Madden 16 Review: 10 Hands-On First Impressions

The greatest game on turf?

Madden 16 is here. After months of anticipation, EA Sports have dropped their latest edition on the public, and just a few games in, it's clear to see that they've gone all out this year to come up with a tremendous game, but have they succeeded? The American Football simulator has had a sketchy history, with some installments sparkling while others failed to deliver, but Madden 16 certainly feels like a success with a range of new features and an array of fairly major gameplay tweaks. They add realism and excitement to the game, and at the end of the day, those are the two crucial aspects Madden needs to deliver on. The NFL season's sprawling off-season can be tedious, but now it's great to sink our teeth into a new bit of gridiron action, here are our 10 first impressions of the new game.

10. Storylines Have MASSIVE Potential

Before you've even reached a menu page you're thrust into the future. Super Bowl 50 sees the Pittsburgh Steelers squaring off against the Arizona Cardinals at Levi's Stadium, and you watch the game unfold in awe. Players are chatting away to each other, coaches are firing their men up on the sidelines, and Big Ben Roethlisberger is on the comeback trail. You're dropped into some fairly simple situations where the game holds your hand through some big plays to demonstrate its capabilities. It's a gentle start in terms of difficulty, but watching the players' cut scenes in between the several plays you make is outstanding. It makes you feel like your in control of an actual NFL game. This matters, these aren't just globs of pixels you're controlling. It's a fantastic example of how the game is drawing storylines into gameplay and how incredible that blending could be.

9. Modern Music, Modern Menu

So, you've won the Super Bowl. Not a bad start, then you get to the menu. Odell Beckham Jr's standing there in front of you jumping, spinning, flipping, and just generally being Odell Beckham Jr. You click through to find a clean, simple menu. The box style remains, but there are fewer than before. After the seven you see above, there's just one large box for customisations. It's not at all overwhelming and keeps a complex game relatively simple. You'll also notice the lack of intense, booming, orchestral music. That's cool to begin with on other Madden games, but after a while it drills into your skull. Now Madden has seen the return of licensed music and it's a very welcome addition whether you're a fan of the tracks or not, at least they're different.

8. Graphics Are Improved

You march right on into a game with your favourite team and straight away you're met by slick, fluid graphics showing off stats, player comparisons and a greyed out metallic stadium which bursts into life with colour as you enter the game. From a distance the stadium looks incredible, and the attention to detail when it comes to the interior is second-to-none. Unfortunately, the crowd is still lagging behind that of another top EA Sports game FIFA, but if you can overlook the robotic arm flailing, you'll see that the players look utterly stunning. The face scans look incredible even through visors and helmets beautifully and accurately reflect the stadium surroundings depending on the light. Players have a presence, jerseys have a texture and your team looks like a team.

7. Stats Are Useful

Football is an uber-technical game, so the more stats there are available to you, the better. You can see the strength of each matchup from an indicator at the bottom of the screen, with easy access to compare your player's stats to his opponents in search of an advantage. See if you can out-pace, out-jump or out-think him. Then when it comes to selecting a play you've got a whole host of team-specific probability stats to unpick the opposition gameplan. Get percentage chances of success based on previous plays, recommended routes to run, and a more detailed look at each option rather than just a scattergun approach.

6. Penalties Happen

For maximum realism, players need to feel like living breathing human beings. They need to feel like aggressive rampaging bulls in their armour, and when players get feisty, penalties happen in Madden 16. Holding, interference, the game has it and the referees will call you up on it. So far it's a realistic balance, with controls to prevent every play ending in flags being launched onto the field. Players have a trait which mirrors their real-life tendency to give away needless penalties, so over-zealous warriors in the real world will be similar in-game. This is an excellent way to inject a little more personality into the pixels.

5. Air Supremacy Is Excellent

This is the big one, Air Supremacy. The key area EA have worked on is the passing game and that's highly exciting, after all, there's nothing quite like hurling a ball downfield into the end zone where your receiver battles through to snatch it for a touchdown. You can choose to catch the ball in three different styles: aggressive, run after catch, or possession. They depend on the throw and your willingness to risk, with possession securing the ball, aggressive sending your player high to haul down the ball, and run after catch doing exactly that. They all have their benefits and disadvantages, and all of them work as advertised. It's possible that the aggressive style may be abused, but EA have done their best to combat that with the next feature...

4.Pass/Run Defence Improved

When you're boosting up the passing game, it's easy to be concerned that Madden would be broken, every game would finish 67-74, and defenders may as well go and sit down on their benches. Wrong. While there aren't sop many specific changes to the defence, EA have certainly made them tougher to overcome. Players stick with their man, and feel like muscle-laden presences rather than flimsy formalities that you can easily walk past. Also on previous editions, the running game has been too easy. It sucks the fun out of the game knowing you want to pass the ball and that it's the right option, but it'd be easy enough to run the ball that far. Now that isn't the case. Run stoppers can make big plays and pass defenders are given a decent chance if their positioning is correct.

3. AI Slightly Slow To React?

This is just a small issue but during the first game on Madden - a Deflategate rematch between the Patriots and the Colts - my defence were doing a decent job of holding back Brady's forces. On one particular play, I simply couldn't break down their O-line, yet Brady remained deathly still despite an ominous, growing hole to the left side with receivers flashing around the field. He eventually threw an incomplete pass. Brady isn't the finest runner, but he didn't even move an inch left or right. Then later in the game, he did trot to his right before hurling the ball far out of bounds when he still had options. They were just two 'iffy' moments from the opening game and didn't compromise the enjoyment of playing, but it did leave me wondering whether than AI (on Pro level) may be a fraction too slow to react.

2. Draft Champions

A new game mode is always a welcome addition to a new Madden game and Draft Champions feels like an excellent new way to enjoy the game. You start by selecting a coach according to your style, then flicking through rounds of players to create your temporary team. Do you stock up the receiving weapons or reinforce the defensive line? These decisions will be commonplace. It all combines to create a great Fantasy experience, though the difference is that you can obviously use these players in your very own team. It's reasonably quick to figure out and get playing, with the mode lasting the length of a knockout tournament. Some great times could be had delving into Draft Champions.

1. Playmakers Are Key

With Odell Beckham Jr. on the cover and a host of passing game improvements on board, it all makes sense that playmakers are more important than ever. Risk-and-reward is a key theme throughout the game, and having players capable of pulling out huge plays on both sides of the ball is important. Beckham has been handed a monster 94 Overall rating with a 99 Spectacular Catch stat meaning he's tremendously fun to play around with, while the elite cornerbacks around the league are challenging yet rewarding if you can master them. Madden 16 feels like an excellent game so far, and while minor problems may arise over the coming months as everyone gets into the flow, the early report is that Madden 16 is one of the finest editions in the series.

Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.