Final Fantasy XV: 6 Ups & 8 Downs

Chapter 13 is just the worst.

Final Fantasy XV Noctis Cindy
Square Enix

After a decade of waiting, Final Fantasy XV is finally here, and the gaming press has largely praised it for delivering another entertaining entry into the epic RPG franchise.

Indeed, in many ways FFXV is the lavish, absurd spectacle fans were hoping for, even if it's important to appreciate that the game is sure to prove much more divisive with franchise fans than critics.

This is a controversial game for a number of reasons, many of which actively encroach upon the gameplay, while others merely feel like missed opportunities and conjure up some interesting "What if?" scenarios.

Basically, if you're expecting the best game ever, you're probably in for a letdown unless you can forgive some glaring creative and technical issues, but if you already wrote the game off as a disaster, you'll probably be pleasantly surprised.

If you were smart enough to expect a good but flawed, often contradictory entry into the series, probably on the lower end of the core titles in honestly, then you were pretty much on the money.

Here are 6 ups and 8 downs from Final Fantasy XV...


Downs

8. The Story Is Disappointingly Minimal

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

One of the hallmarks of any Final Fantasy game is a dense narrative filled with exposition, plot twists and character-driven drama.

While FFXV has all of those things, they're in much smaller measure than most fans will be both expecting and probably hoping for.

Much like last year's Metal Gear Solid V, the game throws you out into an open world and relies on a lot of "emergent storytelling" rather than reams of cut-scenes and dialogues.

A bit part of the problem is that, in order to fully understand the story, you really need to watch the Kingsglaive movie and Brotherhood anime, which at best feels like a lot of effort just to get the full story, and at worst feels like a cynical attempt to take even more money from fans' pockets just to know what the hell is going on.

It helps that the core story is actually one of the simplest and most coherent of the entire series, but it ultimately doesn't prove that interesting because it's just "there" and doesn't give much reason to get particularly invested in it.


7. Main Questline Is Too Short & Too Easy

Square Enix

Though there is an absolute wealth of content here that allows players to invest hundreds of hours into the game, for those who were hoping for a sizable core questline as well, you're going to be sorely disappointed.

The main quest can be comfortably beaten in under 20 hours, aided by the fact that EXP is plentiful throughout and you can easily get to the end of the game without needing to do any side content or grinding at all.

Conspiring with the short length is the incredibly forgiving difficulty. Even when Noctis' HP hits zero, he'll be thrown into a "danger" state, where he can use potions to revive himself, and even if he fails to do that, he can just use a phoenix down to come back from the dead.

There's also a much-hyped boss fight that has been significantly nerfed from earlier gameplay previews, and basically ends up feeling more like a drawn-out QTE event than a traditional FF boss fight. You'll know it when you see it.

On one hand, it makes the game very accessible for more casual players, but it also makes it feel a bit "dumbed down" in some areas. Perhaps Square Enix should patch in a Hard difficulty setting in the future.

Still, those used to 30-40 hour main quests in previous games that required strategy and planning will be very surprised at how much of a breeze this game is.


6. Low Frame Rate During Busy Moments

final fantasy 15 XV
Square Enix

Though the game is a significant technical improvement over those earlier demos, it still leaves a lot to be desired when played on either the Xbox One or base PS4.

During battles that may contain over a dozen enemies, it's not uncommon for the frame rate to chug down to around 20fps, and this is also true when entering large city areas such as Altissia.

It can be incredibly offputting, and whether you're sensitive to frame drops or not, it's very hard not to notice such an inconsistent performance.


5. The Incredibly Linear Second-Half

Final Fantasy XV Train
Square Enix

After Final Fantasy XIII received a ton of flak for opening with essentially a hyper-linear 20-hour corridor, fans felt reassured that FFXV's open world would prevent Square Enix from repeating the same mistake.

Sadly, FFXV is basically a reverse FFXIII, in that the first half of the game embraces the wonderful open world, but at a certain point, the open world basically goes away and the player is funneled towards an end point in the most unimaginative of ways.

While the player can still use a bizarre time travel gimmick to return to the open word at rest points, this is basically just an awkward solution that further underlines how much the second-half of the game pales to the more open first half.

The irony of all this is that the second half has far more in terms of exposition dumps and plot revelations, but it's amid a decidedly less exciting style of gameplay.


4. Women Are Still Troublingly Depicted

Final Fantasy XV Cindy
Square Enix

It's Final Fantasy, so of course, there are going to be at least a few eyebrow-raising depictions of women.

At least the discomforting focus on jailbait is toned down this time, but considering that the first woman you meet, Cindy, is a busty mechanic wearing an impractical string bikini and hot pants, it doesn't set a particularly promising tone from the outset.

Iris meanwhile feels like a fan service character rather than an actual person, Lunafreya has a surprisingly small role in the game, and it's only really the warrior Aranea who proves to be both strong and interesting, and yet sadly she doesn't stick around for very long.

And of course, Aranea has to be kitted out in a figure-hugging, low-cut outfit rather than something more practical for a fighter. While this approach shouldn't surprise anyone familiar with the series, can't we strive to pander to 12-year-old boys a little less in video games these days?


3. The Camera Desperately Needs A Patch

final fantasy XV
Square Enix

Easily one of the most complained-about aspects of the game is the frustrating camera, which is especially a source of irritation during combat. When warping around and attacking large numbers of enemies, and during one late-game boss fight in particular, you may well have little idea where Noctis is in spatial relation to his enemies, the rest of his party and the surrounding environment.

Though Square Enix released a patch to apparently remedy the camera issues, they're still running rampant at the time of press, and make the otherwise slick combat often feel disorientating.

