Madden 21 Wishlist: 10 Things We Want To See

The next generation of Madden is here. Maybe.

Madden 20

First, an experiment.

Boot up last year's Madden 20, put every option and gameplay slider to its default setting and then play four quarters of EA's out-the-box experience. Unless you enjoy playing on 'Arcade' and don't mind impossibly big throws and catches, it can be a frustrating, unrealistic adventure.

Playing on 'Simulation' with some handy slider guides is very much the way to go for that authentic, real NFL experience, but wouldn't it be nice if EA's own system was rebuilt to feed a little more realism? That's a core complaint in this wishlist of things the next Madden game must have when it launches in the summer.

Don't listen to the haters though. Madden 20 isn't bad, and not every gamer wants a hyper-realistic game of football anyway. Some just want to toss in the disc, have some fun with friends and pop off big plays on every few snaps. It's finding a balance between those over-the-top and sim elements that EA needs to focus on perfecting.

Here's everything the developers must do so series veterans don't begrudge forking over serious cash on yet another rinse and repeat Madden game...


10. MUT That Isn't Intrusive

Madden 20 Ultimate Team
EA Sports

Hey, do you want to spend some extra cash? Hi, did you know that you can play Madden Ultimate Team? Dude, why not try out MUT instead of playing Franchise? Ultimate Team, Ultimate Team, f*cking ULTIMATE TEAM.

That's EA's approach to MUT in Madden 20.

Intrusive pop ups reminding players they could be playing the cash cow feature are everywhere on the game's menu screens. It's annoying to pay for a full-price release and then get constantly poked into paying more for the same product. Although Microtransactions have a place in modern gaming, they shouldn't be shoved down people's throats every two minutes.

Those MUT popups need to disappear in Madden 21. It's fine for EA to promote it once when players first boot up the game, but being battered over the head with persistent, pesky advertisements is just grating. If someone hasn't opened Ultimate Team after owning the game for three months, then they're unlikely to give it a go.


9. Alternate Commentary Teams

Brandon Gaudin Charles Davis
EA Sports

The main complaint in that previous entry was tied to repetition, and the same nagging gripes exist elsewhere in the Madden universe.

As good as Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis are (the pair sound lively, knowledgeable and like they're having a real conversation 99% of the time), they're also tired after being Madden's go-to commentary squad for years. Over in the other football game, FIFA, EA rectified this by adding alt voices for different competitions.

There's an idea for Madden 21 to try. Gaudin and Davis could handle regular season games in Franchise, and then another duo like Joe Buck and Troy Aikman, Al Michaels and Cris Collinsworth or Joe Tessitore and Booger McFarland could take over for Playoff and Super Bowl showdowns. Or, just give the entire thing to Tony Romo.

Whomever EA choose, it's true that Madden needs fresh voices. There are only so many times the same jokes at 4th and 1 plays can be recycled before gamers start to wish they'd muted commentary completely.


8. Player Faces At Launch

Madden 20 Daniel Jones
EA Sports

Surely EA know that drip-feeding out real player faces after launch is incredibly lazy. It's unacceptably poor for such a big production; when players buy what is effectively NFL: The Video Game, they expect the sport's biggest stars to look like their on-field counterparts from TV.

What they don't expect is to see a bunch of waxy-looking cosplayers staring back at them.

This is less forgivable for main position guys like QBs, WRs and other stars of the game. Also, would it be too much to ask that EA do a better job of using the creation suite on guys they haven't had the time to face scan before release? Honestly, it's like someone who'd never watched one snap made half these guys.

Madden is a multi-million dollar product every summer, and it deserves to be soaked in attention to detail, quality across the board and authentic, true-to-life experiences. Immersion is hard when Giants' Daniel Jones looks like he should be passing out Gatorade on the bench.


7. A Better Offseason Experience

Madden 20 Ezekiel Elliott
EA Sports

Launch head first into Franchise mode in Madden 20 and you'll find a better suite overall than in 19. It's not perfect (the community continues to strive for that), but little touches like scenarios and improved contractual negotiations improve the feature.

There's way more they could with it.

Take the offseason, for example. In between campaigns, there's precious little to do other than drift aimlessly through Draft menus and press that skip button. This is a missed opportunity when real-life NFL coaches work tirelessly to get things ready for September's kickoff. EA would be doing themselves a favour by adding some randomised storylines here.

Retirements you don't want, in-team conflicts, contractual holdouts (like the one Dallas chewed their fingernails over with Ezekiel Elliott last year) and more would enhance down periods between seasons. Then, there are training camps, free agency battles and more to add greater immersion to Madden 21's ugly duckling of a single-player favourite.


6. Team Records That Matter

Madden 20
EA Sports

Every NFL fan knows that there's way more lore to pro football than who won the Super Bowl.

Stats matter more than in most other sports, and they're keenly tracked by some of the best analysts in the world. Look at the hubbub Ravens' QB Lamar Jackson created during the 2019 season by breaking Michael Vick's single-season rushing record against the Jets in week 15. That kind of excitement is a Madden 21 must.

