Metal Gear Solid V: 8 Reasons To Be Concerned

image_metal_gear_solid_v_the_phantom_pain-22272-2584_0001 Metal Gear Solid is one of the most popular and beloved series of all time, and Hideo Kojima has been teasing us with the latest entry in the award-winning series for over a year now. It all started with the reveal of Ground Zeroes at PAX 2012, and then the reveal at the VGAs of the mysterious and supposed new IP titled simply The Phantom Pain. The veil was finally removed at the Game Developers Conference in March of this year, where Kojima officially revealed that Ground Zeroes and The Phantom Pain together will make up Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. For the legion of fans of this series, we were left in awe of what we witnessed in that trailer, as well as what was shown at E3 several months later. Conspiracy theories began to circulate that David Hayter would actually return as Big Boss and that Kiefer Sutherland was just a diversion, that Punished Snake was not actually Big Boss. Personally, I feel that Kojima was sitting in his office laughing hysterically at what Metal Gear Solid 2 had done to all of our psyches. Most recently, there was a gameplay demo shown behind closed doors of Ground Zeroes, and the feedback that was shared by those at the event was, let's say, somewhat concerning to fans. Over the past week, at the Tokyo Games Show, Kojima did reveal several gameplay demos for the public to see. This was the first time he has shown what the next-gen version of Metal Gear Solid V will look like. I figured this was as good a time as any to try and look forward to the eventual release of the game, and why the game could potentially disappoint when we finally get our hands on it. I want to make it known that I don't necessarily believe this will happen, but there are definitely some issues that could plague the game.

8. Supernatural Elements

Supernatural1 When the initial trailer for The Phantom Pain was revealed, the supernatural elements that were on display really jumped off the screen. Metal Gear has always had these types of events included in their stories, but none of the previous games were being rooted in as much un-reality as Kojima is supposedly going for this time. Flaming whales that swallow helicopters, burning unicorns, and seemingly resurrected characters were peppered throughout the trailer that debuted in December 2012 at the VGAs. Most fans have already concluded that these are a result of some sort of mind control from a young Psycho Mantis, and that these visions are only present inside the mind of Big Boss. I truly hope this is the case, and that these happenings will not extend outside of the hospital escape scene. However, if they do extend throughout the rest of the game, they could override the tone that Kojima is going for with this story.

7. Dark Tone/Themes

Revenge The E3 Red Band trailer really showed what an incredibly depressing story we may be about to bear witness to. Donna Burke, who sang the great Heavens Divide in Peace Walker, is once again lending her voice talents to the Metal Gear universe in the form of The Sins Of The Father, which debuted with the aforementioned trailer. The song itself seems to give a lot of insight into the game, but that is for another discussion. The overall tone and sound of the song is very foreboding, and goes along with the grizzly events that we see throughout the trailer. We already knew that this game will trace the events that led to the ultimate downfall of Big Boss and transformation into the maniacal villain we first battled in the original Metal Gear game for the MSX. The red band trailer showed numerous instances of torture, executions, emergency surgeries, child soldiers, as well as the different phantom pains that Big Boss and Kaz are wrestling with. I do worry that all of this could add up to a Metal Gear experience that is very emotionally draining and depressing, which could drag down the overall experience.

6. Open World

Openworld Much has been made about Kojima's decision to move Metal Gear into the open world of gaming. At first glance, it sounds great and seems to open up a wealth of possibilities for MGS V. However, there are reasons to be concerned about the effect this could have. When I hear "open world", my mind immediately goes to Grand Theft Auto. To me, these games are the epitome of the sandbox style of gaming. Kojima himself has also invited comparisons to GTA when he commented that he was "depressed" upon seeing gameplay of GTA V, as he feels that his V cannot measure up to it. This screams to me that the open world we have been promised may not actually be as "open" as we are hoping. It seems like MGS V will instead be comprised of very large levels, where the openness really comes into play only in how you approach that particular level, instead of getting a Grand Theft Metal Gear experience. The other thing the open world setting could have a negative effect on is the story, which is the most important part of any Metal Gear game in my mind. I will get into that further a little bit later.

5. Gameplay Changes

Gameplay Fans of the series were sent into a frenzy when details of the gameplay demo at the Kojima Productions LA office were revealed. Some video game websites wondered aloud if Metal Gear Solid V was even Metal Gear anymore. A lot of people are comparing it to Splinter Cell instead. Some of the changes that were revealed included the following: slow motion executions to avoid alerts, possible regenerating health instead of the tried and true ration system, tagging enemies to monitor their movements, lens flares indicating when an enemy is able to see Snake, an evolved CQC system where stealing the enemy's weapon is possible, and the ability to steal and pilot vehicles. Some of these changes have me very excited, but others have the opposite effect so far. Minimising the elements contained in the HUD is a welcome change, but using blood spatter on the screen and just needing to seek cover to get back to 100% health would take a lot of the stress out of sneaking through a level and trying to avoid full-scale alerts. The executions could really go either way for me, but it does feel a lot like a copy of Splinter Cell, or even the latest Hitman for that matter. Stealing and driving different vehicles adds another level to the game, but the reports indicate that the driving itself seems to be very clunky and that could definitely detract from the experience. I am holding my breath with some of these changes, and putting my trust in Kojima to make them work.

4. Lack Of Cut-Scenes

Cutscene This is the one item that may get the most reaction out of the 8 I have featured. Kojima has stated in interviews that the cut-scenes in MGS V will be severely limited compared to all previous entries in the series. In the past, these have been one of the biggest knocks against the series by naysayers, but I for one have absolutely loved them in each game. The scene on the Volta River after Act 3 of MGS 4 stands out to me as one of the greatest in the history of gaming. Heck, there isn't much that Hollywood has produced that can match what Liquid Ocelot pulled off, as he slaughtered all the US troops after The System had been taken offline. These cut-scenes have served to add so much to the storytelling element over the life of this series, and I fear that the big drop in these could really end up hurting the game. Kojima has also stated how he will be giving so much control to the players, in terms of story progression, and I assume this is the reason that the cut-scenes will not play as big a role as they have in the past. With MGS V serving as the game to close out most of the Metal Gear lore, the way in which Kojima tells that story will be of the utmost importance. I fear that by abandoning the way he has done this in the past, he could be hurting the final product of what should be the greatest game in the series.

3. Unreal Expectations

Unreal The buildup for Metal Gear Solid V has been nothing short of extraordinary, and is still happening as we speak. Kojima has done an excellent job so far of slowly revealing more information, and keeping us starving for more when the reveals finally did happen. My jaw literally dropped when I saw the reveal trailer from PAX 2012 of what was then only known as MGS: Ground Zeroes. The amount of detail in Camp Omega was really just amazing, and obviously unlike anything we had witnessed in a Metal Gear game before. The Phantom Pain trailer left us wondering if we would be getting two new Metal Gear games (and as of this writing, it still has not yet been confirmed as to whether or not Ground Zeroes will be getting a separate release from The Phantom Pain portion of MGS V), and when the first reveal of MGS V was made at the GDC convention, fans of the series were bursting at the seams. By the time MGS V is finally released, I think it will have taken the unofficial title of the most anticipated game release of all time. The last time expectations were this high for a Metal Gear game was for the release of Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty. Regardless of how you felt about that game as a whole, the proverbial gut punch we all felt when Raiden was revealed as the main protagonist quelled all the anticipation fans had for the game. Is there any realistic way for this game to live up to everything it could possibly be? I am afraid that is now an almost impossible task. If anyone is up to surpassing expectations, it probably is Hideo Kojima. However, he may have set the bar so high with what we all hope MGS V will be, that he may have set himself up for a colossal failure.

