Ranking EVERY Fallout Game From Worst To Best
Wait... is the best Fallout game NOT made by Bethesda?
War. War never changes.
It's a phrase that's become embedded into the minds of nearly every Fallout fan thanks to it's Ron Perlman boosted grit, but when actually applied to the franchise itself, couldn't be further from the truth.
Across it's tenure the Fallout games have wildly mutated from a top down isometric perspective, to first person open world odyssey and even jumping ship to mobile games for good measure. And while the series is still beloved thanks to it's surgical use of dark comedy, outstanding lore and a mind-melting amount of choices, this desire to keep pushing the boundaries has sometimes resulted in Brahman dung.
And seeing as we're spending time in our own personal vaults, why not cast a judging eye over the pack and separate the true Glowing Ones, from those synths simply pretending to be true Fallout classics?
11. Fallout 76 (2018 Launch Edition)
I don't think there will be many who oppose the launch version of Fallout 76 placing as the worst game in the franchise as to be blunt, this game was utter garbage when it dropped in 2018.
It feels like beating a dead horse at this point, but the list of issues with this game were long. From enemies adopting a deadly T-pose at any given moment, rewards not being doled out to players, the incessant bloom lighting, a hilarious discovery that looking at the floor made you run faster because the game could load quicker, and of course, players exploiting nuclear weapon codes. The latter would sometimes fail to reset and if used, crash the entire server.
It was hilarious for those on the outside looking in, but a nightmare for players wanting more.
This was a risky move for Bethesda in the first place, choosing to take a single player focused game online, but they promised us "it just works". However when the company couldn't even provide a duffel bag to it's loyal customers, it was clear that it was a case of "actually... it really doesn't"
10. Fallout: Brotherhood Of Steel
In the dark period between Fallout 2 and the reinvention of the franchise with Fallout 3, there existed a lull where two games bearing very similar names crawled out of the vaults below.
One, which I'll detail later, was a glorious approach to tactical combat in the vein of the Commandos series of games, and the other...well the other was Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel, a top down dungeon crawler with a post apocalyptic theme that absolutely nuked itself when it dropped on the Ps2 and original Xbox in 2001.
Simply put, this isn't a fallout game. At best it's a hack n'slash affair with the most minimal of nods towards it's own franchise. If you cut the Fallout name from this title I'd not even be able to tell, and thanks to it's insipid controls and dire fighting, it's not one you'd even want to play regardless.
It's a real shame as this game uses the same engine as Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance, which is a truly great top down experience. However this feels like anything decent has been irradiated or rusted away into a game that is a shallow pretender hiding in the shadow of the Fallout licence.
9. Fallout Pinball Table - Zen Pinball 2
Ok, listen.
I'm not going to get many other chances to talk about the fact that a Fallout 4 themed pinball table exists and while I know that this isn't a "main entry" title it quite literally is a Fallout game.
It's a shame that this table, while looking the absolute business and possessing some truly interesting concepts, doesn't feel all that fun to play through. I am not a pinball expert, but the balancing act of keeping an eye literally on the ball while being fed missions and important information in a small box in the top left of the screen, really was quite challenging.
However personal skill level aside, the stop and start gameplay was something that critics took umbrage with as it completely interrupted the flow of an otherwise decent pinball table.
The gimmick of building a character with RPG stats which grew depending on your playstyle is great on paper, but in delivery this meant a lot of cycling through menus and visiting areas you didn't have the caps for. It's not a bad game by any stretch, it just tries to hard to keep to the strengths of the mainline series for it to truly feel like a decent pinball game.
8. Fallout 76 (2020 Update)
You may wonder why I've split one game into two entries, but honestly I feel like for all the stick that Fallout 76 has gotten (and rightly so) the 2020 iteration has improved by such an extent that it does feel like a new game.
It's still not a great game, but it as a better one.
You'll still encounter ridiculous bugs and glitches, framerate issues, crashes and some instances where you'll be thinking you've somehow managed to port the "Wild Wasteland" perk into your game, but there have been significant improvements in other areas.
Now, instead of a world populated only by other players, NPC's have arrived to make the world feel more fleshed out, and give a sense of familiarity that the playerbase was pining for and providing a bit of feedback on choices that you'll end up making. The code is marginally more stable as well, meaning that you might actually hit your intended target (not something to brag about but at least it's more stable), and enemies aren't as bullet spongy as they were.
There's still a long way to go however; from the in game economy, slow weapon reloads, extreme bottlenecking, and the slog from level 10 to 20 (which might well distance anyone who gives this a second chance), but in this iteration Fallout 76 is in a place where it's turning, slowly, into the game players wanted it to be from the off.
7. Fallout: Shelter
During the 2015 E3 press conference Todd Howard took to the stage and promised us something unique was headed to the Fallout universe. He claimed it would be a new way to interact with everyone's beloved bomb shelter based franchise, and before anyone could start thinking "jeez this sounds like the same way he announced Fallout 76" he uttered the games title, Fallout Shelter.
Now to be frank, the mobile video game marketplace is very much like the Fallout Wasteland due to the fact that asset flip, cash grabbing, and despicably aggressive micro transaction trash can be found wherever you look, and despite this titles also rather desperate grabs at our bottle cap stash, Fallout Shelter is a truly fun game to play.
The way that the title sprinkles in links to the wider franchise is really well done, brekaing up the micromanaging that so many other titles of the same ilk have done with missions to complete and light RPG progression.
Now, not only do you have to keep your dwellers happy and fed, but also repel raider invasions or Radroach infestations and besides hitting some very ardous pay walls is a very smooth experience.
Its biggest criticism could probably be that the end game isn't very well defined and you'll soon max out a vault without even realising why you wanted to do this in the first place.
