Madden NFL 21 Review: 4 Ups & 8 Downs

A year to forget. A lack of polish to remember...

Madden 21
EA Sports

It's not good.

A quick glance at the disparity between 'Ups' and 'Downs' in this article's title reveals that Madden 21 isn't a revolutionary entry into the long-running series. The game is another of those cursed annual updates, but it doesn't even have the decency to boast a banner gameplay feature like last year's title did (Superstar X-Factors).

It's always depressing when you want to like something so bad but know you're being taken for a ride. Honestly owning up to that is troubling for gamers who just want to be entertained. The fact is though - EA are happy to take everyone's money, laugh all the way to the bank and offer the opportunity to spend even more money as some sort of sick "reward".

That's Madden 21 in a nutshell, and yet...what's that coming over the hill? Is it...yes! It's a positive or two (or four). Perhaps the most annoying thing about this year's NFL sim is that it does do some things well and offer some fun, but it's all let down by a stunning lack of innovation or progress.

There's always next year, eh?


Downs...

8. Intrusive MUT Ads Kill The Experience

Madden 21
EA Sports

Fire up Madden 21 and you'll be asked the same question repeatedly: DO YOU WANT TO PLAY ULTIMATE TEAM?

Boot up the disc, ULTIMATE TEAM. Go to the main menu, ULTIMATE TEAM. Hover over Franchise Mode, ULTIMATE TEAM. Go to phone your mother and ask if she wants to meet up for a coffee, ULTIMATE TEAM. ULTIMATE TEAM, ULTIMATE TEAM, ULTIMATE TEAM!

Those bold inserts are likely getting a bit grating by now, but that's deliberate. It's what playing Madden 21 is like; EA don't hide the fact that they want you to play MUT and nothing else, if only so you plump more cash into that game you've just bought and rely on microtransactions to fast-track your way to NFL success.

These ads are constant - they're bloody everywhere! The most irritating thing is that you can't switch them off either. Madden 21 will encourage you to play Ultimate Team every single time you start, and they'll bombard you with new deals incessantly.


7. Presentation Is Seriously Old Hat

Madden 21
EA Sports

NFL broadcasts are routinely slick pieces of business that throw endless overlays, up-to-the-minute stats and enough product placement to make one sick. Somehow, that's all part of the charm, and it's something Madden 21 completely skips.

Their presentation is seriously outdated in 2020.

Commentary regurgitates the same lines fans have been hearing for years (with only a few updates here and there that soon become as tiresome as everything else), players and coaches don't react realistically on the sidelines and the pre-match intros are lifeless and dull.

There's a total lack of half-time banter too, which is a missed opportunity to inject some real-world sports elements. This is particularly weird in Franchise Mode when you should care about what's happening at other stadiums.


6. The Story Mode Lacks Depth Or Meaning

Madden 21
EA Sports

Last year, your reviewer (who desperately hoped EA were onto something) said that the QB1 had potential to be great if the developers chucked in some NBA 2K-style freedom. They didn't. This year's 'Face Of The Franchise: Rise To Fame' chapter is very much more of the same.

It's still an on-rails journey.

Some probably won't mind that they're on a strict path, but even the most happy-go-lucky gamers will be scratching their heads once they realise that nothing you do on-field actually matters. Seriously. You can tank every snap you're involved in and still end up getting high fives from your coach because of things that happened during cut scenes.

The animation of some scenes is also amazingly poor, and a handful don't even have voice acting. It's absurd to think that Rich Eisen, of all people, would have sod all to say when the camera was on, but that's the case in Madden 21.


5. The High School Selling Point Is Fumbled

Madden 21
EA Sports

Pre-release, EA made a ton of noise about the addition of high school football in that aforementioned 'Face Of The Franchise' story mode. The good news is that it's fun while it lasts. The bad news is that, again, nothing you do during games has any impact on the nailed-on narrative, and you can't play high school ball outside of the mode.

Blink and you'll miss it, basically.

High school gameplay may as well have been a cut scene, because it feels incredibly hollow to offer up something new and then leave the player on their own to figure out that he/she is unable to affect the story being presented whatsoever.

There's nothing more to say here. The high school snippet is exactly that, and it's another of Madden 21's missed opportunities when it comes to providing cool experiences.


4. Obvious Next-Gen Focus

Madden 21
EA Sports

One can only hope that EA has a dedicated team beavering away to ensure that next-gen Madden is worthwhile. The power of machines like Sony's PS5 and Microsoft's Xbox Series X should, in theory, lead to the most lifelike NFL experience fans have ever seen.

That doesn't help current-gen players.

They're the one who shelled out more cash on Madden 21 and found out first hand that EA's focus is firmly on things to come. Of course, the much-touted dual entitlement offer does soften this blow (those who purchased Madden 21 on PS4 or Xbox One will get a free update should they buy new hardware), so that's something.

A fair number of critics on social media saw this coming too. They predicted something akin to a 'Legacy' edition of Madden on current hardware this year, and that's sort of what the game feels like. Changing the colour palettes on menus isn't enough.


3. It's Buggy As Hell

Madden 20 Clipping
EA Sports

Clipping is still a problem in Madden 21 despite pre-release claims that it'd be eradicated.

Players often run right through one another, or become some nightmarish collection of twisted limbs as they fight for the ball. That's not the only bug encountered either - frame rate drops are frequent enough to be an issue, especially when they lead to controller-shattering missed field goals.

