Google Stadia: 10 Questions We Need Answering ASAP

There's still so much we don't know.

Google Stadia
Google

Google, one of the world's biggest companies, has long been considering a move into gaming, and it made some moves in the past few years by hiring top-notch industry talent like Ubisoft's Jade Raymond and Sony's Phil Harrison.

March 19 was the day it decided to pull back the curtain and reveal its plans to the world, and the result is Google Stadia.

A streaming service that aims to remove all barriers from gaming such as installing, updating, loading and more, Stadia aims to work on any smart device.

You can play a AAA video game on your web browser, phone, tablet, PC or TV, over the internet, and just with Google's controller (or your own). Google promises no lag or reduction in visuals, even going so far as to state that Stadia's GPU's are more powerful than the PS4 Pro and Xbox One X combined.

What does this mean, however? I, like you, was left with a lot of questions. In fact, there are even more questions than answers following the keynote, as what was billed as the unequivocal 'future of gaming' seems like more of a tech demo.

Google Stadia has a long way to go and a lot to prove to make it must-have, and here's why.

10. What Is The ACTUAL Release Date?

 Assassin's Creed Odyssey
Ubisoft

Google provided a rather vague "Launching 2019" as the release window for Stadia. Considering we're coming up on April, and therefore a third of the way through the year, that's a little too vague.

Even a seasonal window wold have given us more to go on, but we're left knowing little more than we did prior to the keynote.

Is this something Google will simply announce one day and launch the next? Or will it build towards a big Fall launch? At the end of the keynote the company said that we would see more in the summer. So either it launches then, or we get the official fall launch date at the next keynote.

And then there's the question about other territories. So far Google announced that Stadia would launch in the US, Canada, U.K, and "Most of Europe". Once again that's quite vague; which European countries? What about South America? Asia?

Ironically, considering Stadia is all about removing wait times, we'll have to wait to find out.


9. How Much Will It Cost? Is The A Monthly Fee?

1380399

First and foremost, Google failed to reveal what Stadia's business model is.

Is it a subscription service? If so, we'd like to know how much it's going to cost; if it will be comparable to Xbox Game Pass/PlayStation Now, or something more expensive that includes various third-party day-one releases.

Alternatively, Stadia could work with a tie-in subscription to YouTube Premium. Google showed the service working almost exclusively with YouTube, and put a massive emphasis on streamers, so that could make sense, but it also alienates a massive amount of people who don't care about upgrading a formerly free service.

If the service is subscription based with only a handful of Google exclusive games a year (presumably), then why would anyone opt for that over Steam or Epic Games? If it is a subscription service, and the games are pay-to-play, then you'd be paying to simply play your games across multiple devices. However, that angle doesn't seem especially enticing.

At this stage, more brass tacks information is sorely needed.


8. What's The Barrier To Entry?

Google Stadia YouTube Play
PCWorld

In the keynote, Stadia was shown to work instantly. After watching a YouTube video you can just hit play and dive right into a game... but how?

Surely you'd have to buy the game first, enter some details, etc. In which case, it could never be an instantaneous thing. Google wanted to wow audiences with the speed of going from watching to playing, but that just doesn't seem especially feasible.

And that also brings us to the confusion surrounding platforms beyond YouTube. It's entirely unclear where one would go to buy a game, or even resume the one they're already playing, beyond YouTube. It's really quite strange that Google didn't show the service working on anything besides YouTube, because that alone presents a barrier to entry for those who doesn't use the website everyday.

We assume there will be another location to buy games; perhaps Stadia even works with other platforms, but for now we have no idea, as Google forewent explanations in favour of a flashy presentation.


7. Where Is The Home For Stadia?

1380400

If Google Stadia aims to be something akin to Steam or Epic Games, it will need a storefront. Of course, it could be completely unlike those two services and prove to us that a dedicated storefront is a thing of the past, but for now we're left confused.

Google made a point of talking about inclusivity, and being a platform for everyone, however if it has a storefront then it's likely to seek exclusive deals, much in the way Epic has been doing.

We're maybe getting ahead of ourselves there, because we're just assuming Google Stadia will have some sort of "home"; an app that can be launched from your desktop, phone, or tablet. However that also raises some issues because Google and Apple don't play nicely together, and Apple doesn't allow for stores to be sold on its Apple Store. So, as of now, we don't know how, or even if, Stadia will work on iPhone.

Google is trying to buck tradition with Stadia, and slingshot the industry forward ten years, but that would be an easier transition if we knew what it looked like.


6. What Platforms Will It Utilise?

Google Stadia Keynote
GameSpark

Stadia seems deeply entrenched in YouTube and the culture of streamers, and speaker Phil Harrison proudly boasted the willingness to play nice with all other companies, including cross-play and even using the "opposition's" controllers.

So that begs the question of whether Stadia and Google's exclusive games will be on Steam, Epic Games, GOG, App Store, PlayStation, Xbox or even Nintendo. Google conveniently leapt over all those topics to talk more YouTube.

Let's hypothetically say it does have a storefront. That just makes us wonder if your already-owned games from other platforms will cross over. It seems unlikely, but buying them again would be another barrier to entry considering you can go as far as to play Stadia with your Dualshock.