6. Fallout 4
When the first trailer for Fallout 4 dropped, fans across the world could feel a strange magnetic pull forcing their wallets open. After all this was the same game that we knew and loved, with a brand new graphics engine, a huge new open expanse to explore, and for the first time ever voice acting for our protagonist.
And yet for many it was this last feature that actually proved to be a root cause for a lot of this games problems. Fallout 4 is in no way a bad game, the action was spot on and the shooting mechanics had finally been hammered out into a decent FPS experience. The characters felt rounded and in the case of allies such as Nick Valentine and Strong, became internet darlings overnight.
However it was the complete reinvention of the dialogue tree that many held issue with as inestead of actually showcasing what the player was going to say, only gave a general indication of their intent. This lead to humerous and downright infuriating experiences where you'd act totally against the character you were trying to play. And when you're talking about a game with hundreds of hours of potential gameplay, that's a lot of instances where you're straying from your intended play through without even meaning to.
The pros are apparent; it looks great, feels better to control than ever before, and carries some truly impressive set pieces, but for diehard fans it was hard to overlook a key feature being downplayed in favour of becoming an action-oriented game.
5. Fallout Tactics: Brotherhood Of Steel
As a huge fan of RTS games and permanatly sporting a Fat Man in my trousers for anything X-Com adjacent of course I was in love with Fallout Tactics: Brotherhood Of Steel when it released.
However it is a bit of a black sheep when compared to the rest of the flock. After all going from an open world, non linear narrative to a much more tightly scripted, squad based management focus is always going to be an interesting gear shift. However for those willing to try something new Fallout Tactics is a strong, fully realised title with a confidence that is at once challenging and incredibly charming.
Telling the tale of a new Brotherhood Of Steel initiate, you get to explore sections of nuclear scorched earth while directing a team of specialists. This balancing act of know when to use which character coupled with an ever increasing horde of enemies can be overwhelming at first, but thanks to the game's admittedly brilliant narrative you'll be hopping in the power armour and crushing heads again and again with wanton abandon.
4. Fallout
The moment that defined a franchise. The first foray into the desolate Wasteland that we all know and love. The original fallout is truly a wonder of design and a love letter to a time when player choice didn't just mean picking between two options.
It still boggles my mind to this day how much content is packed into this game; the areas are densely detailed with rich characters, an absurd amount of side missions, and nuanced dialogue that allows you to shape any type of character you wish.
From chem-addicted hot head all the way to lobotomised strong man, you can approach the same mission from so many ways that it's impossible not to fall in love with the original Fallout.
And what makes this game even more S.P.E.C.I.A.L is that it dropped in the late 90's, a time when many critics were predicting the death of traditional RPG's in the face of online multiplayer, and still managed to become a standout in both sales and review scores.
Don't be put off by the ageing graphics, because Fallout's gameplay shines just as bright as a Nuka Cola Quantum.
3. Fallout 3
Depending on who you ask, Fallout 3 was either the most innovative game in the franchise for it's brave reinvention of the series' approach to combat and world storytelling, or it's the game that chased action over narrative and felt like a lesser RPG for it's efforts.
Im firmly in the former camp as even though I loved the original two Interplay developed games, it's impossible to deny how immersive and chaotic Bethesda's Fallout 3 is.
Witnessing the wasteland in first person is a true (if slightly disgusting looking) joy, and while the VATS system might act as a "get out of jail free" card more often than not, the move to a more mainstream FPS combat was the smartest choice for a series looking to capture a wider audience.
And it succeeded greatly in hitting it's goals as Fallout 3 went on to be a sales juggernaut hitting over 10 million copies sold worldide by 2015, and critical praise booming in it's wake.
Simplifying the controls while still pushing a brilliant dialogue tree system proved to be the perfect balance between the old and the new. It's just a shame that the actual aiming of the weapons was a little haphazard.
2. Fallout 2
Fallout 2 is a sequel done right.
The weight of expectations for this game was enormous, after all how do you take something already bursting at the seams with critical praise and outstanding content and improve on it?
Well somehow Interplay managed to pull this off, making the world map bigger, unearthing tonnes of new horrors to face and expanding the dialogue branches of this title so much that it resembled a rainforest by the end of things.
It's not just a case of more of the same either, because the new narrative depth allowed for even more nuanced characters and it meant that some moral choices truly were arduous as every party involved had justifiable reasons for their actions and demands.
Elsewhere the tweaks and fixes managed to elevate an already great game into something truly outstanding, wiping clean the slate of bugs and item management issues from the first and making things feel more accessible than ever without compromising on depth.
It's easy to see why some fans were disappointed with the shift to 3rd/1st Person in Fallout 3 because here, Fallout 2 perfected the formula the original had put in place.
1. Fallout: New Vegas
New Vegas was written off unfairly when trailers of it dropped, as people seemed to assume that such a short turnaround between this game and Fallout 3 wouldn't ammount to much more than a "3.5" experience at best.
Oh how wrong the doubters were.
Fallout: New Vegas is to the "new generation" of Fallout games what Fallout 2 was to the original. It expands, refines and recasts the mould of what it is to be a Fallout experience in such a way that it's a masterclass of immersion and design.
Every area of the game has been ramped up, the action feels more kinetic, the horror elements have been dialled up to skin crawling levels, and the environment of New Vegas is so well realised that even the seemingly empty stretches of desert feel deadly and teeming with secrets.
Coupled with this some of the best written characters and choices in the franchise and add in the fact that The Courier is easily the greatest protagonist in the series (finally a character who existed outside of a vault so actually would understand caps being used as currency and the like) and you have an experience that bet on black and came up trumps.
And not a jot of it was made by Bethesda. Funny how The Outer Worlds, also by Obsidian, did so well, isn't it?