GTA: Ranking The 10 Best Protagonists

From Tommy Vercetti to Trevor Philips, who did you enjoy destroying the world around you with the most?

The world of Grand Theft Auto is a gloriously ridiculous and overtly violent one, that we all love to indulge in on various levels.

Outside of throwing the rulebook out the window and letting you run amok in a blur of pedestrian-abuse and vehicular destruction, another huge draw (especially in the newer iterations of the series), is embodying a character that is contributing to your onscreen actions by way of play-by-play commentary or an otherwise hilarious quip.

As the series has evolved and video games have begun to be taken just as seriously as films and other media, more questions tend to get levied at the portrayal of these characters, yet with the newest instalment GTA V, Rockstar managed to create three very different characters, one of which is the perfect middle-finger-flailing catch-all answer to those sorts of questions. Going forward we€™re sure Rockstar will continue to set new benchmarks and push every boundary they can, hopefully eventually creating a female protagonist to balance the testosterone-fuelled previous instalments.

10. Claude (GTA III)

For many, the protagonist of GTA III is actually one of their favourites, due in no small part to the genius of making him mute, thereby allowing all of us at home to inject our own reactions and dialogue into the games many scenes of interaction with a city full of gangsters. If you€™re anything like me, it actually didn€™t even dawn on you that Claude didn't speak, due in no small part to Rockstar€™s exemplary scriptwriting and delivery that effortlessly carry the many one-sided conversations with great pace. Said mutism also allowed Claude to be the unremitting badass we all imagined him to be. A silent weapon of debauchery, existing in a constant state of rule-breaking, going from jacking all manner of cars, to blowing up Triad vans, to taking part in any number of random Rampage missions. His silence did away with the more modern-day discussions on motive and place within the gameworld, and we were free to indulge in the first 3D Grand Theft Auto to placate our darkest desires, all the way back in 2001.

9. Luis Fernando Lopez (The Ballad of Gay Tony)

Gay Tony

GTA IV remains a divisive entry to the series, and the point in which Rockstar took the franchise in a slightly more serious direction, leaving the fantastic Saints Row series to take The Ball of Total Insanity and run a few pitch-lengths ahead in the race.

Whilst IV€™s main character Niko will make an appearance later, the inclusion of Luis on this list is down to Rockstar releasing two downloadable packs that let all of us indulge in our crazier sides once again.

Fed up of dying because you went too fast and flung yourself through a windshield due to the games ice-skate-driving controls? Well how about the return of parachuting to ease those woes?

Although the animation set was kept the same for Gay Tony, Luis' skin was still brilliant fun to be in, and returning to GTA IV€™s take on New York City with more than a hint of a neon underbelly, remains one of the best DLC packs in gaming history.

8. Victor Vance (Vice City Stories)

Onto one of the portable entries into the series, and the character of Vince Vance, brother of fan-favourite side-character Lance Vance from Vice City, and the pilot of the helicopter that can be seen during the opening cinematic where a deal turns sour. Vince€™s military background made him an all-round leaner fighting machine than the chubby Tommy Vercetti, and bombing around Vice City investing time in the new property-management mechanics really injected new life to the already characterful city. With a €˜take-no-sh*t€™ attitude and a contrasting mentality to that of the overblown Lance Vance, Vic was a great main character that was thought initially to be a risky venture due to his demise at the beginning of Vice City, and one we could believe would be up to his eyeballs in questionable dealings with more-questionable people.

7. Franklin Clinton (GTA V)

The characters of GTA V are some of the best written yet, and though later entries on this list play more to a new direction Rockstar seem to be taking in giving their characters adequate motive and a sense of place within the evert-chaotic world of GTA, Franklin is the last to be cast from the mould of old. Feeling like the least developed of the three alongside family-man Michael De Santa and the tornado of foul-language and faux-philosophical garblings that is Trevor Philips, Franklin comes across as a lite version of the San Andreas' Carl Johnson. His opening missions resemble the fetch quests and workingman driving missions of old, before he begins to work for Michael and his world expands in more ways than one. However it remains that by games end, he's still something of a yes-man, and someone who finds himself throwing his arms up for the sake of going along with whatever hair-brained scheme his cohorts have thought up, rather than steering the ship himself.

6. Niko Bellic (GTA IV)

As Rockstar took the franchise into more serious realms, and attempted to tell a story with more weight and purpose than that of San Andreas€™ gangster-turned-high-roller, it also led into the discussions surrounding character motivation and placement within the game world. Now instead of somebody like GTA III€™s mute protagonist who would happily gun down a busload of innocent shoppers if the price was right, we now had Bellic who was constantly talking of leaving the €œold life€ behind him, yet at every turn was engaging and indulging in the most heinous acts imaginable. Whilst you could argue that Rockstar weren€™t about to completely change their gameplay formula, it would be another five year wait until GTA V would perfect the balance between believable player agency, and that of a character€™s existence within the game world. Bellic does have one of the most badass missions in the entire series though, when he takes on an entire warehouse full of armed goons with hardly more than a pistol, just to rescue his brother Roman all the while yelling abuse and Scarface-style insults to all within earshot.

5. Johnny Klebitz (The Lost And The Damned)

The second of the DLC packs for GTA IV, Lost and the Damned would feature Ron Perlman as a hardass biker gang-leader, the underdog of which was Mr Klebitz. It was a tribute to the fantastic Sons of Anarchy, and one that personally made Klebitz a favourite, being the DLC€™s combination of heavy metal hideouts and riding-in-formation mission-starts created an air of being an integral member of the gang in question. Although clearly Rockstar weren€™t as much a fan of Jonny as the rest of us, (or perhaps it was entirely the opposite, to make a point about Trevor), he has a rather unfitting end at the boot of one Mr Philips during the introduction of his character in GTA V. Until then though, Klebitz€™ run through GTA IV€™s world offered another look at the grimy locales within, focussing entirely on the sorts of hovels and hostels biker gangs would contend on a daily basis.

4. Michael De Santa (GTA V)

In a brilliant move for the franchise, GTA V saw the introduction of a character with a family to take care of, however this family are more than a little accustomed to the way the man of the house does business. Now their are a wealth of moral quandaries to be discussed through the implication that a career-criminal who has a penchant for passive-aggressive behaviour has raised two children, in the game his interaction with the aforementioned give way to some fantastic missions and €˜GTA Moments€™. One of the best being when Michael and Trevor pair up to pay a visit to the games version of a Pop-Idol/X-Factor-style show, only for the two to commandeer a large truck and run down the show€™s host, before making him dance trouserless for their amusement. That€™s not to mention Michael€™s introduction being a fantastic reveal (that he€™s already in the back of the car you€™re trying to steal), which then feeds into him having a showdown with a character you were waiting to be served a few knuckle-smoothies anyway.

3. Carl €˜CJ€™ Johnson (San Andreas)

San Andreas is my personal favourite of the first trilogy of releases, due to its incredible scope evident not only in the size of the gameworld, but also in the customisation options that let you deck CJ out in all manner of garb from tailored suits to bright purple hoodies and cowboy hats. Andreas would also be the last instalment where named actors would be used to embody the characters, as developer Rockstar decided the personalities associated with any given celebrity were taking away from the originality of their creations. CJ himself was voiced by rapper young Maylay however, and with the implementation of a two-button interactive system of responding to pedestrians and fellow crew members by way of insulting them or saying something more positive, it served to better immerse all of us in the experience. That€™s not to mention said rigorous customisation options that also allowed you to beef CJ up into a mini-Hulk, or pork him out into a small van-sized gangbanger, all the while having a constant spiel of context-specific dialogue complimenting his appearance.

2. Tommy Vercetti (Vice City)

Following the muted gesturings of GTA III€™s Claude, Rockstar stepped up their game with Vice City in every way possible. Through hiring more A-List talent to voice a plethora of incredibly memorable and hilarious side characters, Vercetti himself was voiced by none other than old leather-face himself, Ray Liotta. Liotta brought his career-defining mobster-flair to the character in a manner that still has many remembering Vice City in the most admirable way possible. Twinned with the sun-soaked vistas of the surrounding area, exploring the cityscape and missions within was an experience many tout as the best from the 6th generation of consoles. Taking over a Scarface-style mansion only added to the escapist thrills, and when you were forced into a gunfight across those iconic red-and-gold-carpetted stairs, with Liotta screaming expletives at his enemies, it was absolute mobster perfection.

1. Trevor Philips (GTA V)

The living embodiment of nihilistic insanity, Trevor is also the realisation of over a decade of player wish-fulfilment. Whilst I personally thought Trevor€™s increasingly disgusting antics caused much discomfort throughout my first playthrough of GTA V, the fact remains that he exists as a mirror through which the vast majority of players can see their own actions represented through the games€™ cutscenes. Have a problem with his opening scene being that of stomping the living daylights out of another main character on this list? Tough luck, as the scene exists to display the wanton life-wasting antics we ourselves have put upon any number of random pedestrians during our time with the franchise. Trevor€™s one-liners and off-the-wall mentality is almost reminiscent of Dark Knight€™s Joker, in that "he just does€things€, yet there€™s always some idea that some part of him knows exactly what they€™re doing, and exactly how to play the people around him. Trevor is the most divisive character Rockstar have ever created, and it€™s nearly all down to just throwing the rulebook out the window and portraying him in the manner that many players forced their previous protagonists to be. Love him or hate him, no character has had this much attention lavished upon them so far after their initial release.

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.