Knack 2 Reviews: 11 Critical Reactions You Need To Know

Knack is back, and this time he's... good?!

Knack 2
Sony

Though the Internet has had a jolly good time making the mere existence of Knack 2 into a running joke, Sony just might end up having the last laugh now that reviewers have chimed in with their verdicts on the platforming sequel.

Knack 2 has settled at a solid 70-ish on Metacritic, a totally admirable score for a follow-up to a game that scored a disappointing 54 upon release back in late 2013.

No, Knack 2 isn't a masterpiece or anything approaching a great game, but it is an encouraging step forward which proves that designer Mark Cerny and his team have listened to the vocal complaints about what came before.

Though it's releasing in one of the busiest gaming periods of the year, not to mention the same week as Destiny 2, its competitive price point and more laid-back gameplay just might make it worth picking up at your earliest convenience...


11. It's An Easy Improvement Over The Original

Knack 2
Sony
"The sequel isn’t without problems, but it’s much improved, with a solid mix of gameplay elements, anchored by fun combat and good pacing." - IGN
"Allocated a decent development schedule for Knack 2, [director Mark Cerny's] avoided many of the problems that plagued Knack’s design. This time around, Knack gets to spend a lot of his time being the big guy." - Polygon
"Knack II is the follow-up to a mediocre PS4 launch game and is testament to the value of iteration. The new game...scrubs away most of its predecessor’s faults." - Kotaku

First things first, yes, Knack 2 is a rock solid improvement over the divisive original, which released in late 2013 as a rushed-out PS4 launch title and was deemed by most critics to be a thoroughly mediocre platformer.

The sequel isn't perfect by any means, but the consensus is that it fans away many of the original's nagging issues, achieving a greater balance of gameplay elements and minimising player frustration.

That it's settled at a respectable 70-ish on Metacritic is all the proof needed that Knack 2 has elevated the unexpected franchise to legitimate decency.


10. Gameplay Is Just Diverse Enough

Knack 2
Sony
"What a transformation this new game is. It’s full of combat, but Knack’s arsenal of moves is greatly expanded with a punch flurry move, an extendable-arm power shot and more. This time there’s a 34-node upgrade tree that weaponizes Knack’s dodge, speeds up most of his moves and adds some new ones. Knack II is also full of platforming, but now levels are built around the new ability to shrink Knack down to child size at any time and then grow him back to whatever his large size is at the moment with the tap of a button." - Kotaku
"Knack's old trick of growing in size over the course of a few corridors still holds, but there are moments that border on invention here, such as the ransacking of a lab that involves moving mirrors about to reprogram its lasers, or a sequence that sees you climbing a big robot to punch its head off from the inside." - Eurogamer
"Knack 2’s platform-puzzle formulas are an amalgam of decades of evolution in platform games. Yes, they are familiar, but their familiarity is also manifested in the variety of things to do. This game is a bit like those old compendiums of board games, like chess, checkers and dominoes. You know what you're getting, but it's still kind of neat to have them all in one package." - Polygon

Though Knack 2 doesn't reinvent the wheel or really bring much new to the genre at all, it does feel much more assured than the first game, introducing a greater diversity of abilities for Knack both in terms of combat and platforming.

From the addition of a skill tree to more complex use of Knack's ability to shrink and grow himself, the game includes an enjoyable variety of different gameplay systems to prevent boredom from setting in during its surprisingly meaty campaign.

Sure, it could've done more, but it's a laudable step-up all the same.


