FIFA 21: 10 Most Shocking Ratings

This year's ratings are as controversial as ever. These cards explain why.

Taa Fifa21
EA Sports

The much-anticipated player ratings for FIFA 21 are here and it's fair to say that they have been met with quite a bit of disappointment from players.

Much of this stems from how EA have decided to approach their ratings for the upcoming game; they have clearly decided that they want to reduce the number of players available with the highest ratings. While this may be disappointing to some, the truth is that, in recent games, the number of high-end golds has become far too high, and it has stifled the ability to make players better in promos.

Unfortunately, this attitude has resulted in many players receiving some big downgrades this year. Some players undoubtedly struggled last season but the extent to which world class players have been nerfed will be surprising to many. Furthermore, some players had phenomenal seasons yet have had their ratings lowered while players who didn't meet their normal standards were given unexplainable upgrades.

It all makes for the most controversial set of ratings on FIFA in quite some time. Here are just a few of them.

10. Trent Alexander-Arnold

Trent Alexander Arnold - FIFA 21
EA Sports

As a key part of Liverpool's title-winning side, it was always to be expected that Trent Alexander-Arnold would be a solid upgrade for FIFA 21. The twenty-one-year-old notched up four goals and thirteen assists, the most for a defender in a single Premier League season ever, making him an obvious candidate for a major upgrade.

However, most FIFA players would not have been expecting him to get quite the upgrade he did. Going from an 83 to an 87, Trent has received one of the biggest upgrades for a high-end player in the game this year. EA has made a concerted effort to upgrade players from teams who won leagues last season, with both Liverpool and Real Madrid players generally getting buffs across the board, and this was likely a key factor in the Englishman receiving the rating he did.

The reason it is so shocking however is because EA has traditionally been very slow when it comes to giving young players big upgrades like this, particularly when it comes to English players. Whereas players such as Harry Kane had to wait years to be given a card of this level, Trent has been given one after just two full seasons as Liverpool's right-back.


9. Christian Eriksen

Christian Eriksen - FIFA 21
EA Sports

The 2019/20 season was a difficult one for Christian Eriksen. After trying to leave Tottenham in the summer, he was made to wait until January to finally make his move away from North London, eventually joining Inter. Unfortunately, he has only managed 11 starts and 4 goals in 2020 so far, with some reports now suggesting that Antonio Conte no longer sees a future for him at the club.

This difficult year is reflected in Eriksen's FIFA 21 card. Despite still being known as a world-class midfielder on his day, EA evidently feel Eriksen's lacklustre season has earned him a downgrade. However, the size of his downgrade is still somewhat shocking.

Going from an 88 to an 85, Eriksen has gone from a solid option for much of the game cycle to a player who will likely be outdated by November. Eriksen has never been particularly fast, but it is the major passing and dribbling downgrades that have hurt his card's rating the most. It represents a disappointing fall from grace for a player who was seen as one of the best midfielders in the Premier League just a couple of years ago.


8. Thomas Müller

Thomas Muller - FIFA 21
EA Sports

Most of the entries on this list are here because of significant changes in rating, but Thomas Müller's FIFA 21 rating is more notable for a glaring lack of change.

As part of the treble-winning Bayern Munich side, Thomas Müller had something of a late-career resurgence in the 2019-20 season. After many felt his time at the top of the game was beginning to come to a close, Müller produced one of best seasons ever in the red jersey. Breaking the Bundesliga record for the most assists in a season with 21, while also chipping in with eight goals, the two time World Cup Golden Boot winner received widespread acclaim for his contributions to Bayern's success.

One would imagine therefore that after a season like this, Müller would receive a substantial upgrade for his FIFA 21 card. Instead Müller's FIFA 21 card as arguably worse than its predecessor. While the 30-year-old has received a notable passing boost, he is significantly slower this year, which will severely affect his usability.

Overall, it's a huge failing on EA's part that someone who has had a season as good as Müller's has not been rewarded with a proper upgrade, and is somewhat reflective of the lack of upgrades Bayern Munich have received in general.


7. Eden Hazard

Eden Hazard - FIFA 21
EA Sports

After seven years at Chelsea, Eden Hazard was finally prised away by Real Madrid for a fee of over £130 million as part of Los Blancos attempts to rebuild themselves following a disastrous campaign. As the first Galácticos signing in quite some time, the pressure on Hazard to succeed was immense, with Real Madrid fans expecting him to quickly hit the heights he managed in London.

However, injuries meant the Belgian was absent for much of the season as Real Madrid claimed back La Liga. Hazard managed just 1 goal and 3 assists for the Spanish side, a far cry from the 16 goals and 15 assists he had managed in the Premier League the season prior.

EA were clearly not impressed with Hazard's efforts; having been rated 91 for the last two years, Hazard now finds himself at just 88. While many were expecting a downgrade for him as a result of his difficult year, few would have assumed it would have been by this much.


6. Roberto Firmino

Roberto Firmino - FIFA 21
EA Sports

Roberto Firmino's performances have been the subject of much debate among football fans in recent years. The Brazilian is lauded by many top managers as one of the best overall footballers in the Premier League and adored by Liverpool fans; however many detractors point to his lack of goal contributions for a top striker as a sign of an overrated player.

