Ranking Every Quantic Dream Game From Worst To Best

Heavy Rain vs. Detroit Become Human vs. Indigo Prophecy vs...

Detroit Become Human
Sony

Developer David Cage with his Quantic Dream studios have been on an ambitious one-studio mission from the jump; to blend the movie and game experience into a gratifying hybrid experience.

Love it or hate it, the fuss they made eventually created ripples; there’d be no Telltale’s The Walking Dead, Until Dawn, or Life Is Strange without their resurrection of what LucasArts started. In fact, the ‘interactive movie’ sub-genre of the adventure game has become its standard... instead of the weird experiment it was initially laughed off as.

Still, despite the innovation, it's not all peaches; Cage, in particular, has the habit of earning many gamers' rage. His high-fluting dismissing of ‘regular games’ (e.g. everything else) has annoyed many, as well as his flawed storytelling and overhyped games mechanics. Also, in 2018, there was a mess of controversy surrounding Quantic Dream as a ‘toxic’ work environment as well.

Regardless, that year also saw the release of their recent venture, Detroit: Become Human; a game that has been championed by gamers and fellow developers more than actual critics - leading to their most profitable project to date.

There’s no better time then, to look back and sort through their eclectic backlog from this divisive (but always interesting) studio.

5. Omikron: The Nomad Soul (1999)

Omikron The Nomad Soul Screenshot_1280 0 0
Quantic Dream

Unless you are a diehard David Bowie fan, this first effort by Cage and Quantic Dream has likely not registered on your radar - and is the only venture from them not in the ‘interactive movie’ mould. Instead, Omikron is a messy blend of every genre that was popular back in 1999.

First the good though; it is bursting with exciting concepts and plot points, with its cyber-punk open-world vibrantly filled with rich lore. The plot itself has enough cool twists and turns as well, with some radical breaking-the-fourth-wall mechanics that are impressive for its time.

Now, the bad; the beyond dated graphics and controls are a given - but the shoehorning of FPS and combat fighter segments are random and handle absolutely atrocious. Also, like many Cage games, the enthusiasm for his ideas are not paid off in a satisfactory and competent fashion.

It really must be said though, the late and great Bowie not only composed the stellar soundtrack but also helped build the story and world elements, plus voiced acted two characters. If you're a completist of the late artist, the game is a must - at least, for curiosity sake.


4. Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy (2005)

fahrenheit indigo prophecy opening intro level murder
Quantic Dream

This was Quantic's first foray into creating a new type of gaming experience; it earns respect as the sub-genres brave baby steps - even if it stumbles all over the place.

The plot is quite fun for the first two thirds, holding an enticing level of zany unpredictability with the gamer never sure what movie genre Cage will throw at us; Hitcockian rollercoaster, psychological thriller, cop murder mystery, supernatural horror - heck, even Matrix-style action movie. Sadly, it all crumbles in the third act, unable to answer the billion questions its plot proposes and decays into ridiculous nonsense.

Gameplay-wise it's painfully misguided; the QTA sequences slap a confusing colour-wheel over the screen as major things are happening - forcing you to click buttons in random sequence instead of reflecting what is actually occurring. It literally makes some parts downright unplayable and is a total contrast to the 'immersive' cinematic experience they were going for.

The game itself is no doubt a ground-breaking experience, with the championed cult status leaving a major mark on the industry till this day - yet judging it in retrospect and on its own merits, it’s just not a rewarding or enjoyable experience.


3. Beyond: Two Souls (2013)

Beyond Two Souls Ellen Page
Quantic Dream

Quantic has felt like a studio consistently improving and refining itself with every game - asides from this effort which was a stumble backwards after Heavy Rain.

Not technically though, as the performance capture and graphics are jaw-dropping. In fact, it is incredible to think this is only a PS3 game and not current-gen.

Also, Cage remedied Rain’s amateur cast by getting an A-list ensemble here; Ellen Page is strong as the troubled lead, and its fun to see the petit indie darling take on an action-heroine type role. The support is great with Willem Dafoe the natural stand-out; even when the plot shifts his character in an unwarranted manner, he's able to still fascinate with his dramatic range.

The plot itself is a mess though - highly disjointed and episodic, with an experience that jumps all over the place. Even if it holds some strong chapters (e.g. Homeless), most episodes feel like lengthy and weird DLC (e.g. Navajo) that constantly sways the focus away from the main story drive.

The gameplay itself shifts from boring to frustrating - out of all of Quantic's game's, the interactive mechanics feel superfluous and implemented just to qualify as a ‘game’, instead of an obvious on-rails experience.

More importantly, the major story choices and interactions are blatantly inconsequential due to the sole protagonist and the jumbled timeline. You have to admire the game's ambition and passion, but it all boils down to just a technically impressive if highly flawed experience.


2. Heavy Rain (2010)

heavy rain
Quantic Dream

Dripping in a thick atmosphere with a moody soundtrack, Quantic's breakthrough game has all the trappings of a suspenseful Hollywood production, with Cage borrowing the initial aesthetic of Fahrenheit but refining it into a stronger and more focused product.

It's a captivating thriller, with each of the four intertwining plot-lines representing a specific sub-section of that genre. The most enjoyable cinematic would be the Noir-ish plot of Detective Shelby - yet the involving heart of the story is Ethan Mars; a dad put to the test to save his son. It's a journey that grips and successfully gives the player the feeling of being immersed in an interactive movie - one where any main character could actually die, and whose decisions could create massive ripples.

The pacing suffers early on though, with a meandering sense of purpose and lots of superfluous interaction (press X to JASON!). Plus, the finale’s big reveal is painfully non-sensical and completely half-assed. Also, despite the actor's dedication to their roles, the mixed European cast struggle with accents and varying levels of talent - in fact, a vital Flashback sequence is ruined by a shoddy child actor and his blatantly French accent.

Still, despite its flaws and the tech dating ever so slightly, there’s no denying this featured Cage at his most grippingly focused. When it works, it works great - in an undeniable thrilling and intensely racking rollercoaster.


1. Detroit: Become Human (2018)

Detroit Become Human
Sony

As mentioned before, Quantic Dream feels like a studio that has improved itself with every game; this is no clearer than with Detroit: Become Human; their latest and clearly greatest game.

Now plenty of critics have banged the drum about how on-the-nose the discrimination allegories are explored, and honestly, sometimes the result can verge on cringe-worthy - yet, for the majority, we are rewarded with an emotionally gruelling, touching and exhilarating story.

The incredible motion-capture performances and graphics tech set a new standard for the 'interactive movie' as a viable rival to a Hollywood production. Also, Cage thankfully avoids letting his story devolve into utter silliness in its third act - instead, keeping a honed razor-focus on his three sympathetic android leads in this dark Sci-Fi tale.

Also, likely for the first time, the multi-choice paths a character can take (in this sort of game) are not hyped noise but substantially deep and intricate. The varying roads lead to such a multitude of vastly alternative events, that as soon as you finish your first playthrough, you'll be tempted to try a second one almost immediately.

Certainly, it's not a perfect game but its a damn fine one - and for the first time, Quantic and Cage have lived up to the high-bar hype they generated. Plus, it features the best use of the great Clancy Brown and Lance Hendriksen in over two decades...and for that it must be commended.


Contributor

is a working dad by day and a determined gamer by night. He’s paid his dues in both the gaming and film industries, and this year his first feature film as screenwriter, the Polish slasher flick "13 Days Till Summer", played at Fantastic Fest and Sitges Film Festival.