Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Reasons It's The Best Game Ever Made
Removed from launch window hype, Rockstar truly have created a masterpiece.
It's been a few months and the dust has finally settled on Rockstar's open world western epic. Now that there's been ample time to step back and view the game and its impact without hyperbole, we can see Red Dead Redemption 2 for what it really is.
A perfect game? No. No such thing exists. Just like there can be no perfect movies, music, or TV shows. Art, perhaps by its definition, must be flawed. Which is to say that this is not a list that aims to prove that Red Dead Redemption 2 is perfect, but simply to prove that it is as damn close as we've ever seen in gaming as a medium. It's The Godfather of video games, The Black Album of video games, and the magnum opus of Rockstar so far.
As evidenced by gameplay, tone, sound design, art-style, voice-acting, world-building, and so much more, Red Dead Redemption 2 is the most intricately handcrafted video game of all time. Most other video games don't even come close to the level of quality and detail present here. At least not open world games.
It's the rarest of rare diamonds in the industry: a jack of all trades and a master of each.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is a masterpiece, and here are some in-depth reasons why.
10. The World
Every bunny rabbit to each individual town. Every random encounter to the meticulous missions. The mud on the carriage wheels to the buildings that get constructed as you play. The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is unlike any other.
The map is gigantic but realistically laid-out; it never feels like you just magically wound-up in the desert or the snowy mountains, each area feels like it transitioned perfectly from the last.
Each town feels memorable, what with their own unique soundtracks and atmosphere, and the group camp always feels like home. It's a world that trumps any other in terms of scope, liveliness and immersion.
Sometimes when you play a game you wonder why it took so long to make. The opposite is true of Red Dead Redemption 2; it's a living, breathing world that feels like it should be impossible on current hardware.
It makes all other open worlds feel completely devoid of life and like a stage play. From the realistic animal hierarchy to the decaying corpses, the ability to speak to any NPC to dynamic weather, down to the shocking lack of glitches - the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is the greatest ever crafted.
9. The Easter Eggs
By Rockstar standards, Red Dead Redemption 2 is a fairly grounded story. Meaning there are no main missions involving aliens or such mad things you might find in a Grand Theft Auto. That said, it wouldn't be a Rockstar game if that kind of stuff wasn't there, tucked away but worth finding all the same.
Yes it may be a little hidden, but the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is chock-full of nooks and crannies to be explored, ones that will offer golden bars as treasure, ones that lead to a serial killer, ones in which you'll find a mutilated pig monster, and so on. It's overflowing with weirdness and that's all we can ask for.
This is an aspect of the game that helps it feel truly alive, because helping a random stranger on the road may come back later in the game. Helping Marko Dragic create his weird robot will lead to a unique find down the line. And then there's random occurrences like finding Bonnie McFarlane's dying husband.
The world is like a love letter to itself, and that makes it incredible fun to explore for hundreds of hours.
8. The Hunting
It may seem like too much at the start, and you may not understand it at all, but, as is the case with the entirety of this game, you can rest assured that it's meticulously designed to the point of blowing your little mind.
You may find yourself frustrated that, try as you might, you just can't get that 3-star squirrel you need to craft a nice new cap. Eventually you'll realise that you need the varmint rifle to do so. The hunting in RDR2 is dependent on the ecosystem, meaning the animals in the game behave like their real-life counterparts.
You'll find beavers by rivers, bears in the mountains and alligators in the swamp. It isn't enough to just find them either, you'll have to study them and use just the right weapon to take them out cleanly. Then you'll skin it and take it back to the Trapper or camp - unless of course you lose the pelt or the carcass rots before you get there.
It's an incredibly deep and meticulous hunting system, and one that could legit be a game all by itself. The fact that it's just in there is worthy of celebration alone.
7. The Cast
Every character you come across in Red Dead Redemption 2 is memorable.
Whether it's the Sheriff of Valentine, Tilly from camp, or a random beggar in the street. Every character has... just that, character.
While a vast majority of video games struggle to even make their protagonist likeable, relatable or memorable, Red Dead Redemption 2 has a cast bigger than any movie, and it makes them all worth listening to.
Part of this is the incredible writing that makes each character feel unique, and like they have a real voice and lives, but the other part of it is the great animators and the phenomenal voice-actors that truly breathe life into each individual.
Playing as part of a large gang could easily have left several characters in the background, feeling not fleshed out at all. However, playing the game means you're liable to truly care for everyone, from Arthur to Mary-Beth, John to Pearson, and every straggler you meet along the way.
It's awe-inspiring to just walk around the world and talk to strangers, most of whom have more personality than any character across the majority of triple-A releases.
6. Dutch Van Der Linde
Arguably the greatest villain in any Rockstar game, and one of the best in any video game period. Dutch is charming, irritating, sympathetic, and, on some level, totally right. He's the perfect foil because he's not a dastardly, moustache-twirling bad guy, even though he has the 'stache for it.