9. The Story Is Totally Forgettable

Knack 2
Sony
"The story is brand spanking new, but it’s just as un-engaging as the plot in the first game... Most of it plays out in cutscenes in which the dialogue is mainly perfunctory, containing none of the sparkle from Pixar films this game obviously wishes to ape. There are a couple of twists and turns, but they’re telegraphed pretty plainly. In short, the plot’s mainly a framework upon which to hang rather uninspired levels." - Gamesradar
"The story...[is] atrocious. No cliche is left alone; all are dragged into the sunlight, screaming for mercy. The dialog comes at me like a 1930s sci-fi short. Villains actually rock back their heads and declare that you are about to "meet your doom." If it's supposed to be ironic, it's not ironic enough, especially for a generation of kids saturated in irony... The whole story feels like it was written by a bunch of scientists who crammed "The Hero With a Thousand Faces" and binge-watched Spielberg movies." - Polygon
"The cast of largely uninteresting characters is wrapped into a story that would be at home in a second-rate Saturday morning kids cartoon. It’s a tale of High Goblins and city-devouring robots, ancient technologies and revenge plans… with some painfully awkward adolescent romantic tension tossed in for good measure. By the end the stakes are suitably high and you’ll become invested simply because, well, you’re ten hours in now, but it’s not good." - IGN

The plot was absolutely one of the worst and least-memorable things about the original game, and in this regard, it seems that Knack 2 is unfortunately consistent.

Granted, platformers as a genre typically aren't great when it comes to rustling up engaging narratives, but critics say it's especially clear that nobody really cared about fashioning a remotely intriguing one for Knack 2.

If you liked the first game enough to bother with this sequel, you're probably not in it for the story, but even so, given that this follow-up is improved in so many other areas, it's a shame that the plot is still a dreadful bore.


8. Co-Op Is Awesome

Knack 2
Sony
"Perhaps the most pleasant surprise in Knack 2 is just how much fun co-op is...Having two Knacks on-screen ups the chaos in combat significantly. There are some clever gameplay flourishes that are only available in co-op too, such as the ability to kick the other player into enemies, set off explosions by body slamming your co-op partner and literally punching relics off them like a machine gun." - IGN
"There's a neat co-op mode in which two players combine to deliver special moves, like creating explosions or launching one another at the enemy. I played this mode with one of my kids and we had a blast." - Polygon

The most alluring addition to Knack 2 for many is the inclusion of a co-op multiplayer mode, allowing parents and kids to play through the entire game together.

It's a great idea for a family-friendly adventure such as this, and by most accounts it's a welcome addition to the game that's actually smart and inventive on occasion.

Though it's disappointing that Knack 2 doesn't support online co-op for some mind-boggling reason in 2017, it's nevertheless great to see another title flying the banner for couch co-op in an era where it's fast disappearing.


7. Checkpointing Is Much More Generous This Time

Knack 2
Sony
"Checkpointing, a source of serious frustration in the first game, is much kinder in Knack 2." - Eurogamer
"The old-school hostility of the first game is replaced with the modern gaming comforts of regenerating health and frequent checkpoints, which feel appropriate to the cheerful scene the game is often trying to set." - Kotaku
"Checkpointing is generous, so if you miss a jump or get killed in combat, you’re generally only moments away from where you died. That’s definitely appreciated, and means you’ll rarely get frustrated. " - IGN

One of the most vocal complaints about the original Knack was the often infuriating checkpoint system, which would severely punish players for dying and often set them back many, many minutes at a time. This was especially odd considering that the game was aimed primarily at kids.

Thankfully, Mark Cerny and co. have clearly listened to this complaint above all others, with far more generous checkpointing throughout the campaign, ensuring that frustration is kept to a more agreeable minimum, and you won't need to repeat the same sequences numerous times over.

Artificial difficulty and padding are some of the worst things developers can insert into their games, so mercifully, it's largely gone in Knack 2.


6. The Camera Will Divide Players

Knack 2
Sony
"As I play, I have no control over the camera, which reels and pans according to the developer’s direction. I seem to have spent the last few years playing games with camera control, so this took me a bit of getting used to. On some occasions, the camera is placed weirdly, making platform moves frustrating. But on the whole, it seems to work." - Polygon
"While I found it mildly annoying to have a dash move rather than camera control on the right stick, the auto-camera at least frames the action fairly well. Moments in which you fall to your death because you couldn't see where you were meant to jump are rare; fights where your view is blocked by an awkward bit of scenery are non-existent. It holds up in the decent local co-op too." - Eurogamer

For all of the quality-of-life improvements Knack 2 makes, the camera is still going to be a sticking point for some players, specifically that the player has no control over it, something that's decidedly less-fashionable in games these days.

