Football Manager 2021 Review: 9 Ups And 3 Downs
Taking a look under the hood of the hotly-anticipated next entry in the famed FM franchise.
For football games, one of the key dates on the calendar is the day that the new Football Manager is released.
Ahead of its official release on November 24, we've been lucky enough to take an early look under the hood of Football Manager 2021.
With several new features added into the familiar mix of the FM series, Football Manager 2021 has the tricky task of building on something so brilliant and somehow making it better. It's a tough ask, yet FM21 manages to take the ball and run with it - with there so much here for football fans to indulge in.
To put it out there clearly from the get-go, the version of FM21 played here is an early beta version of the game that could well have changes made to it by the time the game is officially released later this month. That said, Football Manager 2021 is already looking like being one of the very best football games to have come around in a long, long time.
For the purpose of this review - and to get a more balanced view of different levels of the game - Premier League side Everton and National League team Wrexham were the teams played as.
With that in mind, then, let's break down the good and bad of this impending release.
Downs...
3. Too Many Slip Ups
Not to go all Slippy G, but there seems to be a few too many slip ups in Football Manager 2021.
By that, I mean that you can go on a run where you convincingly smash through all of the better teams in your division, but you'll forever be caught out when playing against the teams languishing at the bottom of the table.
As an example, you could romp past the likes of Manchester City, Liverpool, Chelsea and Manchester United, putting four goals past each team on your way to glory, yet you'll then get turned over 3-0 whenever you play a Fulham, a Leeds, or a West Brom.
Initially, I thought it was maybe something to do with the general system I implemented being not suited to teams who tend to sit back more, but even a change of tactics and formation don't seem to work in this regard.
Football Manager - and before that, Championship Manager - always has a habit of bringing a player crashing back down to earth, although Football Manager 2021 seems to take this to an extreme level. And more-so, it's always against the lesser teams that you'll find yourself inexplicably staring shocking defeats in the face.
2. VAR
Playing Football Manager 2021 can be a truly fist-chewing, desk-thumping, rant-shouting experience - and a good part of that is down the game's use of VAR.
To the credit of Sports Interactive, they have absolutely nailed VAR. The whole concept of a video referee scrutinising the biggest calls of a match is something that has tarnished the beautiful game for many football fans, and this system has now been implemented in FM.
It's maybe a little tough to truly rate this as a Down, for SI has managed to perfectly encapsulate the emotion and oft-annoyance drummed up by VAR
Likewise, another sad reality that FM has delivered is the impending Brexit that's on the horizon, which in football terms means restrictions on foreign players for English clubs. By the time of early 2021, players may have to change their approach or even their playing squad once Brexit arrives.
Again though, it's hard to really label either VAR or Brexit as a negative, for it's merely Football Manager mirroring the real world. That still doesn't make both VAR and Brexit a massive pain in the backside for players, though.
1. Injury Crisis, Ahoy!
Not to sound like a miffed Liverpool fan whose club is clearly the only team in the history of football to experience an injury crisis, but the injuries soon pile up on Football Manager 2021.
It may just have been a blip or it may even be a niggle that will be fixed when FM21 gets a full roll-out later this month, but a first run on this year's FM saw a ludicrous number of injuries pile up by the January transfer window. And not just squad players or youth players, instead I was left in bewilderment after my star striker (Dominic Calvert-Lewin), main creative outlets (Richarlison and David Neres), midfield general (Allan), defensive rock (Mason Holgate), vice-captain (Lucas Digne), and major right-back prospect (Gonzalo Montiel) all had big injuries at the same time.
As mentioned, this may hopefully be just a one-off and not a direct indicator of what to expect as you continue to make your way through Football Manager 2021. For now though, I'll just grin and bear the piling injuries that have started to derail my title challenge. Seriously, it's fine, honest, no biggie, not a problem, and I didn't shed a frustrated tear at back-to-back humiliations courtesy of Crystal Palace and Aston Villa...
Ups...
