Medal Of Honor: Ranking The Series From Worst To Best

Back in a time before annual-releases and on-rails sections, a certain other first-person shooter ruled the roost from a considerable height.

Once the favourite child of the powerhouse that is Electronic Arts, the classic Medal of Honor series now resembles a beaten down old hag who has seen one winter too many. Hitting its peak amid the early to mid noughties' wave of popularity for WW2 games, it is worth remembering that in their day these works were gaining a wider audience than the other, lesser known entity Call of Duty. Oh how things change. In recent times, it has struggled to catch up and indeed hold its own against the giants of the modern FPS genre; Call Of Duty and EA's newest foray into this market - the Battlefield series. Here we are going to take you on a walk down memory lane to relive the franchise in all its glory.

8. Medal Of Honor: Airborne

Ranking the lowest on the list is this effort from 2007. The first MoH game to be released on the seventh generation of consoles, the main problem this game has is that it struggles to make use of the new opportunities the hardware provides. Truth be told, it feels more like a slightly dolled-up PS2 game. A poor multiplayer mode was joined by an even worse single player storyline, which was as about generic as it gets. You take the role of a member of the 82nd American Airborne division and fight in Italy, France, Holland and Germany. One thing that really sticks out about this game was the poor soundtrack. At this point, the series had been very consistent on the quality of its score, but on this occasion it was not up to standard. All the more surprising about this is the fact that it was composed by the normally-brilliant Michael Giacchino, who had already done stellar work on games such as Frontline and Rising Sun (more to come on those later). The game was, however, received well by critics. It holds a rating of 7.9 on IGN, for example. I will admit, however, that one interesting, if not very well executed element of the game was the ability to parachute into missions at the beginning of each new campaign. Basically, after choosing when to jump, the player could then steer the direction of the descent all the way down in order to begin the mission on their own terms. This was the series' last foray into the WW2 genre on the main consoles, and it was a poor way to check out.

7. Medal Of Honor (2010)

Released in 2010, this was Medal of Honor's first attempt at basing itself in a modern setting, and the general feeling remains that it failed big time. Essentially a clone of the Activision-developed Modern Warfare 2, it fell down in too many areas to be considered anything other than your typical run-of-the-mill FPS. The first Medal of Honor game to put more of an emphasis on multiplayer as oppose to single player mode, the online gameplay was not very memorable. Put simply, it seemed to struggle to find itself against the fast and frantic nature of Call of Duty and the slower, more tactical approach of the Battlefield series. The story mode as mentioned is based in a modern setting. To be honest, for purposes of this feature I literally had to recheck what it was even about, so little was its lasting impression. Based in the current war in Afghanistan, you take control of various different characters from across the US military. The boring story was accompanied by numerous gameplay problems. Upon looking down the sights of your weapon the shoddy textures of the game stood out as very poor. Small components of course, but the sum of these parts added up to make a broken game.

6. Medal Of Honor: Warfighter

The most recent game of the series, Warfighter unfortunately seemed to thread the same line as its predecessor in that it was basically a clone of the Call of Duty and Battlefield games. The game continues on the storyline from Medal of Honor, but you wouldn't know it, considering the single-player mode lasts roughly four hours. The main issue that arises with this game is the fact that it is extremely hard to play. Not the difficulty that is, more the frequent bugs, frankly awful AI and generic set-pieces. The game was received quite badly by critics. It holds a 55/100 rating (PS3) on metacritic, and was also a commercial flop. The game sold roughly 300,000 copies upon initial release, which was well below EA's expectations. It seems as if this was the final nail in the coffin of the series, with EA realizing the games "poor critical and commercial reception", and deciding to put the series on hiatus.

5. Medal Of Honor: Vanguard

Next up on the run down is this 2007 effort. It was the final Medal of Honor game to be produced for the sixth generation of consoles (along with the Wii), and also the final game to be based in a WW2 setting. The game takes place over the course of four campaigns from Italy, France, Holland and Germany, and the player takes the role of Cpl/Sgt. Frank Keegan, a member of the 82nd Airborne Division, and 17th Airborne Division. Nothing out of the ordinary here you could say, as it seemed to follow a familiar pattern to previous games. Despite receiving poor reviews from critics (review websites GameRankings and Metacritic gave the PlayStation 2 version 64.35% and 63/100 and the Wii version 57.52% and 56/100), the game was a satisfying enough experience. The added bonus of customising weapons prior to missions was a nice perk for a WW2 game too. It was also the last game to include the split-screen mode which had played a big part in previous games in the series. While this is understandable considering the online multiplayer wave which was about to wash over the FPS landscape, the thrill of completing a mission with a friend who is actually in the room is still a nice memory. The reason this game has a higher ranking than perhaps some may think it deserves is due to the fact that considering there was little publicity for the game, it was a case of getting what you paid for. If you were looking for a simple FPS experience, it surely delivered.

