Hull City or sick of the sight of Barcelona's away kit, there are always reasons to force a move somewhere else. Unfortunately FIFA 15's jobs board was never its strongest point.

Players might be top of the league with an unlikely club, having won a trophy the previous season and the chance of a bigger job comes up. Instead of offering any kind of explanation, FIFA seems to decide that you're staying where you are.

The perfect solution- and something that FIFA is well known for- would be a series of criteria managers have to complete to be eligible for a certain tier of job. As an example, perhaps Manchester United would be looking for a player to have finished in the top three of their league in two out of three seasons, whereas QPR might just be looking for someone who hasn't spent their entire transfer budget on Niko Kranjcar and dog food.

It would be the perfect balance, giving players who aspire to something greater something to aim for and players who are bored of their current situation a way out.


1. Jump In!

Italy's Andrea Pirlo is comforted by teammates as he cries after losing the Euro 2012 soccer championship final between Spain and Italy in Kiev, Ukraine, Sunday, July 1, 2012. (AP Photo/Darko Vojinovic)
Darko Vojinovic/AP

It's a bit of a cheat, but there comes a time in every Manager Mode where simming a few games is the only way to avoid going stir-crazy. Surely there's nothing that can go wrong in an away game against the club at the foot of the table?

What's that? You're 0-3 down after the first half? As opposed to sitting on the edge of your seat hoping that FIFA's simulation engine allows your boys to turn it round; give players the option to jump in and put things right! 

Not only does it give players the chance to rectify mistakes in their tactics or team selection, many will see it as a challenge to come back from a deficit as the seconds tick away. 

The Manager Mode is a marathon and players shouldn't be punished for choosing to simulate a few games here and there.

What would you do to reinvigorate Manager Mode for FIFA 16? Leave some ideas in the comments!


In this post: 
FIFA 16
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Freelance writer and Web Editor. | Once won a Cosmopolitan Award. No idea why. | @MichaelJayPark