2. Kiefer Sutherland

Kiefer I'm not sure which enraged fans more; the announcement that David Hayter would not be returning to voice Big Boss/Snake in Metal Gear Solid V, or the reveal that the new voice actor would be none other than Jack Bauer himself, Kiefer Sutherland. I was, of course, shocked at the news that Hayter would be replaced. I understood that Kojima wanted to take the series in a new direction with this game, and I trusted him enough that his choice for the new actor would be a good one. When it was officially announced that Kiefer would be lending his voice to Big Boss this time, my initial reaction was that of elation. "Combining Jack Bauer with Big Boss?!?! That's freaking awesome!!" Reactions on Twitter and across the interwebs seemed to be about 50/50. Some people loved it, others started petitions to get Kiefer removed and Hayter placed back in the starring role. At E3, we got out first taste of Kiefer, during the trailer which showed Big Boss rescuing Kaz from a camp in Afghanistan. The very second I heard "Kaz... It's me...", I instantly became concerned. Kiefer's voice was the exact same as Jack Bauer. Same cadence, same tone, same everything. I immediately began to worry that I would not be able to get past the voice that I hear, and lose myself in the experience of MGS V as I have been able to in previous games. This seems to be very similar to how so many have reacted to Ben Affleck being announced as the next Batman. People worry that they won't be able to separate the character from the actor playing it, that they will be watching the movie only thinking, "That's Ben Affleck in a Batman costume" instead of just accepting the character. Recent reports of the gameplay demo for the English version of the Ground Zeroes portion have claimed that Kiefer seems to just be "phoning in" his performance as Big Boss. If this turns out to be true, the game could be ruined because of it. As much as I am worried about Kiefer's performance, there is one thing that worries me above all others...

1. New Snake

Punished The conspiracy theories seemed to begin the instant that the name Punished Snake appeared on the E3 trailer. As I mentioned earlier, conspiracy theorists were quick to jump to the conclusion that this Snake was not actually Big Boss in the Phantom Pain portion of the title. The actual identity for Snake was theorised to be Gray Fox, or Decoy Octopus, or a previously unknown clone of Big Boss, or Solidus Snake, or the incredibly ridiculous theory that it could actually be Major Zero in disguise. That last entry is so crazy and nonsensical, that I don't even think Kojima would come up with it. I personally think these theories are completely off-base as I can't fathom why Kojima would release a game that will chronicle the descent of Big Boss into villainy, without allowing us to actually play as Big Boss through the entirety of the game. This game doesn't require any tricks or misdirections like this; the content of the story to be told is more than compelling enough all by itself. But what if I'm wrong? What if this character really is someone other than Big Boss? What if Kojima thinks it has been way too long since he completely screwed with the gaming world when Raiden was revealed in MGS 2? For me personally, this would be the biggest letdown that I could ever remember related to video games. We as fans have gone on such a journey with the Metal Gear series of games. Our journey with Big Boss started with his time as a young and inexperienced soldier who was seemingly betrayed by the one person who meant more to him than any other. We witnessed his utter despair and hopelessness when the truth about The Boss was revealed to him by EVA. We saw him eventually accept the title of Big Boss when he concluded, at the end of Peace Walker, that The Boss really did betray him when she laid down her gun. And now, with The Phantom Pain, we are to take the final steps of his journey that will show the events that turned him into the monster we met in the original Metal Gear. If all that is thrown out the window, and we are instead controlling another character while Big Boss continues to recover from his coma or something to that effect, that will really end up being the nail in the coffin for this game. I really do hope that everything mentioned here will not come to pass, and that we will end up with the ultimate Metal Gear experience from this title. If not, Hideo Kojima may completely isolate the fan-base of one of the best series of all time. What do you think? Should we be worried about Metal Gear Solid V? Let me know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Loving father. Sports fanatic. Lyrical genius. Metal Gear Savant. Just your typical all around ball of awesomeness.