Elsewhere, there are instances of players running around in circles without reason, others being totally out of position pre-snap and more. This will likely get patched out in a few weeks, but that's not the point. People want a polished/finished product on release day, not later.

Yours truly didn't personally experience as many glitches in Madden 20 as others. That's not to say they weren't there (just look them up on YouTube), but it seems more obviously problematic this year. That's just not good enough.


2. Franchise Mode Has Been Neglected (Again)

Madden NFL 21
EA Sports

Before critiquing Franchise, here are some changes EA made this year.

There are new X-Factor abilities available, the Wild Card rounds have been extended for the Playoffs and there are new contract negotiations for rookies. That's literally it. Everything else, right down the in-office main hub for your coach, remains exactly the same aside from a colour switch or two.

It's heartbreaking that EA seem so unwilling to listen to their customer base when it comes to this mode. People want Franchise to be a success, and they'd be happy with incremental progress if it showed the developers were actually paying attention.

They're not though. EA want you to play MUT instead and line their pockets by buying 'pay to win' card packs there. If you're still playing Franchise in Madden 20 and have a good thing going, stick at it. There's no need to start from scratch in 21.


1. EA Has No Goodwill With Long-Term Fans

Madden 21
EA Sports

Any goodwill EA still had has been shot to pieces by Madden 21's lack of innovation.

On-field gameplay has shown signs of life (more on that to come), but the lack of new features, zero depth to Franchise and the obvious focus on Ultimate Team has p*ssed people off. It's why the game currently has a dreadful 0.3 user rating score over on Metacritic.

Fans are sick to death of EA overlooking their wishlists and giggling as they count their millions. Of course, nothing will change until people stop buying Madden - EA won't really care much when they're still raking in cash. However, their reputation isn't just on thin ice with series vets - it's already in the water.

EA badly need a competitor to help spur them on. They need a kick in the ass, in other words, and a reason to re-develop Madden from the ground up. The team's iron grip on the NFL license isn't good for gamers, and neither is EA's spotlight on MUT.


Ups...

4. Gameplay Feels A Little Zippier

Madden 21
EA Sports

Ready for some positives after all that negative energy? You got it.

There's a greater sense of speed and power to Madden 21's snap-by-snap gameplay. It's like EA sneakily cranked the overall pace up by 1-2%, and that makes a bigger change than some might imagine. This, of course, has the knock-on effect of giving quarterbacks less time to make passing plays.

It's awesome for running plays though. Put the ball in your star back's hands and you'll have a great time mowing through defensive lines and snaking your way to the end zone. This is where Madden 21 is at its best; there's an arcade-ish thrill that comes from this sense of speed.

Everything generally has more of a zip to it, and that's neat. This is even true when playing the game on sim mode and removing those unrealistic Hail Mary attempts from every single possession. Sim doesn't lose that impactful velocity one bit.


3. Linebackers Aren't Gods

Madden 21
EA Sports

Last year, linebackers had springs in their shoes and could leap up to intercept even the most vicious of bullet passes from the air. That always felt a little cheap, and like the game was punishing your receivers for running anything other than a straight route down the middle of the field.

They've been toned down in Madden 21.

That's a welcome change, because it means defenders aren't joined at the hip to your wide men. They still made impossible catches every now and then, but not nearly as often as they did in recent versions. There's more variety now, and they even get lost if you mix things up with slants or comebacks.

This is great when playing against human opponents too. You're rewarded for digging deeper into your playbook and don't have to worry as much about AI-controlled linebackers leaping out of nowhere to destroy your schemes.


2. Skill Stick Improves Running Plays

Madden 21
EA Sports

That doesn't mean pass plays are more effective than running ones though.

Running the ball is still the most practical way to play Madden, and the new 'Skill Stick' helps. By mapping most skill moves to the right stick, EA has successfully made run plays more fluid. You don't need to rely on that same old spin move every single time now.

It feels more gratifying to play this way. Add in the greater sense of speed explored earlier and you should be able to made the NFL's best running backs more potent. They should be this dangerous, and defences should never have an easy gig talking them to the turf anyway.

Honestly, if you do buy Madden 21 and want the most from it, experiment with the skill moves. You'll have an easier time than ever doing so and will likely be repaid in kind by some of the best plays you've ever manufactured in your time with the series.


1. The Yard Is A Fun Diversion

Madden 21
EA Sports

Depending on what type of gamer you are, The Yard might be a difference-maker.

It's a 6v6 matchup between big-time star players with no quarters, no time limits, an 80-yard field and three offensive possessions each. You're also allowed to make multiple throws behind the line of scrimmage to keep rivals guessing, which is a really nice touch and gives each game a unique flavour.

Arguably, EA could've done more to flesh out the mode with some sort of league structure or mini-Franchise integration, but what's here is fun. The wacky uniforms you can customise and overall focus on over-the-top plays make this a blast with friends.

There's potential here, but that's been said before with other modes (like 'Face Of The Franchise') in recent Madden history. Still, this will appeal to a select group of casual players who think Madden's main feature set is a bit po-faced and serious.

What did you think of Madden 21? For more content, check out 10 Wrestlers That WWE Are Failing Right Now and 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 1995!


In this post: 
Madden 21
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.