PES 2015: 10 Improvements Konami Must Make

A good year for PES, but what is needed to make this great game a FIFA beater?

Pro Evolution Soccer has had an illustrious time in the gaming industry. There are scarcely any better football games out there when the Konami-made-juggernaught is on the top of its game, but over the last few instalments, PES has suffered from a poor transition; from the PS2 days to the PS3/360 era. The last instalment, PES 2014, started something with the move over to the Hideo Kojima (Creator of Metal Gear) developed engine known as the Fox Engine, and this year has seen the game grow into a genuine FIFA beater and one that already develops a debatably better game of football than its flashier counterpart. But there are still so many areas that PES is lacking and which need to be improved if the once all conquering PES is to retain its footballing crown again. Looking at the ten biggest suggestions, you could argue that none of the features mentioned make up a brilliant game on the pitch, which is what PES has always been exceptional at, but with FIFA reaching superb merchandising deals (using the FIFA engine for replays on Sky Sports Football coverage is ingenious) and turning the game into a brand, there is much work for the Japanese giant to do in order to catch up. And it's not all about the pitch.

10. Defenders AI

One thing that isn€™t immediately obvious, but it€™s one thing that grows into something rather important is the AI of the defenders. In fact, you could argue it€™s the team as a whole, and this isn€™t limited to just your team as the opposition suffer as well. There is a fine line between realism and fun and that€™s the thing that Konami have always seemed to balance correctly but this year, the defenders just seem extra dumb. Early crosses can fly in to a centre forward who is completely unmarked for easy headers. The centre backs fail to close down any high ball. And most annoyingly, if a ball is played into the box they will often wait to launch the ball instead of heading the ball, allowing any swift striker or midfielder to simply nod the ball in. This is fine every once in a while as it adds to the elements of mistakes, but when it starts happening every ten minutes or so - on the hardest difficulty - it starts to really grate. On the back of that, opposition AI have a knack of reading your mind and also being in the right place at the right time no matter what direction they are facing or what ability they are, though that might be more in line with number five on this list.

9. Editing Suite

In the late PS3 days, the editing suite was the most powerful tool available to any PES fan. Finally, the screams of €˜Come on North London!€™ could be drowned out with screams of the real team names. Teams walked out draped in sponsorship that fans are used to seeing week in and week out and despite the argument that purists play the game for how it handles, it has always disgruntled every PES fan to see that no difference has been made in the licensing area. So imagine the surprise when the newest addition to the PES family has had its editing suite entirely ripped apart. Some blame has to lay at Sony and Microsoft's door for this one as the PS4/Xbox One are still stopping users from uploading their own photos, therefore disallowing the creation of kits to lay over the top of the fake ones in the PES games. But why didn't they use a bit of imagination? Why couldn't they have papered over the lack of editing by introducing a system similar to that done by the previous WWE games? The introduction of a pixel editor - like the old fashioned PS2 games - where clever people can create the logos themselves and then share them across a central HUB would have been the perfect answer. Players could download the newest kits and due to it not being done by Konami, forgo the copyright and licensing laws. Anything would be better than the streamlined version of the suite this year.

8. Sloppy Menus

Konami are not a small developer: they are one of the few giants of the Japanese industry still remaining viable in an increasingly hostile market and yet one thing they just cannot seem to get right is their menus. This year has seen a slight improvement. Now very similar in terms to FIFA, the main menu acts as a kind of pin system where you can pin the most recent or most used option on the front screen allowing instant access. Now, that sounds like improvement, but delve into the menu€™s more and it is once again the same blocky, standard appearance that has adorned the previous ten PES games. Again, does this really matter in a game based around on pitch realism? You could argue not, but take one look at FIFA€™s menus and then a look at PES and it's clear to see where the class is. Stylish and modern menus help show that this game was crafted to perfection throughout, and PES shows signs of a developer stuck in the past.

7. Restricted Movement

A difficult one to describe but infuriating all the same. Imagine the scenario: a looping long ball has gone over the top of the defensive line and Andy Carrol has blasted through the defence (it is a game remember). Two centre backs watch as the ball floats over. Holding R1 to increase the speed of the defenders should allow the player to get alongside Carrol, physically intimidate him, barge him - anything really to upset his flow. However, what actually happens is that the centre back runs slower than ever before, as if suddenly a wall of treacle is now covering him from head to toe. Carrol, seemingly unopposed by this wall of treacle, controls the ball and slots it home. Inevitably, you're in danger of destroying your controller at this point. This is not something that happens often, but it is enough that it is noticeable by the player and that is the issue. It feels as if the player controlled is scripted to NOT reach the ball; as if Carroll is pre-destined to control this ball and run on, instantly dragging any player out of the immersion they were feeling. Freedom of movement has been improved so much over the years, but some work remains and this is the last place to focus on.

