Red Dead Redemption 2: 8 Disturbing Secrets & Locations You Totally Missed

2. The Creepy Statue Game

There's no real explanation for the strange statue game existing in the world of Red Dead Redemption 2. In between Window Rock and the Granite Pass you should be able to find some markings on the side of the rock pointing you towards the location of the puzzle, which is further south.

If you make your way through a crevice just above the Mystery Hill Horse point of interest, you'll stumble across a bunch of eerie statues all missing fingers. One has a missing arm, which you can find lying around the cave and will give you all the numbers needed to solve the mystery. The idea is that you have to count the fingers on each statue, and then press the ones which have an amount that's a prime number.

Why? Well, it's not entirely revealed who set the game up, or why the only instructions revealing its existence were scrawled onto a rock wall, but it will net you a couple of gold bars for your trouble.