Final Fantasy: Building The Perfect Sequel (1 Feature From Each Game)

32 years, 15 games - 1 perfect idea?

Final Fantasy 7 Cloud
Square Enix

Which Final Fantasy game is the best? It’s an impossible question to answer.

Every fan of the series undoubtably has their own subjective opinion, but the beauty of Square Enix’s flagship franchise is how it constantly evolves between titles, adding, removing or modifying a myriad of gameplay features and series staples with each new release.

As a result, each title has its own show-stopping positive aspects, offset by drawbacks that are more apparent in some titles than others.

Over the next few pages, I'll compile a ‘greatest hits’ of the series. One feature or piece of content from every single-player game, beginning with Final Fantasy IV (when the simplicity and narrowness of I-III was built upon to create something breathtaking), all the way through the saga, with the hope to create a ‘perfect’ Final Fantasy game.

Supplemented further by inclusions from selected RPG spin-offs, including X-2, Type-0, Tactics and the XIII sequels, this deep dive into the franchise’s greatest successes is built from more than twenty years of love, disappointment, bewilderment and frustration with Square-Enix’s one of a kind creation.

Long may it continue.

17. All - Use Nobuo Uematsu

There are a number of names that are synonymous with the Final Fantasy series, such as series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi, designer and director Tetsuya Nomura, former head of studio Hajime Tabata and director and producer Yoshinori Kitase to name a handful.

Few are as renowned as composer Nobuo Uematsu, who is responsible for almost every audial masterpiece ever heard across the series.

Working at a music rental shop in Tokyo when he was approached to compose the music for FF1, Uematsu went on to singlehandedly compose the soundtracks for the first nine games in the series. His creations include everything from emotional tearjerkers like Aeris’ Theme and Aria Di Mezzo Caratterre to high octane battle pieces like Dancing Mad and Clash On The Big Bridge.

Something has certainly been missing since his departure from Square Enix to become a freelancer in 2004, three years after he shared credit on a title for the first time on Final Fantasy X. He contributed just one track to XII but none for XIII and XV, with his initial first set of tracks for XIV largely removed following the game’s A Realm Reborn relaunch.

The new breed of Hitoshi Sakamoto, Masashi Hamauzu and Yoko Shimomura are all hugely talented individuals, but the most popular tracks from the series remain those composed by Uematsu. He has now appeared alongside Bach and Beethoven in the Classic FM Hall Of Fame on five occasions.

Bringing him back would be a win-win for all parties.


16. FF IV - Active Time Battle

final fantasy 4
Square Enix

The core of a Final Fantasy game has always been its battle system. Story, content and exploration are important, but none would matter if the mechanic that drove the game forward was poorly executed.

Thankfully, Final Fantasy IV nailed it, to the extent that the turn-based Active Time Battle (ATB) system that it pioneered was barely modified for the next five games in the series.

Simple to understand, ATB enabled characters to take action once the gauge under their name gradually filled, with the time taken to do so determined by their Speed stat. This was replaced with a new system in every game from Final Fantasy X onwards, evolving into a fully real-time action-based system with no wait between inputs by the time XV came around.

Such continuous tweaking was indicative of a major quandary for Square Enix, as the ‘standing still and taking turns’ back and forth element of ATB has definitely been past its sell by date as a concept for some time.

The replacement of it with a ‘hack and slash’ system more akin to something like Dynasty Warriors is not universally appreciated by series purists, however. This has seen the strategic timing of combat success replaced by button mashing and dexterous block responses.

A return to ATB, in a modernised rather than its traditional form (like in X-2 or the upcoming VII remake), would therefore be highly welcomed, giving the formula a long overdue homecoming.


15. FF V - The Job System

final fantasy 5
Square Enix

All Final Fantasy games typically fall into one of three camps when it comes to character development and optimisation. The likes of IV and IX limit characters to a predefined class with abilities determined by levels and equipment, which is somewhat restrictive in that some are inevitably superior to others and an arbitrary ‘best party’ becomes apparent.

FF VII, VIII, X and XII ultimately allow every character to learn every ability in the game through Materia, GFs, the Sphere Grid and License Board respectively. This lets people pick their favourites but ensures that characters lack any distinction outside of things such as limit breaks. Endgame challenge is therefore eliminated given that everybody can be an absolute powerhouse.