While many stated that the camera system mostly worked fine after a brief adjustment period, the consensus seems to be that camera control would still be preferable, as it does occasionally catch the player off-guard.

Something to consider for Knack 3, then?


5. Knack Is Still A Boring Character

Knack 2
Sony
"Knack's real issue for me is that he remains a weirdly charmless creation, and mere competence will not add that much to the basic proposition... Knack is spiky and angular and forgettable. I doubt that there is much in the way of a Knack cosplay community, and not just because it would be so uncomfortable to sit down in character." - Eurogamer
"The baby Knack is mute and cute. The big Knack is aggressive and humorless. His eyes constantly have the quality of a man in a TSA line, absolutely certain he's not going to have time to grab that latte on his way to the gate. It's not that I don't like Knack. He has moments of charm. But he's certainly not a classic character. He’s a bit of a dull fellow, really." - Polygon
"Given how much fun Knack is to control, it’s a real shame that outside of gameplay he’s one of the blandest characters in modern video games. He has almost no discernible personality...Where’s his sense of wonder? Or confusion? Or growing understanding about the world? The absence of any kind of meaningful dialogue, and thus on-screen relationship, with the main human protagonist Lucas is also baffling. Shouldn’t their dynamic be at the heart of the game? There was so much more Japan Studio could have done with this duo." - IGN
"The team also could have toyed with the idea of giving Knack some more emotion. His small, medium, and large formations kind of elicit the nuances of a child, teenager, and adult respectively, but most of that is fleetingly in spurts, and they never really go anywhere with it. I'm not expecting a touching Pixar-quality tale per se, just a little more of a reason to care about Knack." - Destructoid

Much like the story, the title character of this franchise has been a frequent point of derision, simply because he's got so little of the personality that has endeared so many other platforming mascots to millions of players.

Knack 2 doesn't do much to rectify the protagonist's lack of charm or interest, sadly, all the more unfortunate because if he'd shown a little more emotion, it sounds like he could've compensated at least a little for the dreadfully dull narrative.

Every AAA platforming franchise needs its charismatic, plucky, entertaining hero, and Knack is a pretty mild proposition in that regard.


4. The General Difficulty Is Fairer For Younger Players

Knack 2
Sony
"On normal difficulty there are a few minor challenge spikes, but it’s pitched about right for average gamers, and combat encounters mix and match enemies to force you to prioritise and use different tactics." - IGN
"Knack 2’s best idea is to offer four different levels of difficulty. Easy and normal will find favor with younger, less experienced players, who ought to be able to get through even the toughest battles without too much trouble. I found the middle sections of the game spiked slightly in difficulty, as Knack encountered tougher enemies before he has won better moves, but not to the point of frustration." - Polygon
"Mario veterans won’t find anything here too challenging. Besides, if players become stuck on a particular puzzle, the game helpfully provides a hint or two." - Gamesradar

The original Knack was a surprisingly difficult game, not merely because of the poor checkpoint system, but because of the unexpectedly intense and busy combat, which ultimately made it a tough sell for younger players, even on lower difficulties.

Thankfully Knack 2 has improved things across the board here, and in addition to fixing the sparseness of checkpoints, has toned the combat down somewhat to be a little more manageable.

Several reviewers have noted the occasional difficulty spike, but thanks to the intuitive checkpoints, there's nothing that measures up to the infuriation of the original game.

In short, kids won't be calling on their parents to help them out every 10 minutes.