9. Sleeker Matchday Interface
With a new interface at play, Football Manager 2021 looks absolutely glorious.
The in-game screen has so much more to tinker with, with Sports Interactive making it a far easier, smoother, sleeker process to make any changes to your side during a match. The bottom of the match setup has your starting XI detailed, with a heart representing each of your players' fitness, while a simple click here opens up a pop-up menu where you can make quick, sharp changes - be that to a player's role, to barking instructions at them, or even making a substitute.
Alongside that element of the interface, there's also more stats, numbers, and graphs than you can shake a stick at - all available to see while a match is simultaneously ongoing.
All in all, these small tweaks and updates make Football Manager 2021 feel more accessible than its predecessors. Let's face it, said predecessors didn't need a major overhaul on this front - it's more that FM21 has just made a few choice edits that have taken the enjoyment of previous games and updated it in a fresh, positive way.
8. Additional Player Interaction
Gamers have long been able to interact with their squad in the Football Manager franchise, but Football Manager 2021 has brought a whole new level of interaction to the table.
Every interaction with a player - or their agent, for that part - has a whole new level of detail to it. Not only are the conversations more in-depth, but there is now body language at play. Yes, body language.
When speaking to your star player or your next big thing, you have the option to set your body language before you speak to them. That means that there is an even greater level of personalisation to these conversations than ever seen before in any football game. But that also means that there is a greater risk of error for gamers.
Of course, it's ultimately down to each manager to make the best (or worst!) of this new feature. Say the right things presented in the right manner, you're in a player's favourite personnel for life. Say the wrong thing or present the wrong body language, and your best players and prospects will soon be trying to force their way out of the exit door.
7. Improved Scouting
The scouting on Football Manager has been pretty solid in recent years, yet Football Manager 2021 seems to offer up a more extensive, all-encompassing scouting experience.
By just having a modest number of scouts, it seems that FM21 provides you with more potential signings from around the globe. Rather than just being served up with the sort of "We reckon that Neymar fella is half-decent" advice from your scouts, instead there seems to be a renewed focus on your scouting system throwing up potential starts of the future who are currently available for a relative steal.
It's not all cheap, great options to the point of feeling too easy, of course, but it feels as if FM21 throws its players a bone a little more than in recent years. One of the quibbles of many a fan of the series, is that Football Manager can make it a near-impossible task to unearth the next gem. Without throwing all of the best players of the next generation at you from scratch, though, Football Manager 2021 at least throws some names your way who are destined to be great players, but who are also available at a decent price if you know where to look.
This time out, it feels far more rewarding to invest in your scouting department - and having scouts with strong stats seems more important and worthwhile than it has for a long old while.
6. Approaching Agents
What Football Manager 2021 has done so well on the transfer front, is that it has made great changes without really feeling like a major overhaul. In particular, you can now directly approach an agent ahead of making a move for a player.
Found a player who you think could make a big difference to your team in the short or long term, but not sure on whether his club are open to selling him, what his transfer value would be, or what his wage demands are? Now, you can directly speak to the player's agents to find out all of this information.
On the transfer value, there are times where the agent can't give you an exact amount - which usually means you'll have to pay WAY over the odds - but having this conversation can break down wage demands and establish whether the player in question actually has any sort of interest in joining your club.
Again, this is a smart move from Sports Interactive, and it again brings something fresh to the table for a franchise that is forever looking to add new strings to its bow. Having that 'in' with agents means that gamers can at least be able to establish the lay of the land ahead of making any potential move for a new signing.
5. xG Is Finally Here!
As an ideal, some football fans may hate it, but others absolutely adore xG - and now, xG has finally made its way to the Football Manager series.
A good percentage of FM fans have been clamouring for xG to hit the franchise for the past couple of releases, and now there's finally a Football Manager game that has this extra detail included in it. Like so many other features of FM21, this is something that you can make the most out of it you really want to, or something that other gamers may choose to largely ignore.