Google also said Stadia will utilise cross-play with other platforms, although it didn't say which. So if one person is playing PUBG on a phone using Stadia, are they playing against people on Xbox One and Steam? That's a whole other kettle of fish, but one that needs addressing.


5. How Will Couch Co-Op Work?

Google Stadia Co-Op
Polygon

Google were proud to talk about couch co-op in its GDC keynote, saying it's bringing the feature back to the forefront. However, it didn't really mention how that would work.

Most games nowadays don't support couch co-op, so Stadia's lauded feature will probably be a future functionality built into its exclusives and some third-party games. There's no way it can retroactively add couch co-op into existing third-party games, so this seems like an odd feature to spend so much time on, especially when none of the functionality was really new or exciting.

The demo showcased different people playing the same game in varying roles. It was an odd, not very impressive demo that begged the question: Why? It doesn't seem like gamers really care that much about couch co-op in 2019. Sure it's a nice additive, but that's just it: An additive that was discussed in a keynote for 10 minutes.


4. What Kind Of Internet Connection Is Required?

Google Stadia Connection
Inverse

Much of the push-back against the Xbox One when it was revealed was due to the always-online requirements it was to enforce. Millions of gamers simply don't have good enough internet connections to sustain that reality.

Of course, all that was required for Microsoft's Xbox One was a minimal connection for the system to ping the internet every day. Stadia will require a beefier connection.

In fact, Phil Harrison said in interviews following the keynote that the numbers aren't concrete yet, but at least 30 MBPS download will be required for 60FPS, 4K streaming.

Those aren't bad numbers all things considered, but they are still higher than many countries can offer. There are large parts of America, Europe, Asia, and South America that cannot sustain those kinds of internet speeds, making the service unavailable to them. Harrison recognised that fact in an interview; "We know that our internet bandwidth requirements won't reach everybody day one. There's nothing I can promise that will change that. But we'll work hard to reduce the bandwidth required and increase the quality."

So basically, this is a service that isn't for everyone right now, but Google will continue to make it available to more people.


3. What Third-Party Developers Are On Board?

Doom Google Stadia
9to5Google

Consoles and services are entirely dependent on their third-party game releases. The Wii U was the perfect example of this; a total dearth of third-party games, and it died a swift death. Well, Google has more than enough power and money to get developers on board, but which ones?

We know Bethesda and Ubisoft are partnering with Google; Assassin's Creed: Odyssey was the game used for Stadia's beta test, while Doom was confirmed for the service during the GDC keynote.

What many gamers may not have noticed however, were the loading screens before the keynote began that seemingly teased No Man's Sky, Metal Gear Solid, Red Dead Redemption, and other titles. While we didn't see any of those titles actually announced for the service, perhaps we can expect announcements down the line; which would explain why Red Dead Redemption 2 never came to PC before now.

Having Konami, Rockstar, Bethesda, Ubisoft, and more on board is certainly a fantastic start, but what about Activision or Electronic Arts? And surely Google would want Fortnite, which would require a relationship with platform rival Epic.

Google only has one known first-party development team as of now, which is a far cry from the likes of PlayStation and Xbox, so it's going to really need those third-parties on board en masse.


2. Where Are The Games?

Google Stadia Games GPU
Destructoid

Google's GDC keynote may be the first time a gaming platform was revealed from a first-party and no games were shown. Yes it was GDC, where games rarely get revealed, but the keynote should have ended with a trailer for Google's first AAA exclusive game. That would have given the reveal the punch it needed to make it feel real and viable; a statement of intent.

Jade Raymond, founder of Ubisoft Toronto, came on stage during the keynote and stated that her team will cultivate first-party studios and partnerships with third-party studios, but that was it. That's great news but it doesn't mean much when we see no fruits of the labour.

Similarly, Google made a point of showing the GPU capabilities of Stadia, which makes it more powerful that PS4 or Xbox One X combined. Even going as far as to refer to the consoles as "previous generation". That's exciting, but once again it doesn't mean much when all we saw was a tech demo of some water.

Show us a game that utilises the insane power on hand. And if no games are ready, then this service feels like it is being rushed out the gate with no exclusive offering that makes it must-have.


1. Why Should Anyone Care?

Google Stadia
ReviewGeek

Perhaps the biggest question Google failed to answer in its keynote, is "why?"

So far it does little that can't be done on other platforms; the PS4 can Remote Play with PS Vita, PC's, and phones, the Switch is the epitome of game anywhere, and Microsoft is working on its own similar service called Azure. So that makes it hard to see why Stadia is the next must-have service, especially with the potential for latency.

Not to sound completely down on the whole thing, but as of now it seems like just another store like Steam, but a bit more versatile. If it's a pay-to-play model like its peers, then it's hard to see why anyone would jump ship.

PC gamers already have their libraries on Steam and Epic, so it's unlikely they would change allegiances just so they can play on a phone. And the same goes for console gamers. On the other hand, if it's subscription-based and you can play any games for just the subscription fee, that's certainly more appealing.

Google Stadia is undeniably impressive technology, but it doesn't feel like the groundbreaking step forward we were all hoping for. For now though, we wait patiently until Summer to hear more.


Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.