All they really need to do is pull the camera back a little during chaotic fights and big-scale battles would feel much more manageable.


2. Quests Are Mostly Very Samey

final fantasy XV behemoth
Square Enix

This is a frequent problem with RPGs of all kinds, that they struggle to conjure much in the way of imaginative quests. Here, whether you're beasting through the main questline or taking on side missions, it's mostly a case of "trek to a far-flung locale, retrieve a trinket, take on a mini-boss, go rest and cash in your EXP".

While in previous FF games a more involved story helps somewhat mask the repetition aspect, because this game isn't really reliant on plentiful cut-scenes, the sameness just feels much more apparent.

Variety is a tough nut to track in this genre, but considering the effort SE have clearly put into the open world, it's a shame so many of the tasks and missions feel like filler.


1. Chapter 13 Is The Worst Thing In Any Final Fantasy Game

Final Fantasy XV Chapter 13
Square Enix

The game's 13th chapter, Redemption, has been the source of massive player frustration since the game's release. Without explaining the context, the three-hour chapter essentially sees Noctis stripped of all his marvelous weaponry and forced to waltz around a large fortress, employing stealth to level up a key card and eventually get his weapons back.

It's woefully tedious and feels so far removed from anything an FF game should ever be: it honestly feels more like a Resident Evil game with the abundance of jump scares.

It's so awful that it really hampers the game's replay value significantly, considering that it doesn't even have the mercy to be brief and is basically just a total slog. Advice: turn the sound down and listen to something relaxing, because otherwise the jumps will drive you insane.

And after all that complaining, here's everything we actually liked about Final Fantasy XV...


Ups

6. Surprisingly Likeable Protagonists

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

There's been a lot of mockery about the game's four protagonists, Noctis and his buddies Ignis, Prompto and Gladiolus, namely that they look like a freaking boy band.

That said, the road trip element of the game is actually surprisingly entertaining, driven forward by some solid banter between the characters, even if it does venture into cringe-worthy territory quite frequently (especially Prompto bleating about chocobos all the time).

If nothing else, the heroes aren't as forgettable as the protagonists from the last two core games, even if the game could've gone much further with a more fleshed-out main questline.

They're still anime fanbait at the end of the day, but at least they're pretty endearing within that wheelhouse.


5. The Open World Is Grand & Epic

FINAL FANTASY xv
Square Enix

An open world Final Fantasy game could've easily been a total mess, but for the most part SE appear to have pulled it off superbly well...in the game's first half, anyway.

Yes, there are invisible walls that you'll encounter from time to time on your travels, but for the majority, the world feels huge without being overly intimidating in terms of traversal (thanks to fast travel options and the reams of dialogue between your party as you drive from place to place).

There could be more variety in terms of geography and what you can actually do, but given the riskiness of such an undertaking, SE have basically done a bang-up job.


4. Combat Is (Mostly) Great

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

The camera issues are definitely a problem, but on its own terms the combat is extremely entertaining, largely compensating for that lack of difficult with a high entertainment factor.

The game makes the player feel so capable with such a large array of skills, abilities and weapons, that every play style feels pretty damn well catered for here.

While you can admittedly get through most of the game's fights just holding down the attack button, occasionally dodging and just spamming Hi-Potions whenever you get cut down, the game does allow more skilled players to string together attacks in an almost balletic fashion that's really quite hypnotic.

In this respect the game definitely feels inspired by the likes of Bayonetta and Devil May Cry, even if it lacks their speed or depth. Still, it's a major step up from the turn-based nature of earlier games in the series and is arguably the game's best evolution from its predecessors.


3. The Wonderful Musical Score

Square Enix

Though no Final Fantasy composer is going to ever be as revered and near-universally beloved as the brilliant Nobuo Uematsu, Kingdom Hearts composer Yoko Shimomura still did a fantastic job living up to his legacy while bringing her own distinctive voice to the series.

She manages to make the battles feel intense, the more fun, free-wheeling moments feel extremely relaxing, and tones down the emphasis on pianos a little that many have criticised her Kingdom Hearts work for.

Basically, the series is in fine hands musically if she remains in steady employ over Uematsu, though of course, everyone's not-so-secretly still hoping he'll make a return for the inevitable FFXVI.


2. Dungeons Are Awesome

Final Fantasy XV Dungeons
Square Enix

FFXV's dungeons comprise many of the game's most rewarding moments, both in the main questline and especially in the side content. The core story features a number of dungeon-like environments that the player must navigate through in order to unlock more Royal Arms, and though hardly challenging, they help break up the more familiar gameplay quite nicely (even if they may themselves feel a bit samey if played too closely together).

The better dungeons emerge in the side missions, though, especially post-game, where the gigantic Pitioss Ruins dungeon can be discovered, a ridiculously lengthy platform-based dungeon that's easily more enjoyable than anything in the main questline.

Hopefully with any future DLC or spin-offs, they'll lean into how well-received by fans the dungeons have been.


1. The Graphics Are Frequently Gorgeous

Final Fantasy XV Combat
Square Enix

And finally, yes, though there are massive frame rate issues during major parts of the game, FFXV is more often than not a joy to look at. The texture models of the central four characters in particular are marvelous from moment to moment, even if lip sync definitely leaves a lot to be desired during cinematics, and some low textures are apparent throughout the environment.

For the most part, this is a stylistic feast of a game, and it's easy to imagine a lot of players going easy on its technical faults given the sheer mind-boggling scope of the adventure and how stunningly beautiful it looks for the majority of your play time.

What do you think of Final Fantasy XV so far? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.