One of the most note-worthy things Rockstar did with Red Dead Redemption 2 is making you care about the characters. That sounds obvious but RDR2 is a prequel to a game that kills just about every character in it. Rockstar had an uphill battle in regards to making us care about any of Dutch's gang when we know the fate of so many, but it do so within the first few hours.
Best of all Dutch Van der Linde. Any gamer that played the original going into RDR2 saw Dutch as a villain before he ever spoke. However over the course of the 50+ hour story Rockstar Games made you laugh, cry, rage, and pity along every step of the way with Dutch.
He's so much more than a run-of-the-mill bad guy, and his fall from grace is spectacular to be part of.
5. Graphics And Animations
This one is kind of a no-brainer, but you really can't overstate the quality of the graphics and animations in Red Dead Redemption 2.
Despite the world being massive, every inch of it is crafted to the tiniest detail. Some rivers run crystal clear blue, while others run red from the nearby cave. Every forest you enter has swaying trees and incredible sun-rays beaming through. Each town feels incredibly unique with their own style and atmosphere.
There were no shortcuts taken in the graphics department and the same can be said for animations. Whether it's the way the carcass on the back of the horse bounces as it gallops, how snow dynamically moves under foot, the way oranges dance around in a basket in the back of a carriage, or the way mud and blood stick to your clothes and face; Red Dead's level of animation is mind-melting.
These aspects are make-or-break for a lot of games, but many developers take shortcuts. The opposite is true in game that was so painstakingly crafted that it makes all others feel lifeless. Any animator who worked on this game will have a piece for their CV that will guarantee them a job for life.
4. Pacing
Many of the complaints flogged at Red Dead Redemption 2 stemmed from the game's slow pace. Gamers didn't want to endure the slow prologue that introduced the cast while hampering your access to the world.
They didn't like the lack of fast travel, that there's a skinning animation for every animal; that your beard grows in real time or that the game is just really long.
However, the pacing is, in fact, perfect. Unlike most video games, the main story never compels you to move forward; no impetus to save the princess or such. Instead, it allows you to take the missions at your own pace and still experience the sweeping tale.
If you want to hunt animals or find dream-catchers for a few hours, the game never nudges you to get back to the main story. When you do return to the story though, it's a scrupulously paced masterpiece that feels the exact right length. In a world where everyone seeks the instant gratification of Fortnite, Red Dead demands you slow down, stick on some headphones and play for several hours.
The slow-burn story makes the highs higher and the lows soul-crushing. A pace perfectly befitting of a western.
3. Discarding Convention
The very best games and movies defy expectations. And that's not to say they're simply better than we expect. Rather it means they forego any assumptions you may have about the plot and the characters.
To use a separate example; with The Last of Us, Naughty Dog didn't need to kill Joel or Ellie to tug at your heart-strings, that story made you feel emotions games rarely even encroach. As was the case with Red Dead Redemption 2.
It's a game that doesn't feel the need to have one major villain; instead there are several characters that ebb and flow between good and bad, confusing your moral compass. Dutch can be a pain, but you want to make him happy; John is the guy you know you love but he's a douche to his family; Micah is the closest thing to a real bad guy, but the game doesn't let you kill him as most others would.
No, you don't get that satisfaction because real-life isn't like that.
It's a story that foregoes the obvious and conventional options, in favour of emulating real life and crafting a much more realistic and memorable world.
2. That Epilogue
You're reading this article, therefore you're probably a fervent gamer. That means you're all too aware of the disease that has plagued the games industry for the better part of a decade: micro-transactions and DLC.
While these two things aren't inherently negative, we do find them negatively affecting games like Star Wars Battlefront II. It's gotten to the point where we just accept that chunks of games will be left out in order to serve as paid DLC at a later date.
Well, this is just one more area where Rockstar Games bypassed conventions and gave us, not just a massive game, but one with a 10 hour long epilogue. Once you finish Arthur's story in RDR2, it immediately jumps forward 8 years and puts you in control of John Marston.
From there you get a job, lost your wife, rekindle old friendships, build a house, and chase down an old foe. It's a beautiful epilogue that could easily have been cut out and cost $30 extra, but Rockstar went the extra mile and gave us a whole, finished story.
For that in today's climate, the company hasn't gotten enough credit.
1. Arthur Morgan
For the first few chapters of Red Dead Redemption 2's story, Arthur Morgan seems like a rather by-the-numbers protagonist; he's rough, takes-no-s**t, and doesn't care for small talk. Yet, as the story unfolds, Arthur blossoms into a diverse, layered character that belays his troubled upbringing and conflicted mind.
As you progress through Red Dead Redemption 2, you begin to see Arthur change. The events of the story and his run-ins with characters begin to shape him into the man he is at the end of the game. That evolution is fast-tracked by his ailment later in the game, and that's what makes it so heart-breaking to play.
Arthur is a good man deep down, and learning of his illness spurs him to make the most of his final days and weeks by helping others. What follows is true redemption and the development of a character that makes most others seem completely hollow in comparison.
Quite frankly, Arthur Morgan is the greatest character in any video game, and that alone would have been enough to catapult Red Dead into an upper echelon. When combined with all the other elements listed here however, you have the single best video game ever made.