Mass Effect Andromeda: 10 Impressions From The First 10 Hours
2017's first AAA flop?
The highly-anticipated Mass Effect: Andromeda begins its worldwide rollout on March 21st, but EA Access members are now able to play 10 hours of the game ahead of its full release (gated to the end of the first campaign planet, while the entire multiplayer mode is unlocked).
Well, the floodgates have opened, and it's nothing if not fascinating to observe the diverse reactions to the trial. Pre-orders have been cancelled, memes have begun circulating, and the hardcore crowd continues to insist that nothing at all is wrong.
Many expected Andromeda to be an apology for the mess that was the previous game, but going by how divided fans already seem by it, this could be yet another unfortunate stumbling block for the franchise.
It'll be interesting to see how this initial reaction compares to the eventual critical consensus, but either way, props to EA for granting trial access to one of the year's most-awaited AAA games, especially as they surely must have been aware of how flawed the end result seems to be.
10. The Character Creator Is Boring & Bland
Probably the most immediately disappointing aspect of Andromeda is its utterly effortless character creator. Few were expecting something miraculous, but it's pretty embarrassing that, in the five years since the last game, customisation has improved so little.
Options are limited, it feels too similar to the previous games, and the non-Ryder faces in particular look incredibly garish for a game releasing in 2017.
Weirdly, it's also not possible to make a totally pale white character, and while some stupid people will deem it to be "anti-white propaganda", it's really just an incredibly strange restriction.
BioWare are apparently already looking into options for a patch, but expect a major fan s***storm when the game hits stores.
9. Combat Is Still (Mostly) Awesome
Say what you will about Andromeda, but the combat is still ludicrously entertaining for the most part. It's thrilling to head into battle largely because the AI routines are actually surprisingly intelligent, and will put up a decent fight even on Normal difficulty.
Moreover, you've given an incredible variety of abilities and weapons to stage your attack, and of course, the addition of the jetpack adds a whole new layer of verticality to combat.
While the trial sadly doesn't show off a ton of enemy variety (one wouldn't be remiss for calling most of them "generic"), at least dispatching them is plenty satisfying, and sure to be one of the game's most-lauded aspects.
8. Dialogue & Voice Acting Are... Not Great
Oh boy, brace yourselves. BioWare fans are used to dealing with some hokey dialogue and dodgy voice acting every now and then, but Andromeda really feels like the Mass Effect' series worst effort in that regard.
While it's easy to want to believe the game is simply off to a rough start, the pervasively awful, cornball writing and astoundingly robotic delivery is mind-bogglingly bad. Take this howlingly awful exchange that's already gone viral and is sure to remain a fine source of mockery long after the game is released.
That BioWare let such horrendous performance and voice direction slip through the cracks feels like a testament to the belief of many fans that the game was rushed to completion, and due care hasn't been taken to ensure a polished end-product.
"My face is tired" is just one example. There's a lot of lazily-written dialogue and a lot of the performances are just blandly forgettable, like the voice actors had somewhere else to be.
7. Multiplayer Is Fun, But Familiar
The multiplayer mode can serve as a refreshing reprieve from the single-player, serving up a Horde-style co-op loop in which 4 players can team up to take on wave after wave of enemies until they're able to extract.
With Andromeda's faster style of gunplay, the multiplayer feels even more urgent than in ME3, and while the enemy hordes are fairly repetitive for the most part, it's still ultimately a satisfying experience that's likely to have many fans back for hours on end.
It's a shame, though, that BioWare didn't decide to go a little more ambitious with their multiplayer suite and actually introduce PVP elements. Yes, it would potentially create huge balancing issues, but limiting multiplayer to just Horde mode seems a little on the lazy side, to be quite honest.
6. Lore & Exploration Are Impressively Detailed
Players certainly won't want for things to do in this game, that's for sure.
