FIFA 18 Wishlist: 10 Things That Must Be Included

Can EA Sports create the perfect football game in 2018?

Fifa 18
EA Sports

FIFA 17 was one of the slickest games that EA Sports have produced in the franchise's 24-year history. From the gorgeous Frostbite engine to The Journey (FIFA's biggest new game mode since Ultimate Team), 17 brought a number of major improvements to the table, and left the competition in the dust.

There are still those who prefer Pro Evolution Soccer's more realistic gameplay, but at one point, FIFA 17 was outselling PES 2017 at a 40:1 ratio in the UK. EA Sports' dedication to driving the series forward paid-off in a major way, but the game wasn't flawless, and there are a number of big improvements to consider for FIFA 18.

EA have already confirmed that The Journey will make a return, and while details are still thin, FIFA 18 will surely bring the usual annual upgrades in graphics, physics, and general gameplay. Improving upon FIFA 17's greatness should be a simple case of fine tuning these small details, but if EA decide to tackle some of the series' bigger issues, FIFA 18 could be the perfect football game.

10. Smarter Referees

Fifa Referee
EA Sports

EA Sports have struggled with FIFA’s officials forever, and despite all the advances that the series has made over the past few decades, they just can’t seem to nail the referees. As always, FIFA 17’s referees were absolutely bewildering at times, pulling cards from their pockets at seemingly random intervals, botching offside calls, and awarding penalties for even the most minor collisions.

In fairness, it could be argued that FIFA 17’s terrible referees are an accurate reflection of modern officiating, and therefore add an extra layer of realism. This is a game, however, and games need to be fun. Nothing ruins a match like a referee flashing a red card for a glitched physics collision or halting play for a seemingly perfectly-timed sliding challenge, and while getting the referees right is clearly difficult, this shouldn’t really be a problem anymore.

FIFA 18’s referees need to be less like Uriah Rennie, and more like Pierluigi Collina. There’s no real excuse for such frustratingly bad officials in a modern football game, and tweaking them will remove what many fans consider to be one of FIFA’s biggest historical problems. Fans are used to dodgy officials screwing their team out of points in real-life, but in a video game, everything needs to be fair and just.


9. Better Manager Likenesses

David Moyes Fifa
EA Sports

FIFA 17’s manager likenesses weren’t entirely bad Jose Mourinho, Pep Guardiola, and a handful of others looked just like their real-life counterparts, adding another of authenticity to the FIFA experience. It’s these little touches that set FIFA’s presentation aside from the competition, and make 17 one of the most polished football games of all-time.

Not all manager likenesses are created equally, however. Apparently, the picture above is supposed to be Sunderland’s craggy-faced Scottish manager, David Moyes. Sadly, the model looks more like a Ronald Koeman action figure that was left in the sun for too long, which makes a mockery of the effort EA put into implementing real-life managers into last year’s game.

Inaccurate managers aren’t a huge deal, but it’s definitely jarring when the camera swings round to the touchline and fills your screen with a horrendous likeness. FIFA’s player likenesses have always been inconsistent, but accurate managers are few and far between, and this area clearly needs some work. Tightening this aspect of the game up will add the slick professionalism that FIFA is known for to the dugout, and hopefully give poor old Mr. Moyes one less reason to be miserable on Wearside..


8. More Women’s Football

Fifa 17 Women
EA Sports

Women’s football was first implemented in FIFA 16, and it felt like a real step forward. Though the women’s game still has some catching-up to do, its popularity has definitely increased in recent years, particularly in America, whose most famous player - Carli Lloyd - recently signed for Manchester City. Thus, it made perfect sense for EA Sports to capitalise on this wave, and try to draw some women’s football followers into the FIFA franchise.

FIFA 17 featured women’s football for a second year running, but little to no progress had been made on its implementation. The game offered nothing in the way of new features, competitions, and playable teams. If you want to play as the women, you’re pretty much restricted to international games and nothing else. There are no clubs to be found at all, and after FIFA 16, it feels like 17 stagnated when it comes to women’s football.

