Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Mind-Blowing Secrets & Theories You Need To Know
The REAL Undead Nightmare is... the reincarnation of Arthur Morgan?!
Red Dead Redemption 2 has more narrative depth than almost any other game out there. The open world is huge and bursting with life, characters are well drawn, complex and lifelike and the story, while arguably poorly paced from Chapter 5 onwards, in engaging and compelling.
With that comes a whole host of theories. Rockstar tends to cram so much life into their games that you get a generous 50 hour story, but even three times that isn’t enough to experience everything it has to offer.
As a result, some of these theories link to the central plot, others to side missions and some are just about the random events you can come across with little to no guidance from the game.
It’s testament to how well RDR2 is written and how perfect Arthur Morgan is for the story Rockstar want to tell. These theories only work because the characters seem so true to life, it’s impossible not to believe the world goes on around you, away from your influence.
Whether Rockstar truly changed the genre as they hoped is up for debate; regardless, they still created one of the best open-world games of all time.
10. Francis Is The Devil (And He’s Connected To GTA)
Geology For Beginners is one of the harder to come by sidequests in Red Dead Redemption 2, but as long as you’re exploring the world and not just dashing from quest to quest, you should be fine. In that quest you’ll meet a strange (even by Rockstar’s standards) man named Francis with bright red hair, a foppish wardrobe and a birthmark on his face.
Completion of the quest leads you to a shack, where you see, amongst other things, sketches of the Great Pyramids and the Empire State Building. While it’s possible Francis could have travelled to Egypt, the Empire State Building wasn’t built until 1930, so he’d have no way of knowing what it looked like yet.
The ‘theory’ that he’s a time traveller hardly requires super sleuthing, as a woman will approach you in that shack with a red haired baby with a birthmark on its face, telling you his name is Francis. Much more interesting is Francis’ link to GTA.
In the fifth game, the Epsilon cult notes that someone with Francis’ birthmark is a ‘possible decendent of Kraff’ and that people with red hair are ‘unsaveable liars’, meaning Francis could be some version of the Devil they fear.
9. The Lost Colony Of Roanoke
The legend of Roanoke is a tale that has been explored in both Supernatural and American Horror Story, and now Rockstar has had a go too. It details the fate of the first English settlers in America who mysteriously vanished without a trace.
One of the settlers, John White, left in 1587 to gather supplies, but was unable to return until 1590 because of the Anglo-Spanish War. When he did, all he found was a single word carved into a tree: Croatoan.
Impromptu history lesson aside, you might be wondering how all this fits into Red Dead Redemption. The game not only references the incident with Roanoke Valley, it seems to endorse the supernatural speculation surrounding its settlers. Some historians believe that a native tribe killed the English, but then no archeological evidence has ever been discovered to support this theory.
In Red Dead, when you ride through Roanoke Valley, you can hear ghostly voices and wails, presumably belonging to the souls of the settlers. A woman will cry and screech that she wants to go back home, while at other times you’ll hear unsettling laughter. Spooky stuff.
8. Arthur Gets Reincarnated
Arthur Morgan is one of the most developed and complex protagonists gaming has ever known, and his tragically poignant ending is the perfect send off. However, some have picked out various examples of imagery within the storyline that suggest Arthur doesn’t really die; he’s just reborn.
Animals are a huge part of the symbolism in many Westerns, and Red Dead is no different there. Chapters are bookended by sepia tone visions of animals, with different creatures appearing depending on Arthur’s honour; this then occurs again in his hallucination after his diagnosis.
However, the use of spirit animals is not proof of reincarnation. More convincingly, when you visit Arthur’s grave, you see a different animal nearby, again dependent on his honour level, with an eagle reserved for the noblest players. If you try to shoot it, the aiming circle will be greyed out, making it the only wild animal you can’t shoot.
Another take on the reincarnation theory comes when Jack and Charles are building their house. A bluejay features in every scene of that montage, and given that Arthur’s default outfit is blue and bluejays often represent truth and loyalty, it may be a symbol of Arthur watching over John.
7. The Strange Man's Return
The Strange Man himself isn’t a theory - he’s in Red Dead Redemption 2 just as he was in the first. However, his role in the main story this time is better exemplified by the blind soothsayer who offers cryptic predictions of your fate if you put some coins in his cup.
You have to work a little harder to find him, but The Strange Man himself is back again. In a shack in Lemoyne, you’ll find a painting of a silhouette. If you revisit the shack later, the silhouette has been revealed as The Strange Man, and you’ll see his apparition in the mirror behind you.
In RDR1, there were theories that he may be God, the Devil or John’s conscience. All three could still be true, though it would be strange for Arthur’s conscience to be so elusive and to look the same as John’s.
In fact, the Strange Man’s era-appropriate outfit suggests that if he is God, he’s able to change his appearance at will. Why would their vision of divinity be the same? Perhaps the Strange Man, God or Devil, takes the idealised appearance of the man both men admire most: one Dutch van der Linde.
6. Undead Nightmare Will Return At Pleasance
This may just be the over active imaginations of players desperate for another Undead Nightmare, but there’s definitely something unpleasant going down in Pleasance. The door to the settlement is boarded up with the message ‘Stay Out! Plague’, which is heavily reminiscent of The Walking Dead’s ‘Don’t Open, Dead Inside’.
As well as that, around the town there’s scrawled graffiti reading ‘Unclean Sinners’ and ‘Ill With Sin’ too. Whether or not it’s actually zombies, there’s certainly something rotten in the state of Pleasance.