4. Medal Of Honor: Heroes And Heroes 2

For this entry, I choose to group these two efforts together. Released in 2006 and 2007 respectively, both games were actually quite similar. The only Medal of Honor games to be released on the PSP handheld console, Heroes 2 was also released on the Wii. The first game's storyline was tailor-made for fans of the previous games. You take the role of Lieutenant Jimmy Patterson, who was the star of the original Medal of Honor and Medal of Honor: Frontline, Sergeant John Baker from Medal of Honor: Allied Assault Breakthrough, and Lt. William Holt from Medal of Honor: European Assault. The campaigns take place in Italy, Holland, and Belgium. In a nice touch, it also wrapped up the stories and loose ends of these characters. The structure of the missions was simple yet effective, with the player having a number of tasks such as sabotage, infiltration, and capturing certain objectives. Heroes 2 was received in a similar manner to its predecessor. Here, you take on the role of Lieutenant John Berg. The game had a very specific setting in the form of the Allied invasion of France in 1944. Put simply, these games delivered exactly what they promised: a fun FPS handheld experience. There was a limited advertising campaign for both, and it was clear that by this stage EA had an eye on developing the modern-day Medal Of Honor of 2010.

3. Medal Of Honor: European Assault

So we come to the top three of the countdown. Here, I chose to slot in the 2005 release European Assault. Interestingly, the game's story was written by John Milius, the writer of Apocalypse Now. The plot is based on Lieutenant William Holt, an operative in the Office of Strategic Services, and follows his deployments to Allied forces in France, North Africa, the Soviet Union and Belgium. The game was well received, with an average metacritic score of 73/100 on the Playstation 2. The game added in several new innovations such as Adrenaline Mode, activated by killing numerous enemies or scoring headshots, which allowed the player to be invincible and have unlimited ammo for a short period of time. Also, the added challenge of killing a specific German officer is present in every mission, providing the nearest thing to boss battles the series had seen. A special mention must go out to the section of the campaign set in Russia, and specifically the soundtrack that accompanies it. The setting of Stalingrad provides a truly haunting backdrop to Christopher Lennertz's compositions.

2. Medal of Honor: Rising Sun

The penultimate entry to the list ran a close race. Released by EA Games in November 2003, Rising Sun was the first Medal of Honor game to be set away from Europe. In a refreshing break from the normality of the series, it played like a sprawling, epic film. It basically took the previous espionage-based mindset, and mixed it with a vast and expansive setting. As mentioned, the game was not based in the European theatre, which had been the setting of all the games in the series up to that point. On this occasion, the player took on the might of the Japanese empire in the Pacific. The player assumes the role of Cpl./Sgt. Joseph Griffin of the United States Marine Corps. It takes place over a number of different settings, from Guadalcanal to Burma, via an undercover operation in Singapore. Rising Sun met mainly mixed reviews. IGN gave the game a rating of 8/10, the same as its predecessor. The game also garnered an average rating of 68/100 from Metacritic, indicating mixed or average reviews. Gamespot rated 6.4/10. In the end, it was the somewhat mixed reception that resulted in a sequel being shelved by EA. Many people will question why this game is ranked so high on the list. The fact is, despite all the criticism, this is one hell of an effort. The soundtrack plays like a score to a Hollywood production, the enemy A.I. is brutal (in a good way) and the split-screen campaign mode was probably one of the best there has ever been. In a recent revisit, Rising Sun still plays well, and the same can't be said for a lot of games 11 years old.

1. Medal of Honor: Frontline

It was always only going to be one, wasn't it? Released all the way back in 2002, the player takes the role of Lt. Jimmy Patterson, an American OSS operative. Patterson is first tasked with landing with Allied forces as part of Operation Overlord, and to then try and disrupt Nazi U-boat production in France. However, the secret development of a jet fighter instead leads our protagonist on a mission across Holland and Germany to dismantle the potential turning point of the war. Frontline received high praise upon its release. GameRankings and Metacritic gave the PlayStation 2 version 86.67% and 88/100, the Xbox version 78.59% and 81/100 and the GameCube version 78.58% and 80/100. The games score especially received a lot of fanfare. In his review for IGN, Kaiser Hwang wrote: "Composed by Michael Giacchino and performed by the NorthWest Symphonia, the game's score is outstanding.....the sound effects are also of a very high caliber". There are a plethora of reasons this is the best game of the Medal of Honor series. Each individual mission sticks out as a highlight, from the Saving Private Ryan-style opener, to the final boss battle behind German lines. A level that especially sticks out is "Arnhem Knights", where the haunting soundtrack provides the perfect backdrop to the hopelessness of the British forces' resistance. Also, considering the game was released in the time of cheat codes, there was massive fun to be had with perks like "Rubber Grenades" and the classic "Men in Hats". In 2010, a remastered edition of the game was released as a bonus along with the newest entry to the franchise. It says a lot that replaying this simply fantastic piece of work was a far bigger draw than the main game. Feel free to give your own opinion on the best and worst of the series in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

A keen observer of gaming, television, film and football from the distant outpost of Ireland, Shane is studying Sports and Fitness and dreams of joining the Irish Army. Yes, that really does exist.