Red Dead Redemption 3 - 10 Ways To Make The Perfect Sequel

How could Rockstar possibly top Red Dead Redemption 2? 

red dead redemption 3
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption 2 had a tall order to fill when it was announced back in 2016. Not only was it Rockstar's first new game since 2013's Grand Theft Auto V, but it also had to contend with its predecessor, which was -- and still is -- widely considered one of the greatest games ever made.

So what happened when the prequel finally dropped? It exceeded all expectations, both critically and commercially.

Not only did RDR2 have the second-highest launch in entertainment history (sitting behind GTA V), but the universal critical acclaim it garnered catapulted it into the sphere of "Greatest Games of All Time", joining titles like The Last of Us, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.

With that sort of success, it would be the understatement of the century to call Rockstar foolish, should they not pursue another instalment. But where could they go with a Red Dead Redemption 3?

What could they do to make it even better than Red Dead 2, as insurmountable a task at that may seem? Well, I have some ideas.

10. Refined Combat

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar Games & /r/GamingDetails

This is definitely the most technical of the ten entries on this list, but it bears talking about. One of the few legitimate criticisms levied at the Western prequel was the clunky, outdated nature of combat.

The shooting often seemed too easy. It wasn't challenging.

Generally, that's okay, as it makes for a smooth experience. However, there were times where it felt almost TOO smooth, so much so that the sense of danger felt compromised.

It'd be a nice change of pace to feel like we really have to put some thought into our shots, and not just auto-target someone's cranium because video games. You COULD chock that up to the character being a talented marksman. That's fine.

Less excusable, however, is the awkwardness of hand-to-hand combat.

Basically, this is what it boils down to: smash the punch button, block if you feel like it, and when the opponent stops hitting you, you've won the fight. For a game that's on the cutting edge of pretty much everything else, it's disappointing to see such a rudimentary combat system. Hopefully Rockstar polish this up in the future.


9. Give Us A Reason To Be Bad

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

Why would you play as a bad guy in RDR2? There's really only one answer: Because you can.

You don't get anything for making the bad choices. Sure, you may come away with monetary compensation here and there, but there's no real, in-world positive to being a fiend.

The law chases you down, people are scared of you, and then you suffer a bitter, heartbreaking ending (which is fitting). It would be nice to see Red Dead Redemption 3 explore the "positives" of being truly merciless, something that could be a perfect fit for a certain setting (which I'll get to later).

People may look the other way when you commit crimes. Shopkeepers could either give you stuff for free, or flee their businesses in terror at the sight of you, leaving you to thin their inventory at your leisure.

Other outlaws might steer clear of you out of respect and fear. Local cutthroat businessmen and politicians might be more inclined to hire you for a high-paying job, befitting of those with low moral character.

Whatever the case may be, it'd be nice to see some real pros to being a bad guy.


8. Bring Back Single Player DLC

Red Dead Redemption 2 Undead Nightmare
Rockstar/MediaDecided

The first Red Dead Redemption did something the second still hasn't (and almost certainly won't): Give us a standalone single-player DLC story.

Undead Nightmare shouldn't have worked. Upon announcement, its goofy, lighthearted, pulpy tone didn't seem to fit with the realistic, down-to-earth, emotionally mature narrative of the main game. It was a peculiar pitch. Despite -- or perhaps because of -- this peculiarity, Undead Nightmare went on to massive sales and overwhelmingly positive critical reception, with many considering it to be among the best DLCs ever released.

The second game had its fair share of supernatural elements; we saw a "werewolf", a vampire, a Bigfoot skeleton, a time-traveler, a witch's cauldron, a Pagan ritual site, the Night Folk (the God damn Night Folk!), and more than a couple UFOs. There's plenty there to work with, and the absence of a fun, pulpy DLC is one of the greatest disappointments -- one of the ONLY disappointments, but still, one of the greatest -- of Red Dead Redemption 2.

We can only hope that the third game brings back not only creepy, supernatural easter eggs, but a DLC befitting of such a vast, impressive game with equally vast and impressive lore.