6. Flashy Presentation

A goal flies into the back of the net, a wonder strike from the players centre midfielder who they brought through the youth system and built their team around. It's so good that it will be regarded as brilliant as the Beckham half way line goal. The player runs off in celebration€ kind of. Because let€™s face it, they never really look like they are celebrating: it's more running around with their arms in the air and mouths open wide. It's all a bit comically rubbish. Win a major competition and you receive a cut scene made up of the most awkward wooden poses that a video game character has ever made. When a player wins a game like that, or scores a goal like that, they want to feel the passion; that the team has done something utterly amazing. Players want the team to parade around the pitch with the trophy, bringing their kids onto the pitch, streams and streams of colourful paper flying around the place. Players wants to see the manager and the back room staff on there too. It is this kind of flashy presentation and feel for the euphoria of the sport that Konami seem to completely miss. Seeing PES and its group of players walk up to a cardboard cut-out stadium fans with a single flare going off is not a celebration. The game needs more epic.

5. The Bias System

Hinted at already in other parts of the game is the bias system that Konami every year swear that they have removed or that never existed. Nobody who actually plays the game believes this for one second. Again, it€™s something that happens infrequently but it€™s something that when it's felt (rather than seen), it drags players out of the immersion. Players will always understand that the other team may get a boost from a crunching tackle, they may have a close chance from a mistake or hit the bar... But there is no excuse for a team to one minute be playing like Arsenal in the invincible year to playing like Arsenal now and for nothing to work that happened without a hitch just moments before. It feels scripted, as if no matter how good the player is or how good the team the player controls is, the opposition WILL score. Passes no longer reach the right people; the opposition are first to the second ball and everything drops too easily to them. They might claim it's been dealt with, but it really doesn't feel like it.

4. Expand My Club

One of the real positives this year has been the introduction of the My Club game mode that focusses on building a team of players by buying and selling with in-game points or real money and developing the best team the player can. The whole thing screams of Ultimate Team from FIFA and it probably is a reaction to that mode but with a few different twists. Adding in agents and manager that have to be worked with correctly in order to get the best benefit is carefully integrated making it feel quite fresh despite being based on something else. What needs to happen here however, is that the next version is expanded upon. This is without a shadow of a doubt a great response to the FIFA UT, but more is needed. Keep the momentum going and push it far more than ever before. It€™s a good mode that needs tweaking and a bit of work but it will pay off if they invest sufficient time.

3. Online Lag

In the days of offline multiplayer there was nothing more important or more competitive than PES. It was the dinnertime game, it was the 'just one more match' game and was the cause of many arguments between friends. What has happened to that? Of course most games now are online with local multiplayer always given short thrift with the amount of split screen games now in single figures. PES should have been able to conquer the world of online easily and yet they didn€™t, and it's because of lag. The early online PES matches were an absolute mess and in all honesty, the game still isn€™t much better. This is 2015 and no matter what service you play the game on, whether Xbox or Playstation, the internet service is charged for. Lag shouldn€™t be accepted or even seen (unless on rare unavoidable situations) and PES is jam-packed full of lag, disconnections and random bugs that force you to quit and lose points. For an immersive online experience, that simply cannot continue.

2. Master League

It€™s the heart of the game; the mode where a player can buy and sell footballers. Build a team and bring them through the leagues to be champions of Europe, or South America or Asia and it's still the place to be for PES players. But come on Konami, it€™s the same league as last year. The menus are almost the same, the idea is the same, and there's precious little that is actually new here. There's also a lot of pointless stuff in there. Having to create a manager likeness suggested we'd get to see him on the touchline barking orders, but despite spending twenty minutes or so getting the likeness right they're never actually seen again. What about pre and post-match interviews with this avatar the player meticulously created? What happened to unveiling new signings at a press conference? And then there's the silly little cut scenes that made players feel like part of the club. Even seeing the manager profile ordering players around on the training pitch in the background has disappeared over the years replaced with a shot of the stock stadium used for a players club of choice. In short, Master League needs an enormous overhaul. In PES 2012 it looked like they had started it by adding in purchasing items to improve players, short cut scenes when a player was unhappy and pressure from the chairman to play certain players they liked. This has all gone, replaced with a soulless shell of a game that just expects its fans to play the next game, then the next, then the next with nothing in between. This is the one place FIFA has PES by the neck and one place PES really needs to get right on its next release.

1. Licensing

It had to be licensing didn€™t it? If there is one thing that Konami need to do (as difficult or as expensive as it is) is to get more real kits and players into the game. The shocking lack of Premier League teams is astonishing and no amount of Argentinian and Brazilian teams will change that. Factor in a lack of international kits, stadiums and sponsors and the game looks so unattractive it's very easy to see all the good work of the pitch based play coming to nothing as the PES arm goes under. Fans of the genre will surely hope not as its clear that many fans much prefer a game of PES to a game of FIFA. But unless Konami work on all these factors, there will be a real struggle to keep this ailing series going for much longer. What€™s worse than having no PES in the world of gaming? It's FIFA having no competition and therefore no need to improve. And that is a sobering thought. What else do you think Konami need to improve for the next PES? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread

In this post: 
PES 2015
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

What's to tell people? I am a middle aged Yorkshireman obsessed with Bad Religion, The Simpsons, movies and anything to do with gaming. I love everything to do with Final Fantasy, Metal Gear and will hold a discussion with anyone about anything in games.