Nintendo’s 10 Biggest Failures EVER

Looking at the biggest blunders that Nintendo wants you to forget about.

Mario wii u
Nintendo

Starting as a card-selling company in 1889, Nintendo changed forever during the 1970s when the president at the time, Hiroshi Yamauchi, decided to focus on video games. Cut to 2020 and Nintendo has become a gaming juggernaut, having sold five billion games and over 750 million consoles.

Due to the versatility of the Switch, as well as its vast choice of stellar games, the future is looking bright.

As easy as it is to praise the company, Nintendo have made some poor business decisions over the years. Due to mismanagement, short-sightedness, and underestimating the competition, Nintendo has helped their rivals, turned themselves into a laughing stock, and lost billions of dollars.

Obviously, nobody is infallible. If you have to maintain a billion-dollar organisation with countless workers all over the world, mistakes are guaranteed.

Making mistakes is completely acceptable so long as you learn from it. Also, it's tough to maintain success when you're up against steady competition like Sony and Microsoft. But many times, Nintendo caused more damage to their company than their rivals ever could have.

In order for Nintendo to stay on top-form, they need to acknowledge their mistakes to ensure they never EVER do anything this stupid again.

10. Stopping Sales Of The NES Classic

Nes Classic
Nintendo

After the failure of the Wii U, Nintendo rushed out the Switch as soon as they could. Despite the fact the company only worked on it for two years, the Switch became the fastest-selling console in Nintendo's history.

However, the Switch could have come out earlier. Although it was released in March 2017, it was supposed to be available for Christmas 2016. Nintendo didn't want to lose potential sales during the busiest time of the year so they released a mini-version of the NES with 30 games pre-installed that November. The NES Classic did extremely well, selling 3.6 million units in 18 months.

The console seemed like a dream for the nostalgic fans but it had some problems. The controller cord was too short, there were some emulation glitches, and the sound was a bit iffy on certain games. Fans assumed Nintendo would fix these errors with a patch and develop updates for the console so consumers could download new games.

But once the Switch was released, Nintendo decided to fully concentrate on it, abandoning development on the NES Classic. Fans were so outraged, Nintendo decided to reproduce the NES Classic in June 2018. Sadly, development stopped again six months later.


9. Overturning Decisions On The SNES Classic

SNES Classic
Nintendo

If you thought Nintendo learned the error of their ways on how the NES Classic was mishandled, guess again.

Six months after the Switch launched, the company released the SNES Classic; a mini-version of the Super Nintendo. It came with 21 pre-installed games including Starfox 2; a game that was never officially released before. Fans wanted to get their nostalgic fix and so, bought the console in droves.

So how did Nintendo screw this up? Well, because the NES Classic was a success, the company assumed this console would have similar sales. However, the SNES Classic sold almost double the amount, meaning Nintendo couldn't keep up with demand.

Thousands of consumers pre-ordered the SNES Classic on Walmart even though there wasn't enough consoles to go around. This forced Nintendo to cancel Walmart orders, much to the company's embarrassment.

This made gamers so frustrated, hackers were emulating their own games on the SNES Classic and selling the consoles at bootleg auctions, which damaged Nintendo's reputation.

As with the NES Classic, Nintendo believed it was in their best interest to focus on the Switch and decided to cancel development on the SNES Classic in December 2018.


8. Not Playing Ball With Developers

nintendo wii u
Nintendo

On most Nintendo platforms, the most successful games are the ones developed by the company itself such as Mario and The Legend of Zelda. One reason why Nintendo doesn't have many third-party developers is because they're expected them to jump through all sorts of hoops.

During the Wii U's era, Nintendo expected indie developers to have a permanent physical office or they would not be considered. This seems like an unfair and hypocritical stipulation since many of the biggest companies started out in a garage or a warehouse including Microsoft and a little company called Nintendo!!