The third system is the favourite of many. III, X-2, XIII, Tactics and the recent Zodiac Age remake of XII have all offered players a selection of ‘jobs’, each with their own unique advantages and skills to master. Some allow the mixing and matching of different roles whilst others limit use to one at a time but allow switching mid-combat.

This system is perhaps most associated with Final Fantasy V, where crystals and quests bestowed players with 26 (in the Advance remake) different classes to play with. This is more than any other non-online title, allowing almost endless combinations and optimisations to suit play styles or meet immediate objectives.

It’s been a long, long time since the job system was done properly. It deserves another moment in the spotlight.


14. FF VI - Esper Integration

Final Fantasy VI Battle
Square-Enix

Summons are a huge part of the Final Fantasy lore. Whether known as espers, eidolons, guardian forces, aeons, avatars, primals or astrals, the likes of Ramuh, Shiva, Ifrit, Leviathan, Titan, Bahamut and Odin have been omnipresent throughout the series’ storied history since their initial inclusion in III. Other names (notably Alexander and Carbuncle) have bolstered their ranks in subsequent releases.

In some games (VII, for example), summons are just ‘there’, usable in battle but playing no major part in the story. In others (most notably VI, VIII and X) they were a central part of the plot and battle system and it is in these where they were arguably used best.

Espers in VI could be equipped to different party members, allowing them to learn magic over time. The esper equipped also determined which stats would be extraneously boosted upon levelling up, making their usage a lot more strategic than it initially appeared.

This could complement the aforementioned job system in a number of ways, with summons dictating stat growth and potentially teaching support abilities (as they did in VIII) instead of magic that would otherwise be learned through job development.

Regardless of the mechanics, a whole host of summons is always welcomed, giving players a host of different offensive and defensive options in battle. VI had a whopping 27 (31 in the Advance remake) to choose from, beaten only by Type-0 (which had many duplicates). This is arguably excessive, but a good bar to aim for.


13. FF VII - Connection To The Characters

Cloud Tifa Final Fantasy VII
Square-Enix

When prompted to name their favourite Final Fantasy, many fans will go to bat for VII, the first that large volumes of them would’ve ever played as a result of the widespread exposure it got upon its release on Sony’s original PlayStation console.

It has some gaping flaws when critically analysed (what doesn’t), but these are largely offset by a gripping storyline, excellent mechanics (most notably the Limit Break and Materia systems) and spectacular visuals.

What certainly cannot be denied is that it boasts an incredible cast of characters, beloved to this day and with several frequently topping ‘best character’ polls that crop up semi-regularly on the likes of GameFAQs.

Too often in Final Fantasy games are the party members outside of the main protagonist simply passengers in the wider story, contributing little or nothing to it. VII is certainly not guilty of this crime, as all nine playable characters (except maybe Cait Sith) and the vast majority of the supporting players are tremendously fleshed out.

Cloud uncovers his past, his storied history with Sephiroth and develops potential relationships with Aeris and Tifa. Barret confronts his perceived failures to his best friend and village. Red XII develops pride for his father. Vincent tortures himself over Lucrecia. No matter who, every character has a fantastically well-crafted arc.

Great characters make great games and any future Final Fantasy would do well to follow VII’s example by giving players a cast that they develop huge attachments to.


12. FF VIII - Triple Triad

final fantasy VIII 8 triple triad
Square Enix

Personally, I have Triple Triad to thank for my lifelong Final Fantasy obsession. A curiosity piqued by watching my brother play it led to me becoming hooked on it on a save file of my own. The rest is history.

Whilst Final Fantasy VII had incorporated a number of mini-games into its gameplay mix, none were remotely as immersive as Triple Triad. This tasked players to collect 110 cards depicting the game’s monsters, bosses, summons and main characters by engaging NPCs in an easy to understand ‘battle’ on a 3x3 grid.

Whilst it was possible to complete the game without touching a single card, the appeal of Triple Triad was enhanced by how woven it was into the game mechanics. Monsters could be turned into cards to avoid levelling up, and surplus cards could be turned into items, which in turn could be refined into powerful spells and abilities for the Junction system.

This system attracted flak in some circles, but the fact that it rewarded strategy and planning rather than brute force grinding still makes it appeal to many today.

There is clearly a widespread love for Triple Triad, given that it has since cropped up in third party form on numerous occasions. This includes on Square-Enix’s official Final Fantasy Portal App and as one of the many mini-games from past entries in the franchise in the gargantuan world of Final Fantasy XIV. It will always be welcome as a fantastic timewaster.

The ‘Plus’ rule can f##k off though…


11. FF IX - The Volume Of Additional Content

final fantasy IX 9
Square Enix

There is a hidden quest in Final Fantasy IX that requires players to reach a point just before the end of the game in twelve hours or less. The sheer amount of content available in the game made that a pipe dream for most, given that such a short amount of time barely covered everything that could be done in just the first of the game’s four discs.

Admittedly, much of this content can be ignored with no adverse effects on the gameplay experience. Tetra Master is the inferior sibling of Triple Triad, replacing its simplicity and item refinement elements with nothing but confusion.

The racing Hippaul and Jump Rope mini-games, meanwhile, are thumb-breaking frustrations for anybody wanting the achievements associated with them and the likes of Ragtime Mouse can easily be missed without issue.

On the plus side, the game contained the series’ best use of chocobos through the Chocograph system, incorporating an addictive treasure hunting mini-game with a side quest that involves traversing the world, unlocking new locations and finding items.

Moogles were similarly well utilised, with Mognet providing a fun diversion that spans the entire game. Of similar longevity were the friendly monsters and frog catching quests, each tied an optional superboss.

Throw in synthesis and ability mastering and perfection in IX is no mean feat. But with almost every piece of extra content having a unique (if often useless) reward, achieving it is so much more gratifying than simply following the main story to its conclusion.


10. FF X - The Monster Arena

final fantasy 10
Square Enix

Final Fantasy X was the first game in the series released on the Playstation 2. Despite throwing tradition out of the window and casting aside series staples such as the Active Time Battle system and World Map, it nevertheless enthralled. A fantastic narrative, immersive world and a wealth of extra content meant that it became the first game in the series to be a 100+ hour commitment for many.

Alongside the addictive fictional underwater sport of Blitzball, the game’s main timewaster was the Monster Arena. This enabled almost every single monster in the game to be captured and fought at the player’s convenience, giving them the ability to farm items through victory in battle, steals or bribes rather than putting them at the mercy of random encounter rates.

The addition of increasingly challenging Area Conquest, Species Conquest and Original creations, meanwhile, provided a series of increasingly complex encounters for players to overcome.

This gave them the ability to hone their skills, build up an inventory full of the spheres and rare items needed to optimise the Sphere Grid, max out stats and craft the best equipment abilities. All of these were needed to conquer Penance and Nemesis, the game’s two optional superbosses.

Challenging, rewarding and frustrating grind reducing, the Monster Arena was an incredible piece of content, vastly expanding the lifespan of the game by simply offering a twist on its the battle system. Its replication in any future title would be greatly welcomed.


9. FF X-2 - New Game Plus

Final Fantasy X 2
Square Enix

The term ‘New Game Plus’ actually has its origins in a Square game, that being the 1995 masterpiece Chrono Trigger, which was made by a ‘dream team’ of developers and contributors from the Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest series.

The concept of starting a new game with elements of the completed one (such as items and stats) being retained goes back further, but the term Square coined has stuck in the games industry since.

After Chrono Trigger, they didn’t see fit to include it in a Final Fantasy release until 2003’s X-2, the first sequel to a main series title. It was the perfect game to implement such a feature into, given how X-2 had an astronomical amount of missable elements that players likely required a second chance to obtain or view unless they were meticulously following a guide.

The fact that the game also had a handful of irreversible decisions (notably the choice to give the Awesome Sphere to the Youth League or New Yevon factions) also meant that the alternative choice could be made in each playthrough to satisfy curiosity.

X-2 also implemented a percentage completion system, letting players know when they had hit 100% and achieved everything available to them. A huge part of games like Rockstar’s Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption series, it is hugely rewarding to see a screen acknowledging the achievement.

New Game Plus was patched into XV, and should hopefully be in every main game going forwards. Rightfully so.


8. FF XII - The Hunt System

Final Fantasy 12 Yiazmat
Square Enix

After venturing into the realms of tabletop (Triple Triad, Tetra Master) and physical (Blitzball) games to serve as the primary distractions in Final Fantasies VIII, IX and X, Square-Enix opted to integrate the main side quest of XII with its core battle mechanic.

Through the hunt system, they created a series of increasingly difficult optional battles to engage players at every stage as they progressed through the game.

Many hunts had their own interesting mini-story behind them and the fact that there were 45 of them in total, mostly with unique rewards, kept players coming back time after time.

Some were simple, some were mind-numbingly difficult, but together with Rare Game (the only other major side-quest in the game), it emphasised the strengths of the battle system. Elite Marks in particular necessitated precise Gambit setups rather than the button mashing mentality that can be used to get through most of the game’s storyline battles.

XIII and XV have both subsequently featured hunts in their own way, so it would seem a safe bet that they will continued to be included in future titles. XII’s take on them should definitely be the benchmark to follow, as both later titles went for quantity over quality, repeating the same monsters over and over again and offering nondescript rewards.

A good hunt system would also be an interesting way to make callbacks to the series’ history, as renowned bosses from past titles could easily be included akin to how some featured in XIII-2’s Coliseum.


7. FF XIII - Seamless Combat

Final Fantasy 13
Square Enix

Random encounters were the bane of many player’s lives for the first fifteen years of Final Fantasy’s existence. In the vast majority of locations, every few steps would trigger a swift transition to the battle screen, with hapless monsters mowed down before the process repeated endlessly until the next town or safe area was reached.

They were a necessary evil given game limitations and the need for enemies to grind levels against, but few mourned their passing when Final Fantasy XII opted to place monsters on screen with the player for the first time, accentuating the threat of large enemies in particular.

There were flaws in this first attempt at a seamless combat system, most notably that every monster’s spawn was fixed and required travelling three screens away to reset, making grinding an even more arduous process than normal.

XIII greatly improved on the system, with faster monster respawns, the ability to buff the party or debuff adversaries in the field through item usage and a more extensive focus on chaining.

The downside of real-time combat has been that only one character can be controlled at once, putting others at the mercy of the AI (which could at least be negated through Gambits in XII). This will even be the case in Final Fantasy VII remake, despite the original offering control of three individuals at once.

Somehow merging elements of ATB with the fast-paced but still user-friendly combat experience of XIII would be a momentous accomplishment.


6. FF XIII-2 - Creature Collection

final fantasy 13
Square Enix

Everybody loves Pokémon. Nintendo and Game Freak’s series will soon enter its eighth generation through the release of Sword and Shield, taking the number of capturable beasts to over 1000. Many games have tried to replicate and simplify the series’ formula of catching creatures and raising them in battle, including Final Fantasy XIII-2.

With just two playable characters (Serah and Noel) featured in the game, the party could be filled through the recruitment of a monster as the third member.

A surprisingly deep system, each monster captured could play one of the six ‘character class’ roles, with items used to enhance their stats and abilities, infusions with other monsters conducted to make them stronger still and adornments to make even the most vicious Behemoth look cute.

The availability of more than 150 monsters to collect (though no more than one of each ‘type’ could be held at a time) also made for a sidequest with substantial longevity, as like any Pokémon Trainer, a perfectionist would want to catch ‘em all.

A replication of this system could tie in to either the aforementioned Monster Arena or a Job System, as collected beasts could be trained in the arena and then called into battle by the Beastmaster job, which is frequently one of the more underutilised classes in any of the games in which they appear by virtue of having little to no skills.


5. FF XIII: Lightning Returns - Quest Log

Lightning Returns
Square Enix

The role-playing game genre is built on quests and the Final Fantasy series has never been short of them, with each game having a plethora of undertakings to complete, both mandatory and optional.

Until the release of Lightning Returns, however, when the completion of individual quests was a central focus of the adventure, they were never tracked in-game. This forced players to rely on memory or mementos (games like IX gave out items to demonstrate achievements such as defeating superbosses) to determine what they had and hadn’t finished.

This brought the series in-line with the likes of The Elder Scrolls, Fallout and Witcher series, with active and completed quests listed in an easily digestible format. It was a huge boon for completionists, allowing gaps to be easily identified and progress tracked when multiple pursuits were on the go at once.

Final Fantasy XV also included a quest log in its main menu, though it arguably went slightly overboard on quantity given how many broken down cars, fetch quests and random hunters in the wilderness it included.

Lightning Returns’ 66 was much more manageable, though a challenge given the time limit placed on finishing the game as a whole. Regardless of quantity, however, a tracker is a simple addition that goes a long way and should hopefully be a series mainstay going forwards.


4. FF XV - The Open World

Final Fantasy Xv Open World
Square Enix

One major criticism that the Final Fantasy series has faced since transitioning from Final Fantasy X onwards has been linearity. With the removal of the low-res world maps featured in the first nine games in the series, Final Fantasies X, XII and XIII (the latter notoriously) essentially became a series of long corridors with limited opportunities for exploration and discovery.