3. Presentation Is A Mixed Bag

Knack 2
Sony
"Knack 2 is pretty uneven in terms of its presentation overall. There are moments of beauty, and the direction during the quick time events is appropriately stylish and energetic, but the worlds on display are merely adequate from a technical perspective, and your companions are disappointingly wooden, lacking in anything but the most basic of animations during missions." - IGN
"Although I didn't have any performance issues at all during my playtime, HDR and any Pro-specific FPS enhancement don't really help Knack II. There's a lot of really cool sequences to behold like Knack reforming bit by bit when he bodyslams, but there was a moment where I was in an arena battling humanoids that looked like they had been stripped from a mid-2000s Xbox game where I started to rethink my life and the choices that led up to that moment." - Destructoid
"Combat moves and platform sequences are all delivered, shining and smelling agreeably of grease. I found one gameplay bug, but other than that, Knack 2 is polished and highly competent." - Polygon

Critics were also rather divided on how Knack 2 looks, for while Knack himself is frequently impressive and the game's particle effects in particular are routinely gorgeous, the general look of the world and the game's enemies are rather bland for the most part.

It seems to be a game wrestling with what it wants to be: there are moments of genuine visual beauty during intense set-pieces that seem totally of-the-moment, but then much of the combat looks retro, and not in the cool way.

At least there were few reports of major bugs or glitches, suggesting that the game wasn't rushed to market or will be needing a colossal day-one patch.


2. There's A Surprising Amount Of Content

Knack 2
Sony
"The game will take players roughly 14 or so hours to complete and once that’s done New Game + mode is unlocked – which allows players to replay their game keeping all the upgrades they earned in their first play through – and the Time and Coliseum challenges open up too. A co-op mode rounds out the package." - Gamesradar
"It is fun though, and there’s a fair bit of content here. You’re looking at around 12 hours from start to finish to play through the story, which then unlocks New Game+, as well as a time attack mode that offers a host of bespoke challenges, and the ability to re-do any level to finish off sub-missions. I can definitely see the appeal of continuing on – I had a few more perks to unlock at the end of the story, and I was really enjoying having a full suite of combat abilities at my claw-tips." - IGN

The original Knack was a surprisingly long game in its own right, clocking in at around 8-10 hours, and the sequel one-ups it by running even longer.

Estimates for Knack 2's campaign stretch from 10-14 hours, an unexpectedly beefy length for a platformer, especially one being released at a lower price point.

In addition, the game includes a new game + and challenge modes, ensuring that this is one of the more content-rich platformers of late.


1. There's Still Plenty Of Room For Improvement

Knack 2
Sony
"It is not revolutionary and we’re not quite talking Game of the Year contender, but it is the evolution that its mediocre predecessor needed." - Kotaku
"Knack 2 is an entertaining platform game like those of yesteryear. It's been created with due care and attention. Sure, it’s old fashioned, and its story is appalling. But it’s a reminder that the character-led platform combat game is still alive and well. Despite its good looks, it’s more a work of engineering than it is a work of art. But, as my kid said to me after we'd mashed our way through a co-op level, it's kinda fun." - Polygon
"Knack 2 is definitely a step up from the original, then, but until the writing and characterisation improve drastically, it’s not going to be a true first party titan." - IGN
"While the action is repetitive and the overall structure isn’t all that innovative, there’s something rather comfortingly retro about Knack...Ultimately the game’s appeal boils down to one simple question: did you like the first Knack? If you did, then rejoice, because this is basically the same experience with a new plot and a few new features thrown in." - Gamesradar

Yes, Knack 2 is an easy improvement over the first game, but it also still leaves plenty of room for improvement, especially in terms of its story and actually making the most of the potentially awesome title character.

There is certainly potential for Knack 3, assuming it actually happens, to further build on this solid foundation, but most reviewers reiterated that if you at all enjoyed the first game, you will absolutely get something out of this effortlessly superior sequel.

Just don't go in expecting full-bodied platforming greatness on the level of a Mario or Crash Bandicoot and you'll be fine, but this series definitely has the potential to be much better. As ever, time will tell.

What do you make of the Knack 2 reviews? Convinced to play it for yourself or giving it a miss? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Knack
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.