7. The Early Days Of The Van Der Linde Gang

Red Dead Redemption 2 Dutch's Gang
Rockstar

If we keep with the trajectory of the last two games, we'll go further back in time and see the Van der Linde Gang in their heyday, as opposed to them on their last leg with their backs against the wall. We could see WHY people feared them far and wide, and we could see WHY Arthur and John became so deeply infatuated with the ideas that Dutch espoused.

What do we know about the history of the Van der Linde Gang? We know that in the 1870s, Dutch and Hosea tried to rob each other, sparking a lifelong friendship. In 1877, they recruited a 14-year-old Arthur. In 1885, they rescued a 12-year-old John Marston from being lynched in Illinois.

Two years later, the gang carried out its first major robbery. At some point, they had a truce with the O'Driscoll Gang, but that peace was broken when Dutch killed Colm's brother. In 1898, the gang moved from Montana to West Elizabeth, where they would ultimately rob a ferry in the ill-fated Blackwater Massacre of 1899.

That's really it. There's a lot to explore, and it'd be fascinating to see Dutch as an ideologue, and Arthur as his young, zealous devotee.


6. Classic Western Settings

Grand canyon
Wikipedia

When the average person hears the word "Western", it generally conjures up images of sun-soaked deserts, like those you may find in New Mexico and Arizona; giant stone spires, like Monument Valley; and desolate, lawless towns with dusty streets and a saloon with a couple of swinging doors, like Tombstone or Dodge City.

Admittedly, this is an incredibly narrow and reductionist view of Westerns. A Western doesn't just have to be deserts. It can be towering mountains, open ranges, thick forests, booming towns, sprawling plains, and bottomless canyons. The Red Dead Redemption games have covered a lot of the Western biomes already.

All that said, it would be nice to see that traditional Western iconography. We already had some of it in the first game, where we had towns like Tumbleweed and Armadillo. It would be interesting, though, to go further west, exploring places inspired by classic Western landmarks such as Carlsbad Caverns, Antelope Canyon, Zion Nation Park, Mesa Verde, and the Grand Canyon.

We could also see places that are still relative strongholds for American Indian culture.

Speaking of which...


5. More Native Americans

red dead redemption 2 rains fall native americans
Rockstar

This one has still yet to be fully explored, and that's a real shame.

The first game had but a handful of American Indian characters, the most prominent of which was the short-lived, ill-fated informant, Nastas. The others were mostly nameless guns in Dutch's new gang. They played a larger role in the second game, but only towards the back end.

The war between the U.S. government and the Wapiti tribe was pivotal to the game's third act. Even then, though, we didn't get a real sense of Wapiti culture. It would be fascinating to explore what it meant to be an American Indian at the height of the American West.

But what could they explore?

They could draw inspiration from the Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890, or perhaps the preceding Great Sioux War of 1876. Maybe Rockstar could take some cues from Geronimo's War (also known as the Apache Wars), which raged from 1881 to 1886, and saw the U.S. Army going head-to-head with various bands of Apache warriors. There's also the shameful reality of Native American boarding schools.

U.S. history is full of these dark chapters, and Rockstar would do well to explore them. Speaking of which...


4. Lean Into Social Realities

black cowboys
Wikipedia

Believe it or not, neither Red Dead Redemption 1 or 2 are true Westerns.

Instead, they're what's called Revisionist Westerns. Revisionist Westerns place a stronger focus on moral ambiguity, while also casting more light on nontraditional Western protagonists (white guys), such as American Indians, women, and African Americans.

They also focus on the darker parts of American history: The things we've chosen to forget or omit; the atrocities and the morally reprehensible actions of our "heroes".

Red Dead Redemption 3 would do well to explore these things.

Along with the aforementioned persecution of American Indians, they could also draw upon the reality that black men made up about 1/3 of all cowboys on the open range, but were often excluded from drinking in saloons.