For starters, true to form, BioWare has included a ridiculous amount of lore in the game for players to deeply immerse themselves in, and a lot of this can be found through simply exploring the hub worlds, while not necessarily needing to engage in combat in order to learn more.
It remains to be seen if the final game will manage to keep the exploration interesting and diverse, but it's already clear that there's much for the inclined gamer to mine out of this vast universe.
5. The Graphics Are Wildly Inconsistent
On the Xbox One, Andromeda is something of a peculiar, frustrating experience when it comes to graphics and performance. One moment you'll be wowed at the game's gorgeously cinematic feel (such as an early sequence where you fall out of the sky and are free to tilt the camera around), and at others you'll visibly recoil or cringe at a badly-rendered face that would barely pass muster in the previous games.
Conversations in particular feature characters with big, bulging serial killer eyes that are immensely distracting and often hilarious. The lip sync and movement is terrible for a 2017 game, while the running movement often looks goofy (like someone awkwardly running to the bathroom after an "accident"), and at least on Xbox One, there's frequent stutter during cut-scenes.
To describe the visuals in one word? Janky. Some might find it charming and fun, but that just feels like a cop-out, because this shoddy performance really shouldn't be acceptable in a game that's been in production for so long.
4. Auto-Cover Will Be Controversial
Here's where that "mostly" caveat about the combat comes into play. Some players are going to justifiably be a little miffed by the game's cover system, which has the player go into cover mode whenever they get near an appropriate object.
While in theory this can be better than, say, snapping to cover, the unfortunate result here is that players may often find themselves fiddling around trying to get behind objects that cannot be used as cover. You can easily waste precious seconds sorting out your cover while the enemy fires wildly at you, all the more annoying as there's still no damn crouch button.
Some will be fine with it and others will absolutely loathe it, but it's definitely the most awkward element of an otherwise fine suite of combat systems.
3. The UI Could Be Better
It's a common problem in gaming these days, and Andromeda is no exception: the UI is honestly a bit of a mess.
Like too many games nowadays, there's far too much clutter, very little of it feels intuitive to navigate to (especially accessing the map), the quest list is cumbersome to sort through, and it basically feels like you'll end up wasting way too much time here rather than, you know, actually playing the game.
And don't even start with planet scanning, which is infuriatingly tedious busy-work and sure to be a major frustration in the final game.
2. The Characters Aren't Very Interesting (So Far)
Andromeda's introductory mission feels really, really rushed, and one has to wonder: why? If there's any franchise that can take its time, it's this one, slowly introducing characters and scenarios, but instead, BioWare has flung way too much at the player way too fast.
For starters, the player is almost immediately informed about their comatose sibling, but it means nothing because we haven't met that character before. Then a tragedy befalls the protagonist in the opening mission and, again, it falls flat emotionally because no clear bond has been established.
The player is never really asked to care. There are certainly promising characters here, such as Cora and Peebee in particular, but there are also laughable meatheads like Liam. Only time can tell how they'll pan out, of course, because it definitely took (a little) time for most players to warm to Garrus, Wrex and so on in the previous games.
Still, it's not an encouraging tone to strike from the outset.
1. The Game Will Probably Heavily Divide Fans & Critics
Take this one to the bank: unless Andromeda simply has a very shaky start and blossoms to become a far more confident game later on, this is going to heavily divide critics and especially fans.
It's worth noting that even the controversial Mass Effect 3 scored 89-93 on Metacritic, but with Andromeda's clear lack of polish and the blatant fact it should've been delayed, critics might not be quite so kind this time.
With the game's early hours being widely torn down by outlets such as Giant Bomb and PC Gamer, while Kotaku gave it a conversely positive write-up, it seems reasonable to expect a Metascore of around 75-80 rather than the usual high standard for the series.
After seeing so many recent AAA titles land on or above expectations these past months, Andromeda's release sure is going to be an interesting one.
--
Have you had the opportunity to play Mass Effect: Andromeda yet? What do you think? Shout it out in the comments!