There’ll no doubt come a day when FIFA’s female representation is far more comprehensive, and competitions like the FA Women’s Super League and America’s NWSL are present and correct. At this stage, it feels like EA have only done half the job when it comes to this side of the game, and there’s huge scope for expansion.


7. Realistic Crowds

FIFA 16 Crowd
EA Sports

Crowds are another minor presentational detail that EA Sports never seem to get right. FIFA’s use of the Frostbite engine means the game is capable of some truly impressive graphical feats these days, but for all the series’ recent graphical advances, crowds are still lagging behind. FIFA 17’s were bland, washed-out, and blurry, and while this doesn’t have an impact on gameplay, it’s highly noticeable every time the camera swoops down to pitch-level.

It can’t be easy capturing and rendering so many individual supporters, but FIFA’s crowds look laughably amateurish at times. As with botched player/manager likenesses, this is another presentational botch that takes the shine off of FIFA’s typically immaculate veneer, and a small detail that breaks player immersion several times during a game.

EA Sports’ priority should probably be preventing the crowds from looking so low-res, but there’s plenty of room for improvement when it comes to the atmosphere too. Club-specific chants and songs are still relatively thin on the ground, and greater variety in this department (as well as additional play-specific songs) would unquestionably improve the match experience. Such tweaks might seem minor, but they’d go a long way to making FIFA feel more like an actual football match, and not just a game.


6. Better Set Pieces

FIFA 17 Penalty
EA Sports/YouTube

Set pieces and penalties have been a huge bugbear among FIFA fans for years, and 17 saw some radical changes. The penalty system was completely rebuilt, and on your first few attempts, they feel absolutely atrocious. Things improve with practice, of course, but it’s way too difficult to find the corners with any level of consistency, and the new system is too fiddly and awkward for the average player to ever truly master.

The new corner system is functional, and it definitely gives you a lot more precision with your aim, but they’re still tricky to score from. While mastering a well-drilled set piece routine can be a vital component of any team’s attacking arsenal in real-life, finishing from corners is unrealistically difficult in FIFA 17.

FIFA’s new momentum system has been panned by a huge section of the series’ fanbase, and understandably so. Getting a firm grasp of it is incredibly difficult, and it is particularly problematic on free kicks. Frankly, the old power/curl mechanic was far more intuitive, and made set pieces a lot more fun to execute. There’s a lot to be said about momentum’s increased level of control, but it has come at the cost of playability.


5. A Deeper Journey

The journey FIfa 17
EA Sports

The Journey was a welcome addition to last year’s game, and a complete change of pace from existing modes like Career and Ultimate Team. Offering players a new, RPG-like experience, The Journey saw gamers guide English prospect Alex Hunter through his first season in senior football, taking him all the way from pre-season to the FA Cup final, adding some much-needed diversity to the series.

The Journey wasn’t without its problems, however. It was a relatively short game mode that only allowed us to play a single season, and a rigid experience with little in the way of player choice. No matter how you played, Hunter’s journey always finished in the exact same place, and there were very few ways to create your own experience during the game mode.

EA have already confirmed that The Journey will return for FIFA 18, so here’s hoping they add some depth to it. Additional seasons should be the first step, but it’d be great to see EA implement more than just the English Premier League and give players the chance to sign for clubs like Barcelona and Bayern Munich.

Furthermore, increased choices, more dialogue, and greater interactions with other players, managers, and fans would go a long, long way to improving The Journey as a whole.


4. Tighter Commentary

Alan Smith Martin Tyler
EA Sports

No football game has ever perfected commentary, and FIFA 17 was no different. The usual team of Alan Smith and Martin Tyler were present again, but last year’s offering actually felt like a step back from FIFA 16. Smith & Tyler have rarely sounded so robotic and mechanical, and the game featured a glut of scripting issues, many of which weren’t even fixed through patches.