For those wondering what xG even is, the breakdown of xG from Opta reads:
Expected goals (xG) measures the quality of a shot based on several variables such as assist type, shot angle and distance from goal, whether it was a headed shot and whether it was defined as a big chance.
Basically, the higher your xG numbers, the more goals you should expect your team to be scoring. And if they're not scoring the goals to match the xG figures, that's when a manager needs to be asking serious questions of their attacking players, of their system, and of their management style.
4. The Match Engine
Again not a major improvement, but still a definite positive about Football Manager 2021, the match engine itself has had a nice upgrade.
Beforehand, the match engine of FM20 was great, but Sports Interactive has taken that and made some smart tweaks to what was already in place.
If you're a gamer who prefers to watch the 2D approach or merely rely on text commentary, that's fine. But for those who like to watch each match, or at least the highlights, in 3D then there is a fun and fresh unpredictability about Football Manager 2021.
Without any exaggeration, FM2021 has you on your toes and on the edge of your seat just as much as you would be if you were in your favourite stadium of choice and cheering on your own team. What may start off looking like a guaranteed goal for your opposition, can just as easily switch to a breakaway counter-attack that will have you punching the air - and the dynamics of the 3D view of matches is phenomenal here.
Truth be told, this is coming from someone who usually gets fed up of the 3D style of viewership. Instead, every match is now watched in 3D, with the varying camera angles on offer adding further to the touchline managerial experience.
3. Youth Products
While the Football Manager franchise has long established a youth system for teams, that system hasn't always brought major results for FM fans.
By that, it means that you can have the very best youth system and youth facilities imaginable in place, yet you may find yourself going years at a time without turning out even a semi-decent prospect. In Football Manager 2021, though, that seems to have changed.
In FM21, if you have a strong youth system in place then you'll be rewarded with more genuine prospects than in years before. Rather than March proving to be a depressing time of the year as you realise that your new influx of 16-year-olds is full of utter garbage, FM21 seems to serve up young players who have a legitimate chance of making it all the way through to your first team if handled correctly.
To pinpoint a massive change in the approach to youth prospects is a tough ask, but the bottom line is that Football Manager 2021 seems to reward those managers who opt to fully invest in the youth element of their football club.
2. Increased Speed
When playing Football Manager 2021, it soon becomes apparent that, not only is the game smoother and sleeker to look at, but the game feels generally quicker when playing it.
Upon doing a little digging under the covers of FM21, it turns out that the game is indeed faster than its predecessors.
From Football Manager royalty Miles Jacobson, Football Manager 2021 is indeed a faster gaming experience than what we've seen before from the FM series.
Not only is the save time hugely lesser in FM21 in comparison to FM20, but the game is also just overall faster than the previous release in the Football Manager franchise.
As fans of Football Manager, one of the major drags of the series is that sometimes the load and save times can feel like forever. Here in Football Manager 2021, however, Sports Interactive is well on its way to making sure that the franchise is relayed at a super-quick speed.
1. It's The Perfect Tonic For 2020
For anyone who's ever played a single minute on Football Manager, you'll be well aware that the game can serve as a great escape from the real world.
Given how 2020 has been such a tumultuous and terrible year on a whole variety of levels, Football Manager 2021 is the perfect tonic for this most troublesome of years. Never before has the easy escape of an FM game being so welcomed as it it here in 2020 - and it's testament to Sports Interactive at how they've yet again delivered a game that is ridiculously addictive, ridiculously detailed, and ridiculously engaging.
As an example of this, this actual review of Football Manager 2021 was intended to be put together and ready to be published several days before these words are being typed. The reason for that delay? That's because FM21 has already taken over the life of your humble scribe.
Whether it's taking charge of a top level team or plying your trade with a smaller side, Football Manager 2021 is as all-consuming as you would expect and hope. With each passing year, it feels as if the Football Manager series gets better and better, and this is again the case as FM21 once more manages to top its predecessor.
Make no mistake about it, Football Manager 2021 is everything you'd hoped for and then some.