Madden 13 Demo: 3 Positives & 3 Negatives
It's that time of year again - we look ahead to what EA Sports are offering with this month's Madden release.
It's that time of year where I start looking forward to demos. Demos: for all the claims by developers that what we are being allowed to play is a work in progress and what we see does not represent the final product, it would be pretty foolish of them to release something so far from finished that it actually acts as a deterrent. The luxury Madden demos have over something like the yearly disappointment of Pro Evo however (Heads up not this year) is that it's the only NFL game on the market, and they could probably just put their feet up and merely give Madden 12 a roster upgrade. But that assumption would be wrong: Madden 12 got progressively worse to the point where the game was openly laughing at you and your family. But thankfully the laughter's stopped long enough for this new incarnation to be... different. Pros
1. The Passing Game Madden 12 suffered greatly from the performance enhancing bugs commonly found in linebackers and corners. Thankfully it seems wide-receivers are now more keen to attack the ball and corner-backs aren't capable of catches beyond the ability of both players and humans in general. Click next to reveal more observations from the demo...
2. The Commentary Immeasurably better. Science has no measurement for comparing something that sounds ok (in Madden 13), to something that actively made you dumber (in Madden 12). Seriously, it's pointless even mentioning it in a demo review as it simply sounds like commentary, which is a big improvement from Gus Johnson forgetting someone's name from a toilet cubicle (that's not a metaphor). 3. The Running Game Intriguing changes have made it seem easier. The fluidity of the game seems better but a bi-product of this is a lack of weight, especially in the tackles. The running game has benefited as a result and there never seems to be a concern about not making the yardage. But is this a positive? I'm not quite sure, but it's definitely something to watch. Click next to reveal the other side of the coin, as we run through the negatives of the demo... Cons1. Gravity
Mentioned as a positive in the running game, the fluid motion that is possibly caused by the new Infinity Engine for more realistic player collisions gives a feeling of weightlessness, and arguably, an arcade-like feel, which might not be classed as a positive from all quarters. Those who prefer a realistic in-game experience might see it as a compromise too far, but then the effect on gameplay might well over-balance that for others. As I said before, it's definitely one to watch. 2. Lighting Ever wondered what Varsity Blues would be like if it was a hard-hitting detective show from the 1950s? Well, simply turn on Madden 13, turn your TV to black and white and enjoy. The shadows here are ridiculous: on the one side it's like a carnival, whilst the other is like a carnival of the undead as silhouettes of past players hunt you down. EA Sports seem to have picked winter-sun mode, just at that moment before it implodes ending life on earth forever.
3. Presentation
It's been building for years but it's finally hit me: coupled with other sports titles I am done with sports games attempting to be future-proof with scant regard for actually finding where to go to play the game. I appreciate it replicates similar effects from NFL broadcasts, I just wish they'd tried to replicate the work of NFL films. Although this might be a personal issue I have with sports broadcasting in general as Madden isn't even the worst culprit, there's a lot to be said for a more reserved approach that lets the action speak for itself. Overall, I'm more intrigued than anything. Madden 13 certainly feels slightly different to the previous addition to the franchise which I grew to loathe. The issue for me is that I was excited about Madden 12 when I first started playing it so we have to ask at this stage whether the changes made here are enough to remains as positives, or if they too will become major issues as I begin to learn the game and its various intricacies? Find out in WhatCulture's full review at the end of the month.
Madden 13 is released in the US on 28th August, and in the UK on the 31st.