Red Dead Online: 7 Reasons You Should Give It Another Chance

Red Dead Online has more than a few diamonds in the rough. Let's find them.

red dead online
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption 2’s single-player story was a game-changing masterpiece.

It pushed what a video game could be to new boundaries and upped the ante to such heights that it leaves the vast majority of its open-world competitors in the dust. Rockstar received the highest of praise for producing what is undoubtedly one of the greatest video games ever created.

However, Red Dead Online (RDO) has not been receiving the same love and adoration as its offline counterpart. Given the monumental success of Grand Theft Auto Online, it was expected that RDO would be another breakthrough for online gaming.

Unfortunately, RDO was met with a rather lukewarm reception.

Main concerns for players when its (very long) beta launched were that the economy was broken, the community would be toxic (in a similar fashion to GTA Online) and that there wasn’t a lot to do.

However, whilst the economy may still rival that of a third-world country, Rockstar have made strides toward improving many aspects of their online experience.

Now that it’s officially out of beta, there are some decent reasons to show an interest again.

7. It Has A Storyline

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar Games

One great reason to give RDO a try is its story. For those gamers who have finished the campaign and still strive for more of this world’s lore, playing online actually may help scratch that itch. Unlike Grand Theft Auto which offered a quick introduction then sent the player on their merry way, RDO introduces the player into an interesting and mysterious story. This gives their character a sense of purpose for existing in this world.

WARNING: Minor, very early game spoiler in next paragraph. Skip to bottom paragraph to avoid.

The game opens with the player character being broken out of prison, after being falsely accused of murdering the husband of a powerful woman. This woman is aware of the player character’s innocence and offers them the opportunity for revenge by helping her take down a group of four men she believes to be responsible. As the world opens up, the player can pick and choose these story-based missions at their leisure.

The addition of a story was something noticeably missing from GTA Online. It creates an opportunity for those typically inclined to play single-player to give RDO a chance and satisfy their need to explore this world and its stories farther.


6. Mechanical Lessons Learned From The Offline Campaign

Red Dead Redemption 2 Befriending Horses
Rockstar

Being in the online space, RDO gives Rockstar more freedom to tweak the gameplay mechanics than they have within the main story. Whilst it’s true that games can be patched in order to fix certain aspects of their offline modes, players tend to expect the online experience to be ever-changing more so. What’s considered jank to some, may be a charming quirk to others and making changes to the core player experience could result in unintended backlash.

With expectations for change in an online environment, Rockstar can experiment with new ideas then change content on a whim, dependent on customer feedback.

One thing new players in RDO will now notice (at least since the latest update) is that the weapon wheel doesn’t reset every time their character gets on and off a horse. Guns seemingly disappearing as a result of mounting and dismounting was a gripe for a lot of players when discussing the campaign’s gameplay. Having easy access to your selected weapons creates a far more smooth combat experience when playing online.

As Rockstar tweak and test new mechanics, their online component can only grow stronger. However, players need to engage in order to provide the feedback that leads to these improvements.


5. The Parley/Feud System

Red Dead Redemption 2 Micah And Arthur
Rockstar

One factor which may be off-putting to new RDO players is the idea of having to deal with a community similar to that of GTA Online. Whilst GTA is a superb game, these days it can be a real struggle to enjoy yourself in the free-roam mode due to the high quantity of military-grade flying cars, piloted by angry pre-teens who make more obscene mum references than Jules Gill.

Players in GTA Online have grown sick of being repeatedly killed by those at higher level with better gear. This has been addressed with the Parley and Feud systems in RDO. Now when a player kills your character, you can elect to ignore it, or pick one of these options. If you Parley, the offensive player and his online posse members cannot attack you for ten minutes, giving you time to escape. If you choose to Feud, you enter a best-of-three, one-on-one match to prove which of you is king.

This new system allows players to avoid being trolled without having to join a new server or enter passive mode. This makes the world more exciting as you can still be killed at any moment; just not 100 times in a row.


