Mass Effect 4: 10 Ways To Fix A Broken Series

How BioWare can fix a series on the verge of collapse.

When Mass Effect 3 finally landed in our collective hands in March of this year, we were all overjoyed, and then many of us were quickly disappointed when, after playing through the riveting campaign, we were handed an ending that many deemed "cheap" and "lazy". After promising that the huge save files people had invested so much time and effort in would have a biblical impact upon on the events of the third game, gamers everywhere were let down when, in actual fact, it all came down to one single choice in the final room of the game, where you essentially pick a colour, and sit back to watch the result of that choice. The fan backlash was huge, with many quite incredulously asking BioWare to change the ending. The negative publicity was such that they eventually released a DLC to "clarify" the events of its climax, though fans still have a bad taste in their mouth over what happened. The announcement yesterday that Mass Effect 4 is going into production has sparked the debate once again, with many wondering whether a fourth game could rectify those problems and make us like BioWare again. Here are 10 ways they can fix the damage they caused with the last 10 minutes of their previous game; by revitalising the series and breathing new life into it, they can make us forget about all the issues with ME3.

1. A New Protagonist

Though Commander Shepard is the much-loved protagonist of the Mass Effect series, one can't help but feel that, whatever ending you received, his story is near-enough finished, and it's probably time to hand the reins to someone else. Though Mike Gamble stated a few months ago rather cryptically that we'd best all hang onto our ME3 saves, this doesn't implicitly state that the same characters are going to show up in a fourth game, and this could have been a coy reference to DLC above all else. Of course, we've all been poring over and speculating about the star-gazer cut-scene at the climax of the third game, but there's enough ambiguity that in the fourth game, Shepard could either be dead, old, or indeed, very much alive and still kicking ass elsewhere in the galaxy. A new protagonist far away from Shepard would be a key way to revitalise things; perhaps a lowly officer who, throughout what is sure to be a new trilogy, would rise up to become a Captain in the middle of intergalactic war. Of course, we wouldn't mind a Shepard cameo in that event, but best to keep it low-key.

2. Make It An MMORPG

In the lead up to the release of Mass Effect 3, BioWare's founders Greg Zeschuk and Ray Muzyka - who just today announced their retirement - expressed an interest in creating a Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game set in the Mass Effect universe. Now that BioWare have eased players into the idea of a Mass Effect game having multiplayer - with the third game featuring a stripped-down co-op component - they could feasibly turn this huge, sprawling world into an MMO not unlike the fantastic Star Wars: The Old Republic. While BioWare might already have too much on their plate in that regard - and news that SW:TOR's subscriptions are continually dropping off is likely no encouragement - the sheer breadth and depth of what we have seen so far would lend itself extremely well to this sort of environment. Of course, it would be a huge gamble for BioWare to transform the reliable formula into something that fans may not mesh with, so it's more likely they would release this as a spin-off of sorts, in much the same way that SW:TOR might be considered a spin-off of Knights of the Old Republic. Whatever the delivery method, the potential of an ambitious project like this is huge.

3. Contextualise Mass Effect 3

Most of us wound up so irked and upset by the end of Mass Effect 3 that it couldn't hurt if the writers help give it a little extra context in the fourth game, whatever time or place it ends up being set in. Be wary, "contextualise" doesn't mean the same as "ret-con" - though many will immediately jump to that assumption - and the writers should be sure not to change past events to suit their new direction, whatever that is. Simply, much like the recent DLC, they can build on the mess they created and try to steer it clear of anymore fanboy vitriol, rather than simply ignore it and pretend that it didn't happen. One such way would be to set the game a fair way into the future, whereby we can see the effect of Shepard's war against the Reapers; this would also be an interesting and novel for players to make use of their ME3 saves. Whatever choice you made could have an impact several-hundred years into the future. Places your bets on where the Shepard statue is placed now...

4. Proper Co-Op Campaign

When I heard that Mass Effect 3 was to be bestowed with a multiplayer component, I was overjoyed, as the thought of taking down the Reapers with my pals at my side sounded like one of the few ways to make the series even more fun and enjoyable than it already is. However, we of course didn't end up with that possibility, and the final product simply offered a rather generic 4-player c0-op mode in which you and three friends (or strangers) attack hordes of enemies for as long as you possibly can, earning points in the process that contribute to your "Galactic Readiness" rating in the single-player offering. The multi-player having such an effect on the single-player - and essentially punishing those who didn't want to opt into the online stuff - was heavily criticised, so we can hope that the fourth time around, they might invest some time in a proper co-op. Imagine connecting with a mate over Xbox Live or PSN as you might have done on Halo or Call of Duty, and playing through a 20-plus-hour game over a few days; it's a great way to make gaming more social and involving, though we can't guarantee you'll make the same dialogue wheel choices or want to sit through all the same cut-scenes...