Since Nintendo has a family-friendly image, they usually don't port violent games on their systems, even if they are compatible. Nintendo do this out of principle but it makes them lose potential sales. When they have embraced more mature content, it usually works in their favour. R-rated games like Resident Evil 4 and Bayonetta 2 started off as Nintendo exclusives and were considered among the best games on their respective consoles.

The Switch has far more third-party developers, which is one of the main reasons for the console's success. It's just a shame Nintendo didn't realise the importance of playing ball with other companies sooner.


7. Underestimating Online Capabilities

Playstation Plus Nintendo Online
Sony/Nintendo

The Sega Dreamcast was the first mainstream console to have online capability. The console tanked but Sony realised that the Internet was the way of the future and so, made the PlayStation 2 online-compatible. Nintendo, on the other hand, saw the internet as a fad.

Although the PS2 could use the internet, it focused more on its games and its DVD capability. But when Microsoft set up Xbox Live, popularising remote multiplayer, Sony got their head in the game and released the PlayStation Network Adapter with several online titles. Sony may have been a bit late with embracing the internet but when they did, their sales went up.

However, Nintendo did nothing of the sort with their console at the time, the Gamecube, which is one of the reasons it didn't sell well. While developing the Gamecube's successor, the Wii, Nintendo finally came to their senses and allowed the console to have online compatibility.

The most ironic thing is that the Nintendo Entertainment System, which was released in 1983, was meant to have online capability!

It's bizarre that Nintendo could have been the first computers to go online and yet, they were one of the last consoles to embrace the internet.


6. Marketing The Wii U

nintendo Wii u
Nintendo

The Wii sold over a hundred million units, making it the most successful Nintendo console ever. As a result, the successor for the Wii was hyped beyond measure.

But when the Wii U was unveiled, many people were left confused. Because the trailer marketed the Wii U so vaguely, consumers didn’t know if it was a different version of the Wii, a new console, an add-on, or a new controller. (I was one of those people.)

To give you an idea on how badly the Wii U sold, let's look at its replacement. By the end of 2019, the Switch sold over 52 million. Nintendo only sold 13.56 million Wii Us in its five-year life cycle. The Switch sold more units in ten months than the Wii U did in its entirety.

Mario Kart 8 was the most successful game on the Wii U, selling eight million units. The Switch version of the game, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, sold over double that in 18 months.

The fact that the Switch allowed Nintendo to recover in terms of sales and reputation is incredible. Nevertheless, the Wii U will go down as the worst-selling mainstream Nintendo console in history.


5. The Super Mario Bros. Film

Super Mario Bros. Film Bob Hoskins John Leguizamo
Buena Vista Pictures

When Nintendo announced their mascot, Super Mario, was going to be the first video game character to receive a film adaption, fans couldn't contain their excitement. At first, it looked promising. It had a great cast including Bob Hoskins as Mario, John Leguizamo as Luigi, and Dennis Hopper as King Koopa.

What could possible go wrong? Everything. Everything could go wrong. The film had three directors who couldn't agree on what direction to take the story. Despite the fact they were adapting a children's game, one of the directors "shot scenes with strippers and with other sexually-explicit content, which all got edited out anyway" according to Leguizamo.

Bob Hoskins said Super Mario Bros. was the worst thing he ever did. He got stabbed four times and had his finger broken while shooting a scene. Hoskins got so frustrated, he used to get drunk in-between scenes. He never learned his lines because the script changed every day.

This film is directly responsible with studios associating "video game adaptations" with "box-office poison".

Ironically, the first video game adaption to perform well financially and critically was Pokemon: Detective Pikachu, which was the first film adaption based on Nintendo's property in 26 years.


4. Creating Its Competition

Playstation Nintendo
Sony/Nintendo

The PlayStation only exists because of Nintendo.

Nintendo and Sony were supposed to create the Nintendo 64 together. While devising the N64 though, CDs were becoming popular because they could hold 300 times more data than a cartridge.

This posed a problem since Nintendo wanted to stick with cartridges because CDs made games have loading times and blocky graphics. If Final Fantasy VII was on the N64, it would have needed 13 cartridges! Realising that the companies wanted different things, Sony left the partnership and formed their own console.