Whilst rival RPG series (such as the Elder Scrolls) and even action games with RPG elements (such as Far Cry and Grand Theft Auto) wholeheartedly embraced the open world concept from the early noughties onwards, Square Enix resisted the change.

The commitment to one for Final Fantasy XV is part of the reason the game took so long to release, but it pays off in droves with a virtual environment to rival Skyrim and The Witcher 3’s Continent in scope and content.

Lucis is far from perfect – bar Lestallum that are a distinct lack of urban environments and the latter half of the game reverts to being a cumbersome slog despite leaks that have indicated that this wasn’t supposed to be the case and that more of the world was supposed to be explorable.

Nevertheless, it showed fans of the series that it could be done and their dreams of fully traversing a world by airship, chocobo (or car in this instance) with seamless battle integration could indeed be realised.

Hopefully it’s the standard from now.


3. FF Tactics - A Dark Narrative

Final Fantasy Tactics
Square Enix

Final Fantasy Tactics is definitely a contender for the title of the most underrated game of all time. Sandwiched between the releases of Final Fantasies VII and VIII, it bears a lot of similarities to George R. R. Martin’s A Song Of Ice and Fire, depicting seven kingdoms and a host of individuals and groups scheming against each other for control.

There is no traditional ‘good’ or ‘evil’, with every entity (from the military and mercenaries to the church and nobles) having their own agenda that unravels before lead character Ramza’s eyes.

The plot is brutal and unforgiving, making darker Final Fantasies like VI look like children’s stories by comparison, terrifically written and packed with twists, deaths and shocks aplenty. Moments such as the detestable Argath’s comeuppance, a shocking murder that sets the story in motion, Ramza being forced to take up arms against his own brothers or Wiegraf’s depressing descent from rebel to nihilistic monster are up there with the series’ greatest moments.

It’s a shame that Tactics Advance and A2 were heavily dumbed down for younger audiences (necessary given their release on the GBA/DS), leaving Tactics in a class of its own. A dark story can alienate audiences given that it can elevate the age rating, but a good plot should certainly not be afraid to take on mature themes, eschewing the atypical ‘good guys beating bad guys because it’s the right thing to do’ cliché.


2. FF Type-0 - The Rubicus

Final Fantasy Type 0
Square Enix

Final Fantasy Type-0 is not a good game. It’s certainly not a terrible game either, but it struggles to hold a candle to even the weakest entry in the main franchise. Nevertheless, it should be commended for trying something different.

A mission-based game with only a finite amount of time between each scenario that can be devoted to side quests and exploration, Type-0 is complicated further by the fact that the narrative can deviate based on decisions made. This means that a minimum of three playthroughs are required to experience everything that it has to offer.

There is a convenient in-game accompaniment to this complication - The Rubicus, located in the Crystarium of the Akademeia area that serves as the game’s main hub. This serves as a comprehensive encyclopaedia that documents everything uncovered or undertaken by the player and offers hints (in the form of gaps) as to what they have missed.

Broken down into six sections, it has a full bestiary (Enemy Compendium), a database of summons (Eidolon Arcana) and characters met (Historical Personae), a full list of quests completed (Record Of Service) and a chronological list of all of the game’s happenings and story developments, linking to video sequences (Annals of Orience).

Filling every gap is a highly rewarding pursuit and replicating this in other titles (XIII and XV have done it partially with Datalogs, but to nowhere near the same extent) would be a simple way to give players another sizable achievement to pursue.


1. Conclusion

Final Fantasy XV Ardyn
Square Enix

So there we have it, our perfect Final Fantasy game is an open-world adventure with a deep, dark and unpredictable story.

Instantly beloved characters make up the cast, customised for combat with a modern take on the classic job system, with integration of the series longstanding cast of summons.

Such combat is in real-time but focused on strategy and timing rather than hack-and-slash, backed by immersive side quests including a card game, monster capture and collection, hunt slaying and pursuits involving chocobos, treasure hunting and traversing the world.

Every aspect of progress, collection and lore, meanwhile, is exhibited in a readily accessible quest log and library, whilst an epic Uematsu crafted or influenced score plays in the background.

And to top it off, you can do it all over again once the game ends, with progression carrying over if you so desire.

Your move, Square Enix.


Contributor
Contributor

Alex was about to write a short biography, but he got distracted by something shiny instead.