5. Greater Moral Ambiguity

One of the great joys of contemporary gaming is how they have slowly but surely introduced a morality system, whereby actions good and bad have different consequences, from how other characters react to you, to defining your existence in the closing portions of the game. Though Mass Effect is blessed with the wonderful dialogue wheel system, whereby you are presented with a number of options to reply to an NPC, this also strips any and all moral ambiguity away from the situation, as it creates an objective, absolute morality, whereby one choice is "good", and one is "bad". The fact that you're allocated points on this basis compounds this, and a few times I found myself making tough calls and being rewarded Renegade points despite not really thinking my actions were "bad" as such. Drawing along such lines reduces the choices to simple transactions; those obsessed with becoming "good" will dispassionately select only good options, instead of actually thinking about the tough choices ahead. As someone who doesn't care about being a Renegade or a Paragon and just mulled over the options, I found myself sitting there at several points for a few minutes, really thinking about the moral implications of what I was about to do. It's just a shame that BioWare have to quantify it in such obvious terms.

6. Multiple Ways to Complete Missions

While you certainly can make life for yourself easier if you don't run and gun, and instead invest time in becoming a persuasive speaker, Mass Effect thus far has not really looked into the potential of non-violent set-pieces. Games over a decade old have been engaging with this idea - look at Metal Gear Solid, Hitman, Deus Ex and Splinter Cell - whereby you are able to circumvent violence with a stealthier approach, saving ammo and conserving health in the process. Given that Shepard and his team mates are essentially a small squad who can nevertheless bring the force of a sizeable army, it's not much of a stretch that they might be able to sneak in and out undetected if the time called for it. Perhaps if, like we suggested above, Shepard was replaced with a new protagonist for the fourth game, that character could be more along the lines of a Solid Snake-type espionage operative, procuring weapons on-site but mostly having to crawl past guards and snap necks. While that might mean an overhaul of some of the gameplay mechanics, it would be another way that BioWare could promote freedom throughout the game.

7. Fluid Class System

The class system in the Mass Effect games is prominent and potent enough that it's a sure blast to play through each game multiple times as a different type of character, and the sheer number of abilities that each class is privy to makes each experience a distinct one, such that you're definitely going to have a class you love, and a class that you hate. However, one can't help but feel the game could open up even more if BioWare essentially turned these abilities into a Pick 'N Mix of sorts, allowing the player to cherry-pick the abilities they want from each class into a new sub-class. The potential here is huge; players could essentially make their own cross-breeds, and combined with a proper co-op campaign, will make for some awesome match-ups when the bad guys show up. One franchise they might want to look to - despite its recent critical downturn - is Final Fantasy; the newer, albeit less-heralded games have introduced fluid class systems, whereby with the touch of a button you can change classes and endow yourselves with a new set of abilities with which to fell the foes. While we wouldn't suggest something quite so...fantastical, the ability to queue up compatible and contrasting abilities would make our characters feel more three-dimensional and versatile, rather than a generic grunt, tank, medic or mage-type character.

8. Stronger Romance

This is something that just about all video games struggle with, even those games like GTA and indeed, Mass Effect, which are frequently lauded for their writing. The romantic exchanges in the games - which have been oddly controversial in the media for their depiction of human-alien sexual liaisons - are really quite reductive, hinging on getting brief dialogue wheel sections correct, and essentially, telling the prospective partner what they want to hear. Now, while we're not saying we want 10 hours of the game devoted to the courtship of our mate, something a little more substantial and less insulting to our intelligence would go a long way; the current method is precisely why I never invest any time or effort in romantic elements of video games, unless the game forces me to. Simply, there is no chemistry, no allure, nothing that seems remotely real about the romances in the Mass Effect games. Given how "progressive" BioWare have been by allowing homosexuality in their games, the writing still feels curiously stuck in the past; give us a strong-minded independent woman who is going to challenge our protagonist rather than end up just capitulating.

9. Cause and Effect

This one's really a given, when you consider how much of a fuss people kicked up at the end of Mass Effect 3, when the choices we had made through the previous two games turned out to amount to very little, when the final scene in the game presented us with a reductive, simplistic choice of picking a colour and hoping for the best. Branching narratives can definitely get messy in the wrong hands - just look at something as promising and ultimately disappointing as Fahrenheit - but when they're executed well, they are extremely rewarding, as we can draw the line from A-to-B over the course of 10 or 20 hours and deduce that what we did had a significant impact on how things played out. Many games, like Mass Effect, have tackled this in a superficial way, but after the uproar following the last game's climax, it's time to reward gamers who were so let down and actually give them the cause and effect they crave. Though one can imagine something like this being an absolute headache to develop and code, that doesn't mean they should just take the lazy path of least resistance. After ME3, BioWare have something to prove to us, so hopefully this is the area above all that they will focus on refining, even perfecting.

10. More Dialogue Wheels

What was also rather disappointing about Mass Effect 3 was its pronounced lack of dialogue wheels; so many spoken scenes went by without giving the player a single choice, despite the dialogue appearing to veer in that direction. It is as though BioWare had decided that the finale wasn't going to be informed all that much by the previous games when it came to the crunch, so why bother fooling players into thinking otherwise anyway? Though context of course came into play during the game's cut-scenes, choice was really stricken from the record this time around, and it merely felt like we were going to the motions, whereas the first two games actually felt like they were building towards something. It's a simple one to remedy; just include more of the damn things, and make them matter, but don't impose an objective morality onto it as we mentioned above. Keep it vague, yet simply clear that something is happening and our choices do account for something. We think with these choices - or at least some of them - Mass Effect 4 could really be something special. Let us know what you think in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.