The Nintendo 64 was a success, selling 32.93 million units, released 388 games, and made some ground-breaking platformers including Super Mario 64 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

Although that sounds like quite an achievement, the PSOne sold a staggering 102.49 million units, making it the first console to sell over a hundred million.

Because CDs are cheaper and easier to manufacture, the console pumped out 2,418 games during its cycle. Its successor, the PS2, sold 155 million units, making it the best-selling console of all time.

Nintendo also refused to compromise with Sony, creating their greatest business rival - a mistake they have been paying for ever since.


3. The Legend Of Zelda For Philips' CD-I

legend of zelda wand of gamelon
Nintendo

Nintendo are infamous for how protective they are of their properties. This is why gamers were so confused when they allowed an obscure company, Phillips, make multiple games based on one of their most prized properties, The Legend of Zelda. Why would Nintendo do such a risky move?

Well, after Nintendo and Sony's deal to produce a console collapsed, Sony decided to create their own disc-based system. Nintendo wanted to get a leg up on their competition and so, partnered with the CD-based company, Phillips.

Because of the power of Nintendo's brand, the company believed the Philips CD-I system would wipe the floor with Sony if its games had iconic characters like Link and Zelda. As a result, Nintendo commissioned Philips to make three games based on the Legend of Zelda franchise.

Sadly, the CD-I Zelda games are considered among the worst games in history due to their appalling mechanics, game-breaking glitches, and atrocious animations.

Nintendo's partnership with Philips dissolved and the system was discontinued in 1998. The whole ordeal was such a travesty, it made Nintendo distrust producing games for a CD-based system.

Speaking of which...


2. The 64DD

64dd 64 dd
Nintendo

During the late 1990s and early millennium, the Sega Saturn, Dreamcast, and PlayStation popularised CD-based games. Nintendo stuck to their guns and developed the cartridge-based Nintendo 64. Although the Saturn and Dreamcast tanked, the PlayStation proved CDs were on the way to replace cartridges.

Realising they underestimated the efficiency of CDs, Nintendo created an add-on for the N64 called the 64 Disc Drive (64DD) that used discs instead of cartridges. This device was released in December 1999 in Japan; three years after the released of the N64.

Compared to a cartridge, the 64DD disc could hold more content, had an easier production, and was cheaper to manufacture. Super Mario creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, announced 20 games for the 64DD including Donkey Kong 64, The Legend of Zelda, and Super Mario 64.

Despite the fact the 64DD could hold more than a cartridge, it still couldn't compete with regular CD. A 64DD disc could hold 64MB. At the time, a regular CD could hold ten times that.

CDs were also easier and cheaper to produce. Releasing they couldn't compete, Nintendo cancelled the 64DD after only releasing nine games.


1. The Virtual Boy

Mario Clash Virtual Boy
Nintendo

The Virtual Boy was the brain-child of Gunpei Yokoi. Since Yokoi was the creator of the Game Boy and the D-Pad, the console seemed to be in safe hands.

To use the Virtual Boy, the player placed their head in a mounted-display to see the game they wished to play (similar to the Oculus Rift).

This console was ahead of its time... and that was the problem. The Virtual Boy is a great idea. It just wasn't ready when it was released in 1995.

You see, the problem that Nintendo couldn't get around (and many VR systems still struggle with today) is a phenomenon called "vestibular and visual mismatches". In laymen's terms, this is when you think you are moving when you are not, which confuses the brain.

If that sounds bad, it gets worse.

Vestibular and visual mismatching is a symptom of getting poisoned. When people played the Virtual Boy, it activated the "You Have Been Poisoned" section of the brain, causing players to vomit uncontrollably.

Okay, the Wii U didn't sell well... but it didn't make gamers puke all over the place. The Virtual Boy sold a feeble 770,000 copies, making it the most unsuccessful Nintendo console ever.


In this post: 
Nintendo
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows