Madden 21: 10 Ways EA Can Improve Franchise Mode
With a mix of old and new features, this fan-favorite mode can rule again.
After Madden 21 was officially announced in May, #FixMaddenFranchise has been trending a lot lately on Twitter. Franchise Mode has become Madden's forgotten feature due to the focus on MUT. Veterans of the video game are frustrated with what was once a fan-favorite mode. EA needs to seriously revitalize and turn it into the single-player gem Madden fans deserve.
Many of us have fond memories of picking our player's parents in 2006's Superstar mode, running an expansion team in 2002, the first time we stepped up as owners in 2004, or the amazing presentation of NFL 2K5. Is it too much to ask for a rich, immersive experience? What is the point of even including the mode if you're not going to make it fun?
EA need only look to the past to fix franchise mode, but some fresh ideas couldn't hurt. Let's look at 10 ways they can totally make Franchise Mode a fun experience again. As the game will be released on August 28th (or 25th if you buy MVP edition), it's too late to seriously expect any major changes... but here's hoping!
10. League History
One of the cooler (and under utilized) features from recent Madden games is the "Legacy" scoring. When playing "Face of the Franchise", its fun to progress through a career and see how your player stacks up to his peers. Trying to qualify for the Hall of Fame gives us motivation to play through an entire career.
However, league history is mostly thrown away as your progress though seasons. While a player such as Aaron Rodgers could be observed moving up in the record books, once he's retired we only see maybe a "tweet" from the in-game analysts about how he had a HOF career. We don't have any ability to see his stats afterwards, no listing of his Superbowl win, and we won't even be able to see what team he moved to after Jordan Love took over in Green Bay.
While we don't need to be able to pull up the full 1979 Houston Oilers' roster and game logs, it would be nice to be able to have some historical references. Bring back the "team" column in a player's profile so we know where all they played. Give us the list of HOF players (and coaches). Let us see what the league standings have been, award winners, and who played in the Superbowl over the years.
9. Bill Belichick
"What? How can one coach make that much difference in the quality of my video game experience?"
It matters that the greatest NFL coach of all time is no longer in the Madden franchise. Due to Belichick not being part of the NFL Coaches Association, EA doesn't have the rights to use his likeness. This also was the case for Sean Payton out of New Orleans for a while.
Imagine playing Super Mario and instead of facing Bowser at the end, you have to defeat "Lizard Boss". (Or, I guess if you're a Patriot fan, you're playing as "NE Plumber").
Fans of '90s NBA games remember the frustration of not being able to play with or against Michael Jordan, and this is the same feeling we get now when the Patriots fire Chad Masters or Josh Moore after the first season because they aren't actually the GOAT.
8. Emphasis On Coaches
Players are not the only people who can be a "face of the franchise". I mean, the game is literally NAMED after a coach. Jon Gruden is far more of a presence for the Raiders than say Derek Carr or Josh Jacobs. Coaches matter, especially when playing a long career mode.
We used to have the ability to hire offensive, defensive, and special teams coordinators. That needs to be brought back and then some. There needs to be more realism brought to contracts, negotiating, and even an ability to trade coaches should be an option.
Let's go beyond just coordinators. Imagine being able to bring in a young DB coach with a high potential rating. He then speeds up your current secondary's growth and gets added coaching traits such as motivation, intellect, and development in which you can promote him to coordinator. Later, you'll make the tough decision to either make him head coach, firing your HOF bound incumbent, or you let the young hotshot get poached by a rival team.
7. Create-a-play
If we're placing greater emphasis on coaching, then we definitely want to bring back an old Madden staple: Create-a-Play!
We should be able to set-up entire playbooks, edit current plays, and create our own from scratch. Maybe I want to run a 4-4 defense where my entire front 8 pulls back into coverage while my secondary blitzes... probably won't be successful, but at least I got to experiment.
Ridiculousness aside, custom plays could prove useful in Franchise Mode if say your team's playbook was entirely built around a statuesque QB who never scrambled, you added Taysom Hill in free agency, but you don't have any plays to utilize his skill set. Now you can try to one-up Sean Payton in creating an awesome 2-QB-reverse-hook-and-ladder that could... go... all... the... way!