Regardless of your opinion of him, there is no doubting that Firmino wasn't quite able to meet his usually high standards of play last season for Liverpool. Though his performances on the pitch were solid enough, he only managed 9 goals in the league all season. For a striker in the league's dominant side, that can only be classed as a disappointment.

Firmino's shooting has therefore been downgraded to 80 but his overall rating has actually increased to 87. This is likely a case of EA wanting to upgrade more of the Liverpool players for winning the league, as players such as Anthony Martial, who had an excellent season for Manchester United, failed to get any upgrade whatsoever.


5. Kevin De Bruyne

Screenshot 2020 09 14 At 11 41 30
EA Sports

It is a testament to the season that Kevin De Bruyne had that even with Liverpool's domination of the league he was able to scoop both the PFA and Premier League player of the season awards.

Following a 2018-19 campaign that was blighted by injuries, De Bruyne returned to regular action with a bang last season, consistently providing the goods for Manchester City even when other areas of their team started to crumble. The Belgian recorded 20 assists in the league over the course of the season, equalling the record held by Thierry Henry for the most in a single season, while chipping in with 13 goals as well.

Despite his unrivalled success, EA haven't felt De Bruyne has done enough to warrant an upgrade for FIFA 21, with the 29-year-old remaining at a 91. This may be because EA have lowered the ratings of Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi this year and do not want any players to have equal ratings to them due to their superiority compared to the rest of the football world. While this reasoning does make sense, many will wonder what more De Bruyne could possibly have done last season to persuade EA to give his rating a boost.


4. Paul Pogba

Paul Pogba - FIFA 21
EA Sports

Since joining Manchester United for a then world-record fee of £89 million, Paul Pogba has endured a tumultuous second spell at the club. Though he has shown flashes of brilliance over his four seasons at the club, clashes with José Mourinho and various injuries have prevented the Frenchman from hitting the heights that many United fans would have expected.

Despite his on the pitch struggles, Pogba has managed to retain a very solid rating of 88 for the past several FIFAs. Furthermore, while he missed much of last season due to injuries, his performances for United post-lockdown were stellar and positioned him well to carry this form into next season.

Despite these strong performances, EA have decided that Pogba's lack of playing time last season warrants a fairly major downgrade, as he is now rated at just 86. While this is still a respectable score, it is not exactly the sign of the world-class player that many know Pogba can be on his day.


3. Thiago Alcântara

Thiago - FIFA 21
EA Sports

If Thomas Müller's lack of an upgrade was unfair, then Thiago Alcântara's FIFA 21 card is downright criminal.

While the Spaniard is not known for providing excessive amounts of goals and assists, only managing three assists and no goals in the Bundesliga last season, there is little doubt that Thiago is a hugely influential figure on the pitch for Bayern Munich.

Filling in as the central player who held the team together, Thiago's performances in the latter stages of the Champions League were crucial as Bayern stormed to their first victory in the tournament since 2013. The 29 year old was quickly marked as one of Europe's most underrated talents and was seen by many as the Man of the Match in the Champions League Final.

Maybe EA see goals and assists as key to determining whether a player should receive an upgrade or not, flawed as it may be. Either way, it is a staggering downgrade for a player who last season showcased himself as one of Europe's best.


2. David de Gea

David de Gea - FIFA 21
EA Sports

Just two years ago, David de Gea was viewed as the best goalkeeper in the world by EA, who gave him a staggering 91 rated card in FIFA 19. De Gea was crucial for helping steer Manchester United through a particularly difficult time on the field; the Spaniard put on a range on incredible performances in high-profile games such as against Tottenham where he made eleven saves in the second half.

However, the last year and a half have not been kind to the 29-year-old; not only has the quality of his goalkeeping deteriorated at an alarming rate, but he now faces stiff competition from the likes of Alisson and Manuel Neuer for the title of the best shot-stopper in the world.

De Gea's decline in form over the past couple of seasons has resulted in a massive downgrade from EA this year. Rated at just 86 this year, it is clear that EA view De Gea as being a long way past his best. Regardless of form, it is still surprising to see a 'keeper so widely lauded just two years ago given such a middling rating.


1. Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang

Aubameyang - FIFA 21
EA Sports

Normally when a player gets a downgrade in FIFA, players can roughly work out why it has happened. Even though anyone who watches the player will disagree with his downgrade, it is likely that Thiago Alcântara's lack of goals and assists last season played a key role in EA's decision to downgrade him this year. However, when you consider that as the reason it makes even less sense that Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang received a nerf in FIFA 21.

The Arsenal forward was crucial to the upturn in fortunes the north London side had under Mikel Arteta, scoring 29 goals in all competitions and providing three assists, including a host of winning goals in crucial games for the Gunners.

Despite this, EA's attitude to lowering player ratings across the board this year has meant that the Gabonese striker has been downgraded from an 88 to an 87. While this attitude to ratings isn't a bad thing, the fact that Aubameyang, who had his best season so far in an Arsenal shirt, got downgraded and Roberto Firmino, who had a rather average season, was given an upgrade is difficult to justify.


In this post: 
FIFA 21
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Alfie Seymour hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.