There seems to be no real pay off for this in the game, but then Rockstar does love bringing it’s open world to life in ways the players can’t ever influence. Also, there’s an unrelated side mission where a mining company has let toxins loose in a lake and turned a small settlement into deranged lunatics; it’s not unreasonable to think that something similar may have happened in Pleasance.
All in all though, if thinking there’s zombies in Pleasance adds to the possiblity of getting an Undead Nightmare 2 scenario, that’s more than enough for fans to follow this theory blindly.
5. Jack Is Writing Red Dead
This one is taking a meta approach to what may be nothing more than an Easter egg, but it’s still a fun theory that warrants discussion.
In GTA, we see a book called Red Dead Redemption written by one J. Marston, and it’s safe to assume the author is Jack, not John. Throughout the game, there are several references to books, which can seem like knowing nods if we take it as fact that what we’re playing through is just Jack’s retelling.
Jack asks you to get him a book and is frequently shown reading, while Trelawny mentions to Arthur that he’ll end up in a book one day. Also, John mocks Jack, asking if he’ll get rich ‘writing silly stories’.
The game clearly wants you to play as honourably as you can, which makes sense considering how Jack clearly admires Arthur and would paint him this way. There’s the rather obvious fact the game is told in Chapters, too.
As for why it references New York when in GTA’s universe it’s called Liberty City, it may be that Jack simply invented the name New York for his parody, and it just happened to be the name we use for it too.
4. Hosea Gave Arthur Tuberculosis, Not Thomas Downes
A huge motivator in Arthur’s own search for redemption is his terminal tuberculosis, to the point where you could argue his diagnosis is the singular most important event. Arhur believes he got it from beating Thomas Downes to death near the game’s opening; Thomas spits blood into Arthur’s mouth, and he later tells the nun he got it beating a man to death for a few bucks.
However, there isn’t any cast iron evidence for this. The circumstantial stuff is quite convincing, but it couldn’t hurt to look at another possibility.
From quite near the start of the game, Hosea has a persistent cough. It’s not as bad as Arthur’s however, so that means he’s either better at hiding it or it’s an unrelated symptom of his (relatively) advanced age.
Thematically though, it seems Arthur’s redemption hinges on kicking Strauss out of camp and doing everything he can to do right by Mrs. Downes. If Hosea did give him it, that’s arguably more poetic. Arthur is trying to redeem himself by focussing on his more recent behaviour. But the truth is, he was raised as an outlaw. It doesn’t matter what he does; he was doomed from the start.
3. Abigail Is The Rat
The obvious contradiction to this is that Agent Milton straight up tells Arthur that it’s Micah. But then, Molly admits it was her, which turns out to be a lie, so let’s just look at the possibilities here.
Milton has spent enough time watching the gang (and whoever it is, has a mole in camp), so he knows Arthur hates Micah; Milton knew Arthur would believe it was Micah without question.
Abigail at this point is tied up and helpless, but Milton always thinks ahead: if he tells Arthur the (hypothetical) truth that it’s Abigail, he could lose his star witness. Better to protect her, in case Arthur or Sadie escape. He probably wasn’t counting on getting shot in the head by her immediately afterwards.
As for why it could be Abigail, there’s an abundance of evidence. In tracking Dutch’s hiding spot and stealing the key, she’s shown a devious side. Also, how she escapes unharmed when Hosea is shot and why Marston is taken alive are both unclear and slightly unlikely, unless she’d cut a deal.
As for the Pinkerton attack after Guarma, the detectives would obviously wait until Abigail told them the heavy hitters were back before they came looking.
2. Bill Is Gay (And It Got Him Kicked Out Of The Army)
Typically, any popular media tends to come with two persistent theories: either a character dead/in a coma and dreaming, or a character is gay. However, when it comes to Bill, there’s actually a lot of convincing evidence that this time, the theory is correct.
Around camp, there’s a letter which details why Bill was discharged from the army, stating attempted murder and ‘deviancy’; a common code word for homosexuality. On top of this, if you play through believing this theory, there are a lot of interactions that support the idea of Bill’s homosexuality.
During the bar fight in Valentine, Arthur says about Bill “is he trying to punch that guy or kiss him?”, which on its own could just be a joke, but there’s a few too many similar gags for it to be coincidental. Later, when Hosea suggests Lenny shouldn’t have dated Jenny because their names rhyme, he also uses the examples of Arthur and Martha then Bill and Phil.
Finally, in camp Bill tries to convince Kieran to share a bottle with him. If you go up to him afterwards, Bill will get nervous and defensive; possibly because the army made him wary of showing his true nature.
1. Dutch Gets A Brain Injury
A contentious fan theory, as many would argue that Dutch’s behaviour is at the heart of the game’s themes. Did he change under the mounting pressure, or had he always been that way, hiding his dark side?
Suggesting he has a brain injury gives him a bit of a get out of jail free card on the issue, but there’s certainly compelling evidence. Many point to the failed bank job as the first moment Dutch cracks, after seeing Hosea shot in front of him. However, prior to this he feeds Bronte to the alligators; so if we take that as the start of his recklessness, what could have kickstarted it?
The theory goes that it’s the post office heist. During their escape, Dutch hits his head during a tram crash and complains of a sore head the entire way home. It’s never mentioned again, but frontal lobe damage often causes impulsivity and changes to behaviour.
However, he’s arguing with Hosea for most of the game, and things have apparently been going downhill since the events of Blackwater, prior to the game’s opening. Maybe Dutch always had that darkness within him, and the brain trauma just exacerbated it.
Watch Next
Red Dead Redemption & Revolver Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Franchise?