4. A More Survival-Based Experience

Red Dead Redemption 2 Stew Jpg Optimal_960x540
Rockstar

Sadly, it’s undeniable that the economy in RDO is still a complete mess. Jobs and free-roam activities pay literal pennies and it’s a stark contrast to the offline campaign. Right now Rockstar still have a micro-transaction heavy system, aimed at having players hand over real-world cash for those precious Gold Bars. Given the success of Shark Cards in GTA Online, this was an unfortunate inevitability, but hopefully one that Rockstar will tweak in order to provide an enjoyable experience for those who want to earn their rewards in-game.

This does, however, create a unique situation for the online world. As the game currently stands, its harsher economy makes for a more survival-focused experience. Having to hunt for food, rob NPCs, scrape together money and sell everything you can afford to lose creates a tough environment reminiscent of harder times in the Old West. Working your character’s way up from nothing can, in return, be more rewarding as a result.

It would be a stretch to say that this survival environment is worth a terrible economy; especially when a survival mode could be introduced for those who want it instead. However, the economy’s issues are not enough to ruin RDO’s gameplay entirely.


3. The Honour System Is More Meaningful

Red Dead Redemption 2 Litchfield Repeater
Rockstar Games

The honour system in RDO is an aspect which is arguably more meaningful than it is within the main story. In the campaign, the honour system is there to reflect positively or negatively on Arthur Morgan’s actions.

Given the story’s redemption arc, Rockstar attempts to guide the player toward a positive honour rating before the credits roll. In this case, if Arthur’s honour is below 50% some missions and cut-scenes cannot be accessed. The issue with this is that, unlike similar games such as Fallout or Mass Effect, there is no subsequent reward for playing dishonourably.

In RDO, a model is adopted in which having either high or low honour will allow certain missions to be handled from a different perspective. For example, a high honour character may be asked to protect a stage-coach, whilst a low honour character would be asked to attack it.

This online model allows more freedom of choice when it comes to your character. If you want to play an inherently good outlaw with a heart then great, but the game won’t punish you if you prefer to play the villain.

As a result, online players are encouraged to engage their sadistic side, rather than avoid it.


2. A Living, Breathing World

Red Dead Redemption 2 Drunk
Rockstar

With their latest update, Rockstar added random encounters to RDO. This was a step in the right direction toward creating a world that feels lived in; similar to that of the main campaign. Whether it’s a random group of bandits, bounty hunters, or just someone in need of a lift back into town, the addition of these NPC encounters was a very welcome one.

If you look at the disastrous launch of Fallout 76, you can gauge just how dire a world with no atmosphere outside of player encounters can be. These surprise events deliver an authentic experience and can be some of the most rewarding elements of an open-world game. They offer a further incentive to go out and explore.

As the updates continue to come through, the world will only become lively. Under the assumption that Rockstar continue to support this online service, what was once a baron wasteland will soon be a dangerous and exciting Wild West. Laying the groundwork for a new character now will give players time to establish themselves in this land in anticipation for further development.


1. Rockstar's Track Record

Rockstar Games Red Dead Logo
Rockstar

The final and possibly most important reason that players should give RDO a second chance is its stellar developer. This is a Rockstar property and a massive one at that. They aren’t going to give us a half-arsed job and give up.

Whilst the beta was very bare-bones, it’s entirely possible that this was intended in order to keep in line with server capacity. When GTA launched their online service, they did have more content from the get-go, but this was at the cost of reliable servers. Fans from 2013 experienced lag, excruciating wait times and even being kicked from sessions altogether.

If Rockstar pay even half the attention and resource to RDO that they did to GTA then we’re on the road to something special. They’ve taken a risk by dripping content in, rather than rushing out their product to a sea of glitches, crashes and other technical issues.

However, if players are patient and continue to work with what they have, the rewards have the potential to be outstanding. A future of poker tournaments, bar brawls and all-out gang warfare may not be too far off.

Good things come to those who wait. In Rockstar we trust.


Contributor
Contributor

Lvl 10 Maker of pro-gamer moves. Lvl 4 TV & Film critic. Lvl 69420 Sh*tposter. Lvl 1 Knowledge of Comics. Fantasy Football Extraordinaire. I don't know anything about wrestling. Please @ me- I have no friends.