Being alerted if you smash specific and historic team records would be nice. Imagine how much more those final few weeks of the season would mean (whether your team has made the Playoffs or not) if there were records on the line? One more pass competition would break the record for most in a row. Get on it.

Team records need to matter a bit more than they currently do in Madden. It's all fantasy, obviously, but that doesn't mean that some hardcores out there wouldn't get a kick out of personally shattering Jackson's new QB rushing record across 16 regular season games in 2020.


5. Better Blocking

Madden 20
EA Sports

Playing defence in Madden 20 is pot luck. One minute, DTs are laser-guided missiles that cling to an opposition's O-Line, shimmy around them and charge in for a QB sack. The next, they're floundering around like fish on land, turning randomly without reason and acting like they're on drugs.

It's inconsistent, it's jerky and it sucks.

Blocking needs an overhaul in Madden 21. The same goes for pass rushing. This gamer has lost count of the number of frustrated, angry rants he's had at the TV because his carefully constructed defensive set up let an easy short pass expose crappy coverage. Players just don't move like real human beings, or respond to others around them.

All it takes is one CPU-controlled idiot spinning in a circle and that playbook pick is ruined. Of course, when it comes to how players react on the Madden field, there's a bigger, more worrying problem that EA need to address...


4. Less Clipping

Madden 20 Clipping
EA Sports

...clippity-clop, clippity-clop.

Examine the screenshot (from Madden 20) above. In it, two Indianapolis players are attempting to block the same New England man. Seems fine, huh? Double blocking isn't exactly uncommon in the NFL. Then, look at their legs, specifically at the knee. One man's leg is passing through the other's rear end.

It's a mess of pixels, and it's clear that Madden's digitised NFL stars don't have any concept of spatial awareness. Players clip through one another constantly, especially on the defensive side of the ball, and that needs sorted before it becomes a major, game-breaking problem. It's like their legs aren't really there.

The problem stems from something EA call "Real Player Motion". They introduced this as a marquee feature a few years ago, and it's done nothing but cause bugs and glitches ever since. It exposes the fact that 7/10s of a player's physical make up is less-than-solid, and forces them to react unrealistically to contact.


3. Animation Cycles That Don't Interfere

Madden 20 Clipping
EA Sports

"Real Player Motion" relies on a string of animation cycles that are hardwired into each player's AI. Another problem with this is that gravity also exists in the Madden universe (imagine that), and it doesn't sit well with EA's cycle requirements.

Here's an example.

Say you're planning a QB sneak on a 4th and 1 near midfield. You might press the correct inputs for a player dive to ensure the QB leaps over that line to make and secures a 1st Down. If a defensive foe happens to have instigated a sack animation at almost exactly the same time though, then there's a fair chance your player will suddenly stop diving, land back on his feet and take the hit instead.

Those defensive animation cycles seem to overrule everything else before them. That's hardly realistic; in real football, the QB wouldn't magically appear vertical again when he was already horizontal and his legs had been kicked back for a dive.

EA need to fine tune these cycles so they're not so rigid.


2. Create-A-Team

Madden 12 Create A Team
EA Sports

In Madden 20's Franchise mode, players can choose to relocate their team to another city and choose from a number of pre-designed replacements in San Diego, London and other places. Whilst this is a ton of fun and can shake up the mode season-to-season, it's also a poor substitute for a fully-fledged Create-A-Team engine.

That screenshot up there? It's from Madden 12.

Yes, it was possible to create your own teams from scratch in EA's series nine years ago when that game launched in 2011, but apparently not now. It's not much to ask that the developers put this suite back in and let fans from areas that, y'know, don't have NFL teams live out their franchise dreams.

Maximum Football 2019 has a creation feature, so why not Madden? EA are being shown up by a shoestring budget release when they're a AAA blockbuster and should know by now that customisation is everything to some gamers.


1. A Real Next-Gen Experience

Ps5 Concept Creator
LetsGoDigital

If Madden's recent release cycle is anything to go by, then the next game will drop somewhere in the first three weeks of August 2020. Meanwhile, Sony has already confirmed that their new PS5 console will release during the holiday period slightly later in the year (October-December).

Hmm.

This could be troublesome for Madden 21's development. EA will either release an untouched 'Legacy' edition of the game on current-gen hardware and save a souped-up version for the newer systems like PS5 and Microsoft's next Xbox or co-develop two completely new iterations of the game.

Either way, they must deliver a next-gen Madden worth savouring. It's a nightmare to think that those who patiently wait for the first one on PS5 won't get a game worth waiting months for. Madden 21 on newer hardware must blow everyone away, otherwise it could set the series back for years like FIFA 20 threatened to with that lofty franchise.

What else do you want to see in Madden 21? For more, check out Madden 20: 8 Tips To Play Like A Boss and 10 Wrestling Matches That Led To Massive Lawsuits!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.