As always, the commentators could benefit from a greater variety of recorded lines, as every FIFA player eventually reaches a point where it sounds like Smith & Tyler are just regurgitating the same thing over and over. Their interactions are often stunted and completely inappropriate to the action before them, and they can be slow and unresponsive when it comes to reacting to what’s happening on the pitch.

EA Sports would do well to learn from 2K Sports’ NBA series, which has mastered the art of fluid, dynamic commentary in a sports game. NBA 2K’s commentators sound like actual human beings having an in-depth conversation, not scripted androids reacting to pre-programmed trigger points.

The problem isn’t with Smith & Tyler themselves, but the way they reflect the game, and this is something that must be improved upon in FIFA 18.


3. Character Customisation In The Journey

The Journey, FIFA 17
EA Sports

Following Alex Hunter’s career during The Journey was one of FIFA 17’s major highlights. As is often the case with such predetermined protagonists, however, there were times when Hunter felt distant and shallow as a character. It was often hard to get invested and immersed in FIFA’s pre-built avatar, and thus, there were times when The Journey’s bigger moments fell a tad flat.

Introducing full-on character customisation would solve all these problems. It’d be so much easier to invest in The Journey if you were able to play as your own creation, rather than EA’s chosen fictional player. So much of The Journey feels like Be A Pro as it is, so bringing that game mode’s player creation system over shouldn’t take much effort, and would be a big step in making The Journey feel like a less rigid experience.

Voice acting would be the one major stumbling block, but EA could get around this by hiring a handful of actors to record a number of different options. Be A Pro has always been a fun game mode, and by coupling its customisation with The Journey’s narrative-driven focus, EA could strike gold.


2. VR Support

playstation vr
Sony

Sony have invested bags of time, effort, and money into their PlayStation Virtual Reality system, but the roll-out hasn’t been entirely smooth, and the game line-up is still underwhelming. Resident Evil 7 remedied this somewhat, but PSVR is still lacking in the mainstream titles it needs to really take-off. Fortunately, FIFA 18 could go a long way to addressing this problem.

The days of throwing on a VR headset and running around a full-rendered football pitch are still a while away, and you won’t be playing as a first-person Leo Messi anytime soon. There are plenty of others ways in which EA can implement the technology, however. From crowd camera angles to first-person referee footage during the game’s more heated moments, such small touches would increase FIFA’s immersion level tenfold.

There’ll likely be some major kinks to iron-out at first, but there’s no reason why PSVR can’t be worked into FIFA 18. EA certainly have the resources to pull it off, and if they’re successful, the could wind-up creating the most immersive football game of all-time. At this stage, FIFA and PSVR coming together feels like an inevitability, and it’s a question of “when?” rather than “if.”


1. Revamped Career Mode

Man United FIFA 16 Career
EA Sport

Career Mode used to be FIFA’s main selling point, but Ultimate Team’s incredible success has seen it surpassed in popularity. Plenty of people still play Career, of course, but it has very much taken a backseat in recent years, and this is reflected in the developers’ effort towards improving it.

Career Mode is dying for a revamp. It has never felt so stale and lifeless, and it’s full of minor bugbears that only turn players away. From the clunky interface to inaccurate player valuations, FIFA 17’s Career was rife with problems, and brought few improvements from 16.

Career has become a shallow experience, particularly in the advent of The Journey, and there’s little reason to play for any longer than a season or two. Last year saw EA try to freshen things up by implementing long-term goals, but it wasn’t enough, and there was little to differentiate FIFA 17’s Career Mode from previous incarnations.

EA are often criticised for the lack of innovations between FIFA games, but revamping Career Mode could go a long way to squashing these claims. For many players, embarking on a long, eventful career is still the game’s most enjoyable aspect, and things like increased player communication, a more in-depth transfer system, and new menus would go a long way to improving the experience.


In this post: 
FIFA 18
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.