6. Revamped Scouting
If we're going to add position coaches, there's no reason why we can't hire scouts who actually do something. A much more in-depth scouting department would be amazing.
Similar to how we can send out regional scouts in FIFA, imagine being able to direct a scout to observe offensive linemen in the midwest and another to scout receivers in the south. Your scouting department will give you updates on what school they chose, how they're progressing in their college careers (indications if they will declare early), and ultimately give you enough detail to make the decision on drafting them.
Basically, we should be able to track Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields as high school phenoms out of Georgia. Then get updates on how Lawrence took over as starting QB at Clemson while Fields transferred to Ohio State and now both of them will be Heisman hopefuls. We'll then have better indications on which of them we should be considering with our #1 draft pick.
5. Combine & Offseason Workouts
Go back to Madden '08 and see how fun it was to play those mini-games.
When playing franchise mode as a player, we should be able to participate in the combine leading up to the draft. And as coach/GM, we should be able to observe the combine and pro-day workouts. These mini-games shouldn't stop at the draft as we should have an opportunity to workout veterans and undrafted free agents to decide if we should add them to our rosters.
Performing well in the mini-games wouldn't necessarily alter the player's abilities. Depending on how well we did, it would unlock stats in the scouting windows. It would also add realism for our created player when we need to prove ourselves to a team as an older veteran in free agency.
4. Better GM Tools
The Madden games seem to always tweak their approach to contracts and free agency. But, they still never seem to get it right. We're blocked from adding any mid-season free agents to anything other than a one-year deal. Negotiations seem to always end with paying exactly what the player asked for or they walk. Off season free agency feels more like a silent auction.
We should be able to have more organic "conversations" with players/agents when talking about their contracts. Even installing a "relationship" metric like the NBA 2K franchise mode would add to our experience as NFL GMs. We should be able to build our reputation through the league in conversations with our owner, other GMs, coaches, etc.
Restricted free agents, hold-outs, extensions, and basically any conversations we would have between GM and player should be revamped with the relationship/conversation system.
3. Upgrade Trading Mechanic
Another thing 2K definitely has figured out over EA is how to pull off trades. In some versions of Madden, you can game the whole league into eventually giving you the #1 draft pick every year. Other years, no other team would even give you the time of day for trades involving draft picks. If I want to give you everything I have for the 5th overall pick... then no way should the AI turn that down.
Putting a player on the trade block virtually means nothing in most versions of Madden, and forget mid-season offers.
Added to the GM relationship mechanic from earlier, trades should be included with this upgrade. Other GMs should be more or less willing to accept lopsided trades based on their rating/relationship stats. Trade talks should be more organic and come more often. Players should be able to request trades to specific teams which we could pursue or deny
2. Better User Interface
The menu screens in Madden have always been frustrating, and they've only gotten worse in recent years. Players find themselves constantly bouncing between screens and menus in an attempt to adjust their rosters and keep everything organized. Sometimes it feels like we need to sit with a second screen open with an excel sheet of our rosters.
Whether we're drafting, trading, signing, or scouting... we need to be able to better access our team information. We don't need a third of the screen taken up by a view of our coach/player messing around on their cellphone.
1. Upgrade Relocation & Create-a-Team
How is it that in 2002 we could create any team we wanted and have them play in any city we wanted? Now, our creative freedom is limited to a handful of cities of which we are restricted even more on choice of team name and logos. Unacceptable. Having a "fan popularity" metric is fine, but it shouldn't limit our creativity and options.
Again, NBA 2K is miles ahead of Madden when it comes to creating teams, relocating, and adding expansion teams in franchise mode. Especially on the next-gen consoles, we should have a deep set of tools that allow us to pick the best uniform, perfect color combinations, full stadium customization, etc.
And for future reference, whenever a team is about to change stadiums in real life... incorporate it into the game! One of the biggest disappointments of Madden '20 was playing past the first year and the Chargers, Rams, and Raiders didn't move.