Final Fantasy XIV Review: 10 Ways It Rules
10. Sales Aren't Driving The Game
Though Square Enix obviously hopes that A Realm Reborn does well financially - and going by the fact that heavy demand caused SE to temporarily halt digital sales of the game - they have made it very clear that this concern is secondary to restoring the good name of the Final Fantasy franchise, which they feel was severely diminished by the previous effort. Though most fans of the series will admit that it has been in a steady decline ever since the PS2 days, the near-unplayable nature of the original FFXIV was something else altogether, a phoned-in mess of a game that, to their credit, they have made extreme pains to fix. The fact that this is a game driven by a passionate desire to win gamers' hearts back is the most encouraging thing I can think of; it's not really about money (though that would be nice), and really, the key here is in making the game as purely great as it can be. A superb mission statement, then.
9. It Will Please MMO & Final Fantasy Fans
There's an extra hurdle thrown in front of this game from the outset, even excluding the prior mess they had to clean up. FFXIV doesn't just have to deal with trying to differentiate itself in an already overcrowded MMO market, but it also has to try and please the legions of Final Fantasy fans around the globe, too. As an MMO, it may not aggressively shake-up the formulas we're used to, but it cherry-picks desirable elements from a number of recent games and works them into one massively cohesive whole (something I'll expand upon later). As for appealing to FF fans, it is absolutely chock with references to the main canon of games; pilots going by the names Biggs and Wedge make an appearance, Chocobos are ubiquitously present, and there are supremely subtle references to the earlier games in the series that you'll need to be an ardent devotee to catch. It is a game that manages to be referential but also stand on its own too feet.
8. It's Brilliantly Optimised
Though A Realm Reborn is a great-looking game, it's also important that, like all MMORPGs, it's carefully optimised for the systems it is running on; so many of us have complained in years gone by about games that simply cannot handle a high player-load on anything less than top-spec rigs, but so is not the case here. A Realm Reborn will run perfectly fine on a modest, years-old PC, and running it on a top-tier system will just add a few nice flourishes here and there. As is perhaps more of a pressing concern, reports suggest that the game is also immaculately designed with the PS3 in mind. I haven't played it on the platform myself, but reviews so far indicate that the game has clearly been developed with the system limitations of the console clearly thought-through. How different it will look on the PS4 next year, though, is anyone's guess.
7. An Engaging Story
To be fair, storylines in the vast majority of MMORPGs aren't that great, and it's because most people just skip through them anyway, after becoming obsessed with dispassionately grinding their way to the next level. This isn't to say that A Realm Reborn is massively different - it's still a pretty garden-variety good vs. bad epic adventure yarn - but it makes a better effort than most similar titles, and pulls you in with the punchy writing that defines some of the stronger titles in the series. There might not be any classic characters here to contend with the more memorable offerings of the best games, but they still make a firm impact with their characteristic looks, even if it's a little disappointing that only some of the characters have voice-over actors (it feels like Guild Wars 2 did a far better job, frankly).
6. Versatility
One of the more impressive facets of A Realm Reborn is its class system, which is wholly original and extremely intuitive. It is a player's choice of weapon that essentially defines their class, and so simply swapping weapons will allow you to instantaneously change class. The classes are divided into War (combat), Magic (self-explanatory), Hand (crafting) and Land (gathering resources), and from here, players will also be able to select a "dominant" Job to specialise in up to level 30, and then a secondary one up to level 15. This creates an interesting trade-off, but also one which can be changed up on the fly; there aren't the arbitrary restrictions here that stymie so many MMOs. The fact that you are given so many different classes and jobs to level ensures that the game has an immense level of freedom and replay value, while feeling like absolutely no other MMO on the market.
5. Learning Curve
A major flaw of so many MMOs is that they set you up with your gear, send you off into the open, but then don't continue to slowly nurture your skills, but simply expect you to suddenly keep up as the difficulty spikes up considerably. A Realm Reborn walks the impossibly fine line of being challenging enough for MMO veterans, but also not alienating FF fans who just might be dipping their feet in this type of experience. The dungeons, for instance, start off as a piece of cake, but by the time you're approaching level 30, you're likely to start feeling the grind, and will need to be vigilant to emerge in one piece. Still, bringing in a Chocobo to help out as a tank or healer is useful in papering over any strategic errors you might make, yet at the same time it won't effortlessly bail you out if you've bitten off more than you can chew. The word here is balance, and A Realm Reborn tackles it perfectly.
4. Tasks
It's safe to say that there is a lot to do in this game. Once you've set yourself up with a class, you'll start getting offered class-specific quests, you can hunt down special creatures that will earn you masses of XP, and then there's the Guildhest and Levequest services, which allow you to quest in both groups and on your own, and what's more, you can perform these challenges as many times as you like. Then there's the Full Active Time Event (FATE) system, which many players will instantly parallel to that of Guild Wars 2, essentially a public quest system which allows un-unified players to temporarily ally to take on a huge boss. These FATEs make for easily some of the game's most rewarding moments, even if it's initially a challenge getting used to the level of chaos. Also, like in Guild Wars 2, you'll no doubt find yourself hanging out with some players for hours on end as you tackle a number of FATEs together.
3. The Community
Nothing can sink an MMO for me quite like a community of douchebags; it's one of the (many) reasons I stopped playing World of Warcraft among other titles, because if a game doesn't have a welcoming, friendly community, what's the point in it being massively multiplayer in the first place? Though it's early days yet, and of course, like any game, it has a certain allocation of idiots, A Realm Reborn seems to benefit from appealing to a slightly more discerning breed of gamer, who might be slightly more mature than some (some, not all) of the types that obsessively rinse World of Warcraft without a single thought to hygiene or social convention. Overall, I've felt like I'm playing mostly with fans of the franchise, which frankly is a pretty great thing; it's something that binds us all together from the outset.
2. Cross-Server Play
Something I hadn't read about before playing A Realm Reborn but something I truly admire about the game is the Duty Finder, where you can party-up with players regardless of their server placement, something that is extremely rare in most MMO games, sadly. When tackling some of the game's challenges, you'll find yourself making friends with folks on different servers, which is refreshing, though at the same time, it is a tad frustrating that there's no ability to add a player from another server to your friends list and chart their progress. Instead, you have to look them up using the game's web directory, which allows you to see how they're doing, but doesn't allow you to chat in-game. It's something for Square to think about for a patch, perhaps? Surely, it can't be that difficult to implement?
1. Bosses
Most MMORPGs don't really put a whole lot of effort into bosses; you'll be greeted by a hulking enemy that you just have to beat down with your teammates ad nauseum, but A Realm Reborn does make a little more effort in its approach. At the worst, bosses will require a specific strategy to defeat, whereas others will be accompanied by intricate puzzles, and some will hurl a surprising fleet of enemies your way when you least expect it (and could really do without it). Though the fights are certainly challenging, they don't ever prove mouse-destroyingly frustrating, and rarely do you find yourself stuck for more than a few moments. Simply, the battles are carefully thought-out, so that they're satisfying to win, but not overly infuriating to lose. Have you given A Realm Reborn a go yet? Let us know what you think in the comments below.
