Halo 5: Guardians - 9 Shocking Changes That Will Divide Fans

How the hell do you make a Halo without split-screen multiplayer?!

Although it doesn't have the power to enslave the western hemisphere like its third instalment back in 2007 (seriously, Halo 3's launch completely overtook Time Square), 343 Industries second attempt at continuing where Bungie left off sees them making some huge leaps forward with Halo's core formula. And if there's one thing that riles gamers up and gets them shouting on forums and comment threads the world over - it's major changes to a trademark franchise. As such, although Halo 4 already told a far more intimate tale, focussing on the relationship between the Chief and Cortana - alongside MC's background as an indoctrinated child soldier, some bold new territory for a franchise otherwise focussed on blowing alien hordes to Kingdom Come - it's Guardians that sees 343 determined to shake up the gameplay just as much. The Halo of 2015 is a refined 60 frames-per-second, 1080p beast on Xbox One - a landmark creation that Microsoft are looking to shift consoles whilst also staying faithful to thousands of 90s gamers who've been consistently blown away since 2001. That said, there's no room for sitting on the fence with this one, Halo 5 sees the biggest shakeup to the core formula in the franchise's history - something that's produced 10 solid talking points it seems nobody can agree on...


9. No Big Team Battle

For many - including myself - the idea of shipping a Halo game without Big Team Battle is tantamount to morning cereal without milk. It's the go-to mode that does exactly what it says on the tin; a glorious explosion of vehicle-meets-firearm combat that just screams "HALO!" when viewed for any length of time. In BTB's place we've got Warzone, a risky experiment on 343's part that restricts the mode to only a handful of maps. Thing is, the goal here isn't to rack up the kills, it's to take over buildings and areas, Battlefield-style, all whilst fighting AI bots that are baying for blood from both sides. The awesome part comes with the fact that killing these AI guys can award you more points than a human, thankfully making it something more than just a next-gen version of Territories. That said, although 343 have mentioned they'll be patching BTB in at some point in the future - assumedly as a way to 'force' players to give the new mode a try first - Big Team Battle is a staple mode in the series, and should've made an appearance regardless.

8. Shields Don't Recharge When Sprinting

Halo's regenerating health changed everything when it came to designing first-person shooters - a fact you realise evermore if you ever revisit the original Halo, which featured a half-health, half-shield combo that needed depleting before you carked it. In Guardians, 343 are changing this up for the first time in 15 years, not only returning the visualisation of your health bar, but making it integral that you learn map layouts and hiding spots, as you'll only get your shield back if you can find a place to stay stationery for a few seconds. It'll completely change the flow of any match as we used to know it, potentially ushering in a mentality where it benefits players to stay in one spot, camping as they take many others out, safe in the knowledge their shields will restore faster than those trying to get away. On the other hand it directly effects the notion of sprinting from one place to another, knowing that by the time you get there, you'll be battle-ready. Needing to essentially take a knee and wait out the recharge is definitely more strategic, but is it conducive to a fun Halo experience?

7. Kill-Cams Are In (And Optional)

If you were to list all the things that are associated with Call of Duty, after "Angry twelve year-olds" you'd most likely land on 'Killcams' - the post-death feature that shows you exactly what your opponent was seeing before they took you out. Shear reputation surrounding COD over the years has simply made this feature a dirty word, alongside the fact that Halo fans aren't exactly rooting for game mechanics to become increasingly homogenised across both franchises. They easily serve to shake up any campers or those who kill from defined spots on the map - but you could totally argue that it's in tracking down enemies on your own, learning the maps and the tunnels within, that should separate who's even capable of delivering payback in the first place. In Guardians, Killcams are actually an optional toggle - the flip-side being to watch your team through third-person as it has been in the past. That just points out another talking point though - if you're going to do killcams at all, why not implement them properly for all players?

6. Cortana Not Being Dead

So much for almost the entirety of Halo 4's story, eh? On the one hand I'm totally glad Cortana is still involved in Guardians, albeit in a far reduced role from talking through every part of every mission - but on the other, it totally nullifies the close of Halo 4, which saw the Chief and Cortana part ways following the latter's increased degradation and AI rampancy. When it comes to bringing back beloved characters in any media, you're always going to fall into one of two camps; either you're stoked they've returned, because this isn't real life and why the hell can't they - or you're annoyed because now your previous outpour of emotion and the original 'death' itself feels cheaper in retrospect. Cortana being part of the story once again was leaked thanks to voice actor Jen Taylor mentioning she'd be involved in Halo 5, but you have to ask yourself; was it worth essentially making the events of Halo 4 pointless, in favour of having a staple member of the cast return once again?

5. No Split-Screen Multiplayer

It's still hard to believe - one of the most life-defining game experiences you can ever have, is no more. I'd wager every single person reading this either has very specific, fond memories of hurtling across the Silent Cartographer level from the first Halo with their buddy, or at least knows of how frantic and fun a game of Halo split-screen can be. Halo's multiplayer was the experience of choice for Xbox across the 2000s, and that came from not only ticking the box of online multiplayer, but also in taking your couch co-op buddies online too. Microsoft's Phil Spencer has mentioned the decision to scrap it comes directly through both performance for the base game of Halo 5, and the fact that statistics point to online playtime far outweighing that of split-screen. Because of this, Guardians is the first high-profile multiplayer-focussed experience to ditch the component that made multiplayer such a fantastic construct and experience in the first place - a sad indictment on where we're heading as an industry. If you were looking forward to sharing Guardians' campaign with anyone other than yourself, it's just tough luck.

4. Microtransactions & The REQ System

Most likely conceptualised when Titanfall was still tapped to be the 'big shooter' on next-generation hardware, Guardians also features a collectible card-based system that dictates what you'll be able to equip and/or use in the field. Now, the problem isn't a loot-based unlock system of cards that give random boosts and perks, it's that 343 have included optional microtransactions to acquire them, if you wish. Personally I don't subscribe to the whole "Well they're optional, so just don't get them and don't complain" shtick, as come on, we're already paying $60 for what used to be a full product. There's just no reason to have these things in the game when it's already clear we can grind and unlock them anyway - 343 have had to clear up as much in various interviews, falling back on saying they're just in there as optional paid extras for people who want to bypass the time-sink to acquire better gear along the way. That's all well and good, but you try not reacting to getting floored by a last minute rocket launcher-spawn by thinking "I bet they paid to win". It'll end up defining this entry in the series going forward, and if 343 insist on keeping it in, why not simply have custom games where we can choose to only play against those who've attained their cards through hard work and progression instead?

3. Smart Scope (Letting You Zoom In With Any Gun)

This was always going to be the big one; the inclusion of a very COD-like ability, first unveiled in the midst of The Master Chief Collection's terrible performance on Xbox One. Because of that - and because having the ability to aim down the sites for every gun forever changes Halo's patented gameplay into something that puts way more focus on headshots and playing like Call of Duty - fans have rebelled against its inclusion for over a year now. The thing that saves it - for those willing to give it a chance anyway - is that getting shot whilst in this mode instantly snaps you back out of it. Attempting to win a close-quarters firefight by aiming down the sights will just see you ventilated instead, and that's great. However, this puts the focus on increasing damage from ranged attacks, regardless of if you've got a pistol, assault rifle or whatever else. Clearly 343 saw how reliable the Battle Rifle has become for headshots and sought to rebalance by bringing every other weapon up to speed, but it remains to be seen how making ranged combat more effective will work when the entire world is looking to exploit it.

2. The New Ground Pound's Splash Damage

Here's a scenario that'll happen in pretty much every game you go into - you'll come around a corner, have an enemy come divebombing out the sky with a ground pound, lose your shield and die from another's stray bullet. Although this move can be stopped mid-flight by anyone who's a bit faster on the trigger, their substantial area of splash damage (and the accompanying loss of shield that means for anyone caught in the way) makes for entire platoons of players to get wiped out by just two of the opposition. One person can suicide-pound their way into the ranks, another will then mop everyone up or toss a grenade in. Simple. It'll surely make for more frantic and intense gameplay for a while, but as the beta already proved, some people will make it their mission to spam these sorts of attacks - and with no ground-based counter you can pull off, it'll wear thin very quickly. Throw in the fact that inevitably people will disconnect and unbalance teams mid-match, and spamming this sort of thing will be infuriating for anyone on the receiving end.

1. Choosing Frame Rate & Performance Over Actual Features

Did anyone on console actually demand we get higher frame rates and resolutions? The whole "Urgh, why's it at 30fps?!" has always been more of a PC-based argument. Console gaming is about the immediate experience, not counting frames or worrying about losing out on a particularly shiny ground texture. Going back to any of the past Halos (especially on 360) proves that we never needed liquid-butter frame rates for the perfect feel. Halo already had a solid engine when it came to handling huge amounts of explosions and frenetic firefights - there was simply no reason to double down on making an even smoother version of this, especially if that meant losing past features that fans are already demanding be returned. Whilst you can't deny that Halo 5 plays better overall thanks to these tweaks, its ability to remain one of the premiere first-person shooter experiences was never in question in the first place - especially from a purely technical standpoint. Being 343 have mentioned they'll be returning signature modes like King of the Hill, Oddball etc. soon enough, it only proves the new engine could've handled them anyway. Let us know where you fall on Halo 5, and if you'd like to get paid to write for the site, please sign up for an account!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.