That the Chinese were often targets of racist vitriol, with Los Angeles's Chinese Massacre of 1871 being one prominent example.

That the oft-exalted Texas Rangers committed acts of horrific violence (sometimes sexual) against Mexicans living in isolated communities, or the institution of collecting Mexican and Apache scalps for cash, which was the business of Ranger/outlaw/serial killer, John Joel Glanton.

The West was far from a pristine utopia, and Red Dead Redemption 3 should acknowledge that.


3. New Cities

colorado wild west 1800s
Wikimedia

This one is a no-brainer, but it's always worth mentioning.

Rockstar has steered clear of using actual cities, instead imbuing their fictional locales with homages to real places. Saint Denis was very clearly inspired by New Orleans; Armadillo is an analogue for traditional Western desert towns like Tombstone; and Valentine is reminiscent of livestock towns like Cheyenne, Wyoming, Ogallala, Nebraska, and Abilene, Kansas.

What real-world cities may Red Dead Redemption 3 take inspiration from?

Since Marston was rescued from Illinois homesteaders, perhaps the game could model its obligatory metropolis after Chicago.

Alternatively, if they wanted to head further west, they could take cues from San Francisco, known then as the 'Paris of the West', which exploded in population after a gold rush in 1848.

Other cities include Denver, Colorado, home to lavish opera houses, luxury hotels, and real-world outlaw crime bosses like Soapy Smith; Santa Fe, New Mexico, known for its elaborate pueblos and an imposing Spanish cathedral; or, perhaps most promising of all, Deadwood, South Dakota, which hosted famous Old West figures from both sides of the law.

Drawing inspiration from Deadwood would allow the game to really lean into the "wild" in Wild West.

Which, now I mention it...


2. The Golden Age Of Outlaws

Red Dead Online Bounty Hunter
Rockstar

Both games featured the American West on its last leg.

The first saw John Marston actively hunting down and exterminating the vestiges of the West's violent, lawless past, only to be exterminated himself.

The second showed us a bit more of that lawlessness, but even then, the gang was backed up against a wall, and they were forced to stare down the barrel at the imminent end of their way of life. Those themes were poignant -- and made for two of the most emotionally-rich video game stories ever told -- but wouldn't it be fun to see the gang running wild? To see them as wide-eyed bandits fighting for a philosophy they believe in, back when they ACTUALLY thought it could work?

If the story follows the early days of the Van der Linde Gang, then we could see the lifestyle that thoroughly intoxicated Dutch, Hosea, John, and Arthur.

We didn't see too much gang warfare and outlaw camaraderie in RDR2, so it'd be nice to explore what the gang was like in its glory days. And if not Dutch's gang, then maybe a new gang or a new outlaw.

Or, just possibly, one that we've already met...


1. Landon Ricketts

red dead redemption landon ricketts
Rockstar

Yup! The man, the mustache, the legend himself! If we can't get a young Dutch and Arthur (or an altogether new story), perhaps we could explore the early days of the greatest Sam Elliott stand-in in the history of gaming.

A young Landon Ricketts story offers us a lot of possibilities.

He was a gunslinger in the golden age of outlaws; his story could explore social stratification (like anti-Chinese racism if they explore his time in California, or the conflicts with American Indians in the Southwest and the Dakotas), and we could see a redemptive arc where he turns away from a life of crime and follows a more honorable path (ultimately fighting on the side of the police during the Blackwater Massacre, before retiring to Mexico after a shootout in California).

Granted, this probably won't happen.

His voice actor, Ross Hagen, passed away in 2011 (in fact, Mt. Hagen in RDR2 was named after him), and though Rockstar could just as easily cast a different voice actor, they may want to let his legacy rest in peace.

But if they wanted to place RDR3's focus on a preexisting character, they could do a lot worse than Landon Ricketts.


Watch Next


Contributor

Dustin is your friendly neighborhood historian, nerd culture enthusiast, and professional wise-ass. Some of his favorite pastimes include writing, philosophizing, and antagonizing stupid people.